What to Do if Your Pension Is Terminated

Retirement Revenue
9 followers
1 Video View·Jan 13, 2025
Kodak is the latest of many companies that have stopped their pension, giving participants options on whether to cash it out, roll it over, or draw a monthly retirement payment. In this episode of Wise Money, we are explaining all the options you have if you find yourself in this situation and how to decide which is best for your unique financial situation.
It's time for Wise Money with Corhorn Financial Group with certified financial planners, Kevin
Corhorn, Mike Bernard and Josh Gregory.
Welcome to another episode of the Wise Money Show with Corhorn Financial Group, where every
week we're helping you take your next wise step in your financial life.
Thanks for being here, friends.
My name is Mike Bernard.
I'm your host.
I'm also one of the certified financial planners on the program.
And with me in the KFG studio is my business partner and fellow CFP, Josh Gregory.
Well, another company has announced that it's shutting down its pension.
It's been happening a lot over the years.
This time it's Kodak, and they have announced to their participants that they either get
to cash it out, roll it over or draw a monthly retirement income.
Today we're going to talk about what do you do if your pension gets frozen?
What are your real options and how do you plan for it?
All of that and more on today's episode.
That's right.
And special guest today.
Join us in the studio again.
Amy Masters, CFP, all-star, just amazing person all around.
And Amy, we couldn't decide.
This is probably your third time on or fourth time?
I think so.
So thanks for having me again today.
That's well, we had to, you know, answer the fan's requests and so by popular demand, glad
to have you.
If you have a question for the program, we'd love to hear from you.
You can call or text us 574-222-2000.
That's 574-222-2000.
Online wise money show.com is where you can find us and reach out to us that way as well.
And then wherever you're at on social media, we are there as well, just search wise money
show, not on TikTok though.
And I don't think that's changed in 2025.
So it is what it is.
I spent a little time in my life in Western New York, just outside of Rochester.
And the big employer over there was Kodak.
Now this was, this was over 20, it's over 20 years ago.
So this is, this is pre-iPhone.
So Kodak was the man.
Like it was, it was a big employer.
Yeah.
I remember that about my time in Western New York.
I remember two other things.
It snowed.
It's, it's like you, you, we think we get a little snow here and I grew up in Grand
Rapids.
Yeah.
We get snow there.
No, no, no.
Buffalo, Niagara, Rochester.
They get snow.
It's different.
Feet at a time.
It's at a different level.
And then last thing, food.
Like it, there is some, and I'm not going to say cuisine because you can't call a garbage
plate, which is, which is a delicacy there.
You can't call that a cuisine.
Like that's a dish.
They call it the garbage plate.
Yeah.
I've never heard this.
French fries, you know, chicken fingers, hot sauce.
Like every day.
Just pile it on.
Yeah.
They just pile it and they call it a garbage plate.
Cause it's like all these different things.
They just throw it on one plate and mash it all together and here you go.
And since living here in Indiana, have you ever had, what's it called?
A haystack?
A haystack meal?
I've never even heard of that.
It's, they just layer stuff that doesn't belong together, but you put it together and you
call it a meal.
I don't know.
Same thing.
Yeah.
All right.
Well, so yeah, Kodak was the big employer back there.
And just recently Kodak is joined on the long list of employers that have frozen their pension,
terminated their pension.
In fact, and I'm not, I don't fully, fully understand it from the article, but in offloading
this off of their balance sheet, they're actually going to retrieve about a half a billion
dollars.
$500 million will be added to their balance sheet in liquidity because they're offloading
their pension.
They're freezing it and they're offloading it to MasterCard Foundation apparently.
I'm not sure in the article that I'm reading here, this is not a show just about this incident,
but more about the trend.
But that's very interesting.
Does that imply that they were overfunded?
Yeah.
It says it's done great.
That's increased significantly due to contributions and market performance and all that while
Kodak has really struggled.
Yeah.
The company itself.
Yeah.
They missed the off ramp out of the film industry and into digital cameras and everything.
Yeah.
That's kind of a famous story.
Well, so they're giving employees options and we want to go through those options just
in case you find yourself in a similar situation where your retirement plan or your pension
is frozen or changing.
I mean, Amy, we've dealt with this with, I know some clients that we were jointly working
on recently where some large employers here in town, all of a sudden the pension's frozen,
no longer being funded, but then sometimes it's getting forced out like it is here.
I think this is a perfect example of why you really have to be flexible with your financial
decisions that you're making because you might have all 20, 30 years been like, all right,
I have this pension, this is how I'm going to be drawing it.
And then get a little bit of a curve ball.
So being able to be flexible and pivot when you have decisions like this to make, I think
is really important.
Well, and having your financial life not only be flexible, but then have it be decisionable.
And Amy, for all of her incredible talents, she is one of the leaders at KFG in some of
our retirement planning and some of the tools that we use to kind of forecast, well, what
if this and what if that?
