LIVE: US Incoming and Outgoing National Security Advisers Talk Policy Priorities and Transition

Live News Network
1.4K followers
80 Video Views·Jan 14, 2025
Incoming national security adviser Michael Walz and outgoing national security adviser Jake Sullivan talk policy priorities and transition at 6:00 p.m. ET on Jan. 14.
He currently serves on the boards of several organizations,
including the Atlantic Council
and the Council on Foreign Affairs.
May I invite Mr. Hadley, Mr. Sullivan, Mr. Waltz
to the podium to the stage.
Thank you, George.
Good evening and welcome to this timely and important event.
It's my privilege to serve as moderator
for this conversation.
And joining us this evening are two distinguished leaders
who both embody the continuity and change
that define our democracy.
First, we have Jake Sullivan,
the National Security Advisor to President Biden,
former National Security Advisor to then Vice President Biden
and former Director of the Policy Planning Staff
at the Department of State.
Thank you, Jake, for your service
and for being with us tonight.
And second, we are honored to welcome
Representative Mike Waltz,
the incoming National Security Advisor
to President-elect Trump, a member of Congress
representing Florida's 6th Congressional District
and a combat-decorated U.S. Army Green Beret.
Thank you for your service, Mike, for being here as well.
There may be no more challenging time
in our nation's recent history
than the period in which Jake served
as National Security Advisor
and that Mike will serve as National Security Advisor.
And in the conversation tonight,
we'll delve into the pressing national security issues
that make this period in our nation's history so critical.
We'll explore the vital process of political transition
and reflect on the future of U.S. foreign policy.
So let's begin.
I want to ask a question of both of you.
The transition from the outgoing Biden administration
to the incoming Trump administration
is now well underway.
How's it going?
And how are the two of you getting along, Jake?
Well, first of all, every transition is obviously vital
because it is a period of both opportunity
as a new team comes in
and starts thinking about their agenda
and of risk as adversaries and competitors
around the world look to take advantage
of the time of transition
to kind of get the drop on the United States.
But I would say this particular transition,
it's especially important that there be deep consultation
and a smooth handling
because just in the period of this transition,
we've seen the fall of Assad.
We've seen the declaration of martial law in Korea.
We have an active ongoing negotiation
for a ceasefire and hostage deal in Gaza.
We had the first deadly terrorist attack
of the Biden administration on January 1st of this month.
That's all during the transition.
And so Mike and I have spent a considerable amount
of time together going through the issues,
making sure that the incoming team is lashed up
with my outgoing team
and that they're getting briefed on the immediate issues
that will be on their agenda on day one,
but also on the longer-term trends
that we see in some of the larger initiatives
that I think have bipartisan support
and could be carried forward.
And I wanna just say thank you to Mike
for his professionalism
and the way in which he has approached ensuring
that we are sending a clear message
to anyone who wishes America harm
that they are not gonna be able to take advantage
of this time of transition,
that we are going to make sure
that we are serving the national interest.
Even if we see things differently on a given issue
or a given country,
we are united in the basic proposition
that the smooth transfer of power
from one president to another,
especially in the national security enterprise
is absolutely vital.
And Mike has really done a fine job.
Well, Steve, it's great to see you again.
Thank you, USIP, for hosting.
And I have to give a special shout out
to many of you know her, my amazing wife, Julia,
Dr. Julia Neselot, who was Homeland Security Advisor
in the first Trump term and has far many more degrees,
speaks more languages and even more combat tours than I have.
So this is the wrong seat,
but thank you, honey, for your support.
And I think Jake said it well,
as a member of Congress, we tend to be a little vocal.
I've been very vocal on the areas where I've disagreed
with this administration's policies.
At the end of the day, we're all Americans
and we're sending the message that to our adversaries,
don't you dare try to take advantage of this time.
And we have things that aren't slowing down
just because we have a constitutional transition date
or because we have an election.
Just ask the poor people in LA of the wildfires.
I mean, we are gonna literally have to
take that federal support up
and they deserve for us to not drop
not even an inch of that support that they need.
There's been reporting of President Trump's
Middle East Envoy, Steve Whitcock,
out in regular contact and out there right now
with Brett McGurk and they're both reporting back
to both of us and back to the president-elect
and the president as we have a shared mission
to get our people out.
And to get the Middle East, I think,
back on track towards stability
and towards the next round of the Abraham Accords
or normalization or whatever moniker you want to give it.
So there are a number of things that are ongoing
that aren't going to slow down, cyber being another.
And then there are areas where we're having conversations
about where do we maybe need to change ASNA
and go in a different direction.
