Psychology: Does Mental Practice Really Work? (3/3) - Mental Training in Surgery

www.LearningPsychology.net
87 followers
Jan 29, 2025
www.learningpsychology.net
Inspired by positive results in sport psychology more and more
scientists wondered: Can mental training be applied to other areas?
Mental Training seems especially promising for the training of surgeons.
Similar to athletes, surgeons have to perform complex movements under high pressure.
First studies (e.g. Immenroth et al., 2007) yielded promising results.
we finished this episode with a nice
example for a transfer from mental
practice in sports psychology to mental
practice in
surgery
this is a quite new research field but
it really makes sense because many
movements many
scripts you have to follow in surgery
are quite complicated and
demanding and demanding movements and
especially for this kind of movement
mental practice seems to be
helpful
and one of the first studies in which
mental training or mental practice was
tested in surgical education
was the study by mark immenhold and
colleagues published in 2007 in the
journal
annals of surgery
all in all 98 surgeons participated in
this study
which was conducted during a training
course
offered by the european surgical
institute
at the beginning of the study a pre-test
had to be conducted to see the baseline
abilities of the surgeons
therefore all participants performed a
videotaped laparoscopic cholecystectomy
which is the removal of the gallbladder
using a mini camera
of course they were not practicing on
real patients they were practicing on a
simulator which is called pelvic trainer
after this pretest they were randomly
assigned to three experimental
conditions the first group received on
the one hand practical training
all groups received practical training
but in addition this first group
received mental training
on the first day 90 minutes
instructed by a
experienced and also in mental practice
experienced surgeon
on the second day right before the post
test a second 30-minute
mental training session was conducted
again supervised by a
experienced surgeon
so all in all only 120
minutes of treatment
the second group received as i said also
practical training plus
more practical training
while
the other group received mental practice
they received actual practical training
just like the mental training group on
day one they practiced 90 minutes
but on the second day
and this is probably the reason why
in the post-test this group was not
better than the mental practice group
on the second day they for example
were just reading scientific articles
for 30 minutes so right before the
intervention they did not receive more
practical training
the third group received also practical
training but no additional practical
training
so this was the control group
after the treatment the
three groups again performed
a videotaped laparoscopic
cholecystectomy the removal of the
gallbladder
and as all these operations were
videotaped
the experimenters could show these
operations to other experienced surgeons
who had no idea in which group the
participants had been
so when they showed the videotaped
operations to the surgeons they said
those participants who had practiced
mentally
were on average significantly better in
performing
some of the really important movements
they were not better in all variables
that were assessed
but at least there were some trends
and i think these results are quite
interesting
even though as i said the research field
is still developing
i think it really makes sense because
the movements you have to learn as a
surgeon
can be quite complicated can be
complicated like learning some demanding
dance movements
and therefore mental practice
could be helpful even though of course
surgeons and dentists
already practice with a lot of
simulators
like for example the pelvic trainer that
was used in this study
and this kind of
real practical training is highly
effective but sometimes additional
mental practice can have
positive effects
you