And so immediately I think of you and where we, okay, well, let's pivot or let's make
this technique or change as if that pension is frozen and it will no longer grow.
Now what does that do to your plan and what trade-offs do we need to make?
Exactly.
We like to build what we call Monte Carlo analysis for our clients.
And so being able to show this is what it looks like if we do, example, a lump sum with
a pension, or here's what it looks like if we do take a stream of income.
Being able to kind of see those side-by-sides, kind of play around with what ifs, I think
can be really helpful in making what that decision, what makes the most sense for that
person in particular.
Because it's not a, everybody should make the same election.
In fact, it's often different person to a person depending on what their goals are.
You know, over the years as we've helped so many people with their retirement planning
and we look at the five different factors, the different levers they can pull to get
themselves ready for retirement, one of the determinants on how ready they really are
is the amount of income that they're going to have in retirement.
And man, can you imagine though planning and working your entire career assuming that there's
a stream of income coming to you?
That's what a pension is, right?
Some listeners may not even be familiar with a pension, but it's kind of like Social Security
where you have a promise from your employer that they're going to provide a certain stream
of income to you for the rest of your life potentially.
A stream of income that you can't outlive.
That sounds pretty good.
And certainly, if you have that kind of stream of income, if you have a great Social Security
check that you believe you can count on, then it reduces the amount of demands that are
going to be placed on your retirement assets that you're building up, like in a 401k, an IRA,
a Roth IRA, that sort of thing.
You need to accumulate less money if there's a stream of income that won't ever be shut off.
But what if, what if as you get close to retirement, the game all changes on you?
And no longer can you count on that stream of income or they're potentially going to
reduce it, give you other options, that kind of thing.
That's really what the folks at Kodak are facing.
Yeah, I like the idea or the approach.
And this isn't easy, I'll tell you that, but if you happen to have a pension, you work
at an employer that offers a pension, building that into your plan, but then saving up for
retirement as if you're not going to have it.
And that really puts you in the driver's seat.
And for a lot of people, what that means is, well, if the pension turned out okay, then
maybe we're retiring early, earlier than we want.
Maybe we get to enjoy more spending or whatever.
You've got flexibility.
So it's not for everyone, but if you do have a pension right now, I'd consider saving up
for retirement as if you don't even have that pension.
Well, that principle applies to Social Security as well, right?
If you're younger, maybe you're in your 40s or 50s and you're kind of looking at Social
Security, questioning whether or not, is this dependable for me?
Is this still going to be around?
Well, what if you build it into your plan, but save as if it's not going to be there,
like you just described?
One thing that this makes me think about too, is so many people that reach out to us to
set up an appointment, for example, they think they need to have an event already happen
to say, now we need to start a relationship with somebody.
But I think these are exact reasons why it can be helpful to start those relationships
when you're not kind of backed into a corner of, oh, I have to make these decisions because
I have this deadline.
Going ahead and building that relationship, having that trust already built, makes it
very easy to pivot when you get news like this, rather than finding someone to help
you make these decisions and needing to make a quick decision.
When you think back on clients who have received a letter in the mail saying, hey, sorry to
break the news to you, but your pension is changing or it's going away, we're freezing
it, whatever.
How much time, if you're thinking back, how much time do people have to make a decision
on what they do?
Is it a couple months?
A couple months is what I would say.
I think so.
There was a hospital system a couple years ago that we saw a lot of these letters get
sent out, and I think they had like 90 days to make a decision on what they were going
to do.
90 days goes by real fast, especially if you're kind of paralyzed by, how do I even make this
choice?
And to your point, if you don't have someone already on speed dial, a financial advisor,
a coach that you've had a longstanding relationship with, they know your situation, they can help
you figure out how to pivot.
To go establish that relationship on the fly, that's not as ideal, right?
No, no.
And we're talking about a terminated pension.
A frozen pension is a little bit different.
Frozen pension is typically, they're just going to stop being funded.
Now this is an event, you need to update your retirement projection, your retirement plan.
You might need to have some trade-offs there, but oftentimes there isn't a forced decision.
In a terminated pension, like we're talking about here, no, there's a decision.
What are your choices?
Which one's best for you?
And we're sort of talking about it, but we're going to expand on it as we go.
What's the process you make to figure out, or the process you go through to figure out
what the best decision is for you?
So we've got that and more coming up on the Wise Money Show with GoHorn Financial Group.
Hello YouTube, thanks for being here.
This is the Wise Money Show.
What you're watching right now is our weekly one-hour talk show that airs right here on
this channel, 10 a.m. Eastern time every Saturday morning, also on podcast at the same time,
but also on a couple of local radio stations at the same time as well, which is why it's
the length that it is and why we have segments and breaks and all that sort of stuff, because
it's on the radio.
But if you're like, hey, this isn't really my pace or the speed I want to go, we've got
next Wise Step videos that air all throughout the workweek right here on this channel as
well, eight minutes long, 10 minutes long, 12 minutes long, taking a certain financial
concept, applying it to your financial life through the financial planning perspective
and looking at all six areas.