We've had very candid conversations on things like,
we've tried this, this works, that doesn't work.
If you wanna try that, you go right ahead.
And we probably will.
And the American people can then judge.
But it's just such a unique moment in our history.
President Trump is not a year one president.
He's not even a year five president, he's year nine.
He's been thinking about all of these issues
the last four years.
And so my team, we're trying to get our feet underneath us
and he's already put on the gas
for a man who stays in 10th year, I think.
So that's our internal challenge.
We'll get our team in place, we'll have a smooth handover
and we'll continue to march.
I must say this press report of having Brett McGurk
and President Trump's envoy for the Middle East
together in meetings with foreign countries
talking about the Gaza disengagement,
really unpleasant and I haven't heard of that before.
Speaks well for this transition.
I'm gonna ask each of you the same question
to see what kind of, how the answers compare.
Jake, let me start with you.
As current National Security Advisor,
what do you think are the most pressing
national security challenges
the Trump administration will face
and what should they be most worried about
in the first six months?
You know, it's like a very strange,
slightly awkward version of the dating game.
You know, the old game where you wrote down your answer
and then the other person wrote down the answer
and you see how much they match up.
So going first is funny because I'll give an answer
and then Mike will say, that's not right at all.
This is totally other thing.
But I'll do my best.
I'll go first next time.
So, yeah, right.
Look, there are obviously the immediate crises.
Mike mentioned the wildfires in California.
That is something that's gonna be a long and tough effort
and it has from our team.
There's closing out the T-Star hostage deal
which hopefully we'll do this week
but then the actual implementation.
But for me, the critical thing is
in the midst of dealing with the immediate crises,
we can't take our eye off the ball
of the long-term strategic competition
with the people of the Republic of China
because China is the one country
with both the ambition and the potential capacity
to really compete with us across all dimensions.
We have not faced a challenge like that
in a very long time, perhaps ever,
because the Soviet Union didn't have
some of the economic and other engines that China has
and we have to stay focused on making sure
we're investing at home, rallying our allies
and pushing back against China's unfair economic practices
and aggressive tactics in places like the South China Sea.
So for me, making sure that you have a balance
between dealing with the urgent and the immediate
while also making the investments in the long term.
That's probably the single most important thing
for in this current era,
a National Security Advisor to really be focused on.
And then even, so it's urgent, immediate,
the long-term challenge of China
and then there is the just ethical challenge
of artificial intelligence in the way in which
just in the time that Mike will sit in this seat,
it's gonna transform society,
the economy and national security.
We've taken some steps to try to make sure
that AI works for us rather than against us,
to preserve and extend our lead in AI
against our competitors.
But that is gonna be an issue
that is gonna touch virtually every dimension,
including Mike mentioned cyber,
of America's national security.
And so at every one of these levels,
Mike will be walking into an extremely full plate
where ensuring that we are on top of every aspect
of each of these levels is the difference
between really succeeding and failing.
Mike, as the incoming National Security Advisor,
what do you think of the principle
national security challenges
and what are you most worried about
in the upcoming six months?
Well, the most immediate aside from the natural disaster
that we're dealing with, I think is our southern border.
And the open nature of it is just unacceptable
in my view and I certainly think loud and clear
in the president election.
So you're going to see a lot of action
to close the border, to go back to the policies
that we believe are working,
whether that's remain in Mexico
or working with the Mexicans
to fortify their southern border.
But we just cannot sustain the millions of people
that have come across.
We were fortunate that we intercepted a plot
of eight ISIS terrorists that were scouring sites
in three cities.
Unfortunately, we were hit with inspired attacks.
We were literally talking about this today
as ISIS reinvigorating to try to inspire individuals
inside the United States.
So with over 100,000 Americans dying per year
of fentanyl, we have to get our arms around that crisis.
And if you haven't watched the news,
the president-elect is very focused
on the Western hemisphere these days.
And so some of these things, I think have gone on frankly
for quite some time across multiple administrations.
I can't tell you how many hearings I've sat in
with the generals in charge of southern command,
ringing the alarm bells about Chinese influence
in South America and Latin America.
Well, we're going to take steps to take that on.
We're all winging our hands in Congress about supply chains
and the fact that we have such dependencies
on not just another country, but our greatest adversary,
and that China produces 90% of our pharmaceuticals,
are responsible for over half of the critical minerals.
I passed a bill years ago to push the Defense Department
to create an antimony stockpile,
because there's only three countries in the world now
that mine and refine antimony, Tajikistan, Russia, and China.
Why is antimony so important?
