What does really help after a traumatic experience? Should we, directly after a traumatic experience, talk through the traumatic experience again in great detail in a conversation with a psychologist (or another person we trust) so that we can process the experience better? Or might it be better to play Tetris, for example. The answer is perplexing... __________________
Studies and books (only a small selection):
James, E. L., Bonsall, M. B., Hoppitt, L., Tunbridge, E. M., Geddes, J. R., Milton, A. L., & Holmes, E. A. (2015). Computer game play reduces intrusive memories of experimental trauma via reconsolidation-update mechanisms. Psychological science, 26(8), 1201-1215.
Holmes, E. A., & Iyadurai, L. (2020). Can we develop a «cognitive therapeutic vaccine» for the early hours after trauma to prevent the reccurrence of intrusive memories of trauma. Risk Management of Terrorism Induced Stress, 66-71.
Horsch, A., Vial, Y., Favrod, C., Harari, M. M., Blackwell, S. E., Watson, P., ... & Holmes, E. A. (2017). Reducing intrusive traumatic memories after emergency caesarean section: A proof-of-principle randomized controlled study. Behaviour research and therapy, 94, 36-47.
Iyadurai, L., Blackwell, S. E., Meiser-Stedman, R., Watson, P. C., Bonsall, M. B., Geddes, J. R., ... & Holmes, E. A. (2018). Preventing intrusive memories after trauma via a brief intervention involving Tetris computer game play in the emergency department: a proof-of-concept randomized controlled trial. Molecular psychiatry, 23(3), 674-682.
Kanstrup, M., Kontio, E., Geranmayeh, A., Olofsdotter Lauri, K., Moulds, M. L., & Holmes, E. A. (2021). A single case series using visuospatial task interference to reduce the number of visual intrusive memories of trauma with refugees. Clinical psychology & psychotherapy, 28(1), 109-123.
Kessler, H., Schmidt, A. C., James, E. L., Blackwell, S. E., von Rauchhaupt, M., Harren, K., ... & Holmes, E. A. (2020). Visuospatial computer game play after memory reminder delivered three days after a traumatic film reduces the number of intrusive memories of the experimental trauma. Journal of behavior therapy and experimental psychiatry, 67, 101454.
Kessler, H., Holmes, E. A., Blackwell, S. E., Schmidt, A. C., Schweer, J. M., Bücker, A., ... & Kehyayan, A. (2018). Reducing intrusive memories of trauma using a visuospatial interference intervention with inpatients with posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 86(12), 1076.
Lau-Zhu, A., Holmes, E. A., & Porcheret, K. (2018). Intrusive memories of trauma in the laboratory: Methodological developments and future directions. Current Behavioral Neuroscience Reports, 5(1), 61-71.
About the Author: Eskil Burck, a psychology graduate, is a psychological consultant and textbook author. He teaches psychology for Kalaidos University of Applied Sciences (Zurich). His psychology podcast "psychologie-lernen.de" consistently ranked #1 on iTunes in the "Education" category. His books "Angst - was hilft wirklich ...?", "Das manipulierte Gehirn" and "Neue Psychologie der Beeinflussung" became Amazon bestsellers. Even in his spare time, he enjoys reading studies...😅🙈 For more information, visit: www.psychologie-lernen.de
What is more helpful after a traumatic experience?
Talking to a therapist and discussing every single detail
of your experience or playing Tetris?
The answer is absolutely mind-blowing.
In psychology, we know for a very long time
that many psychological disorders like anxiety,
depression, obsessive-compulsive disorder,
and of course, post-traumatic disorder,
often have their roots in traumatic experiences,
like for example, having an accident,
losing a beloved person, or just a very big failure.
So failure, a big mistake, a big error,
which haunts you in your everyday life,
and you always have the question,
could I have done better?
Or why didn't I do this or that?
And knowing that these traumatic experiences
are the genesis for many psychological disorders,
wouldn't it be fantastic if we had
some kind of psychological vaccine,
like for example, a vaccine against rabies,
which we could apply right after a traumatic experience
in order to prevent the development
of a psychological disorder,
like for example, anxiety, depression,
or as I said, a post-traumatic stress disorder.
Fortunately, it seems like that we're not far away
from such a psychological vaccine.
