I have one um big question that I think
everybody would like the answer to which
is to what extent do you think there's
life
outside Earth um or not on Earth and
when people hear this they think aliens
but you know like an insect like
creature uh single or small multicell
organism on another planet that that
itself would be a spectacular find well
yeah I'm kind of an out liar so just
everyone should you know look to the
actual experts in this field but I have
some rigorous you know kind of logical
arguments that I believe the probability
of Li I never say it's zero but I think
it's very low and I I think I can
substantiate that and the best part is I
can't be falsified right now there's
zero evidence that there's life anywhere
else in the universe period full stop
end a sentence there's no evidence
conclusive evidence in fact lot of
drones over New Jersey right now not no
evidence of Life knew we get into drones
um uh so the the argument that it would
somehow first of all transform our
understanding of human place is
inarguable to me I I believe that's true
although in um this movie contact is a
really wonderful movie uh it's not
cheesy science fiction it was the first
to like use a wormhole and all sorts of
cool stuff as contrivances but in that
movie there's a scene where President
Bill Clinton is talking about the
discovery that this fictitious character
made but he's actually talking about a
meteorite that was discovered in
Antarctica and they just clipped that
and the meteorite was believed to have
microbial life and that meteorite's
origin was in inarguably from Mars okay
so the reasoning was this is 1997 that
there was a meteorite found on in
Antarctica where it's easy to find
meteorites is in the movie or in real
life this in real life in 1997 a
scientist announced a discovery of a
meteorite from Antarctica it's called
Allen Land Hills meteorite and it had
what they claimed were evidence of
microbial life and even respiration
byproducts of these microbial life forms
okay it was such a big deal that within
minutes you know Bill Clinton had a
press conference on the White House lawn
where he goes this Rock speaks to us
from across the generations and if
confirmed will undoubtedly you know
revolutionize our understanding of the
universe around okay now the movie clips
that clip to make it seem like Ellie the
fictitious character discovered Al like
you know set extraterrestrial technology
not a microb but in the Public's in mind
that
actual scientific discovery was never
falsified it was certainly never
confirmed no one's ever come back to say
that was correct and that we did find
mical evidence of microbial Life on Mars
now how did that meteorite get there
well uh some asteroids hit the moon
that's why it has craters on it it hits
the Earth that's why we have uh meteor
crater Arizona winsa Arizona uh Yucatan
chiel where the dinosaurs Doom was was
sealed by the giant impactor 66 million
years ago those uh impacts occur on
every planet every moon in our solar
system so some asteroid hit the surface
of Mars probably millions of years ago
ejected material low gravity on Mars low
atmosphere uh and that material has been
orbiting around and eventually made its
way and hit the earth okay so matter
from Mars landed on the earth does that
make sense that's how I gave you I have
a lunar meteorite that I giving to you
again as a as a as a token of my
appreciation for all you do that came
the same way something hit the moon
blasted off some lunar it's called breia
it's the crust of the Moon eventually
made its way landed in northwest Africa
and I bought a slice of it from a I got
a dealer you know I got a meteorite
dealer um and I got that for you okay um
so what's the lesson material gets
exchanged from planet to planet now I
asked the following question if that
happened on the Mars to the Earth the
moon to the earth so too has material
from the earth been ejected since life
emerged 3.7 billion years ago
there's literally millions of tons of
Earth that's floating around in space
some of that will have landed on Mars so
someday we'll get there we'll find some
piece of it now could it some of it have
a tardigrade on it could some of it have
a protozoa on it obviously it could um
and maybe some interesting mic microbes
yeah it could maybe some ancient
microbes that are no longer that's right
um extent so one theory of the formation
of life on Earth you you asked me about
that earlier the origin of life on Earth
is a huge mystery how did life get here
one proposition was made by Fred hoil
and other people it sounds dirty but
it's not it's called pans spermia just
means that genetic material has been
transferred from another um another
astronomical object landed here on Earth
so uh the converse reaction occurs as
well but the the the fact is we don't
observe it even on Mars so if I told you
you know we've discovered a planet and
there's another planet right next to it
it has almost the same conditions it's
in the so-called goldilock Zone where
the temperatur is just right to have
liquid water which Mars can have on it
at certain times of the year and certain
places on Mars it flowing water on it we
know for sure Mars had flowing water on
it we know for sure that material from
the earth got there when Earth had life
on it so the absence of Life on Mars is
a data point it's not pro probative or
probative or just positive rather that
life couldn't exist on Mars we haven't
searched all of Mars but it at least
shows that there's an impediment to it
so people are lot fond of saying as I
told you earlier there's about 10 to the
24th um planets probably in our
observable universe going back to the
Big Bang going out to the farthest
reaches of the universe but even if you
just take the Milky Way galaxy there's
probably you know literally 10 Bill
hundreds of billions of planets in our
galaxy alone and um when you look at
that people like to say as Carl Sean did
if there's no life it's an awful waste
of space right why is there so much
space and there's no life that seems
incomprehensible but nature you know I
love when atheist scientists will say
like you propose God exist and that's
the god of the gaps to explain things
that you don't understand but when
science advances we'll have an
explanation for why you know Thunder
occurs it's not because of Thor right we
get rid of gods as we learn more and so