So make sure you hit that subscribe button, turn on notifications so you're made aware
every time we drop new content, and if you like the content, like the content and share
it as well.
Thank you.
The other thing, Western New York, you got the authentic New York-style pizza over there,
just because there's so many people.
The foldable kind?
Oh yeah.
Floppy pizza?
Greasy pizza?
Pizza was by the slice, not by the pie.
That's what they called it as well.
It was like normal, hot sauce or ranch.
What?
Pizza.
Yeah, hot sauce or ranch.
And so everyone, you fold it and you dip it in your hot sauce.
What?
Did you?
I learned to.
Did they convert you?
Oh yeah, I learned to.
And for a while, then it was, I would throw like Frank's Red Hot on the pizza as well,
which that's a thing.
People like it.
But that was like, yeah, your pepperoni pizza, your cheese pizza, with hot sauce.
Wow.
Yep.
Explains a lot about you.
I'm the person at Thanksgiving that has to have all my food separated out and cannot touch,
so what you guys were describing, not high on my list.
So you've never had a garbage plate, is what you're saying.
I have not.
Probably won't.
Okay, so have either of you guys, my family's never been to Niagara Falls, which is, like
I'm embarrassed by that, but have you guys?
I've never been.
I have.
Yeah.
I'm glad I went, I don't know if it would be necessarily a repeat, but it's pretty cool,
you can go behind the falls and it's just, it's crazy to think that much water is falling
every second and it never runs out.
Like how is that possible?
I know.
It is something, it's a sight to see.
Also, last shout out before we get into it, if you're thinking, oh yeah, we should drive
over there.
Where I went to school in Geneseo State, part of the SUNY system, right next to it, your
father-in-law just went, actually.
So they call it the Grand Canyon of the East in Letchworth Park.
There is an enormous gorge and it is beautiful.
It is very, very cool.
So Western New York, very, very hilly and so yeah, so that's, if you could go swing
over and see Niagara Falls and then drive another hour and a half and see the Grand
Canyon of the East, so yeah.
Travel agent here now.
Yeah, there you go.
There you go.
You getting a commission somehow or?
Nope, nope.
All right, here we go.
So let's talk a little bit more about that process.
So maybe just briefly the five-factor retirement plan or if we want to talk about that Monte
Carlo process and techniques or however we would talk about that.
And then we can go into the three options.
So starting the second segment, but I'm assuming we're like squarely in the layout of the first.
So here we go.
If you find out that your pension, that maybe you've had a pension, you've been planning
on it, all of a sudden is being terminated.
Number one, you've got a choice to make, but number two, it's going to significantly impact
your plan for retirement.
So what do you do?
We're helping with that right now.
This is the wise money show with GoHorn financial group.
Thanks for being here.
My name is Mike Bernard with me in the KFG studios, Josh Gregory, special guest Amy Masters.
Every episode of the wise money shows on podcast, wherever you listen, just search the wise
money show, subscribe to it there, rate the program there as well.
We appreciate it.
You can share those episodes as well if you'd like to do so.
Okay.
So yeah, employer Kodak, obviously it's gone through a lot of turmoil over the past 20
years with, with, with, you know, last week we were talking about what to, how to plan
for having a child.
I remember one of the big things that we had to plan for when we had our first child was
buying the video camera.
That's not a thing.
That's not, that's not a thing anymore, but it was a way back when.
And yeah, Kodak obviously it's, it's been hit hard.
And so they are offloading their pension.
When you, when you get that show or when you get that, um, that announcement, what's the
process that you would go through to determine, well, what do I do?
Right?
It's, is it a feeling?
Well, hopefully you're going to have some feelings, frustration and maybe fear, but
what do you do with those emotions?
It's gotta be process driven.
So guys, let's talk a little bit about the retirement planning process to kind of categorically
see, all right, well, how do you adapt and what would you adjust?
Yeah.
So one of the exercises I like to go through with my client is building out that Monte
Carlo analysis that I mentioned earlier.
And part of that process, we go through the five factors of someone's financial or retirement
life.
So first factor is age and age is two components.
There's the, well, when do we want to be retired or not be reliant on a paycheck anymore?
So that financial freedom of a paycheck, but there's also the life, life expectancy component
of age.
And that plays a really big role sometimes in this pension decision.
Our second area.
So age is first, we have income, what income sources are we going to have?
This is especially where again, that pension is going to make a impact to that retirement
projection and where we might see two side by side scenarios, right?
Right.
One, if we have the stream of income versus one way, we might have a lump sum that we're
kind of creating our own stream of income from by doing some withdrawals from investments.
And then also right there, you might be where, okay, well, I'm assuming I'm still going to
work another 20 years.
And therefore the pension calculation that we've got is it's going to be this high number.
