Landscape design on a BUDGET: It doesn't have to be boring!

True Gardeners
273 followers
Do you get frustrated when you see the suburban landscape turning into the same thing over and
over and over again? I certainly do and I know that there is a better and more interesting way
to do what homeowners are trying to achieve on a budget. I just don't think they know how to
get there. So today I want to tackle that problem. Hey everyone I'm Erin the Impatient Gardener. I
live and garden here in southeastern Wisconsin zone 5b 6a. I am a Master Gardener volunteer
and I have designed a bunch of gardens both at my property and others and I am so frustrated by what
I see happening when I drive past the same houses all the time and I do not blame the homeowners
for what's going on. So our case study that we're going to be designing a new landscape on a very
tight budget for today is a house that I figure I have driven by more than 10,000 times in the
20 years. I drive by this house twice a day every single weekday because it is on my route to and
from work. Not to mention this is in the town where I grew up so I'm very very very familiar
with this house. When I was a kid we used to go to this house to buy watermelons from the um he
seemed like a very old man at the time and now I fear he may have been like in his 70s or something
which is not old. So anyway I call it the watermelon man's house nobody else does. This is a very cute
smallish house that is on the main drag into town. It is on a corner lot is in a very busy part of
the street it is very exposed where it is. Now I've watched the landscaping change at this house
over the years but the last owner before the current owner was not there for that long and
they took out quite a bit of some landscaping that was there. Now there was never a lot of it
but they took out a fair amount of it and it's there's a good chance that they took it out because
it was just old. In spring new people moved in. Now I don't know these people they don't know that
I'm gonna create a new landscape for their house but I'm gonna assume something. So although this
sounds creeperish remember I just drive by this house all the time so I think it's kind of a young
couple. I'm going to imagine in my head this might be their first home and I also remember what it's
like to buy our first home and I remember that you pour every bit of money you have into buying
your house typically and sometimes there are some necessary upgrades that need to be made on the
inside and I get that landscaping is farther down the list of priorities. Now I mentioned that this
is a really exposed spot. I'm assuming that the large picture window that's on the front of the
house is maybe a living room and I can only imagine what it's like to try to sit in that room
with headlights going by at night or being able to have everyone see in. So privacy is obviously a
huge issue. So these new homeowners did what I see people do everywhere. They planted 15 small
arborvitaes. I'm going to say these are less than two feet tall. I did ask people for some indication
of what they thought someone might pay for a plant like that. The general idea and what I've
kind of seen around here is that my guess is they went to probably a big box store and I'm going to
guess they paid maybe $25 for these for these plants. That's the number I'm going to work off
of. In addition in the corner of their property they planted four shrubs. I think at least two
of them are small hydrangeas and there might be something else there. They're all very small
shrubs and I get what they're trying to do. They are desperate for privacy as anybody would be.
They may or may not have looked at the price of fencing which would be this is actually a pretty
big city lot. They have quite a big backyard in it. I can only imagine how much fencing would be
and I don't actually even know what the fencing regulations in the city are because as I drive
down that street no one has a fence so they might have only been able to get a four-foot fence there
which isn't going to really do that much good from a privacy standpoint so it might not even
be worth the money even if they wanted to spend that money. What they did on this property you can
drive around town you can drive around new builds you will see a version of the exact same thing.
If you aren't into gardening and aren't a student of gardens or don't have never really paid much
attention to gardens which probably describes many first-time homeowners who have never really
even thought about gardening until all of a sudden they own a property and they need to figure out
some landscaping you probably know that you see this same thing a line of arborvitaes with maybe
some daylilies thrown in a spirea and a couple hydrangeas. At least in my area of the country
that is essentially the generic most common landscape that you will see. So I'm going to
make some assumptions here and say that maybe they spent $600 on these four shrubs and these 15
arborvitaes and I think $600 is probably a very typical amount of money that a brand new homeowner
moving into a property would want to spend. Unfortunately I'm going to tell you why all of
that $600 was a big waste of money and they don't know it. This might have even been an arborvitae
that wasn't even named where they bought it but let's just assume this is a pretty generic arborvitae.
So here are some of the problems with it and by the way I'm working off of a couple of photos
that I snapped from across the street and some google images here and although of course I could
have stood right on the sidewalk outside their house and take pictures I didn't want to seem
like a total creeper. I don't think most people would appreciate that. So the pictures are not
optimal here but between the google images I think you can and what I took I think you can get a feel
for what we're talking about with this property. So first off they've spaced out these arborvitaes
quite a bit. Now maybe they're intending on adding more in the future but we're just going to make
some assumptions on what's happening here. I would say it's going to be at least 10 years before any
of those plants are creating you know are touching which I assume is their intention but the problem
is I don't think any of those arborvitaes are ever going to make that. So first of all you'll note
that the way they planted these was they dug a hole the size of the root ball and they planted
in there is grass all around it so you know that that grass is sucking up a lot of water and in
fact this fall one of the things I noticed was that they had been watering the trees which I could tell
because there was a ring of extra green grass around them so they were keeping up on watering
the trees big kudos to them on that but that grass is going to suck up a ton of that water.
