5 Housing Market WARNING Signs in 2025

Money Mansions
1 follower
16 Video Views·Jan 18, 2025
Watch these 5 housing market warning signs if you want to be a better buyer, seller, investor, or even realtor in 2025!
Today, I'm giving you five housing market warning signs for
2025 that you can't ignore.
The goal of me showing you these five warning signs is to help make you a
better buyer, seller, investor, heck even realtor.
So let's get to the first warning sign.
But first, my name is Jason Ferrier.
I am a realtor.
I am an investor just outside of Columbus, Ohio.
I appreciate you joining me on today's video.
Do me a favor, comment below.
I want to know what's happening in your local housing market.
I'm going to use the latest Redfin data update to show you
these five warning signs.
So let's get into this update that Redfin just published on January 9th.
All right.
So the title of this update is home tours rise modestly to start 2025, but
that hasn't translated into more sales.
That's true.
You should know that demand is still low and that's kind of one of the first
warning signs we're going to talk about, but I'm not going to read this update.
I'm not going to read their, uh, their summary of their article.
I'm going to instead jump to their data because this is the
most important part folks.
And so I just mentioned, uh, buying demand, and this is the first warning
sign I want to cover with you guys.
So daily average 30 year fixed mortgage rate, 7.17%.
This is part of home buying demand.
And this is definitely one of my five warning signs, interest rates, mortgage
interest rates right now, folks are high, high compared to recent standards.
Right?
I mean, historically they're not high, but when you think about the
last decade, they're definitely high.
A lot of people thought they would drop, you know, underneath 6% over the last
six months, but they, they kind of got to that low 6% number, but then shot back
up and now they're at 7.17%.
So comment below.
I want to know, do you think mortgage rates will drop substantially in 2025?
Most experts don't think they will.
I don't think they will.
I think they're going to hover in the six and a half at the low point, maybe as high.
I mean, brace yourself.
It could get as high as 8%.
So this, the fact that mortgage rates are high right now, comparatively
to the, you know, the last few years, that's definitely a warning sign.
It's a warning sign for a buyer because it's like, man, rates don't look
like they're coming down anytime soon.
So if you're sitting around waiting for mortgage rates to crash, you may be
waiting for, for years, you could be waiting, who knows, right?
I mean, they could crash, but in 2025, but all indications are they're not going to.
So that's definitely a warning sign.
Um, if you're a buyer, if you're a seller, that's definitely a warning sign
because shoot, you know, that buyers out there are having to contend with
these high mortgage rates, you better price your home, right?
You better price it out of the gate correctly.
Don't overprice your home or it will sit on the market more than likely.
And you can see, according to Redfin, the highest level since may that, I
mean, it's just mortgage rates are crazy, right?
It's actually up from 6.75 last year.
Now look at this.
This is another warning sign mortgage purchase applications.
They're down 7% from a week earlier.
They're down 15% year over year.
That's home buying demand.
Now, this is a big warning sign.
If you're a seller, why?
Well, if you have less people applying for mortgages, it means there's
less buyers on the market.
Less people probably going to see your home that you've just listed.
So you better list that home correctly.
It better be dialed in and don't have foolish optimism
about your, about your home price.
Your neighbor sold their house for 450 grand.
Don't price yours at 500 grand just because it's a few months later
and you think your house is better.
Everyone thinks their house is better than their neighbors.
Everyone, generally speaking, a lot of times it's about the same.
Or not as good, but people just don't want to believe that sellers.
A lot of times we'll say, nah, mine's better.
I have a, you know, I've got a finished basement and they don't know, but they
have an amazing backyard and they've got another 500 square feet
in an extra full bathroom.
So you have to price your home, right?
So mortgage purchase applications being down 7% shows you buying demands down.
Now it's, it's really not a warning sign for buyers necessarily.
Because buyers could look at this and go, well, there's
less competition out there.
That's kind of a good thing for buyers in this case, but it is
definitely a warning sign for sellers and home buying demand.
So mortgage purchase applications down.
All right.
Now we're going to look at, um, this is another indication of demand.
Uh, Google searches for homes.
It's up 29% from a month earlier.
So what, but it's down 8% year over year, meaning year over year, less
people looking for homes on Google, just less interest in the housing market.
Okay.
Median sale price in the U S right now, 379,988.