And all of a sudden you find out the pension is frozen and, or, or, or terminated and it's
no longer, you need to recalculate what that number is before you get to your choice of
whether to take this money lump sum or as a stream of income, know that your stream
of income and it's likely different than what you're planning on.
And that's going to make a big difference, right?
If you're planning on, you know, a thousand dollars a month of pension, it turns out to
be $300 a month.
That's, that's a significant change.
Yeah, absolutely.
So, yeah, so we have age income is going to be things like Social Security as well.
We're going to have spending.
So what we want lifestyle to look like in retirement, what type of travel, what my
earlier retirement looked like versus later on in retirement spending.
We're going to have savings.
So what is that savings rate that we're taking into maybe like a 401k?
And that sometimes is the difference with a pension, too.
Sometimes people are heavier on pensions.
But then when this pension gets frozen or terminated, that's where we often see a big
shift into 401ks.
And that might be where the employer is now contributing to that, where it was more the
pension before.
So what is their savings rate?
And then the last one is risk, right?
What risk are we going to take with the investments, both while we're in that
accumulation phase, as well as likely going to see a little bit different risk when
we're actually in withdrawal mode of the investment dollars.
So might be a little bit more conservative later on in life.
And so what that Monte Carlo is taking all of those inputs that we're building and
kind of oversimplifying it.
It's normally maybe even more than one or two meetings to get through all of that
conversation. But we're running that through our Monte Carlo.
So we're running a thousand different possibilities of market cooperates, market
doesn't cooperate, and we're getting a probability of success.
And that probability of success is really the key to helping us figure out the, OK,
what if it's this? What if it's that?
Because it's going to move that lever on what that probability of success is.
And ultimately, that's what we're trying to do is look at what is our ideal
retirement. And are we on track to accomplish that or not?
As in, is that probability of success in that window we want to see it in?
Yeah, that's right. And not everyone starts in that window or has a high enough
probability of success that we would say, yeah, you're on track or you've got a game
plan that's going to work. And so adjustments have to be made and there are
tradeoffs. And all those tradeoffs happen in those five different areas that you
were just describing. You can think of those as five different decisions or levers,
as you said, that you can pull to make changes to your output.
Well, sometimes circumstances can change, you know, the factors or change the
decisions. All of a sudden you have a health change and you thought you were retiring
at 65. You need to be done at 62.
That changes everything in the calculations.
So where are the other areas that we can compensate or adjust to help make sure
things are still on track?
Well, we're describing today in the show a situation where what if your employer
makes a change that affects you when you have a pension and you have a stream of
income that you are counting on?
And now they're saying, hey, we're not going to be maintaining this big retirement
plan and this pool of assets that are going to generate that income to you.
We're instead going to kind of hand it over to you.
Now it's no longer income that you can count on, but instead you have a pool of
assets potentially that you have something to do with and or decisions to make.
And that could improve your plan or it can impact it negatively depending on your
situation. But it will have an impact.
And that's why you have to go back to the drawing board.
You have to adjust the assumptions that you're making.
Yeah. I mean, it will have an impact.
So in that 90 days or whatever window you have to make a decision going like
updating that analysis to say, OK, well, if you if the pension stops and you have
a you take a lump sum, let's input that and let's see what that looks like.
And if you don't take a lump sum, but you keep the monthly annuity and it changes,
you know, it's a lower amount and it becomes this.
Let's see the probability.
And then what other adjustments do you need to make because of this?
I mean, that's yes, you're going to have some emotions, but but follow that
process. And that planning will help lead you to what's the right what's the right
choice for you. And you may be listening today thinking, well, I don't have a
pension. I mean, this doesn't even pertain to me.
Right. You know, click.
Let's change the station, whatever.
But here's the reality. There's going to be some other decision that is dropped in
your lap at some point.
Maybe it's an inheritance and you have some choices on how you receive it.
Are you going to take it in a lump sum?
Are you going to spend it in one, you know, happy year or are you going to spread it
out over time? Are you going to turn it into a guaranteed string of stream of
income? How are you going to approach it?
Again, your your decisions in those areas are going to have an impact on whether or
not your retirement is really solid and healthy, very dependable and predictable.
Or is it one that's a little sketchy?
Is it one that, you know, maybe it will all work out if the planets align just
right. Those are things that you need to know.
And that's the whole reason why you work with a certified financial planner.
We're all about we want to provide confidence and clarity.
I think having a game plan, knowing, hey, my game plan is probably going to change
over time. What does that look like?
I think that just really gives people confidence.
Yeah, agreed.
And this situation.
Well, in most situations, not when the pensions frozen, but when it's terminated,
you've got three choices.
You can cash it out.
We're going to start there.
Pros and cons and all that.
Or you can lump sum, take the lump sum and roll it over to an IRA instead of cashing
it out. Or you can keep it as a monthly annuity.
Now, in this instance, we're talking about with Kodak.
They said that if you're already retired, you're no longer working there, then you
don't have a choice. You have to take it as a monthly payment.
