We’re Watching the Silent Collapse of Europe in Real Time

Global Finance News
11 followers
#finance
#financeadvice
Make sure you use Coupon Code: eurodollaruniversity
A return to historic low interest rates in Europe is now practically guaranteed. Chances for ultra-low and maybe even zero is becoming too much to ignore. More importantly, why Europe has become a leader of the pack in the race to the bottom.
Eurodollar University's Money & Macro Analysis
After the ECB cut its three main policy rates by 25 basis points each this past week,
comments made by officials afterward largely confirmed what markets have been saying
and where they've been positioning and pricing all this time. Interest rates in Europe are indeed
going back to historic lows, and now there's a growing and high probability that also means
What the ECB really said was unlike the hapless gang at the Fed,
they know the economic risks are all tilted decidedly in one direction, and that's not
inflation. One reason why is that these are no longer mere risks, nor is this downside fear
being driven entirely by sentiment. It's already happening. Forward rate markets have hit new highs
meaning that sub-2% short-term rates are practically a given. Nothing is ever 100%,
but this is about as close as it gets. Given the events of the past month,
combined with the ECB not acting like the Fed, the door is wide open for rates to plunge well
past 2% on down into the ultra-low territory. Bond rates in Germany, for example, are already
there. So again, this isn't strictly theoretical or based solely on expectations,
especially as the German curve is behaving in classic bull steepening fashion as we'll see
here. Low growth, no inflation, the 2020s looking more and more like the 2010s all the time. Higher
for longer never stood a chance. While they're blaming tariffs in every way imaginable, the
simple fact is bond yields have been moving lower since October 2023, the two-year German
since September 2023, bull steepening the entire way. Now the ECB began cutting rates back in last
June, and the Swiss warned, and I told you back then, once they started, they were not going to
be able to stop. At least in this case, the Europeans are no longer pretending that they're
trying to. So what the ECB announced this past week, they're setting their deposit rate floor,
which is the lowest value of their three main benchmark policy rates, at 2.25%. They're only
25 basis points at the floor from historic low territory to begin with. Remember how this was
supposed to go. Last June when they started cutting, they said we're only going to go slowly,
maybe every other meeting at the most. But here we are in April of 2025, this is the seventh rate
cut out of the ECB, the sixth straight one, which has taken their short-term rates from 4% last June
when what was supposed to be higher for longer all the way to 2.25%, and there is more coming. So
they're already at historic low territories, very near it all to begin with, and the markets are
saying more, more, more, and now the ECB officials are saying yeah, more, more, more. So while markets
are pricing that more rate cuts are coming and that rates have a path to go lower, officials
aren't coming out exactly in saying so, but they are indeed intending to get out of the way, and
that point was very clear at the press conference this past week. As even Bloomberg reported, the
ECB dropped the word restrictive from its statement in relation to the monetary policy stance, really
interest rate policy, not monetary policy, but markets boosted bets on further cuts in borrowing
costs as officials underscore the headwinds that Europe currently faces. Quoting Christine Lagarde,
the president of the ECB, downside risks to the economic growth have increased, stressing that
it will take time for the full consequences of U.S. tariffs to become clear, and if that was
really the problem, we wouldn't be sitting here. The major escalation in global trade tensions and
associated uncertainties will likely lower euro area growth by dampening exports, and it may drag
down investment and consumption. Deteriorating financial market sediment could lead to tightening
financial conditions. At least she realizes that tightening financial conditions are consistent
with low rates, even though maybe she doesn't realize it. She's at least making that connection,
that low interest rates are not the same as loosening financial conditions, and we've already
seen in a number of ways that financing conditions and monetary conditions across the world are far
from loose and accommodative in everything that everyone says. Effective monetary conditions that
we see in everything from liquidations in the commodity space to these absolute plunges in
stock markets, it's already happening. It's not some distant future worry. It's what's going on
today, and there are going to be consequences from it, which is exactly why, as I pointed out in
recent videos, a couple, too many of them actually, we see these historic lows or historic highs,
depending on which measure we're talking about, these historic extreme levels that suggest markets
are positioning for the fact, the increasing likelihood that there's going to be substantial
consequences from what has already happened to this point. Before we get back to the rest of the
show, I want to take a second to introduce today's video sponsor, Defy the Grid. You know how much I
respect gold as an airhead for when the world isn't looking so great? So if you're buying gold or silver,
this is the place to get it. They're a small family-owned business, the kind where the owner
answers the emails and picks up the phone, and their prices are some of the best you'll see.