This is a, I highlighted this in red.
It's a warning sign.
This is my second, I guess, third big warning sign right now.
Median sale price continues to be sticky.
And you're going to see that more in a minute in the charts, but it's
up five and a half percent to start the year.
So home prices haven't come down yet.
All right. So that's median sale price.
It's not crashing folks.
Prices are not crashing.
Why?
Because sales are in the toilet.
Meaning there aren't a lot of transactions and because there
aren't a lot of transactions.
You can't really free up the market in order to have any type of price
discovery and really the people that are listing their homes right now
have a reason to list their homes.
And you'll see that right now in the next warning sign.
So pending sales, new listings and active listings.
This is my third, fourth, and fifth warning sign.
So pending sales, 50,445.
It's down 3.1% year over year.
That's the biggest decline since September, meaning pending sales.
And when that pending is when a house goes into contract, they're, they're
less than they were last year.
And last year was horrible.
And the year before was worse than the year before.
And the year before was horrible as well.
So there aren't a lot of transactions.
This is a big warning sign.
If you're a realtor, it means that shoot, there aren't a lot
of people buying and selling homes.
There's not a lot of homes going into contract.
But if you are a seller, this is also a warning sign because it means
there's not a whole lot of people out there feverishly buying homes.
If there were a lot of people, you would see that number a lot higher.
As a buyer though, this could mean that there's actually opportunity out
there, right, because there's less people out there trying to buy a home.
New listings.
Um, new listings are down two and a half percent biggest
decline in over a year.
Big, big warning sign.
Even honestly, as a buyer or a seller, as a buyer, it could
be a warning sign that shoot.
There are less houses to choose from when there's no new listings.
There's less competition on the market, less houses to choose from.
That's not really good.
If you're a buyer, if you're a seller and you have to sell your home, it
could mean that you have a good opportunity to sell it because there's
less competition, but at the, on the other hand, it also means there's
less, you know, market, uh, movement.
There's less transactions going on.
And so when you see that number 44, five 19, that's not going to cut it
because it's underneath pending sales.
It means pending sales are outpacing new listings.
We're taking away more houses than we're adding to the market.
Comment below, tell me what you think about that.
It's just crazy to me, but nonetheless, we're down in new listings.
There's a lot of people out there that I've heard on YouTube predict of this
wave of inventory, exploding inventory in the market.
I keep looking for it.
Don't see it now.
Real estate's hyperlocal.
This is national stuff, but still nationally, you would think if there
was a wave of distressed people, a wave of foreclosures, you would
see that in the new listing.
Ain't seeing it folks.
All right.
Active listing, another warning sign.
892,000 active listings under a million.
10.6% up year over year.
You're going to see that in the graph in a minute.
It's headed down.
We need more active listings to have price correction.
So as a buyer, big warning sign, keep this warning.
Not a lot of active listings, not a lot of homes on the market.
If you're a seller and you can price your home, right?
That's a good thing because there's less competition.
All right.
So we'll go through a few more data points here.
Um, and then take a look at the graphs and then look at some local markets
where you can apply these five warning signs to your local market.
All right.
Months of supply, 4.3 months of supply.
That's how long we have of the current homes on the market, uh,
to sell if we didn't add any more.
Um, that's really indicative of the fact that homes are sitting longer.
It doesn't mean there's more supply.
Cause I just showed you there's not, it just means homes are sitting longer.
The ones that are on the market share of homes off the market in two weeks or less.
22 and a half percent.
That's down from 23% of homes are sitting longer.
Median days on market, more indication that homes are sitting longer,
49 days up six days, year over year.
22% of homes are still selling though.
Look at this.
22% of homes are still selling over this price.
Nuts, right?
Even though that's down 24 from 24%.
Right.
Uh, last year people were still 22% of the time paying above list price.
Average sale price, uh, sale to list price ratio, 98.2%.
That's essentially unchanged.
So, um, we will do this as well.
We'll do some, uh, Metro level highlights.
This is where they talk about the best metros and the worst metros in the U S.
And, um, this can kind of give you an idea of some local flavor, but again,
we're going to dive into some very local charts here at the end.
Um, median sale price.
I highlighted this as red as.
Uh, one of the warning signs because it declined in one Metro.
Meaning median sale price went up in 49 of the top 50 metros.
That's what this is.