You can't make ammunition without it.
And so that is going to be really
a whole of government effort in terms of permitting,
in terms of mining, in terms of refining,
but really looking at the Western hemisphere
as a source of the energy, the critical minerals,
the food supply that we absolutely need.
So that's, you know, as Jake knows, as you know,
pulling all of that together across the interagency
will be quite a challenge.
And so, but it's really fortifying ourselves.
The president-elect firmly believes we can avoid conflict
with the Chinese Communist Party
because they need our markets.
And we're going to use the leverage
in a way that's in line, that we have,
that's in line with our national security
while we're still there.
I want to stay on China just for a minute,
because it's an area where there seems to be
a fair amount of continuity
between the first Trump administration
and the Biden administration,
and a fair amount of consensus
across party lines in the country.
So if you, just in sort of shorthand terms,
what are the elements of a bipartisan policy on China
that you think are most important
as you navigate this kind of difficult relationship?
Mike, why don't we start with you on this?
And then we'll go to Jake.
Tell everybody where I'm wrong.
Well, I think there's multiple elements.
I just spoke to the supply chain aspect of that.
I was also the Republican chair of the US-India caucus.
So that's, you know, one,
it's getting them back here to the United States
where it makes sense.
If it doesn't make sense here,
how about the Western hemisphere?
If we're, you know, concerned
with the core causes of migration,
let's get that foreign direct investment
and those jobs there.
If not there, then to our allies with AUKUS
and with the Quad.
Again, areas that have continued
from one administration to another,
and I think will continue further.
So the supply chain aspect,
the porcupine Taiwan,
we have over a $20 billion backlog
of things that they've paid for
and that we need to work hard to free up
and have them get what they paid for as a deterrent measure.
And then thirdly, to really continue
to reinforce those partnerships
and those alliances
where I certainly give this administration
some credit is the trilateral dialogue
between South Korea, the United States and Japan,
and then also between the United States,
Japan and the Philippines,
really helping those countries
and those governments overcome historic animosities
with a shared vision of a free and open Indo-Pacific.
I think all of those things will continue.
And then if I didn't mention India,
I will again as a critical partnership.
Actually, I was just in India last week
and they love you there as a co-chair of the India caucus.
They love the India caucus
and so they're excited to have you come on board.
I told them I could be the chair
of the India Spouses Caucus going forward.
They were a little less than they were at,
but we'll do our best.
So first, I think I agree
with basically everything Mike just laid out.
I would say a good China strategy is a good Asia strategy
and that means building on the work that we have done
with respect to our allies and partners,
some of which, as Mike mentioned,
was work that we inherited and built upon.
So I think there is continuity in that regard.
A good China strategy, though,
is also a good ally strategy writ large.
I think Europe is important in this regard,
making sure that the United States
is deeply engaged with Europeans,
working on convergence,
on pushing back against unfair Chinese economic practices,
on the supply chain resilience piece and so much else.
And then there's the question of technology
and here we need to both promote and protect.
We need to make the investments domestically
in keeping our lead in the key technologies
that will define the future.
Here, the science part of the Chips and Science Act
has never been fully funded
and America at its best over the decades
has been an America that spends the dollars
on basic research and development
to power the innovations that shape the future.
And then there's the protect side.
We've taken a number of steps to ensure
that our high technologies
that have national security applications
can't be used against us or our friends by China.
And I think seeing that work continue
in the new administration is very important.
The last point I would make
is that the PRC is facing some stiff economic headwinds.
And it seems to me that a big part
of their solution to those headwinds
is to try to overproduce in key sectors,
to flood the market with cheap goods
that undercut American workers
and undercut our supply chain resilience
by maintaining a chokehold in supply chain.
And we need to continue the work
to ensure that we are standing up to that
and bring a bunch of other countries on board with us.
It's interesting to me,
it's just in the last couple of years,
not only the EU and Mexico,
but countries like Brazil and Turkey
have taken steps to fortify their markets
against Chinese overcapacity.
And this is, I think, gonna have to be an ongoing effort
as we look out to the coming years
because when we are flanked by strong allies
and partners in contending with China,
we're much better off
than being able to push back against their excess.
Final thing I would say,
there are areas where it is in our mutual interest
to work together with China.
And one of those is to stop the flow of precursor
chemicals with respect to fentanyl that come from China.
In the Trump administration,
the first Trump administration,
they stopped finished fentanyl.
In the Biden administration,
we've stopped or substantially reduced the precursors
and it's had a big impact on overdose deaths,
which have come down quite considerably in the last year.
We gotta keep doing that work.