If you were going to do this a far better way to plant that would be to dig out a strip at least
two feet wide the entire length plant them in there and then mulch between them that would
have been a much better way to do that if you were going to go ahead with this planting. The other
thing is that these arborvitaes are in my opinion the wrong plant for here because although they grow
fairly quickly they're never going to make it that long for a couple reasons.
The first is deer. Believe it or not downtown this part of the city has a really big deer problem.
There is a herd of deer that live in town that is happy to munch on anything and everywhere.
They have actually eaten the plants that I have planted outside our office
which there is no grass anywhere near that they are just walking through paved streets right down
the sidewalk eating plants. About once every one or two weeks I will have to stop for deer in town to
cross the street and they don't care they have no enemies no one's hunting them there is a buck
who walks around like he owns the place which he he pretty much does he's an eight point buck
I'm sure hunters are salivating when they see that and he walks around like he's got not a
care in the world because no one's hunting him no one's going to move him out and he's got a whole
lot of does out there who are just hanging out waiting for him so he he thinks he is pretty hot
stuff and he saunters across the street makes all the cars stop for him. So deer are a problem deer
will absolutely go after these arborvitaes that is the other thing we see when these landscapes
are planted is anywhere there are deer they might get them established but if they don't actually
put pretty ugly deer fencing around them for winter a lot of people actually use snow fence
they will be lollipop trees in no time. The other problem is dogs these people live on the main
sidewalk in town which means I can only guess at the number of dogs who are walking by this property
every day and I know these dogs are peeing on those trees because shortly after the trees went
in so did a bunch of signs that said please don't let your dogs pee here. The other thing is they
planted these maybe 18 inches from the sidewalk which means that these trees are going to get way
too big for that spot width wise covering up the sidewalk which the city is not going to allow
before they ever get close to meeting. And lastly the big problem with any kind of hedge
if you plant a hedge that is made up of all the same trees the odds of all of those living
especially when you're starting with really small plants is nearly impossible you're going to lose
some and then it's never going to like look right. Now again I want to just state be perfectly clear
here I don't blame these people who did this at all this is what they see out there growing this
is what they think should be done and I'm sure when they started looking at other options they
thought this is the best way to get us some privacy. But I have a much better plan so let's
walk through what I would do with that $600. So I think when people think about creating privacy
they think about creating a wall but that's not the only way to create a sense of privacy and I
think that a much better way to approach this problem would be to create privacy basically
almost instantaneously in the area that is the most exposed and that is the corner. So most of
the headlights when we're talking about cars are going to be hitting right at that corner so if we
can create a really nice block on that corner that will create a much better feeling of privacy both
inside and I think outside. So what I'm proposing here is using that corner creating a garden bed
there ripping out all that grass on the corner and we're going to create this nice curvy bed on the
corner and we're going to plant that intensely. So the first thing we're going to add to this bed
is a nice dense wider evergreen and I'm going to propose not in Arborvitae here because we
want to think about deer resistance here. Deer resistance and just general city toughness. I'm
thinking some kind of spruce would be nice here and ideally something I mean you could have something
that grows up to 20 feet tall here would be just fine over time but my guess is these people are
going to live in this house for maybe 10 or 15 years and then they're maybe moving on to the
next house and I think if you are planting a new garden you just worry about yourself. What happens
with that garden down the road you can let the next people decide what they're going to do because
they might hate it anyway. So maybe we're looking at a spruce and I'm thinking a nice size one
that's going to get you some privacy hopefully immediately like maybe we can get something that's
at least four feet tall from the get-go maybe even bigger. We're going to put at least a third of our
budget into this tree because this is the tree that's going to solve part of the problem from
day one. So the next thing that we're going to dedicate a good portion of the budget to
is a small flowering tree and this should be something that's going to be wide not columnar
because again wide and low this is a ranch house after all wide and low is going to get us the most
screening and it's not going to overwhelm the house. So this could be something like a crab apple
this could be a multi-stem service berry this could be something like heptacodium seven suns tree
there are a lot of options out there this could be maybe even a hawthorn something like that and by
the way of course this is all full sun so there are a lot of options here for things that could
go in this spot. I'm going to say maybe you can get it if you go for something that isn't too
wild and crazy I bet you could get a very nicely sized tree for maybe $150. So we're going to put
that in the south corner of this garden bed but on the edge that's closer to the house. So we're
going to put in a nice tough panicle hydrangea that's going to grow fairly big. I'm not thinking
limelight but this could be limelight prime which is six to eight feet tall we could do something
that gets in that sort of five to six foot range that could be little lime that could be quickfire
really love quickfire there as we all know there is no limit to the hydrangeas you could pick from
so this could be something where you know they could actually like pick a budget option even to
see what would be there but I would I would think six feet tall would be a really nice height for
that to grow to and of course if you keep those flowers on in winter that's going to provide
screening in winter too and I would say start with a bigger plant for that we want to get privacy
instantaneously because these people's patience is going to wear out if they have to wait for too
long so I'm going to say probably $60 for a plant like that $65 could even be if we're looking at
like a three gallon kind of plant and then the next thing I want to add in because I want to
