Join my mailing list: https://briankeating.com/yt to win a meteorite 💥! Have you ever seen the sun turn green? It’s not a camera trick, not an illusion—it’s the incredible Green Flash.
Recently, I went on Andrew Huberman’s podcast (@hubermanlab), and we explored how the human eye perceives sunlight. Andrew is an expert in the human eye and neuro-optical systems, so it was a real treat to get to explore this phenomenon with one of the world's foremost experts.
During our conversation, Andrew asked, Could the green flash merely be a trick of human physiology or psychology? Today, we'll explore why his hypothesis is not entirely correct and the science behind the phenomena.
I’ve captured this rare emerald glow over 16 times, and in this episode, I’ll teach you how you can see it for yourself. We’ll dive deep into the science behind this phenomenon, bust some myths, and even discuss how climate change is playing a role in its visibility.
Along the way, I’ll share the fascinating physics that explains why the sun’s peak color is green (even though it looks yellow to our eyes) and how the interplay of refraction, dispersion, and Rayleigh scattering creates the Green Flash.
Plus, you’ll get my go-to settings for both smartphones and DSLRs to photograph it like a pro. Key Takeaways:
00:00 Intro 00:13 Understanding the Green Flash 02:14 The Color of the Sun 04:20 Refraction and Dispersion 06:19 Scattering and Its Effects 08:35 Climate Change and the Green Flash 10:54 Capturing the Green Flash 13:16 Best Places to View the Green Flash
have you ever seen the sun turn green
it's not an illusion it's a rare real
and stunning effect and today I'll show
you why the Green Flash happens debunk
some common myths and teach you how to
capture it yourself the Green Flash is a
fascinating Confluence of astronomy
planetary physics atmospheric Optics and
even a little bit of global warming
thrown in just for good measure I've
actually captured the Green Flash over
16 times using a method I'll share with
you today over the next few minutes
you'll learn how to find the perfect
conditions use just two simple camera
settings and understand why this rare
moment of emerald jeweled Beauty occurs
green flashes are real and they're
spectacular they're real and they're
spectacular recently I had the honor of
appearing on Andrew huberman's hubman
Lab podcast and we explored how the
human eye perceives light now Andrew is
an expert in the human eye and neuro
Optical systems so it was a real treat
to get to explore this phenom on with
the one of the world's greatest experts
during our conversation Andrew asked
could the Green Flash merely be a trick
of human physiology or psychology the
idea was that if you're looking at
something that's very enriched in Long
wavelengths like orange red and you
stare at it for long enough one
biological explanation is that the the
Sun is setting and you're looking at
this orange red thing when the sun is
low in the sky you can actually look at
it uh without um distressing your eyes
right because right as opposed to
overhead when you should never stare at
the Sun
and then the moment that that reddish
orange disappears The the biological
explanation is that there's a a kind of
perception of a green flash yeah because
of the opponent seeing to switch to the
other let's just say wavelength channel
so to speak today we'll explore while
his hypothesis is not quite correct and
explore the deeper sence behind the
phenomenon let's get started the first
time I saw the Green Flash I was 18
years old staring at the Horizon during
a picture perfect sunset on the Pacific
coast that moment sparked my love for
astronomy and made me want to capture
these ephemeral Emerald Vistas for all
my life now Sailors have been talking
about these for Generations Jules Vern
actually immortalized the Green Flash in
a book called The Green Ray calling it a
signal of true love but beyond the
romance or Bromance scientists have been
fascinating by the green flash for
centuries it was dismissed as a sailor's
myth until the 19th century when
atmospheric Optics helped explain its
Origins yet even today most people
haven't seen it or even heard of it and
very very few people can understand why
it occurs now first I want to take a
quick detour the sun's color why does it
look yellowish white to our eyes when in
fact it's actually green that's a hint
as to the ultimate resolution of this
atmospheric phenomenon the Green Flash
gives us an opportunity to explore a
common misconception what color is the
sun really I actually did a poll on X
formerly known as Twitter and I asked
over 50,000 of my followers what color
is the sun you think that would be a
non-controversial question but only 16%
of people got it right well the Sun
appears yellowish white to us as I
explained its peak radiation output is
actually in the green part of the
spectrum this is because the sun is a
nearly perfect black body radiator an
object that emits and absorbs at all
wavelengths the distribution of this
radiation was first described in the
early 1900s by Max plank himself and
it's described Now by what we call
Plank's law which has a peak wavelength
that is inverse ly proportional to the
object's temperature the higher the
temperature the shorter the wavelength
or the higher the frequency the sun's
surface temperature is approximately
5800 Kelvin and according to Wan's
displacement law where the temperature T
is in kelvin the peak wavelength for the
sun is about 500 nanometers or 5,000
angstroms this puts it squarely in the
green color of the electromagnetic
spectrum so why does the Sun not look
green is it because I'm smoking too much
of that green leaf
[Music]
no it's because the sun emits light
across the broad spectrum and when this
light combines from yellow to green to
blue to indigo violet and even with red
it appears white or slightly yellowish
due to atmospheric scattering which
we'll explain shortly now our sun is a
