Will Europe Get Enough Natural Gas for the Winter?

Wealth Wizards
9 followers
9 Video Views·Jan 14, 2025
Storage levels of European natural gas are on a trajectory which could see lows of 10-20% by the end of the winter season, says Nadia Martin Wiggen of Svelland Capital. When levels drop below 30%, "you can reach that bottom very quickly," she adds.
It's getting cold. We're starting to think about gas storage. We're going through it pretty fast.
How fast are we going through it and how big a problem could this be?
Good morning. So we're on a trajectory that matches what we saw in 2016-17 and then 2017-2018
where we ended the winter season at 10 to 20 percent stock levels. When we compare that to
where we've been since Russia invaded Ukraine it's a massive difference. Already the market
seems to be thinking that we could be as low as 35-40 percent but to come that low it really
puts pressure on imports and when you have storage dip below 30 percent your withdrawals
are less efficient so you can reach that bottom very quickly. In addition we don't have floating
storing floating storage of LNG available offshore like we've had the last two winters
to prevent price spikes if there are production outages for TTF.
So how do we refill? Presumably if we don't have Russian pipeline gas that's going to be more
tricky. How much extra LNG do we need and how much capacity do we have to refill via the LNG
route? So if we start with what we know right now Russia is no longer transmitting
gas through Ukraine. To replace those volumes which is 15 BCM that means one LNG cargo entering
Europe every other day. For that we have ample capacity. It can very easily be done. If we're
down to these low stock levels that I described we could face demand for up to 400 additional
LNG cargoes needing to come into Europe to hit that 90 percent target on storage for November 1st.
I mean Nadia good morning it's Lizzie. Do you think that the real issues start next winter
as you get the storage with rolls now? I was talking to Javier Blass on Bloomberg Opinion
about this yesterday and I think you're even more pessimistic than him about where the storage levels
drop to. Absolutely. I think that we've just seen how cold weather really draws it down quickly
and we're in a situation that we've already had a lot of demand destruction right. So it's not
where we were in 2022. So this need for LNG is much stronger this time and this is of course for
next winter. But that mandate for 90 percent levels of storage that that comes from the EU there are
some very big penalties in certain countries if you don't reach that. And the feeling amongst the
trading community is that if storage holders don't do it then the TSL will do it. And when we look at
the shape of the natural gas curve in TTF we can see that summer prices are still very very high. We
don't have the contango we should to build that storage. So it's really looking to be an issue
already in the summer to prepare for next winter not waiting until next winter to really have the shock.
So we're talking about the US ramping up production to make up for this lost Russian gas through
Ukraine to keep Europe supplied. Where do you see it flowing to mainly.
So when we look at last year U.S. exports of LNG went number one to Europe especially the
Netherlands. Then it went to Asia Japan South Korea India. What we saw is overall imports of LNG
to Europe were down year on year. But then that was immediately almost one to one replaced by this
extra Asian demand. When we look at what we see in extra production coming out of the US it
perfectly can match what is no longer transmitted via Ukraine from Russia. However when we're
looking at rebuilding the entire storage situation that would probably require LNG from all sources
even possibly including Russia. Nadia when we traditionally talk about LNG we're doing it from
a energy perspective from a heating perspective a certainly an export perspective. Today's kind
of big theme on the show is a lot of the tech story the data build out the A.I. build out. There's a
narrative in the states that to do that to kind of fund the A.I. growth to fund those data centers and also to
supply the energy needed to make that sector thrive. Natural gas is the way to do it. What
does that outlook look like and how much of a tailwind is it for pricing in that sector.
Absolutely. We believe it's fell in capital that natural gas is the reliable fast solution and least
expensive solution to have these data centers up and running. When we look at where prices have
been in Henry Hub though we saw curtailments in production last year. You know when we're at three
point five four dollars for an MVP to you that we start to see production coming back. And this is
where we've been waiting to see Marcellus really ramp up production. But right now there's such
a cold snap in the U.S. that instead of increasing production we now have cuts to production. Last
year you know we had a massive cut to production. Granted it was short term but this is where we need
additional infrastructure build out to make it more across the lower 48 to bring that going
forward for the next five years. Nadia what does that relationship then mean for the oil sector
especially in the United States. Again we're so many of the utilities that use oil as as kind of that power
generator and that commodity for the reasons you've outlined in terms of just how expensive it can be
have switched to natural gas. What does that mean in terms of correlation between oil and natural gas from a
pricing and trading perspective. Well they will be increasingly related. And what we also see is what natural
gases prices get very high. We see switching back. And so that can continue to happen. One thing that is very
helpful for the oil sector is that a lot of shale production has associated gas with higher gas prices even where they
are just a little bit higher on Henry Hub. It means that producers will be able to produce more oil with less high oil
prices and still be above their break even prices. So it should help the entire sector together hand in hand.
