The BEST Fertilizers For Vegetables Ranked BEST To WORST!

True Gardeners
273 followers
What's growing on, gardeners? If you ask me, what is the biggest source of confusion in the
gardening space, it would be fertilizers. There are so many types. What are the differences?
What type should I be using? Are some better than others? On today's video, I break down the
differences in fertilizer types and rank them from best to worst, so you can feel confident
that you are fertilizing your plants the right way. If you're new to the channel, please subscribe,
hit the bell for notifications, and check out my Amazon store and Spreadshop links
in the video description for everything I use in my garden and awesome custom apparel and gear.
What is the best fertilizer for your garden is controversial and can vary based on your
unique situation. In this video, I will do my best to break down how these fertilizers work,
so you can make an informed decision when it comes to the right fertilizers for your garden.
Ultimately, the rankings are my opinion based on my years of experience. No matter your decision,
I will place links to the fertilizer products featured in this video down in the video
description for your convenience in case you decide to incorporate any of them into your
fertilizing routine. The number one ranked best fertilizer for your garden is technically not
fertilizer at all. It is compost. Now, while compost is technically not fertilizer as we
understand fertilizer to be today, it is technically the original fertilizer. It is
what we used as humans for agriculture for thousands of years before fertilizer technically
existed. Fertilizers as we understand them today are concentrated sources of nutrition for our
plants, so because they are concentrates, they rely on human intervention to some degree. If you go
out and you buy a fertilizer, whether it's organic or inorganic, that fertilizer was
manufactured by humans somehow. Compost, on the other hand, is just raw biological matter. It's
decomposed urine and feces and plant material and animal parts and other things that have broken
down over time. In order for it to be finished compost, it has to have been completely decomposed
so you basically no longer recognize the original materials that were put in and it basically is
just a black humus. So if I break this bag open right here, you'll see all compost just kind of
looks like this. It kind of looks like just a forest floor because that's basically what it is
and it should have little to no odor. It should just basically smell like dirt.
The reason why compost is so important to add to our garden is it is more than concentrated
nutrition for our plants. It is a living, breathing, thriving ecosystem. You get more
than just macronutrients and micronutrients. You get trillions of bacteria, billions of fungi,
a whole living ecosystem of organisms that is going to come along with it and it is going to
bring your soil to life. Your plants need more than just nutrition to live. They need a healthy,
thriving ecosystem to process the nutrients and to help them uptake all of those nutrients from
your soil. And that is what makes compost so unique and irreplaceable in the garden. Just
like you can't build a nice house without a strong foundation, you cannot have a healthy,
thriving garden without strong soil. So before we even think about planting things in our garden,
we need to build that soil so it is healthy and alive and breathing because that is the
foundation of the house that we are building. If you were to take a dead sandy lot and then
pump that soil full of fertilizers to help feed plants that you planted in it, you will not get
results as good as if you planted them in healthy soil and gave them less fertilizer because that
whole microbiological web, that is a real thing. Your plants literally have a symbiotic relationship
with the soil. So if you don't build that strong foundation with compost first,
all of the other fertilizers, well, they are just not going to do it for you.
So before you plant anything in your garden, make sure you build your soil with lots of compost.
Make sure that every time you sow seeds or you transplant things out into your garden,
you add compost. Make sure that when your garden is done for the season and you are ready to put
your beds to rest, you add compost. That way you can re-nutrify the soil, keeping a constant
source of fresh compost added to your garden a few times a year. So you are constantly adding
back in those bacteria and fungi cultures into your soil that will keep it alive and active.
And that is the key to having healthy plants. We don't even want to worry about fertilizers before
we worry about our soil first. Now that we have the soil health taken care of,
let's move into the actual concentrated fertilizers. The number two ranked best
fertilizer for your garden is going to be an organic all-purpose granular fertilizer.
And an organic all-purpose granular fertilizer is going to be made with, generally speaking,
whole animal parts. So because they are formulated from the parts of animals,
they contain all of the micronutrients, the macronutrients, and the different amino acids
that were inside that animal. So they are, generally speaking, nutritionally complete.
Now while we have three different bags of fertilizers in front of us, and they are
different colors, different brands, and different NPK ratios, they are all all-purpose fertilizers
because it all comes down to the ingredients. Let me show you. Now if you look at the ingredients
on the bag of this Job's fruit and nut fertilizer, you will see that it is derived from feather meal,
bone meal, processed poultry manure, and sulfate of potash. And it has an NPK ratio of 3-5-5,
so it's 13% NPK per volume. And it also has 8% calcium, and then half a percent magnesium,
and 1.6% sulfur. So basically, over 23% of what you get in this bag of fertilizer
are macronutrients for the plant. Now this Dr. Earth's bag is made out of alfalfa,
fish bone meal, potassium sulfate, and kelp. And it has an NPK ratio of 2-2-2, so 6% of this bag
is your actual macronutrients. So this has almost four times less total fertilizer in it
than that Job's product, even though the ingredients are somewhat similar.