star and stars follow a very interesting
color temperature relationship called
the herzsprung Russell diagram or HR
diagram red stars like Bal juice are
cooler around 3,500 Kelvin now blue
stars in the same constellation of Orion
like Riel are much hotter over 10,000
Kelvin the HR diagram Maps these
relationships revealing a star's life
cycle and its energy output the Green
Flash is a complicated Optical
phenomenon resulting from refraction
dispersion and scattering let's break it
down step by step first refraction when
sunlight passes from the vacuum of space
into the Earth's atmosphere it bends due
to changes in density the Earth's
atmosphere acts like a giant lens and
near the Horizon this bending is
exaggerated because of the local
appearance of the curved Earth appearing
flat now don't give any fluers any ideas
the Earth is a curved surface and that's
actually also indicated by the fact that
when you see the sun go below the
Horizon as shown here it's actually
below the physical Horizon and that
occurred at least 8 minutes ago and
actually more like 10 to 20 minutes ago
due to the refractive properties of the
Earth's atmosphere each layer of the
Earth atmosphere shown here has a
slightly different refractive index
objects with different refractive
indices whether it's glass or water or
lead crystal refracts light or bends
light more strongly with higher and
higher refractive index then the
refractive index is related to What's
called the dialectric constant of the
material so high dialectric constant
materials like diamonds have very high
refractive indices they have very high
dialectric constants they're actually
related by a square root function
refraction at the Horizon also depends
on the optical path Ling which increases
dramatically as the sun approaches The
Horizon this extended path causes the
sun to appear slightly higher in the sky
than it actually is lengthening the time
we see it and further enhancing
refractive effects now we come to the
second effect dispersion dispersion is a
separation of light into its constituent
wavelengths this what you're familiar
with a prism or a rainbow doing shorter
wavelengths like green and blue Bend
more than longer wavelengths like red
and orange the refractive index for a
wavelength Lambda can be modeled using
the so-called couchi equation A and C
here are material specific constants as
the sun nears at Horizon dispersion
isolates green light for a brief moment
however blue and violet light which are
refracted even more than green are
scattered out before they can reach
their eyes due to scattering effects the
third major atmospheric Optical effect
is called scattering in this case it's
called Rae scattering this explains why
blue and violet barely reach our eyes
during the Green Flash ra scattering is
the effect of particles smaller than the
wavelength of light causing scattering
of the light and it's very very strongly
wavelength dependent except it depends
as the inverse fourth power of the
wavelength so wavelengths that are
roughly two times as long like red
compared to Blue Light scatter 16 times
more this leaves a net deficit of blue
and indigo light from the otherwise
primary black body function leaving
green Left Behind as the shortest
wavelength that's visible to the eye and
that ends up dominating what we see
there's another type of scattering
called my scattering or me scattering M
caused by larger particles like dust and
aerosols this scatters all wavelengths
equally because the particles are like
giant chunks of light so they scatter
and block and obscure all light the same
this has the net effect of muting the
green Flash's intensity particularly in
polluted or human conditions there are
many many other effects such as the
famous Mirage effects where temperature
gradients in the atmosphere bend light
creating mirages you've seen that on hot
desert roads perhaps or in wandering
through the desert searching for an
oasis the superior mirages where cold
air lies below warm air can amplify the
Green Flash by actually stretching it
vertically or extending its duration
so-called inferior mirages can distort
or even split the flash into multiple
bands you sometimes see that in layers
where the sun will actually look like a
pyramid or a ziggurat a stack of
horizontal slabs now the Earth's
curvature plays a role as well this is
because the curvature is actually
ensuring that the optical path length
increases near the Horizon creating
conditions for extreme refraction and
dispersion a flat Earth model would fail
to produce these effects because the
atmospheric thickness would remain
constant across the Horizon there'd be
no dimunition or limb dimming as you get
away from say the direct path between
you and the sun now in the beginning I
mentioned the effect of climate change
what role does it play The Green Flash
is not necessarily associated with the
green movement don't worry in fact the
Green Flash is a natural phenomenon but
human activity does shape it slightly in
ways that make it more or less visible
first of all when fossil fuels are
burned they release aerosols tiny
particles that contribute to me
scattering as I said before this mutes
all colors including the green color in
highly polluted areas like those
neighbors to the north where Andrew
lives Los Angeles but AOS can also
enhance sunsets creating the Deep Reds
that make the green flash even more
prominent against the red or orangish
Hue in the Horizon I'm not advocating
for more carbon dioxide emissions but as
they continue expect sunsets to get
redder and the green flash to get
slightly mutter relative to what it
would be in the absence of these aerosol
particles now there's a far more serious
consequence that was discovered here at
scrips institution of oceanography by
colleagues that work on atmospheric
global climate change and the effects of
cloud cover you see cloud cover is the
bane of the Green Flash Watchers