But if you're still working there or you're not yet retired, you'll have a choice of
cashing it out, taking lump sum or still keeping it as a monthly annuity.
Let's let's talk about all three.
But I want to start with the with the obvious one.
Likely we're not going to recommend.
But a lot of people do make this choice.
And that is I'm just going to cash it out.
What first, I guess what happens mechanically?
What happens when you say, give me the money?
Yeah. So if you take just a distribution right to your bank account, often there's a
mandatory tax withholding that they'll do.
And I would say ninety nine percent of the time that mandatory tax withholding isn't
probably the exact amount of taxes that need to be withheld.
But there's going to be, you know, it's a taxable event.
It's all going to land on that one calendar year that the distribution is occurring.
And if you're not fifty nine and a half, there's probably going to be a 10 percent
early withdrawal penalty as well on top of the taxes.
So, yeah. And we hear this all the time.
And this is Amy said earlier, you might have missed it.
But having the financial planning relationship intact and in place before these
decisions are made, so crucial because so oftentimes people say, I just made this.
I just had this event, just made this decision.
Can you help me moving forward?
And often when we when they say I took the cash out, they say, but they withheld the
taxes. No, they they withheld taxes.
It might not be the taxes, though, because it might not be most often.
It's not going to align with the amount of taxes you really need withheld.
More of sort of the pros and cons of cashing it out.
But then also the other options.
How do you know which one's best for you?
We've got that more coming up on the wise money show with Gorehorn Financial Group.
OK, I had a feeling this is going to take a whole show.
A whole show. Yeah, I always do.
That's good. So third segment.
We'll pick that back up and.
Yeah, like the first thing that you do.
If you if you do the cash out, I'm assuming there's not a ton to hit there, but it'll
probably take half the segment and then we'll get into going to lump sum first or or.
Yeah, let's do lump sum.
OK, all right, here we go.
If you choose to cash out a terminated pension or even just choose to cash out an old
401k, what do you do next?
What do you need to plan for after making that decision?
We're helping with that right now. This is the wise money show with Gorehorn Financial Group.
Thanks for being here. My name is Mike Bernard with me in the KFC studios.
Josh Gregory and special guest Amy Masters.
Stay up to date on all wise money content.
Find us online wise money show dot com and all over social media wherever you're at.
We are there as well. Search the wise money show.
Talking about a a just continued trend of employers terminating their pension, getting
that off the books, getting that financial responsibility off of their backs and saying
here you take the money, you deal with it.
Kodak was a recent example and and employees are left with, well, do I cash this money
out? Do I take it as a lump sum and roll it over to a retirement account or do I take
it as a monthly pension?
We're breaking down those decisions and starting with with just cashing it out.
Recently, we had a local employer that was an ESOP get acquired by a national
organization. And this ESOP, which can be a confusing vehicle, it's like a retirement
plan. Ownership is pretty, pretty fantastic.
And and when this company acquired the ESOP, all of a sudden these employees saw their
balances grow significantly and then they had a choice.
What do I do with this?
And I got to tell you, a lot of a lot of people said, yeah, this is I'm cashing it out.
I'm nowhere near retirement.
But in one example that I can think of, but we're still renting and we want to we
really want to buy a house.
So I know I'm going to have to pay taxes, but I'm taking my lumps and we're going to
buy a house. And so not that oftentimes we would advise that.
But a lot of times people do make that choice and it is happening more and more often
just because the affordability of housing and and whatnot can be difficult.
Some people are feeling more of the pinch in the aftermath from the pandemic when
everyone received a big chunk of cash or multiple chunks of cash from the government.
All those dollars have been spent down now while life keeps getting more expensive.
And so you may be tempted to have at your at your disposal.
You have at your fingertips a chunk of money that you had previously thought of as off
limits. You know, it wasn't even available to you.
And now what if it could solve a short term problem for you or make an opportunity that
wasn't going to be an opportunity?
Suddenly a goal that you have becomes within reach because you have access.
But but here's the thing, even though we would say we would coach you work with your
CFP before you make that before you make that choice.
And if you make that choice and it's not the one they advise, they're not going to be
mad at you. They're not going to shame you.
They're not going to they're not going to kick you out of their office.
It's it's your plan.
It's your choice, even though it might not be the one that they advise.
They would quickly pivot to the next thing you need to do, because, Josh, you said if
it if it. Oh, gosh, I already lost the train of thought, exactly what you said.
But what you want to avoid is you don't want I know what you said.
This is going to solve a problem.
I'm going to cash it out and it's going to solve a problem.
You don't want that choice that you think solving a problem, creating another one.
That's right. I think the first rating problem, right?
The first thing you would do is if that's what you decided, you would do that tax
projection as geeky as that sounds to see what really is the tax impact.
And did you withhold the right amount or do you need to set some of this money aside for
the upcoming tax bill?
Because that would be one of the biggest nightmares.
You cash it out. They withheld for taxes.