This Espoma Plantone actually has the widest variety of ingredients, and it's derived from
feather meal, poultry manure, bone meal, alfalfa meal, green sand, sulfate of potash,
and sulfate of potash magnesia. And it has an NPK ratio of 5-3-3, with 5% calcium, 1% magnesium,
and 1% sulfur. So this is basically 18% macronutrients per the bag. So as you can see,
all of these fertilizers are derived from similar things, but they have pretty significant
differences in the amount of fertilizer concentrated within these bags. So while you
can use all of these things as an all-purpose fertilizer, you can see some are definitely
stronger than others. So people ask me all the time, what is the best all-purpose fertilizer
that I should buy? And the answer to that question is the one that is on sale and contains the most
amount of concentrated fertilizer in that bag, generally speaking. So basically, just get the one
that you get the best price per pound on, because they all basically do the same thing,
and they all basically contain the same stuff. Now, these fertilizers have been granulated
in order to increase their surface area and break down in the soil as quickly as possible,
because all of these different raw materials on their own would take weeks, if not months,
to break down. But because they dry them and they granulate them, when you work them into the top
inch or two of your soil and you add water and then you mulch on top of them so they stay
constantly moist, they will break down rather rapidly and release those nutrients into your
soil. And that is what is unique about these fertilizers. They are actually inert in their
raw form. They are precursors for food for your plants. When you apply them that day or that week,
they are not going to work. They have to be decomposed. They have to be consumed by the
bacteria and the fungi in your soil. And as they are consumed and decomposed, the nutrients leach
out for your plants. So it's very important that you understand how these fertilizers work. You
want to apply a couple tablespoons around each plant. You want to massage them into the top
layer of the soil, about an inch or two. You want to water them in very well to increase the rate
of decay. And over time, they will slowly trickle feed your plants, and your plants will grow based
on the nutrients found in those fertilizers. The third best fertilizer ranked for your plants are
your organic soil amendments. Now, these are not complete fertilizers in and of themselves. They
are actually a component in the organic all-purpose fertilizers. Some of them may actually sound
familiar because I read some of these off the bags of the all-purpose fertilizers that I just
featured. Some of my favorites are bone meal, blood meal, crab and lobster shell meal, and azomite.
Now, your bone meal, your blood meal, and your crab and lobster shell meals are leftover byproducts
from the meat and seafood processing industry. So just like the name implies, bone meal is literally
steamed, dried, powdered bone. Blood meal is dehydrated, powdered blood. And your organic
crab and lobster shell meal, this will come as no surprise to you, but they are made out of
crushed shells from crabs and lobsters. And your azomite, this is actually a trace mineral
supplement that's made from, I think, some kind of rare volcanic rock. They basically micronize it.
They powder it to the point where it is so fine you could actually mix it up, and it becomes
water-soluble. And it adds all sorts of trace micronutrients, namely soluble potash, calcium,
magnesium, and sodium. It says it's derived from a volcanic ash deposit.
Now, the reason why I classify these as soil amendments and not fertilizers is because
if you grew your plants in an inert medium and all you gave them was one of these things,
it wouldn't be enough to sustain the plants, because on their own, they do not contain
every single thing most plants need to survive. But that being said, each individual product
targets something different that a plant needs. For example, bone meal is extremely high in
phosphorus and calcium, as you would expect, because it is made from bones. So this is
incredibly helpful for growing stronger roots, developing bigger bulbs on things like tubers
and root vegetables, and they also help in the blooming process with your fruiting vegetables.
So adding bone meal to your soil can really help boost blooming on things like tomatoes
and peppers and eggplants. Blood meal, on the other hand, contains almost no phosphorus and
potassium, but it's about 12% nitrogen per volume. So it is fantastic for growing leafy
greens, and it is great to help green up your plants if they're looking a little bit yellow
and they're developing a nitrogen deficiency. Your crab and lobster shell meal is not going
to be the greatest fertilizer in the world because the chunks are so big that they will
take a long time to break down. But what this is great is, it is great for adding trace
micronutrients to the soil, and it contains a compound called chitin, which actually helps
inhibit root-knot nematode growth. So if you have sandy soil like I do, rich in root-knot nematodes,
this actually helps chase them away. And of course, your azomite is a great all-purpose
water-soluble source of micronutrients to help give your plants a micronutrient boost,
which is really helpful if you're growing inside a greenhouse, hydroponically, in containers,
or maybe you just got really heavy rain and it flushed out all of your raised garden beds or
your garden soil, and you just want to add trace micronutrients back into them.