existence the Green Flash cannot be seen
when there are clouds anywhere near
where the Sun is setting on the horizon
and scientists here and elsewhere
suspect that more climate change means
more clouds more moisture in the
atmosphere and perhaps a diminution or
reduction altogether of the green flash
phenomenon depending on where you are so
this is also a reminder of how closely
the earth's climate and our atmosphere
are connected through these moments of
fleeting Beauty like this atmospheric
phenomenon as I said in the beginning
during our 5H hour plus conversation
Andrew huberman hypothesized that maybe
the Green Flash could be a physiological
effect or psychological effect of the
human's brain visual system while our
eyes are exceptional tools the Green
Flash isn't just visible to humans it
can be captured by digital cameras this
proves once and for all that it's a
physical Optical phenomenon now I bring
this to you as an example of what I call
Hammer Theory and that's the famous
saying that when all you have as a
hammer everything starts to look like a
nail now Andrew has many Tools in his
toolkit he has a deep understanding of
human Vision that has naturally shaped
his worldview and his hypothesis of the
origin of the Green Flash but as
scientists he and I both know that our
job is to test hypothesis with evidence
so that brings us to how you can capture
the Green Flash yourself using a simple
camera system now let's break down the
how to capture the Green Flash with both
a smartphone and a DSLR I'm going to
give you just two critical settings for
each that's all you're going to need to
focus on get it first let's start with
your smartphone forget what you've heard
about needing expensive gear I've
captured stunning green flashes with
just my iPhone and you could do it too
even if you're a heathen with one of
those Android devices the first crucial
setting is exposure lock about 30
seconds before Sunset press and hold
your finger on the brightest part of the
sky near the sun you'll see a lock
indicator appear this prevents your
phone from constantly adjusting
exposures which would otherwise ruin the
shot the second key setting is raw mode
not raw dogging no on an iPhone enable
Pro raw in your camera settings Android
users you can switch to PR mode this
gives you much more detail to work with
later this is very significant when
capturing something as ephemeral and
subtle as the Emerald like green flash
now for DSLR or mirrorless camera users
we're keeping it just as simple two
settings that's it first switch to
aperture priority mode that's usually
indicated by a or a with a little V on
your dial set it to about f8 I've tested
most every aperture and f8 gives you the
perfect balance of sharpness and light
Gathering ability any wider and you risk
overexposure any narrower and you lose
critical light and it becomes too dim
now the second setting for a DSLR camera
is to lock your ISO or ISO at 100 don't
use auto ISO it'll try to compensate for
the dropping light and that will ruin
your shot as well at ISO 100 you'll
capture the cleanest possible image with
little to no digital noise to muddy the
green flash now everything else can say
on default settings white balance leave
it on daylight Focus set it once on the
sun and leave it on image stabilization
turn it off if you're on a tripod now I
only know these settings are successful
because I failed thousands of times
testing everything else you don't have
to learn it the hard way these four
settings total two per camera type are
all you need need to focus on just to
recap for smartphones exposure lock and
raw mode for dslrs f8 and ISO 100 that's
it don't let anyone tell you it's more
complicated than that next what's the
best place to view the Green Flash well
it's best viewed in locations with clear
Horizons and stable weather like Hawaii
or California's Pacific Coast because
it's dry frequently there as is also a
desert the Green Flash occurs at both
sunset and sunrise but it's much easier
to see at Sunset as you're already
tracking the sun's descent it's very
hard to know exactly where the Sun is
going to come above the Horizon and you
need to catch that at Sunrise and know
exactly where it's coming up it can be
done and some of you on the East Coast
can catch This Magnificent appearance
for my extrema files out there the South
Pole offers perhaps the best place on
Earth to witness the Green Flash there
because the fact that the sun is slowly
sinking towards the horizon spiraling
around it actually takes hours to cross
the Horizon from the disc of the sun's
bottom to disc of the sun's top that's
only half a degree in angular diameter
but you can see that lasting for several
hours as it traverses the Horizon
meaning you can watch the Green Flash
for hours but be careful in order to be
there you have to be there at Sunset
which occurs just once a year on March
21st now if you miss the Green Flash or
you catch it I don't know which would be
better or worse you're going to have to
stay there until November because planes
can't get in or out of the South Pole
between those two periods without their
hydraulic fluids and their actual jet
fuel
solidifying and becoming a unworkable
mess so planes don't land or take off
there in the winter which is where you'd
be there after you see the sun set
that's the beginning of fall March 21st
down there and you won't see it again
arise above until September 21st I talk
about that phenomenon in my first book
losing the Nobel Prize if you happen to
catch the Green Flash yourself you may
make your friends Green With Envy I like
your explanation better now I know if
you've enjoyed this conversation you're
going to enjoy my conversation with
Andrew huberman on his podcast but
you're also going to make enjoy these
videos that I've made featuring the
physics behind the eye telescopes and
the secrets of stargazing click here and
I'll see you in our next adventure