And if you see a better deal somewhere else, they'll match it, if not beat it. And it's not just about
buying. Their buyback prices are some of the highest in the business, which shows they take
both sides very seriously. Shipping is fast, it's fully insured, and it usually goes out within 24
hours. And when your order arrives, it's packaged discreetly, no logos, no hints at what's inside.
This is a company that respects your privacy. They never sell your info. They never cold call you.
And there's no upselling, just honest, straightforward service. It really feels like you're
dealing with people who care, not some giant corporate machine. So if you're stacking, check out
There's a link in the description of this video. We thank them for their sponsorship.
And now back to the rest of the show. And those extreme levels, as I said,
are nothing more than the market saying the chances of downstream and downside consequences
from everything that's gone on already are exceptionally high. They're way too high.
And as a consequence of that, what's going to happen in interest rates? When things are going
in the wrong direction, you've got deflationary monetary outbreaks all around the world.
You've got dimming economic prospects. Rates are going to go down, not because central banks push
them there. Rates are going to go down because they reflect the economic fundamentals of those
circumstances, especially in the longer run, the longer run consequences from all of this.
And that is low growth, zero inflation. The 2020s end up looking like the 2010s. It sounded
far-fetched back in 2023. It even sounded somewhat ridiculous last year. This year,
not so much. But of course, they're blaming this on terrorists because what else are they
going to do? They're going to say we were wrong about the shape of the economy. Like I said,
the markets have been moving in this direction far longer than the past few months. The bond
rally got going in October 2023 because the market was saying the possibility and the probabilities
were only growing that we were going to end up in this shape in the situation, specifically about
interest rates, with interest rates going back down, race for the bottom to historic low
territory. And then if we're not lucky, even into ultra low territory and maybe zero at the front
end of some of these curves. So after the ECB's rate cut this past week and the comments made by
Christine Lagarde and other officials and commentators and everybody else surrounding
the situation, you look at forward interest rates and forward rate markets, Euribor, Euribor futures.
The June 2025 contract, which is the closest quarterly contract to today, the price of that
one is back above 98 for the first time since early December, which suggests that the market
is pricing more out of the ECB in the short run, not just in the longer term, the second half of
this year. The December 2025 contract that priced all the way to 98.375 as of Thursday before the
holiday, that had been 97.845 back on March 6th. So you're talking about a 50 basis point move
higher in the contract price and a little over a month in what a month it was. Remember, this is
December 2025. So we're talking about interest rates for the rest of this year. Now, the literal
interpretation, which you should never do for these types of contracts, forward rate markets,
you should never interpret them literally. But as a way to conceptualize what we're talking about
here, the literal interpretation of Euribor futures in the December contract price would say
that the market is expecting the short run Euribor to be around 1.625 percent by late December,
which would mean three more rate cuts from the ECB. Or if you want to be overly precise when
that's not the thing we have here, that would mean two rate cuts plus a chance for the third. But
that's not what these Euribor curves or these Euribor contracts and the Euribor curve overall
are telling us. It's not to be taken literally. The market is not saying we expect short term
Euribor rates to be just under 1.7 percent at the end of December. This is a probability spectrum.
And the probability of short term interest rates falling below 2 percent is now seen, as I said in
the introduction, not quite 100 percent. Nothing ever is for sure. But this is as good as it gets.
It's almost a 100 percent chance that the ECB has to cut rates even further,
getting it below 2 percent, especially as they're already very near 2 percent to begin with.
But more importantly, when you look at the curve shape, the changes in the curve shape
and all the contracts that go into it, what the market is saying and what the curve is saying
is that the probability of short term rates falling even further, below even 1 percent,
is now more than realistic. I won't put a number on it because I think it's misleading to do so,
even though that's the tendency in the mainstream media when they do talk about these markets,
in the few cases when they do. But the probability spectrum is now edging below the 1 percent
threshold, and it's getting to be uncomfortably high that the trajectory is moving in that
direction to begin with. You see that in the June 2026 contract. That's 9836, which backs up this
entire curve shape and this interpretation of what the forward rate market in Europe is saying.