Now what's also great about these products is they feed your soil. They all have to be broken down
by the bacteria and by the fungi in the soil. So again, when you place them right away,
they're not going to be immediately bioavailable, just like your granular all-purpose fertilizers
won't be. But they feed your soil, so they will help grow your soil's bacteria colonies
and fungal colonies, so you have healthier, thriving living soil while also boosting
the growth of your plants. Now, in a perfect world, all we would need to grow our plants
is compost and maybe a little bit of granular organic fertilizer. But alas, we do not live
in a perfect world. We grow non-native species where they're not supposed to be. We grow in
containers. We deal with weather problems, and for that reason, sometimes we need these types
of fertilizers. Which brings me to fertilizer number four ranked, and that is your organic
water-soluble fertilizers. Now my favorite organic water-soluble fertilizer is Alaska Fish Fertilizer.
So it has all of the nutrients that you will find inside of ground-up, pulverized, fermented fish.
So for that reason, this feeds your plants and your soil. It's really good stuff.
But because it's been processed by humans, it's immediately bioavailable.
A fertilizer like this does not need to be consumed by the microbiome in the soil
and then slowly broken down to release those nutrients. When you apply this in a watering
can, you'll mix two to three tablespoons inside of a one-gallon watering can and apply it to the
area of your plants, and they will immediately be able to uptake those nutrients and put them to
work. Alternatively, you could also buy a fertilizer like this Miracle-Gro Organic
Water-Soluble Fertilizer. It has an NPK ratio of 9-4-12, and that's because it has more ingredients
added to it. This product has a whole bunch of additional stuff added to it, so it's a lot more
than just fish. And while some of these ingredients may be questionable, at least at first glance,
and some of them appear to be salt-based, they are technically organic. So for that reason,
this classifies as an organic fertilizer, and it has more in it than just the fish fertilizer.
So why would we need products like these? Well, we would use products in order to either boost
the growth of plants, help them transplant with less shock, or correct an immediate nutrient
deficiency. So, for example, here where I live on the southeastern coast of North Carolina,
we got 17 inches of rain in one week from Tropical Storm Debbie about a week and a half ago.
And when that happens, it flushes out my raised garden beds, it flushes out my container garden,
and it just removes all of those organic nutrients that took a long time to break down inside those
containers and raised beds. So my plants will start to yellow unless I come to the rescue and
I give them something to help boost their growth. If I were growing inside a greenhouse, I wouldn't
have to do something like that, but because I'm subject to the elements and I can have problems
like that, sometimes I have to resort to things like this to help green them up. Also, because we
do non-natural things like start seeds indoors, create transplant plugs, and then bring them
outside and transplant them, sometimes those plants go through something called transplant
shock, where they won't like being pulled out of their containers, and they will go through a
period of shock where they will not grow very well or they could even die. And sometimes giving
them a little bit of water-soluble nutrition can help push them through that phase a little bit
more quickly and reduce their stress so those roots grab hold more quickly and you have less
losses in the transplanting process. And finally, maybe you do things like you grow things in
containers like I do. Well, the problem is when you grow things in containers, you're dealing with a
very limited soil microbiome. There aren't very many bacteria or fungal colonies in there,
so they don't necessarily do a great job at breaking down organic granular fertilizers
efficiently, and if you over-irrigate them or you get too much rain, you could wash all of those
nutrients out. So for that reason, if you container garden, I like having a water-soluble fertilizer,
something like fish fertilizer, or even something like this, performance organics, just to help
boost plants because they are basically in non-native situations. You wouldn't find a plant
growing in a container in nature, so sometimes if we're going to grow things in a man-made environment,
we need to use some man-made products to push them through. The fifth best type of fertilizer
ranked for your garden are going to be your inorganic water-soluble fertilizers. Now,
unlike the fish emulsion and the Miracle-Gro performance organics, which are derived from
basically whole foods that have been either fermented or superheated or broken down to the
point where the nutrition is immediately bioavailable, these are your salt-based fertilizers,
like your nitrates and things like that. So for that reason, they are not considered organic.
Now, these don't feed your soil at all. They simply target the plants. So when you give
these fertilizers to your plants, you would mix them at the recommended strength, at the
concentrations, inside a watering can, and then you would pour it on the plant's roots,
and they would be able to uptake that nutrition immediately. But it will do nothing of benefit
to your soil. It's only going to target the plants. So you're not doing anything healthy
to your soil by giving your plants these fertilizers. So for that reason, we would
want to use these sparingly. So that being said, why would we want to use these fertilizers in our
garden? Well, we would want to use these fertilizers for the same reasons that we'd
use the organic water-soluble fertilizers to boost our plant's growth, to container garden,
or to correct a nutrient deficiency, but we can do it with these products a lot cheaper.