the god gaps shrink smaller and smaller
but they'll say the same argument about
life in the they'll say well there's got
to be life because there's so much room
there but as I told you I've been in
Antarctica twice the only life forms I
saw there okay were people um I saw a
few penguins in the distance and a
couple of dead sea lions there's no
trees there's no Flora at all on the
entire continent it's incredibly Barren
and yet Andrew it makes up 8% of the of
the land mass of the Earth wow and you
would think well it's just proportional
to the amount of area I.E the number of
stars there should be 8% of the life on
Earth there should be a billion people
there whatever you know 600 million PE
no there's nothing there except for
scientists that go there so the the odds
of life you know are you can't construct
probability from possibility that and
many many other arguments that I could
give you the the the improbability of
Life how hard it is to create life and
you know if you just sprinkled imagine
you had a coal Canon okay people like
Peta are going to get you just go to
Mars and spray it with koala it's
obviously not going to like start would
probably be okay with you populating
with the an area with koalas a Canon to
take out koalas they would probably
that's right they would not like that so
yeah so probab uh you know possibility
is not probability uh the number number
of hurdles to create a a single cell is
enormous uh we have yet to reproduce you
know to make a functional cell in the
laboratory not that that's a requirement
to prove that life could Exist Elsewhere
just saying it's very hard our history
of life we have an N of one it's very
difficult to speculate on and if we're
alone if if life is abundant as fery
asked many many many years ago um if
life is abundant and the Galaxy is is
old where are they where are the aliens
there should have been plenty of time
not only for them to evolve and and be
superior to us in many ways and travel
the distances of the of our our galaxy
not even of the cosmos of our galaxy
where are they where are they they've
known about us for 880 years because
we've been broadcasting radio waves for
the last 85 years do you know this
theory about the gut microbiota you know
our our guts our skin our eyes our nose
but certainly our D entire digestive
tract um the whole way down from our
lips um out the other end are populated
with these little microbiota that
influence everything from fatty acid
production neurotransmitter production
Etc influence more than human cells
right yeah oh yeah and it's powerful for
modulating all sorts of biological
processes and um and every time we
interact shake hands if people kiss if
you interact with dirt if you interact
with a pet you the the microbiome
changes it's a it's an inner uh
reflection of of all your outer
behaviors and internet yeah yeah and and
we're learning a lot about it that
there's this one theory that I like that
um kind of turns life as as you and I
know it on its head which is that um
humans and other species are just
vehicles for the microbiome and that you
know and so you would take something
like oh the desire to uh like like
uh populate Mars or to shoot or to land
on the moon as just the microbiota you
know taking advantage of this weird old
world primate species that we call Homo
sapiens that loves to develop technology
almost destroy itself but then continue
to to uh evolve social media Etc warn
each other about declining birth rates
and then just to to basically the
microbiota have a what you know a sort
of quote unquote Consciousness not a
brain but consciousness of their own
which is like species to make more of
itself and to go further and further out
and populate it's hard to punch holes in
the logic of of this of this model but
it it certainly diminishes our our
conscious experience um we could go on
forever about uh this Trail I I'll just
kind of put a kind of a cliffhanger out
there it'd be wonderful sometime to sit
down with you and discuss the
possibility of rather than thinking
about life elsewhere in the
Galaxy given what we know about physics
and Engineering astronomy Etc would it
be possible to build a planet at the
appropriate distance from the Sun that
we could spawn Life by bringing things
there as opposed to trying to take it
you know figure out how to how to do it
at a at a distance that it might not be
amenable to life right you know maybe
creating a garden Planet maybe we don't
put humans there right away um but
trying to create a garden that could
Thrive at the some appropriate distance
from the Sun yeah um and seeing what
what what nutrients could be grown there
you know so you could have robots man
this this plant but you'd have to
somehow aggregate um stuff in space to
build this planet or launch this planet
up that it would collect things I mean
that to me feels like a fun experiment
and a lot less risky than going up up to
other planets um yeah I was I was
blessed as my first guest on the an
impossible podcast that Freeman Dyson
you mentioned with your dad your dad
mentioned him uh one of the greatest
intellects of the of the last hundred
years great physicist he had these ideas
for these Dyson spheres which would be
you know uh energy harvesting so the
first you know ingredient that you need
to construct the the huberman planet uh
uh habitable zone is to have uh is have
energy Harvest as much energy as
possible from a star so he he basically
conjectured a a mega structure an alien
mega structure that could be observable
by astronomers could detect these these
objects and and some have claimed that
we have but those have always been
refuted and it would be basically
surrounding a star capturing every
Photon worth of energy that came out of
it and then converting that to
mechanical energy and then yes and then
once you have Infinite Energy you can
actually do Fusion you can make up
whatever molecules you want you could
make up you know print 3D printing at
the at the Quark level on up basically
and so that was his you know conjecture
of how super Advanced aliens would
behave but again we have no evidence for
it but it's fun it's certainly fun to
have the science fiction you know kind
of you know a lot of interesting science
you know originates from ideas and
creativity that originates from science
fiction so yeah it' be a lot of fun
[Music]