Depression: Exercise for Depression? - Part 2

www.LearningPsychology.net
87 followers
27 Video Views·Jan 29, 2025
http://www.learningpsychology.net
Some of the most influential experiments were conducted by James Blumenthal et al. (1999; 2007).
In their studies one group of participants recieved antidepressants (Sertraline) whereas another group was running on a treadmill...
The first really huge study that was conducted to compare physical exercise and antidepressants
was conducted by James Blumenthal and colleagues in 1999. The title of the study was
effects of exercise training on older patients with major depression. So obviously the intervention
was aimed at older adults aged 50 to 77. All in all they had 156 participants who were attracted
via advertisement for example in newspapers. They wrote well we want to conduct a study
on the effects of aerobic exercise on depression and in a way this is a weakness of this study
because probably only those participants decide to take part in this kind of study who are generally
open to exercise. So it's a bit questionable whether the results can be generalized
for the whole population. Besides that the methodological procedure was very good.
All 156 participants were randomly assigned to three experimental conditions.
One group received aerobic exercise. They met three times per week for about 45 minutes
for a supervised group session in walking or running. The second group received an antidepressant.
They received Sertraline which is a commonly used antidepressant and the third group is also
very interesting because in this group the participants received both treatments. They
did not only receive the antidepressant but they also exercised exactly the same time
as the first group. So for this group in fact they expected the biggest results.
The treatment duration for all three groups was 16 weeks. So after 16 weeks of treatment
they diagnosed of course not knowing to which group the participants belonged so they were
blinded. They diagnosed the remission rates. So which of the participants were no longer regarded
as clinically depressed. Well it turned out that in the aerobic exercise group about 47 percent
were no longer diagnosed with MDD major depressive disorder. Quite surprisingly exactly the same
result turned out for the combined group for the group that received aerobic exercise and
antidepressants. In this group the remission rate was also about 47 percent. What about the
antidepressant group? Well this group was a little bit but really only a little bit better. In this
group the remission rate was about 56 percent. Now you might say well 56 percent in comparison 47
percent. Hey that's obviously better. Yeah numerically it's better but it was far from
being significant. So maybe this difference was just due to chance. Of course maybe if they had
more participants much more participants they would have more power to see whether this numerical
difference was really a significant one. But nevertheless it was definitely far from being
a big difference. As I said it was far from being significant. So this is really exciting stuff
because antidepressants can have a lot of side effects. For example they can affect sexual
functioning whereas aerobic exercise has as well some side effects. But these side effects are all
positive. I mean it makes your heart stronger, it makes your bones stronger, it strengthens your
immune system and it even seems to have positive effects in relation to cancer. So a long list of
positive side effects.
Even though these results are really promising and really interesting this study from Blumenthal
and colleagues was criticized. Why? Because they had no placebo group and therefore the
critique said well you can't be sure whether the results are due to social effects for example.
Because think about it the participants who were exercising exercised in groups in supervised
group sessions and maybe this feeling of belonging to a group being accepted and having others who
are in the same situation. Maybe this is the positive effect of the aerobic exercise intervention.
Well to rule out this possibility Blumenthal and colleagues conducted a second even bigger and
better study in 2007. This study was published in psychosomatic medicine and the title of the
study was exercise and pharmacotherapy in the treatment of major depressive disorder.
This time they had even more participants. They had 202 subjects, 153 women, 49 men and the average
age was 53 years. All the participants just like in the previous study were physical inactive
participants. So we have to keep in mind that all the effects probably would not occur at least not
to this extent in participants who are already physical active. Again the participants were
randomly assigned to this time four experimental groups. They had one aerobic exercise group which
was in fact exactly the same like in the first study. They were exercising in supervised group
sessions three times per week for 45 minutes on a treadmill. The second group was also a aerobic
exercise group but this time the participants were exercising alone at home. They should practice for
exactly the same amount three times per week for 45 minutes and the idea behind this experimental
condition was quite obvious. They wanted to make sure to have a group that was not that much
socially supported so they could make sure that in this group so they could make sure that the
effects are also present when the factor social support is no longer present. The third group was
just like in the previous study a antidepressant pill group. They received Sertraline and the fourth
group was as many researchers had said you need this kind of group. The fourth group was the
placebo group. This group received a placebo antidepressant pill. Again the treatment duration
was 16 weeks and after 16 weeks they again took a look at the remission rates. How many of the
participants could no longer be regarded as clinically depressed. Well those participants
who had practiced in the supervised group showed a remission rate of 45 percent. Those participants
who had practiced at home had a remission rate of 40 percent. This was just a numerical difference.
It was not statistically significant but I wouldn't be surprised if with a bigger number
of participants maybe this difference would become significant because of course the group
has a positive effect and furthermore it was observed that participants who exercised at home
probably did not exercise that hard. But what about the antidepressant group? Well again just like in
the study conducted in 1999 there was no significant difference. They had a remission rate of 47 percent.
And what about the placebo group? Those participants who were told that they were receiving
an antidepressant pill but in fact it was just a sugar pill. Well the remission rate in this group
was 31 percent. Also not that bad. I mean think about it 31 percent with a sugar pill
that's not bad. Why is there such a big effect? Well first of all there are spontaneous remissions
over time so after being depressed for a while usually some people's moods just get better
and on the other hand the placebo pill group was also in contact with the experimenter for example
telling them well my pill does not really work that well and then the experimenter talks about
possible reasons and then they decide well maybe we have to increase the dose and this kind of
contact can also have a positive effect. So it's called placebo effect but in fact there are also
some other psychological mechanisms at play. Well to sum this all up in my opinion I think
it's quite interesting to see that a quite simple aerobic exercise treatment of three times per week
for 45 minutes for 16 weeks can have a similar effect as antidepressants but I think and that's
also found in some studies I think there might be even stronger effects possible. For example if we
send the participants in the woods instead of letting them run on a treadmill because especially
some recent asian studies could show that forest bathing the japanese call it shinrin yoku can have
positive effects as well and so one could combine the positive effects of being in the nature and
aerobic exercise and I guess even bigger effects might also be possible for individualized
treatments. For example some people don't like aerobic exercise they like playing football,
baseball, tennis, beach volleyball, basketball, whatever and probably it's much better for them to
do the sport that they really enjoy.