Now, in a perfect world, we would only use the organic ones because, well, they're a lot better
for our soil overall. These don't really do anything positive for our soil,
but these are a tiny fraction of the price compared to the organic. So for that reason,
you can get a lot more production using these fertilizers. Now, again,
if you want to be a 100% organic gardener, you wouldn't use these at all. If you are not
concerned about being 100% organic, I would really only use these in the event of a super
heavy rainstorm that flushes out your container garden and you need to give them quick nutrition.
These are good for container gardens. For me personally, I don't believe in the concept of
organic container gardening because a container garden is pretty much the least natural medium
that you could possibly grow your plants in. So why would you be 100% organic in a container
that basically defies nature? That being said, a lot of us have to garden in containers because
we don't have a big yard. I love container gardening. I'm not knocking it. I'm simply
saying if you're going to garden in a container, they don't do a great job being grown 100%
organically. So if you're going to grow in a container, I don't think it's all that bad to
use these types of fertilizers. Now, when it comes to an in-ground garden, I would only use these if
you want to boost your plant's production and you're certain that it will do so. So for me,
because I have so many issues in my climate in the humid Southeast that gets a ton of rain
growing tomatoes, I have found that I can keep my tomatoes alive and productive more often
if I give them a little bit of a product like this about twice a month, once every two weeks.
So for that reason, I have found value in it for my heaviest producing plants and for my
container garden. If you choose to use these products, I would recommend you do your own
research and find out if they are right for you. And fertilizer number six comes at the absolute
bottom of my list. And that is the slow release pelleted inorganic synthesized fertilizers. Now,
these are the fertilizers that come in those little colored pellets and they are processed
in such a way that they shed very slowly. So instead of releasing all of their nutrients at
once, like the water soluble fertilizers that you mix in a watering can, they take a little
while longer to break down. And they are typically what you find that you dump inside a spreader and
spread on your lawn. Those fertilizers are the absolute cheapest fertilizers that you can buy
in terms of price per pound. And for that reason, they are very attractive to people because you can
add fertilizer for very little money. But in my opinion, they don't belong anywhere near your
garden. Now, I do use them for my front lawn because I live in an HOA and I have to treat
the front yard with weed and feed because I live in an HOA. But aside for use on my lawn,
I don't let these anywhere near my garden because in my opinion, I don't think they do
anything well. You can make a real argument for the water soluble inorganic fertilizers that you
put inside a watering can because it's really easy to fertigate your crops. They legitimately do
increase yields and they can correct nutrient deficiencies immediately. And if you grow in a
container garden, they're actually a really good thing to use. But these things just don't do
anything well. If you apply them to your containers or to your garden, they're not really going to do
that much right away. They actually tend to shed the nitrogen component a little bit more quickly
than the other components. So you can actually wind up giving your plants too much nitrogen
all at once and they don't do anything to increase your soil health. So if you want something that's
going to take weeks or months to work, just use the granulated organics because they're going to
break down more completely. They're going to have a much better micronutrient profile and they're
actually going to feed your soil and keep the bacteria and the fungal colonies in your soil
happy. So if you have time on your hands, just use an organic slow-release fertilizer. These things
are the cheapest fertilizers on the market for the reason. That's why I really think they only
belong in a lawn if you even have to have a lawn. Believe me, if I didn't have to have a lawn, I
probably wouldn't even have one. And that right there are the six different types of fertilizers
ranked from best to worst in my opinion. So if you are confused by all of the different fertilizer
products on the market, hopefully this will help set the record straight and get rid of some of the
confusion so you can make a more informed decision about what products are right for you to use in
your garden in your unique situation. Now that being said, if you are a more experienced gardener,
I would like to hear what you think about my rankings of the different fertilizers.
Did I do a good job ranking them? Do you agree? Do you disagree with the order? Do you think that I
got some things wrong? I'm really curious about your feedback for the experienced gardeners out
there. Drop a comment down in the video description and let us know what you think. So everybody,
I sure hope you found this video helpful. If you did, please make sure to hit that like button,
subscribe to the channel, and please ring that notification bell so you're notified when I
release more videos like these. If you're curious about where to get any of these products that are
featured in this video, I will place direct links to them all down in the video description for your
convenience. And for everything I use in real life in my garden in general, they are all linked
in my Amazon storefront in the video description. So expand the video description, click on the
Amazon link, you'll see everything I use in real life. And while you're down there, please check
out my spreadshop for custom merch if you want to support the channel. Thank you all so much for
watching and I hope to see all of you again on the next video. Oh boy, I bet I know a certain
somebody that would love a dried fig with some peanut butter on it. Oh Dale, you want a treat?
Come on. It's been a while since we've had a fig, buddy. Now be gentle. Oh, very good. He's gotten
so good at taking treats. He's such a gentle guy. Now the other one here, this is for your dad.
Mmm, so good. Go ahead, buddy. You can finish, you can finish the peanut butter.
Don't worry, it's not a sharp knife. Good boy.