You're good. You spent all the money and then you do your taxes.
And it's like, oh, now I owe all this money because maybe it wasn't enough taxes that
were paid in. But I don't have that money anymore because I've already spent it.
I think that tax projection gives that clarity of how much truly needs to actually go
towards taxes. If that's the route we're going to go.
And that's only one of the shorter term problems that you're trading in in that
scenario, because you still do need to pay attention to those dollars that are
coming out of the pension that you're cashing in and using for some other financial
priority in the short term.
That was money that was helping to prepare you for retirement and retirement may be
so far out in the in the future that you don't give it a whole lot of thought.
But the risk is that if this were to happen multiple times in your career, maybe you
cash in a pension this time.
Next time you've accumulated some dollars in a 401k.
And then before you know it, you're cashing that in and you're never really getting
the compounding effect of accumulating dollars in retirement accounts.
I often refer to it as as you're saving for retirement or your employers doing it for
you. It's like planting acorns and those acorns someday will be mighty oak trees that
you will be able to live off of in retirement unless you start pulling them up by the
roots when they're saplings.
And that could be effectively what you're doing when you cash in that pension.
Just because an employer gave you the option doesn't mean that you should.
It's part of the reason why I was going back to some data.
The median retirement assets or or account balances for Americans is $87,000.
So if you looked at all Americans lined, everybody's account balances up and pick the
middle option or the middle balance, it's $87,000.
But that's only amongst those that even have a balance.
Well, 53 percent don't.
Roughly half. So the number, the median would be far lower if we included everybody
who doesn't have a balance.
And it doesn't mean that they don't have the opportunity to be saving for retirement.
It doesn't mean that they never had a balance.
It could be that unfortunately they pulled up a sapling somewhere along the line and
never let it continue to mature down the road.
Yeah, I would I would do that tax projection to see really what your tax bill is so you
can get prepared. And then I would update that retirement plan to see.
All right. Well, this is the new normal.
Made the decision. Here we go.
Let's move forward. How do we get back on track with retirement?
So that's if you cash it out.
That's the least likely option.
The one year CFP is likely not going to recommend.
Really, it's going to be a choice between do you take it lump sum or do you take it as a
monthly payment?
Let's assume let's talk about lump sum first.
What are the pros and cons?
Logistically, how it works, I guess, is you roll it over a lump sum into an IRA.
The money in your pension is has not already been taxed.
So it's not option.
You can't roll it over to a Roth.
That would be a Roth conversion.
You might want to do that.
Maybe that'd be one of the reasons you do want to do the lump sum.
But it would need to go to an IRA first pre-tax and that as long as you do that
correctly, it's not taxable to you when you do that.
And then you've got flexibility.
You've got choice with those dollars.
You can draw some out.
You can keep it invested.
You can invest it all in one specific stock.
You can make it diversified.
You can keep it low risk, high risk, whatever.
You've got choices and you can keep contributing to it.
Yeah.
You know, again, if all of a sudden your employer is discontinuing a retirement
plan, you may need to pick up some slack somewhere in your financial life and get
going on some additional contributions.
That's right.
And I would say this lump sum is probably one of the most common ways I'll see
people making this decision.
Again, it doesn't mean it's the right or wrong way for you, but this is often one
of the most common routes I see.
And some of it too is, especially if the company is having this be an option for
you, is it might be because they're trying to put themselves in a better place
financially, the health of the company.
Sometimes people want to lean towards that lump sum just because they're fearful of,
well, what is the comfort level of how I feel like this company is making decisions
and their financial future, you know, just because they say you're eligible for X
amount a month doesn't necessarily mean that's going to be what you get if the
company doesn't maybe make some wise financial habits.
Now there's some insurance protections and things like that in place.
That's not going to go to zero, but sometimes that is what I hear people say
is I'm scared of keeping that money with the company.
I want to have control over these dollars.
Yeah.
Just by the simple fact that the company is saying they no longer want to offer the
pension is a sign that, yeah, maybe I shouldn't leave it there.
I would, I would agree, Amy, that this is if you were just to survey folks and out
of 10 that have the choice, I would say seven probably lump sum it.
And, uh, I'm just thinking of a couple recent examples where I've helped plan
through this with clients and every time they've taken the lump sum and what's
been the deciding factor, flexibility.
And just to clarify, again, lump sum does not mean cash it in all in one big chunk.
It means roll it over into an IRA so that you continue to postpone the day that you
have to pay taxes on it.
You get to choose how it's invested.
You can allow it to continue to compound and accumulate for retirement, which could
still be years and years into the future.
So you're, you're kind of parking it in a new spot essentially, where you can kind
of, uh, recalibrate your game plan.
And as we said, maybe add more money to it, possibly start converting those IRA
dollars into Roth.
So doing some special tax planning, none of that was even on the table when the
money was in the pension.
Yeah.
You had no choice.
It was, Hey, this is what you're going to get.
It's all going to be taxable.