And then intense competition does require intense diplomacy.
I spent a huge number of hours with my counterpart,
Wang Yi.
It's not my place to necessarily give advice,
but I have found it very valuable
as national security advisor
to have that strategic channel
so that China understands what we're up to
and so we understand what they're up to.
Because it's not about making compromises
on our national security or interest or values,
but it's about having an open channel of communication
to manage the competition
so it doesn't tip over into conflict.
Same goes for military to military communication.
Same goes for leader to leader communication.
So I think it's gonna be absolutely vital
in the period ahead,
even if we continue to be precursors.
Let's go to the Middle East quickly.
And I'm gonna start with Jake this time
and really ask you,
where is the Biden administration
leaving the situation in the Middle East
with Hamas and Hezbollah and Houthis
and the situation with Iran?
What does the table look like
if Biden's getting on the air?
Well, first, Iran is at its weakest point
since the Iranian Revolution.
It's lost its deterrent power of its main proxy, Hezbollah.
It's lost its main state client, Assad.
Frankly, it's lost its air defense capability.
And its economy is reeling.
So Iran is in a weak position.
And that creates real opportunities,
but it also brings risks.
Because Iran, you hear voices inside their system saying,
given how much deterrent capability has been degraded
and eroded over the past year and a half,
maybe we need to think more seriously
about changing our policies in the second quarter.
That is a matter of consideration.
I think there is an opportunity now
with Iran in the position it's in
to conduct diplomacy to try to get a negotiated outcome
that puts Iran's nuclear program fully in a box
and also deals with some of their other excesses.
But that'll be up to the incoming team
to decide whether they want to take that on.
Hamas, in terms of its military formations,
its leadership, its capacity to hold Israel at risk
has been basically decimated.
And hopefully we will get a ceasefire
in the hostage zone.
The Houthis remain a clear and present day in, day out.
And Mike and I have had now a couple of conversations
about the steps that we are taking
and what we will be handing off,
including the military operations,
the intelligence work, the work with allies
and partners in Houthi to try to deal with this.
That is a serious ongoing threat
that the new team will be taking on.
And then finally, Mike mentioned the Abraham Accords.
We have put a lot of investment and effort
into a vision of an integrated Middle East,
building on the work of the first Trump administration,
and in particular, focused on a long-term
normalization track between Israel and Saudi Arabia,
tied to steps forward towards a Palestinian state.
We think there is a formula there
that could really lock in a foundation
for greater stability, prosperity,
and integration in the Middle East
that we've done tremendous state work on,
and I would love to see get done in the years ahead.
And that would vindicate, from my perspective,
the kind of vision that could have bipartisan support
that would enhance the stability and security
of our partners and really marginalize
and weaken our adversaries in Houthi.
So that's what we see.
I should mention, because there's so much happening
in such a short time on Syria,
Assad going, a brutal dictator responsible
for the massacre of so many of his citizens,
that is a good thing, and it brings an opportunity
for a better future for the people of Syria.
It also brings risks, and the most consequential
of those risks is the possible resurgence of ISIL.
We have, in this transition period,
really intensified the military tempo
of our campaign against ISIS
so that they cannot reconstitute in a serious way.
That is gonna be ongoing work,
and that too is something that's coming.
Mike, what do you think are the opportunities
in the Middle East that you can say
that the Trump administration has
in the Middle East, and what do you think
the priorities should be?
Well, we have a number of opportunities now.
I think there's been some incredibly bold leadership
on the part of the Israelis and Prime Minister Netanyahu.
The movie is going to be made
about the Pager and walkie-talkie operation,
which I think is one of the most bold
and incredible covert operations in modern history.
I mean, if you just think, just a short time ago,
the thought, I mean, this has been going on
for quite some time, the thought
of taking out Nasrallah was seen as provocative,
was escalatory, can't be done,
that'll kick off that sword of Damocles
that was hanging over Israel's head, and it's gone.
Between the Pager and walkie-talkie operation,
between the decapitation of Nasrallah,
the taking out of their finances in Beirut,
the incursion into southern Lebanon,
and now the ceasefire to pull back out
the destruction of, I mean, miles and miles of tunnels
and rocket systems, which, by the way,
were within earshot of the UN Peacekeeping Force
that was there, and I think we need to have
a very real conversation about the future
and the efficacy of that force.
It is an incredible, it's an incredible opportunity
for Lebanon, it's a moment,
and I give a lot of credit to the effort
that went behind the election of President Aoud,
working with our Gulf partners
and working with the Saudis in particular,
so that is, it's a moment to translate that
into some political headwinds,
now that we've seen that tremendous military victory.