They look at the top 50 metros.
Can you believe that declined in one Metro only?
That's a warning sign.
If you're a buyer, you're a buyer.
That's a red alert.
Like man, prices are not crashing.
I have this conversation with clients all the time.
They're like, man, if somebody's serious about buying a house, they start to come
to the realization that, wow, we've been looking at houses for a while, Jason.
And it doesn't look like prices are coming down.
Are they?
No, they're not.
At least not in Columbus.
I mean, some of them are sitting a little longer if they're overpriced, but in
general prices are not, you know, crashing.
So waiting a year, you know, if you, if you were going to buy when rates are six
and a half percent and prices are here and now rates are here and prices are
here, oops, it now just costs you more money for waiting, but that's just the
way it is sometimes I guess.
Right.
All right.
So the areas where median sale price is growing the most Milwaukee, Cleveland,
Warren, Michigan, Philadelphia, and Nassau County, New York, Austin, Texas,
the only Metro in the U S top 50 that, that declined.
All right.
Pending sales were pending.
Sales went up the most adding housing supply to the market.
I'm sorry.
Pending sales went up the most taking away supply from the market.
You've got Anaheim, California, Cincinnati, San Jose, Portland,
Oregon, and Montgomery County PA.
And then where pending sales went down, where there was less activity, Orlando,
Houston, Fort Lauderdale, Miami, Nashville.
So pending sales increased in nine of the metros, new listings.
This is one of those, you know, big warning signs to watch out for.
Right.
Where did we add the most inventory?
Washington, DC, Phoenix, Virginia beach, Miami, Las Vegas, new listings went
down the most in Newark, Detroit, Warren, Michigan, Austin, Texas, and San Antonio.
Look at this.
New listings only increased in 13 of the top 50 metros.
That means 37 of the top largest metros in the U S declined in new listings.
You think people were more distressed than they were last year as homeowners
count below comment below and let me know if they are more distressed and
ain't showing yet in the new listings.
Cause if people are like on the brink of financial ruin and they've got a house
they can't afford, they're going to try to sell it, right?
That's a new listing.
That's not showing in the data yet.
So no, not a lot of new listings means to me, not a lot of people in distress
when it comes to homeownership.
I know a lot of people want to stress in the home market right now.
I ain't seeing it at least not across the board, certain metros
probably, but not across the board.
Okay.
So here are those charts I was talking about.
So median sale price was one of my big warning signs.
You can see three 79, nine 88.
It ended last year, by the way, up compared to 2023, no crash last year.
Folks like a real estate mindset, melody, right?
Uh, probably Nick at revenge or consulting.
We're like, Hey, we're doomed.
Watch this at the end of 2024.
We're going to see price crashing.
We're going to see, uh, home prices down 5% year over year.
They were completely incorrect.
It's actually up.
It ended up year over year.
It's starting up year over year.
Will it crash this year?
It could, but we don't have the inventory yet.
Folks meeting asking price.
We'll skip that for now.
Um, house payments.
That's definitely another warning sign because it has
to do with interest rates.
I mean, house payments right now are definitely higher than
they were in 2022, 2023, 2024.
So home price is higher home house payments, higher.
Everything's higher.
I'm sure, you know, that pending sales down 3%, down 3%.
So this is really the only thing keeping them house prices
from, from going parabolic, right?
Why?
Because there's not a lot of pending sales.
If there were more people out there buying homes, it's even
less supply and higher prices.
New listings.
This is in the basement.
Still look at this new listings.
You can see where it ended up right over here on the right-hand side.
I mean, that blue line is 2020, 2024.
You can see it didn't skyrocket up.
People thought new listings would go this way at the end of the year.
Like all of a sudden people would list all their homes for sale.
They're not, and they didn't.
People were not listing their homes for sale because they
can't afford to buy the next one.
It's not that they can't afford to sell.
Don't listen to that garbage.
They can afford to sell because they have tons of equity.
They get cash in and get tons of equity.
Problem is they don't want to pay the rent for the next place or a higher
house price with a higher interest rate.
Who's going to trade in a 3% interest rate for a 7% interest rate.
No one, no one.
All right.
Active listings.
Look at this starting right here.
It is up 10% year over year, but look where it ended last year.
Headed down again.
If we had distress in the market, you would see that active
listing go keep going up and up and up.