The ECB, like I said, they're no longer pretending that they're trying to stick around. In fact,
other comments that Lagarde made on inflation in particular show that unlike the Federal Reserve,
the ECB knows tariffs, whatever impact they're going to have, it's not going to be inflationary.
There might be an increase in prices in the short run, but all that will do, and even the ECB knows
this, all that will do is harm the economic prospects moving forward. In the German cash
market, the German bond market, Germany's two-year, and the two-year spot is an incredibly important
part of the yield curve because it's the junction between the long end of the curve, which is
independent price mostly, not quite entirely, but mostly on longer-run growth and inflation
expectations, whereas the two-year has also got to factor in what the ECB is doing and the short-term
consequences for short-term developments. The German two-year, that important spot in the curve
that has both of those factors oftentimes competing with one another, like Euribor futures, the two-year
is saying the ECB is going to get out of the way and let rates go lower where they really want to
go, where the fundamentals of the global economy demand that they go. And Thursday, just before
the holiday close, the two-year German rate was just 1.68%, right around this multi-year low that
was set earlier during the liquidations, earlier this month during the liquidation. So even the
front end of the German curve is already well into historically low territory right now as we're
talking about. Again, this is not theory, this is not expectations, it's already happening. And so the German
two-year is backing up the signal from the Euribor futures curve, saying the possibility, the
probability of rates going into the historic low territory, close to 100%, never exactly 100%,
never going to get there, nothing is ever certain, but as close as you're going to get here. But most
important of all, with the German two-year at under 1.7% and the Euribor futures curve behaving the
way it is, the chances of getting down below 1% and maybe even going farther are rising all the
time. Those chances are already realistic to begin with where we stand right now, and they're getting
higher as we go further along here. As far as the back end of the German curve, like any of the
other interest rate markets in Europe, government bond markets in Europe, back in March they had the
announcement that the Berlin government, the new government in Germany, was going to unleash this
massive tidal wave of fiscal spending, which led to a backup in interest rates as a response. As I
said at the time, the knee-jerk reaction anytime someone comes out with these massive fiscal plans
is to sell safety and see where it goes. And even though it almost always goes nowhere, in fact it
really never does go anywhere, sometimes it takes time for everyone to realize this. And this time
it took almost no time. The 10-year rate has been moving lower ever since, and as of Thursday before
the holiday, it was back down to 2.47% all over again, basically completing the entire round trip
from the fiscal spending announcement early in March. So much for the stimulus and the promise
of it. Now the overall action in the German curve, the cash market curve over there, is every way
consistent with bull steepening that we've seen during recession patterns and cycles in the past.
The last one, the last big one, we have rates that started out relatively high, so we're not
talking about 2011 and 2012, the recession there, because rates were already ultra low. But you go
back to 2007, 2008, 2009, what you see is the German curve bull steepened in exactly the same way that we
see today, late 2008 heading into 2009. In July 2008, just after the ECB had hiked rates, and yes you
heard me right, the ECB hiked rates, raised rates, in July of 2008, two months before Lehman Brothers,
and four months after Bear Stearns had failed. So after the rate hike from the ECB, both the two-year
and 10-year in Germany were around 4.7%. By the time Lehman Brothers actually was announced in the
middle of September 2008, the two-year was down sharply at 3.8%, while the 10-year was also down
pretty sharply, but only to 4.08%. So the front end of the yield curve was moving faster and going
farther than the long end of the yield curve. That's bull steepening. They both kept going lower for the
next couple months, so that by the early part of December 2008, the two-year German rate was down
to 1.96%, and the 10-year was kind of hanging around at 3.14%. But from there, from early December 2008,
the 10-year yield kind of went sideways to higher into early 2009, really the first half of 2009,
even as the two-year rate continued to go lower. In fact, the two years kept going lower all the way
to a low of 1.21% by March of 2009. And so the 10-years were going sideways, even though the worst
of that recession, the worst of the not-recession, was just then beginning to hit and erupt. So the crisis
was still going on, the worst parts of the contraction were still happening, and yet the bull steepening
saw longer-term rates begin to rise, certainly rise relative to where short-term rates were, and
short-term rates were going down into sub-2% historic low territories on their way to ultra-low.