You couldn't control the growth and, and all of that.
And, um, and often one of the challenges and we'll, we'll pick this back up as
years and years ago, pensions, many pensions did have a cost of living
adjustment.
Now, most of them do not.
And so choosing to roll it over lump sum gives you an opportunity to keep up with
inflation.
So, all right, we've got more coming up here on the wise money show with
financial group.
Okay.
We hit all of those things like sort of rapid fire.
We can probably go a little bit deeper and then we can talk about monthly pension
pros and cons.
And then if I'm assuming we're going to be out of time, which is fine.
Uh, if not, then we can kind of turn it over to, well, same sort of scenario with
a bold four, one K and anything.
Else do we, I want to hit lump sum fiduciary because without doing that
analysis, we do have a lot of people in our industry that that's what they're
going to recommend, whether that's in their best interest or not.
So I think that's an important topic.
Yeah.
Weave us there.
Cause I'll launch it with lump sum and I don't know whether it will be perfect for
you to take it right at the beginning or not, but we'll see.
That's good.
All right, here we go.
Thanks for being here.
This is the wise money show with Corhorn financial group.
My name is Mike Bernard here with me in the KFT studios, Josh
Gregory, special guest, Amy masters.
Every episode of the wise money show, as well as a lot of other
content is on the YouTube channel.
Go to YouTube, search the wise money show, subscribe to it there
and turn on notifications.
You're made aware every time we drop new content like today's talk show, but
also next wise step videos, content that airs all throughout the work week.
We've got well over a thousand videos there and millions of you.
So make sure you go over to the YouTube channel, check it out
and subscribe to it there.
Talking about what to do with a frozen or terminated pension.
You then have a choice.
Do you cash it out?
Do you roll it over to a retirement plan?
Or do you continue just to take it as a, as a monthly pension, a
monthly annuity out there in retirement?
How do you make that choice?
We already talked about that.
And that is process driven, not emotion driven process driven and
evaluating it in those options within your five factor retirement plan.
And as we said earlier, when you, when you kind of mix all of those decisions,
choices together, those five factors, and then stress test it, you're going to
get some sort of, uh, I don't know, confidence score as to whether you're
on track or not, and when you make this change to this pension, that's going
to change your score and that's going to help you determine, well, what should
you do and, and what are the trade offs you need to make?
When we're talking about lump sum or pension, a lot of people do choose
lump sum because of the flexibility, but you do want to make sure that
that's sage and, and, and, you know, wise advice.
Yeah, absolutely.
That's where running the pros and cons of both running them in the context of
that overall financial plan is so important because, you know, if you're
not working with a CFP or fiduciary who needs to do what's in your best
interest, this is an area we can see a lot of conflicts, right?
And an advisor who's not bound by that fiduciary duty, they can do what's in
their best interest and their best interest is that you take the lump sum.
Now, again, that doesn't mean that's not in your best interest, but there
might be some instances where taking the pension could be the better route for
you, but if the only way they're getting paid is if they say, Hey, move this to
an IRA and I'm going to manage it for you, it's just something to be aware of.
That's where doing a full analysis, going through those pros and cons,
I think is really important.
Yeah.
And you're being gracious.
There are many people in our industry who they want you to take that lump sum.
They want you to roll it over to an IRA because they want to sell you something.
Like if, if we're just being blunt, they want to sell you some investments.
And as you said, that might not be in your best interest.
In fact, it might give up some of the goodness of doing the lump
sum rollover to begin with.
Because, because think about this, when you had money in your pension, you
really didn't have any control over it.
You didn't get to choose what kind of investment options there were.
You, it was structured, whether you wanted it or not this way, it was
structured to be generating income.
But maybe what's in your best interest at your stage of the game is that you
want it to be more growth oriented.
If you were to take the lump sum and roll it over to an IRA, now all
of a sudden you do have control.
You do have the whole world to choose from.
As far as investment options, you can pivot to be more growth
oriented, to build for, for the future.
And if someone steers you towards a product, you know, a investment tool
that in the right circumstances for the right use, it's a wonderful tool, but
it right out of the gate checks all those boxes in the wrong way.
You give up control again.
You don't really have investment options.
It's not really growth oriented.
Maybe it's really expensive.
That's not in your best interest.
And so we've said this multiple times on this episode.
That you need to make sure you have a certified financial plan or a
relationship where you already trust them.
You already know that they have your best interest at heart so that when you are
facing this type of decision, you don't wander into the wrong office or start
trusting the wrong person who might give you good advice, but good is the enemy
of great, as we often say, right?
And so don't, don't give up all the goodness of the lump sum.
If, um, if that's the best option for you.
All right.
So then let's talk about that monthly annuity or that pension.
What are some of the pros and cons of that?
What are, what are some of the reasons or circumstances where someone may say, no,
no, no, that's, that's still the best option.
Well, I'll start really quick too, is if you're choosing the lumps or the
monthly stream of income, you also probably have a lot of choices to make
within, well, how do I want that to be given to me?