get some movement here but also again screening quickly I'm going to add in a couple of ornamental
grasses and actually I've drawn in two but I really think you hate two of anything honestly
so there's probably a spot to work in a third one looking for quite a tall one but a well-mannered
one because I'm going to assume that these people are not really that interested in gardening at
this point in their lives maybe ever but based on what I saw them planting I don't think that
these are necessarily people for whom the gardening bug has bit yet so we want low maintenance and we
don't want anything that's going to reseed all over the place so this could be something like
good old-fashioned carl forester which stands up really well I don't want something that's
going to get floppy and they're going to have to worry about it falling onto the sidewalk
there are also some really good millennias that would work there and by the time we put those
things in I feel like the budget is getting close to being used up so I have a couple of options
for where they could go next year because remember now we've got this big bed that is you know all
that grass is removed and it's going to look a little empty so while it's not nearly as fun as
having a finished beautiful garden in front of you I think when budget is a big concern I think
a staged garden plan is a pretty good idea so for the first year of this bed what I would suggest
they do is they're going to plant these plants that we've talked about and these trees but before
they mulch anything except for the areas right around the tree they're going to throw down a
whole bunch of zinnia seeds and I'm talking about tall zinnias I'm talking about state fair zinnias
zinnias that get some height to them and I'm going to propose that they just fill this whole thing up
with zinnias for this first year this should not be that hard zinnias generally grow very well from
seed they're going to have nice fresh soil there that's all worked up if we're worried about weeds
you know potentially they could mulch around the edges where a lot of weeds or grass is bound to
creep in and they could create just holes and that would still work really well and then leave
big holes and that's where you put the zinnia seed and that maybe provides a little bit more
structure for someone who isn't quite sure how to decipher what zinnia seedling is and a weed is
and we're just going to fill this up with zinnias this first year now zinnias themselves are not
going to provide any you know screening in winter so they're not great as far as that goes but they
are going to create a really nice feeling of enclosure which is as equally as important as
actually blocking what you're seeing I think so that's my cheap way to get through that first
year and I think that leaves money in the budget probably enough money to get yourself some mulch
and whatever else you need to do to get those plants established and then you just focus on
keeping that happy for the first year so let's say that they look at this and they think we love
where this is going we can find a little bit more money this year to add some stuff in the next place
I'd go is super tough perennials and again we're looking mostly at height here and probably on the
front edge towards their house we're going to stair step that down but for the middle and back
we're talking about height so I'm thinking agastache blue fortune would be an excellent
addition there that stands up over winter too so you leave that standing and you get something
there instead of a bare landscape echinacea I wouldn't fuss around with fancy echinaceas I go
for good old-fashioned echinacea purpurea which reseeds around comes back reliably is asked for
very little looks beautiful during the winter as well now this house has always had sort of a pink
or purple door so that's why I'm thinking pink but if they wanted to go to like a yellow thing
certainly you could add in some rudbeckia American goldrush would be a perfect one for that
also sedums now I'm thinking that kind of front edge that'd be great for there I mean I think if
they wanted to we could also look at adding in some smaller shrubs obviously you could put in
some more hydrangeas there certainly a flowerful hydrangea actually in the middle of that bed
would actually be quite interesting smaller shrubs though you could think about something
like spothergillia legends of the small I absolutely love that clethora just fallen in
love with clethora I think clethora is a beautiful little shrub as well of course there's so many
really really good small shrubs now that there's really no limit I guess I would probably pick one
of those and plant those in multiples this is a very small bed and it's going to get a little
mishmashy if you start throwing in too much now just for fun because I can't resist a big garden
I drew just this just the beginning sketch of what a bed might look like that would really
enclose this house and really make this feel private and give these people the sense of
enclosure and privacy that I would certainly want if I lived in this house and that is basically
creating almost a circle around the entire house that would give them protection from that side
street which by the way that side street is not super well traveled so that's why I'm not as
worried about what's happening on that side street but it would certainly enclose you from that area
and it would create a really interesting sort of lawn area going around the house now they
like I said they have a big backyard so I don't feel bad taking out a lot of grass that we have
in the front because you got a whole backyard to play with there they do have a couple of Alberta
spruces on the corner of those houses those are ancient those have been there as long as I can
remember certainly they could leave those in if they like those and then of course I would you
know I would create a foundation planting to add a little bit of interest against the house as well
and then that creates essentially a garden in the front that is a very wide shapely path
around the house and then opens up to that backyard so if you happen to be in this position
I hope this helps you rethink how you could spend a small budget to create almost instantaneous
privacy that is also going to grow better last longer and I think be a much more beautiful
planting than something like a line of little arborvitaes I hold no ill will towards arborvitae
there can be very nice plants in the right place and in the right position asked to do the right
job none of which I think applies to this particular instance all right if you found
this interesting or helpful do me a favor give a like subscribe if you haven't already and I'd
love to hear your thoughts on this kind of idea of coming up with design ideas for people who
never asked me to come up with design ideas all right thank you for watching have a great day in
your garden we'll see you soon