For example, take a look at a study published in 2018,
in which 71 people who had a severe motorcycle accident,
which usually could lead to a post-traumatic stress disorder,
were allowed to play, and I know it sounds really crazy,
but were allowed to play Tetris right after the accident.
More exactly, they were first told,
well, please try to remember your accident
and tell us the most stressing details of this accident.
And by that, their traumatic memory was activated.
And when memories get activated,
they actually enter a changeable state.
And this is really absolutely mind-blowing and fascinating
because in this moment in which they are changeable,
you can intervene by, for example,
providing some visual working memory input,
like for example, playing Tetris.
And this visual input is supposed to interfere
with the old traumatic memory.
I know it sounds absolutely crazy,
but the scientists could show
that right after this intervention,
after playing 20 minutes Tetris,
the motorcyclists experienced 63% less
of so-called intrusive memories.
So those haunting memories that invade our consciousness
were strongly reduced in comparison to a control condition.
And I wouldn't tell you about these
too-good-to-be-true results
if there weren't already some replications.
So for example, in a very recent study published in 2021,
they also could show that right after a week
in comparison to a control condition
in which the participants were listening to podcasts,
again, the intrusive memories were reduced for about 48%.
And after one month, they were even reduced 90%
in comparison to the control condition.
So this approach of memory interference
and memory reconsolidation is in strong contrast
to former first-line treatments after traumatic experiences,
like for example, the so-called psychological debriefing
in which, among other things,
patients were asked to describe in detail
the traumatic experience to a therapist.
But surprisingly, many studies could show
that this therapeutic approach
in which you have to speak about the traumatic event
in order to structure your memory in a better way,
that this approach right after a traumatic experience
was astonishingly ineffective.
And the reason probably is
that by talking about a traumatic experience,
the traumatic memories,
the memory traces of this traumatic experience
become deeper and deeper in your brain,
and therefore the traumatic and problematic memories
are actually becoming stronger and stronger
and more vivid and therefore also more intrusive.
But the new studies about memory reconsolidation
and memory interference and playing Tetris,
for example, after a trauma,
or another approach, for example,
might be the so-called EMDR therapy,
the eye movement desensitization and reprocessing therapy
in which you move your eyes very fast
from one side to the other
and therefore also give yourself a lot of visual input,
a lot of working memory input
that can interfere with your traumatic experiences.
And especially when it comes
to post-traumatic stress disorder,
EMDR could be shown to be at least as effective as CBT,
and in some meta-analyses, it was even more effective.
These new memory reconsolidation
and interference research results show us
that right after a traumatic experience,
and I guess it could be everything
from sexual abuse to bullying situations,
for example, right after such traumatic events,
it seems to be more helpful
to disturb the consolidation of those memories
in order to make them less haunting and less intrusive.
And from that perspective,
let me give you one last real-life example.
Think back to the 2020 European Football Championships
in which Christian Eriksen
had a severe heart attack during a game
and the whole world was witnessing
when he had to be reanimated.
The pictures were really horrible,
and it was, especially for the players,
a very traumatic experience.
Right after the game, there were very strong discussions
about whether it was the right decision to keep on playing,
because after a break, the players were asked
and they decided to keep on playing.
From the perspective of today's study results,
I think this actually has been a perfect decision
because the new visual input they got by playing
probably interfered with their traumatic memories,
because playing football,
especially in such a demanding game and important game,
was very taxing for their visual working memory.
And maybe the decision to keep on playing
was even very good for us as an audience,
because for us, the pictures, of course,
were also very distressing.
And probably it was better for us
to watch a second halftime
instead of making a big break in the program
and to show the pictures of the heart attack
of Christian Eriksen again and again.
So whenever you experience a very traumatic event,
keep in mind that it might be better to do something
that demands a lot of visual working memory
instead of reliving the traumatic memory again and again.
I hope you enjoyed this episode.
Of course, there will have to be more evidence
on these new results,
and there will have to be a lot of clinical studies.
But as I said, we already have a lot of evidence,
for example, when it comes to EMDR.
So actually, the idea of memory reconsolidation
is already quite robust.
I hope you enjoyed this episode.
Of course, feel free to take a look at the books
or at the website, and maybe we will see you next time.