Is it going to be for my life only?
There's often some type of life only with period certain.
So five year, 10 year, that means if you pass away before that five or
10 years, it's still going to pay out for that period of time.
There can be some type of survivor benefits, a benefit for like a
surviving spouse, sometimes even that's at different levels.
So there can be a lot of choices just within the taking the stream of income.
And that itself can be a big decision to be making.
The benefit of having a stream of income that you can't outlive is
just simply that you can't outlive it.
And that's one of the risks that you face.
Everyone listening today right now is facing the risk that you're going to
live longer than you ever imagined or live longer than your assets would
allow, you know, you outlive your, your resources in other words.
And you, you eliminate at least part of that risk by having streams of
income with guarantees attached to it.
And that can create a foundation, an income foundation that allows someone
to know, okay, my needs are going to be met for as long as I live.
Now I'm planning for the extras.
I'm building up additional resources that will supplement those streams of
income so that I can do the fun stuff.
The, the things that I have discretion over and you know, the big trips or the
projects or the purchases or major gifts that you want to give, all of that stuff
gets funded with a retirement nest egg that you build and accumulate to, to add
some fun or add some benefits to your retirement outlook.
Yeah, I think, you know, the, the main, if we were to just over simplify, yes,
you need to be doing this financial planning and make this decision as
part of, uh, of, of your financial plan.
But the reason you would do the lump sum rollover is for flexibility.
And, and to me, the first thing that comes to mind when now do the monthly
annuity instead is if you already have that flexibility elsewhere, right?
If you've built up enough resources where next time, you know, it's time to buy a
vehicle, you've got the resources right there as you want to take, um, more
withdrawals to fund a trip or whatever.
You've got the resources, you've got your investment strategies built out
and there's a lot of choice there.
Then you might say, yeah, adding this to my foundation of monthly income in
conjunction with my social security.
Um, I'm comfortable.
And then also when you're looking and saying, yeah, from a tax standpoint as
well, I'm, I don't need the extra flexibility.
I'm okay.
I've got enough flexibility elsewhere and with resources that I can do a Roth
conversion, or I can choose to take money out where it's not going to influence the
tax on my social security or the tax bracket that I'm in.
If you've already got that flexibility built up from a tax standpoint as well,
that might, again, also when you update your plan, you might say, yeah, the
monthly annuity is okay.
It makes sense in my situation.
Especially, you know, not, not everyone is like this, but I generally see a trend
of my clients who are in retirement.
Sometimes it might be a little bit nervous about the market more so than
younger clients, because naturally if there's a big drop in the market, for
example, they don't have quite as much time to let those dollars recover as
someone who's very much still in that accumulation phase.
So having that flexibility of I'm less reliant on the investment dollars because
I have something like social security and this pension stream of income.
The, uh, not, you know, the flexible dollars that might be in the IRA, Roth
IRA, those are, uh, I'm just less reliant on exactly what's going on in the
market, I think can be really helpful.
It's such a powerful spot to be, uh, to be in retirement, to know that you've
got a stream of income to cover your needs and it allows you to be patient
when the market does drop.
And that could be because you have a pension.
Maybe you're, uh, one of the retirees these days who still has that as an option.
It could also be, we see this where folks have maximized their social security
benefits, you know, they have amazing social security benefits and that allows
them to, uh, again, maybe pause some distributions out of the retirement
accounts during a dip in the market and then pick it up and maybe even make up
for it, uh, catch up, uh, down the road on their distributions when the market
has recovered to have that kind of flexibility or the, uh, the ability to
be patient with your investments is such a strength and I wish we could give that
to everybody.
Um, those who plan are the ones that end up having that kind of, uh, game
plan and safety net in place.
Yeah.
So I guess, uh, let's finish where we started and that is you do want to be
prepared at any time, whether you've got a pension, you're listening to this and
saying, there's no way I worked for a government, uh, institution.
There's no way I, my pension will be, you know, terminated or forced out.
No, no, no.
I would save up as if, as if you, as if you're not going to have the pension and
then you've got a lot of choice.
You've got a lot of flexibility.
Second, we said, work with that CFP, build out that five factor retirement
plan, even before there's an event so that you're prepared, your financial
life is decisionable, and then when, and if this does happen, or even if it's
just an old 401k run, run the analysis, update your financial plan, that five
factor plan to see, well, how does my confidence rate change when I update
this and then what adjustments do we make?
So, all right.
That's all the time we have for today.
On behalf of Josh Gregory, Amy masters, all of us at Corhorn financial group.
Have a great weekend.
We'll see you next Saturday for the wise money show with
Corhorn financial group.
Securities offered through Silver Oak securities member FINRA slash SIPC
advisory services offer through KFG wealth management, LLC.
Joint business has Corhorn financial group, KFG wealth management, LLC,
and Silver Oak securities incorporated companies are unaffiliated.