Because distress doesn't care about seasonality folks.
If we have distress, you would break seasonality.
You would have forced selling right now, not for selling people sell
when they want to right now, not when they're forced to.
Not a lot of force selling.
We'll skip months of supply.
This is 22% of pending sales under contract in two weeks or less.
So starting at a four year low right now, homes are sitting longer on average
because a lot of people are, you know, putting their homes on the market.
Those are way too expensive.
So the people that are selling are either.
They have to sell from a job relocation standpoint, the few that are, or
people that are doing wish pricing, like, Hey, I'd sell my house if I
could get 500 grand for it, even though it's only worth four 50.
And then they don't sell it.
And then it sits and becomes.
Uh, you know, it becomes a dead inventory.
That's why the number of homes going pending in two weeks or
less is going down, not up.
Home sold a meeting of 49 days, same situation, just taking longer to sell.
I would also suspect this because people are actually doing inspections now
versus waiting all the contingencies like they were back, you know, in the
nutty times in 2021 and even 2023.
22% of homes sold above finalist price.
That's actually not a four year low, which is crazy.
It's actually, you know, above 2023.
So people are still paying over asking sometimes for homes
when they're priced really well.
I just saw one yesterday on the market here in Columbus price.
The, the, the list price was, uh, six 35.
It's sold at six 70.
Now, when it was priced at six 35, that was a great, that was a great price.
That was like 20% under market.
Why they price it like that.
I don't know, but they ended up getting more than the market price for it
because it started low.
Isn't that funny how it happens?
Starting low on your house listing sometimes gets you a higher price
person versus starting high and going lower.
A lot of people think if you start high, you can always work your
way down if you're a seller.
Not always true.
Sometimes it ends up in a lower price than if you started low at the beginning.
Just crazy how that works.
Average home sold for 98.2% of finalist price.
So there are people on average getting small discounts.
Um, so that's probably a good thing.
You, we need that.
We need some type of normalcy in the housing market.
It's good to see people not paying over asking.
Look at this back in 2022 on average, people were paying 102.5% of list
price of finalist price.
That's crazy.
Good thing.
We're not there anymore, but wow, I just saw this.
Look at this.
We're actually over 2023 right now.
So we're starting the year higher in percent of, uh, an average sold.
What the percent of finalist price was that it sold for.
We're actually over 2023, this orange lines, 2023 back then it was 98%.
Now it's 98.2, not a big difference.
And then there's the Redfin home buyer demand index.
We really don't care about that.
All right.
So now we're going to go to the, uh, local housing markets.
Let me just make this a little bigger so you can see it.
And now we're going to start with Columbus, Ohio, because that's where I am.
And I always do Ohio's real quick.
So we're going to do new listings, new listings in Columbus, Ohio.
We'll get to go back here to the green dot.
That's where the year starts for 2025.
So this is the Redfin data center.
The links in my description below.
Um, you can go here anytime you want and look at your local county or metro area.
Um, and this is their weekly update data.
So new listings, this is crazy in Columbus down 6.3% year over year.
We're starting at a four-year low in Columbus.
As far as new listings, not good.
I don't expect prices to, to, to skyrocket here at all.
Now the weather's been horrible this year so far.
Um, when I say horrible, it's just been cold and snowy and salty and nasty.
So you know that maybe that's why people aren't listing their homes for sale.
Um, so they, you know, that's probably what's happening, but, uh, active listings
in Columbus, look at this, we are starting the year higher 15.41, but you know, just
by new listings that I just showed you, that's probably not going to continue.
I mean, we're really going to need some new listings in order to have active
listings increase because they're, believe it or not, there are people
out there looking for homes.
I'm helping some of them buy right now.
All right.
So that was active listings.
Now we're going to look at pending sales in Columbus.
Pending sales down 5.7%.
That's not good.
If you're a realtor and it's probably not good.
If you're a seller either, generally speaking, unless you price your home
correctly, but if you're a greedy home seller, not good.
All right.
Now let's look at the median sale price in Columbus.
Median sale price for Columbus, Ohio, starting the year higher than 20, 24,
no doubt, and 2023, $331,000 up 5% year over year.
I don't see that changing in Columbus.
I would imagine we end up the year this year, higher than
last year and the beat goes on.
All right.
Now let's do Cleveland real quick.