But they wouldn't get to ultra-low. It actually took another crisis to finally get there. Rates had
plunged again starting in June of 2009, which showed the market wasn't suggesting to the economy
there weren't really green shoots anywhere around the world. And then interest rates in Germany, like
around the rest of the global bond market, they rebounded in 2010 before the renewed crisis in 2011
finally got both short-run and long-term rates down into ultra-low, where they would stay for the rest
of the silent depression 2010s. Low growth, no inflation. And the market knows that's the case
here, at least as far as the inflationary impacts of tariffs. The markets are pricing more and more
like the 2020s are going to end up similar to the 2010s in terms of these fundamentals. So tariffs
are not going to be inflationary, they're going to harm the economy in the short run, as we see in
these other price spikes like due to oil, demand destruction that results from it doesn't lead to
more inflation, it leads to more disinflation and more damage to the real economy. So while the
Federal Reserve hems and haws about inflation, the markets are uniform all across the world, not just
here in Europe, but also in the United States, treasury markets, forward rates, swap spreads, I keep
pointing to those, and all these emergency extreme levels that we see in the gold to silver ratio, the
copper to gold ratio, deflationary signals everywhere. The markets are having none of this inflation
crap that's keeping the Fed supposedly on the sidelines. Even Christine Lagarde said so at her
press conference this past week. On Thursday, she said,
Increasing global trade disruptions are adding more uncertainty to the outlook for euro area
inflation. Falling global energy prices and appreciation of the euro could put further
downward pressure on inflation. This could be reinforced by lower demand for euro area exports
owing to higher tariff and a rerouting of exports into the euro area from countries with over
capacity. Adverse financial market reactions to the trade tensions could weigh on domestic demand
and thereby also lower inflation. By contrast, a fragmentation of global supply chains could
raise inflation by pushing up import prices. A boost in defense and infrastructure spending
could also raise inflation over the medium term. But it's clear from her actions, even
her statements, they don't believe that's actually the base case or even a highly probable case.
Defense spending is not going to raise consumer prices, nor is global supply chain rejiggering
might raise prices in the short run. But the overarching result from all of this, on top of
the weakness the European economy's always experiencing, that's priced into the markets
and has been priced in since 2023 and really going back to 2022, all of it is leading in the
direction for disinflation over the long term. And everything that's happened since then,
including central banks reacting to conditions by lowering rates going back to the middle of last
year, continues to tell us that's the direction for the overall economy. And so whatever tariffs
might actually do, it's only going to add to these pressures pushing the economy in that same
direction, not the inflationary direction. So everyone expected that the ECB is going to cut
rates, and they did so. But we also got more confirmation from officials that though they
don't want to come out and say it, the pathway is open. The ECB is going to get out of the markets
way and allow rates to drop where fundamentally they're going to go anyway. They're very likely
to go anyway. Forward rate markets say that. Swap markets say that. Cash bond markets are already in
low territory to begin with, sub 2% for the German curve, certainly. So everything is going in that
direction. There is a global race to the bottom that didn't just begin with tariffs. It began
last year, this global race to the bottom. And now we're seeing the next stage of it,
where even central bankers are saying, yeah, because of tariffs, we're actually probably
going to race to the bottom. Only the Fed and a couple other ones like the Bank of England
are holding out at this point. There is no soft landing. Fundamentally, rates were going down
after the impoverishment of the price illusion and the supply shock. The forgot-how-to-grow-economy
was the best that we could hope for. If only we could have just ended it there. But like
interest rates and the economy falling off, there is nothing stopping this race to the bottom.
I mentioned these key financial ratios that are at extremes. There's another one based
on commodities that has entered the same chat. It's not copper this time, and I went over it
in the video link below. As always, thank you very much for joining me. Huge thank you,
Eurodollar University members and Eurodollar University subscribers. And until next time,
take care.
