Psychology: What's in a name? Persuasion perhaps?

www.LearningPsychology.net
87 followers
3 Video Views·Jan 29, 2025
If we get to know that somebody shares his name with us, we tend to help this person. Especially if it's a unusual name. Of course this can be used by sales people to influence us...
Author: Eskil Burck (degreed psychologist)
www.learningpsychology.net
But telling somebody that you have the same name as him or her might not only
increase your chances to get more money for something, but it also might have another
quite funny effect. It might lead them to imitate you more. That's at least the result of a study
by Guygain and Matin from the year 2009 published in the journal Social Psychology. The title of
was Incidental Similarity Facilitates Behavioral Mimicry. And what they did was to conduct two
experiments with all in all 94 subjects. And the subjects were told, well, our study is about
first impressions. So we will show you a two minute lasting video in which a student is
interviewed. And in one experiment, the interviewed student surprisingly had exactly
the same name as the participant. And in the second experiment, the student did not have the
same name, but was in the same field of study. So as all participants were students from business
administration, half of them were told, well, this is a student from business administration.
And the other half was told, this is a student from sociology. What the participants did not know
was that they themselves were videotaped when they watched the videos. So the webcam of the
laptop was running all the time, so that all their movements could be analyzed afterwards.
And it turned out that when the participants felt some kind of connection to the interviewed student,
like when they thought she has the same name, or when they thought, well, she's also a student
from business administration, they more often imitated her behavior. Because the interviewed
student was told to scratch or to touch her face five times during the interview. As it turned out,
those participants who thought they had a connection, they also more often scratched
or touched their own face. So this study shows us that perceived similarity causes
imitation, social imitation. And in future episodes, we will hear a lot of evidence that
it's also the other way around, that when you verbally or non-verbally imitate somebody,
he or she gets the impression that you are somewhat alike. And this also improves your
chances that the other person will be compliant to your requests. But as I said, this will be the
topic of future episodes. Let's first take a look at more evidence on the effects of incidental
similarity. And therefore, let's take a look at the study by Garner, published in 2005
in the Journal of Consumer Psychology. The title of the study was, What's in a Name? Persuasion,
perhaps. And in this study, 160 subjects, 100 students, and 60 university employees
received a letter with the request to fill out a questionnaire. And everybody who has ever
conducted a survey and sent out questionnaires knows that sometimes the return rate is quite
disappointing. So what they did in this study was that half of the subjects received a covering
letter with the name and the signature of the allegedly responsible experimenter,
which in one condition had exactly the same name as the subject, and in the control condition,
it was a different name. And it turned out that when the participants thought,
well, this guy has the same name as I have, about 45 percent were willing to fill out the
questionnaire, whereas in the control condition, only about 24 percent sent back the questionnaire.
Similar results were found in a little study with only 50 subjects. This time, the participants
were sent an email to participate in a short survey, which would last about 15 to 20 minutes.
And if the sender of the email had the same name as the participant,
the return rate was again much higher. It was about twice as high. But as I said,
this was only a really small study. It's more interesting to take a look at the next study,
which was a really huge study because they did not only have 50 participants, they had 2,960
participants. And all these participants were contacted via email and were also asked to
participate in a short survey. And the topic of the survey was quite innocent. It was only about
the mascot of the local sports team. So the participants were told, well, for a study
project, we are interested in the mascot of your sports team. Please tell us the name of your
mascot, and maybe you can tell us some funny information about the mascot. And again, the name
of the sender of the email varied between the conditions. In the control condition, of course,
the sender had a different name. In the first experimental condition, they had the same first
name. In the second experimental condition, they had the same surname. And in the fourth
experimental condition, they had the same first name and the same surname. And it turned out,
and it turned out when they had the same first name, the compliance rate already almost doubled
in comparison to the control condition. And when they had the same surname, the compliance rate
almost tripled. And when they had, but when they had the same first name and the same
surname, the compliance rate was almost six times higher than in the control condition.
And what is especially interesting about this study, aside the fact that the more similar,
the higher the compliance rate, it was also observed that the effect was even higher
when the sender and the participant shared unusual names. And this effect was especially
high for women, for which a compliance rate of about 27% was observed when they thought,
well, the other person has the same name, the same unusual name as I have.