Cleveland, Ohio.
Let's do new listings in Cleveland.
New listings down 2.2%.
Same thing as Columbus, not good.
Active listings in Cleveland have been horrible.
Let's see how they're doing.
Whoops.
Let me go back.
I did that wrong.
New listing starts.
Yeah.
New listings in Cleveland.
I was wrong.
Not two.
I was down at the end of 2024.
Look at this.
Down 10.7% new listings in Cleveland.
Nuts.
Now what about active listings?
Down 1.92%.
Look at this folks.
Big, big warning sign if you're a buyer, because there's 1.92% less
houses to pick from versus last year.
You thought inventory couldn't get worse.
You were wrong.
Now prices are higher, less inventory and interest rates are higher.
So this cataclysmic crash that was coming three years ago, two years
ago, one year ago, at the end of last year, hasn't materialized.
Obviously.
All right.
Let's do Cincinnati now.
Whoops.
I got to do median sale price for Cleveland.
Median sale price in Cleveland.
That's weird.
Why do they do that?
Oh, that's for the chart down there.
Median sale price up 17% year over year in Cleveland.
17%.
Again, waiting in Cleveland costs you dearly.
It looks like.
All right.
Now we're going to do Cincinnati.
The nasty natty new listings in Cincinnati.
Okay.
New listings in Cincinnati.
Hey, look, they're up 3.7%.
That's good.
If you're in Cincinnati, at least you're not in Cleveland situation
down 10% or Columbus down where we down two or 3% in Columbus.
So that's good.
Let's do active listings in Cincinnati.
Where are they starting right here?
Up 43%.
They were up a lot all last year, but now look, they're actually under 2022.
And last year at the end of the year, it was falling.
Look at that.
How it was falling again.
That's going to be a sign of distress.
If you see a lot more active listings in your local market, these
warning signs I'm showing you.
I go over every week in Redfin's data.
You can go over them in your local housing market.
Just take a look at one of my videos.
Follow along and look at your active market and go or your local market and
go, Hey, what's going on with active listings, new listings, pending sales.
Um, and then you can look at a median sale price and got to kind
of understand what's happening.
All right.
So that was active listings.
Let's do median sale price in Cincinnati.
Where do we end up here?
Up 10% year over year.
Just ridiculous.
Right.
Unreal.
I it's, it just keeps going up, man.
No, no help for the locals.
No help.
If you're just somebody trying to get in your first house, no help at all.
It's sad, sad situation.
Okay.
That's Cincinnati.
Now somebody wanted me to look at grand Rapids, Brad grand Rapids, Michigan.
So if you have a Metro, you want me to analyze, by the way, put it in the
comments below and I'm happy to analyze it on the next Redfin let's look at
grand Rapids, Michigan, new listings down 18%.
That's not going to help active inventory at all.
I would imagine.
Look at active inventory only up 10% in grand Rapids, Michigan.
I got to think that there's just not a lot to pick from.
Let's do median sale price.
Median sale price up 1.3%.
So it's not like Columbus or Cincinnati.
That's a good thing.
I guess $315,000, but look at last year, last year, it ended up three at 3%
more than the previous year, which by the way is less than average growth of the
you know, 20 years in home prices nationally, nationally, they're like five
or 6%, so to be up 3% isn't as bad as some other areas, but you are up and
there is no crash, it looks like.
And now you're starting the year higher.
So unfortunately with, uh, prices in Michigan, grandma, grand Rapids,
Michigan, it doesn't look like there's any crash coming.
Just not a lot of active listings or new listings to speak from.
You need a lot more to change the price trajectory.
Okay.
That was, uh, grand Rapids.
Somebody asked for Baltimore had a realtor in Baltimore asked for me
to spend more time on Baltimore.
So I thought I would go ahead and hit that one.
New listings in Baltimore, Maryland, where they go down 6% year over year.
Todd Sachs.
Are you hearing me?
What's up, Todd Sachs.
That guy thinks that prices are going to crash every day.
Um, even though I'm sure he owns a ton of real estate, uh, being, you
know, in the business for 40 years, right?
I hope he owns real estate.
Um, but I mean, look at this, Todd.
I want to know what he thinks about this new listings down 6%.
So unless this data is a fake, which he probably thinks that
to, um, down 6%, they ain't going to work active listings.