Hamas, as a result, is incredibly isolated now.
They always thought the cavalry was coming from the north,
and frankly, every time I think they got the news
of these anti-Semitic protests on our college campuses
and the fact that Hezbollah could be coming in
and seeing the calls for regime change
against the Israeli government,
democratically elected, I'll remind everyone,
then they thought they were winning.
They thought they could continue to sacrifice
their own people to turn world opinion against the Israelis.
That dynamic has very much shifted,
and why I think we are so close,
knock on everything we can,
to getting some type of agreement in the short term.
In the longer term, then, how do we translate that
and, as Jake said, get that back to talking about things
like rail and infrastructure and fiber,
and I think the more we're talking about those big deals
and those big projects and integrating the Middle East
with South Asia and then on to Europe,
the more we're talking about those big projects,
the less and less we're talking about those old animosities,
and so the conversations with Mohammed bin Salman,
with MBS and the Saudis, with MDZ and the Maradis,
with Bahrain, with the potential future in Lebanon,
and hopefully getting to a post-Gaza,
where we have to get to a post-Gaza,
and a finally reformed, I've been hearing that for,
I think, since we worked together,
the Palestinian Authority,
then there are tremendous opportunities,
but it has taken some real bold leadership,
and as someone who has sat across the table from true evil,
evil does exist, evil, I've sat across the table
from someone who said, well, as long as I live,
I will try to kill you, and an Al-Qaeda terrorist.
We have to recognize that evil exists,
and it only respects strength.
Hopefully, you can reform the next generation,
but sometimes, we just have to put bombs on for them.
This has been a rich conversation.
Unfortunately, we're out of time.
I would like to invite the two of you to join me
for the ceremonial passing of the baton,
and I'd like to invoke Ambassador Sullivan,
Ambassador Moot to come to the stage and join us as well.
Everyone wondered what it would look like.
Here it is.
It's kept in a jeweled box up in the fifth floor.
Jake, would you please pass to your successor?
All right, thank you.
I promise not to drop it.
Come on up, Jake.
Come on up here.
Cool?
All right.
You're gonna go, Jake, Jake, you know, just like this.
It falls to me to close the proceedings.
I will be brief for those brave souls
who have been with us all day.
It's been a very productive day, but a long one,
so I'll keep this brief.
I want to express my deep gratitude to my friend,
to the current National Security Advisor, Jake Sullivan,
and our National Security Advisor-designate, Mike Walsh,
for their candid and insightful conversation.
Their willingness to engage
in constructive bipartisan dialogue
is a testament to the resilience of the American democracy
and the enduring value of peaceful transitions of power.
Thank you also to my friend
and predecessor as Chair of the Board, Steve Hadley,
whose moderation of the panel brought clarity and depth
to this important conversation.
Steve, your experience and wisdom
continue to inspire us all.
I won't try to sum up the rich discussions
we have had today, but let me say,
the day was really a reflection of what makes USIP unique,
its ability to convene diverse voices
and focus on the critical mission
of advancing peace and security together.
This afternoon's discussions really underscored for me
the urgency of this mission in our turbulent world,
as well as the importance of working together.
And I hope that you will also leave here with the conviction
that we do need to pull together as a nation
over the next four years,
given the complexity of the challenges
that we've heard so much about today.
I'll conclude with several well-deserved thank yous.
First, I wanna thank you, our distinguished guests,
partners, audience members, for joining us.
It's been a great day with a rich discussion,
so thank you for being a part of it.
Thank you to those who have stuck it out
through the whole day.
Your dedication to promoting peace and security
amplifies the impact of this work
and strengthens the mission we serve.
Thank you to Deloitte, with honor,
and Catherine and Rafik Bizri,
members of our International Advisory Council,
for your generous support.
Thank you to the American Enterprise Institute,
the Atlantic Council,
the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace,
the Center for American Progress,
and the Heritage Foundation.
And to our media partners,
the Wall Street Journal and Sirius XM.
I would also like to express my heartfelt gratitude
to the USIP team, who have worked diligently for months
and poured their hearts and souls
into pulling this event together seamlessly,
including last-minute changes
that were accommodated with grace and flexibility.
So the team here at USIP really did a fantastic job.
Can we give them a round of applause?
So I'm pleased to invite all of you
to the reception in the atrium,
where we can continue the conversation,
reflect on the discussion we heard today,
and enjoy each other's company.
Please join us as we celebrate this tradition of dialogue,
collaboration, and the peaceful transition of leadership.
Thank you.
