Mortgage rates are up, but is the housing market finally returning to normal?
Last week 30-year mortgage rates in the US jumped to 6.22%, reaching a three-month high. Homes.com Chief Residential Economist Brad Case speaks on what the spike in elevated mortgage rates is signaling about the US housing market and regional real estate trends.
Brad discusses how the market is slowly moving back into balance after years of disruption, with improvements in affordability mainly driven by income growth. Learn why home prices are reacting differently in the Sunbelt compared to the Northeast and Midwest, and how the critical "lock-in" effect for existing homeowners is beginning to ease.
Plus, find out what metrics define a "normal" housing market and when we might fully return to a state that favors the buyer.
AI Generated·May contain errors
U.S. mortgage rates have ticked back up to three-month highs as the war in Iran weighs
on the housing market. Let's take a closer look at the state of housing into the key spring
selling season. Brad Case joins us now. He's the Chief Residential Economist at Homes.com.
So let's just start with the overall dynamics, Brad, that are kind of most prevalent, let's say,
in the U.S. housing market as we come into really the couple most important months of the year
for single-family home turnover. Yeah, well, the housing market's really been disrupted over the
last several years since 2020, and what we are seeing is that the market is really slowly coming
back into balance. Now, it was actually kind of set up for a nice recovery in the spring,
and then, as you said, the mortgage rates bumped upward because of new inflation concerns,
and that puts a little bit of a hesitation in the minds of potential buyers. But what we're
seeing in general is an increase in the number of homes on the market, so an increase in the
availability. And when you look at mortgage rates now compared to whether they were two-and-a-half
years ago, there's just no comparison. It's just we actually have seen improvements in affordability
for the last two-and-a-half years, and part of it is because of lower mortgage interest rates,
but really mostly it's about income growth that has exceeded house price growth.
Brad, something that stands out to me right now in the housing market is how geographically
different it is. I don't want to say bifurcated because it's not quite so simple, but the
pressures we're seeing on home prices in the Sunbelt, for instance, not quite the same dynamic
that you would see in my neighborhood in suburban New York City. Just talk a little bit about how
we've started to see a real geographic separation, let's say, in the dynamics within
each of these markets. Yeah, well, as I said, it really started with the disruption
of really the aftermath of COVID, where a lot of people moved. In some cases, they moved from
central parts of the city they were in to suburban parts, but in many cases they moved to the
Sunbelt, and that was so that they could get more space without spending a lot more money.
But what we saw as a result was prices went up dramatically, and then home builders responded
by providing supply where they could, which was basically in the Sunbelt area.
So when we look at the price pressure right now in Sunbelt markets, it's because of the fact that
the supply was inadequate and is now adequate again, and that's really a relief.
When you look at cities in the Midwest and the Northeast, they didn't see the same
supply response. In the Midwest, they didn't see the same surge in demand during COVID.
So sometimes it looks like Midwestern cities are doing especially well, and what's really
going on is that they are not making the adjustment from that supply response
that cities in the Sunbelt are making. So we're really getting back into a normal market,
but remember, we haven't really seen a normal housing market since 2018, 2019.
So double-clicking a little bit on those dynamics in the Sunbelt where you are seeing supply
come online from projects that were probably conceived of three, four, five years ago.
If I look at the stock market, I'm seeing home builder stocks have been under quite a bit of
pressure. I think from a consumer standpoint, sticker price and things are looking better,
but it feels like perhaps builders are, well, they've already grown more cautious and may have
a little bit of an inventory overhang they were not really hoping to have
as if this kind of dynamic of rates, 6% or so, and those migrationary flows really slowing down,
that might be a challenge it seems in the years ahead.
Yeah, absolutely. Home builders do have a little bit of an overhang. And so as a result,
buyers who are willing to look in the new homes part of the market are able to talk with builders
about price cuts and other incentives. And that makes that part of the market a little bit easier
to deal with than what we've have seen in the existing homes market. Because in the existing
homes market, there was a time when sellers were putting their house on the market, not even because
they necessarily wanted to move, but they wanted to slap on a really high price and see whether
they would get lucky. And some of them did. That is ending. And so what we're seeing in the broader
existing homes part of the market is that buyers and sellers have much more balance. And so the
negotiations are really meaningful negotiations. When the new homes part of the market, it's true,
home builders are under pressure, and that'll go away pretty soon. But right now, buyers are
probably able to take some advantage of it. All right, so maybe gone are the days when people
are waiving their inspections, which was a real feature of the 2022 housing market that felt like
it was a little too much. But let's stay on existing home sales. And I want to talk about
the lock-in effect, which has gotten a lot of play over the last few years, which is essentially
folks who bought 2020, 21, very low mortgage rates in a home that it seemed like I can't ever leave
because of the rate I'm paying. Is that starting to ease in terms of bringing supply on the market?
Are people saying, you know what, it's a good deal, but I don't think we're going to be here
forever just to hang on to this mortgage? Yeah, I think we are seeing the first signs that the
mortgage lock is easing. Because, you know, remember that when people move, it's because life
moves on. And in some cases, they are looking at better jobs in a different city or a different
part of the city. So they want to move for that reason. In some cases, of course, it's because
they're retiring. And so to some extent, people have been deferring the moves that they would
ordinarily have taken. And now they're, as you said, you know, they're saying, all right, you
know, things are reasonable. Let me go ahead and look at that move. So actually, what we've seen
recently is an increase in the number of houses put on the market available for purchase. And
most recently, a fairly sharp decline in the number of refinance mortgage applications. And
it may simply be that some of the people who would have been expected to refinance a year ago,
instead are thinking, all right, instead of refinancing, why don't I go ahead and put them
put the house on the market because I am interested in moving. And I'll get you out of here on this
one, Brad, you mentioned earlier, 2018, 19, in your view, really the last time we saw a normal
housing environment in the US, two parts, one, when do you think that does return? And we're
seeing some of it is, you know, do we need to see more changes to go all the way back? And I guess
I was just kind of curious in your view, like, what was defining that normal market, you know,
as someone who thinks a lot about the house I live in, you know, future homes, and just what it means
for an economist looking to housing market to be in a quote, unquote, normal state?
Yeah, well, we look at certain metrics that describe any particular market, like the average
number of days or the median number of days that a house spends on the market before it's before
it's bought. And the amount of supply relative to the sales pace, and the the average or median
discount of the final sales price to the list price on the house. And those were all in what
I would call sellers market territory for the last few years. And they are now into the balanced
territory. If you what what what really made 2018 2019 a normal market was that we finally completed
a really long and hard recovery from the housing market downturn following the great financial
crisis. So we had just gotten back to the situation that we would like to be in all the time
when COVID hit and disrupted everybody's housing plans for for a few years. So that's you know,
that's that's what we're talking about. We're talking about a situation where a buyer is not
pressured to move right away. They have time not just to search for the right house, but also to
talk to different lenders and get a better mortgage interest rate, something that many
buyers don't realize they can do. But the ones who do sort of shop around for a good mortgage
can take you know, a 10th of a percentage point off of their mortgage rate, which is real money.
So that's the kind of market that we are moving into.