Where are they in Baltimore, Maryland?
Only a 5%.
Help me out, Todd Sachs.
Tell me how you can have a price crashes.
If you're a new active listings are up only 5% year over year.
And look last year, look at where it was going.
Coley Toledo.
Look at that down like a rollercoaster ride.
Just way down.
All right.
So let's find out what's going on with median sale price.
I mean, it's like shooting fish in a barrel, bro.
Look at this 388 grands where it ended up while Columbus, Ohio is almost
more expensive than Baltimore.
That's crazy up 9% year over year in Baltimore, 9%.
That's where it ended.
Where'd it start this year?
Up 10% crash, not found.
So to that realtor in Baltimore, thanks for suggesting Baltimore again.
We'll keep our eyes on this market, but man, it's off the hook there.
Like no listings, active inventory, barely up year over year prices elevated.
And now interest rates are higher warning sign, warning
sign, warning sign, flashing red.
All right, let's do, um, the next one.
Now, somebody also asked me for another sub market of Ohio.
So this one should be interesting to look at.
This is we're going to look at, uh, I switched to County.
If you look here, I'm pointing, but you can't see where I'm pointing to
at the County level in the region type.
Now I'm going to look at the County.
So the one I'm going to look at is Guernsey County.
I bet you don't know where that is.
Guernsey County is a little County in, um, Ohio, but they wanted me
to look at a sub market of Ohio.
Some of this data is going to look a lot different because there's a lot less
transactions, a lot less activity because it's a smaller market.
I mean, new listings like here, there's only 15 new listings, right?
So where are they starting?
Well, new listings in Guernsey County down 40%.
That's insane.
They're saying in this four week period, there's only three new listings.
That's nuts.
All right.
That is new listings.
Let's do active listings in Guernsey County.
Active listings this year up 71%.
Wow.
Well, look, there's only 137 active listings, but still it's up a lot.
And it ended the year pretty elevated in Guernsey County up 71%.
Maybe there's some dead inventory out there.
Interesting.
Okay.
Let's look at median sale price.
This chart is probably going to look really strange because there's not a lot
of sales, a few sales are going to change the market a lot, but last year,
nonetheless, it ended up 55% higher than the previous year, 285 grand.
This year, it's starting off 76% higher at $284,000.
But if you look last year, I'd probably go here and look kind of what occurred.
Kind of get a trend line.
Like, you know, it hovered like usually around 206 grand or so to me,
knowing them area the way I do.
I think that's probably more realistic, but that's still elevated most of
the last year compared to 2023.
So the point is prices don't look like they're crashing in Guernsey County.
There is more inventory.
That's good.
There are more homes for sale.
That's good.
It looks like, so maybe prices can soften somewhat.
So that's a local market here in Ohio.
I analyze, you can do the same thing I just did for your local market.
You can use Redfin or have data pulled from a local realtor if you want.
But either way, um, that is how I analyze a local market.
I hope that helped you out.
Now, again, my five warning signs you need to look out for in your market.
Number one, we've got mortgage rates.
Watch mortgage rates, obviously.
Uh, and how much money is going to cost you to borrow in order to buy a house?
Median sale price.
That's important.
Obviously want to look at what the trend is on the pricing of homes.
Number three, new listings.
How many homes are entering the market?
That influx of supply is going to help you understand how
much sellers really want to sell.
How many people are willing to, you know, put their house on the market.
And then that can help drive active listings, which is number four.
That's the fourth warning sign is active listings.
How many homes are available to purchase more supply, less prices,
more supply, less competition, lower supply, more competition,
lower supply, higher prices.
That's just how it works.
So that's definitely a warning sign to look out for.
The last warning sign is mortgage purchase applications.
So keep your eye on that.
You can look at mortgage news daily.
You can keep looking at my Redfin updates every week if you want.
And that gives you an idea of what the buying demand is like from a real level,
right from the, from an, uh, from an initial level, like the first thing you
need to do when you go buy a house is apply for a mortgage or not.
People aren't applying for mortgages.
It means buyer demands down.
So I hope that helps you out today.
Now I do talk about foreclosures as well on my channel, because a lot of people
are like, man, foreclosures are going to flood the market.
We're going to have a wave of foreclosures.
It's going to crash prices.
Is that going to happen?
Well, check out this video right here and you'll find out.
