How to Retire: Stay Flexible with Your Retirement Spending

Retirement Revenue
9 followers
6 Video Views·Oct 2, 2024
Christine Benz, Morningstar’s director of personal finance and retirement planning, interviews financial experts about different aspects of retirement in ‘How to Retire,’ the companion podcast to her book of the same name. In this episode, Christine sits down with senior nerd at Kitces.com and assistant professor of finance Derek Tharp. They talk through how adjusting your spending throughout your retirement can enable you to spend more in the long run.
Hi, I'm Christine Benz from Morningstar, and welcome to the How to Retire podcast.
It's a companion to my book, which is also called How to Retire.
Each episode will provide a bite-sized lesson about how to do some aspect of retirement well.
Today's episode will focus on how to make sure that the amount that you're spending
from your portfolio is reasonable. To tackle this topic, I sat down with Derek Tharp,
who's a senior research nerd at Kitsys.com and an assistant professor of finance at the
University of Southern Maine. I've loved Derek's work on how adjusting your spending in retirement
can actually enable you to spend more over your lifetime. I feel like it's so practical and
helpful, especially for people with tight financial plans heading into retirement.
Derek, thank you so much for being here.
Thanks for having me.
Well, you've done a lot of terrific research on the topic of withdrawal rates,
safe withdrawal rates, which is one of the most vexing questions for people embarking on
retirement. How much can they take out? So one of the conventions in the retirement spending
research is that people spend a fixed amount per year on an inflation-adjusted basis. Of course,
that's not really the way that people spend. So can you talk about that, how that's in a lot of
ways kind of a straw man when we approach retirement decumulation?
Yeah, I think there's really two key ways that when we look at retiree spending,
it does tend to deviate from what we actually see there. And the first would be that that
assumption that you're going to get a constant inflation adjustment over time just doesn't
really hold. We don't see that people are actually getting that increase in spending.
And instead, we do see a bit of a decrease in spending. Now, I think it's important to note
that decrease that we do see does tend to be at a rate that's less than inflation. So just to use
some round numbers, let's say inflation is 3%, and somebody's spending only goes up 2%. So they're
still spending more. It still feels like they're spending more. But on an inflation-adjusted basis,
they actually went backwards a little bit. And David Blanchett's retirement spending smile,
when you look at the numbers there, really anywhere from kind of a 1% to 2% real,
or inflation-adjusted decrease in spending is more normal as somebody's aging and going
through retirement. So that's the first thing that I don't think really aligns.
The second piece, which my co-author Justin Fitzpatrick and myself have referred to as the
retirement spending hatchet or retirement distribution hatchet, really talks about how
for a lot of people, especially if they're delaying Social Security, hoping to let that benefit grow,
pulling on their portfolio in the earlier years, we don't see this nice level kind of spending.
We might actually see distribution rates that are significantly higher on the front end. It's
kind of where we get the blade of our hatchet in that metaphor. And then we see those go down over
time. And so somebody spending at a very reasonable level might start out spending 7% in the early
years, and maybe that distribution rate drops to 1% or 2% once their Social Security kicks in.
So it's just a little bit more complex, I think, than really just assuming you're going to get
that constant inflation-adjusted spending amount. That can be nice for research and
kind of understanding, asking some questions about what somebody could have spent in the past.
But I don't think it really aligns with how retirees actually spend.
Yeah, that's helpful. So it sounds like the broad takeaway there is that for people who are
just embarking on retirement, if they're thinking about, say, a 4% type guideline,
that they may be short-shifting themselves and may be actually underspending when you factor in
that potentially they are delaying Social Security, and that'll come online,
and that their spending may naturally trend down throughout the life cycle. So
is that one of your messages, that early retirees should maybe feel comfortable
spending a little bit more than those standard rules of thumb might tell them are safe?
Absolutely. I do think a lot of the kind of standard rules of thumb that are out there
do push people to be excessively cautious when it comes to approaching retirement,
and especially thinking about, we have the ability to monitor and adjust along the way.
So we can make course corrections if it looks like we're headed down a path where
maybe there should be some concern. But especially when we're using something like
the worst historical sequence to set how to spend today, that means in most historical cases,
we're actually being far too conservative and leaving a lot of upside there. And so I think
that's really, it is something that I find concerning, and not just for retirees to be
able to spend at a little higher level, but also because when we think about the ages,
and somebody's talking kind of health span and their ability to use their wealth,
we're talking about missing out on some of the years when they're going to be most able to be
able to go out and enjoy their wealth and use it for things like travel or whatever it might be
that they want to be doing. And so to me, that real mismatch is something that I think can
really cost people a lot in terms of not just the numbers side of things, but the experiences and
what they can do with their wealth as well. Yeah, that's super helpful. It seems like
research from you and from other entities, including our team at Morningstar that have
looked at retirement spending, do point to the value of doing kind of an adjustment-based system
if you possibly can. So you're adjusting to the portfolio's value potentially,
as well as what's going on with your age and your life expectancy. So the question is,
how can you do that simply? Or can you? Are there any simple adjustment-based systems that you like?
So one I sometimes hear about is just do an RMD, required minimum distribution
style spending system, where you're looking at portfolio value divided by life expectancy.
But that one seems to kind of buffet people around an awful lot from year to year. Are there any
simple ways to adjust spending on an ongoing basis?
Yeah, I love simple. I'm always looking for simple. But sometimes I think we also need to
think about kind of doing it right versus simple. And when you look at something like somebody were
to go out and get brain surgery, I don't necessarily want the simplest way to carry
that out. I want that done correctly if I'm going through that. And so I think there's
two different ways to look at it. One being that there is some complexities to figuring out how you
would set up a good distribution or spending plan in retirement. So there's that piece of it. But
there is ways that I think we can kind of simply get at a number that I think is more important,
which is really trying to assess just our total risk or our overall risk that's in somebody's
retirement plan. And for a lot of people, that's really what ultimately matters. And so looking
for something like distribution rates are going to change, somebody's spending goals might spike,
all that might not be so flat and even over time. So how do we find something that
actually would work? And some of the tools that people are already using,
like Monte Carlo simulation, are going to get somebody to... I think people often misinterpret
what that number actually means, but it's going to get them to kind of a... If you think of it more
as just a risk level, and we kind of see where that number is, how it's changing over time,
that's something that is in a nice, simple way, kind of looking at the entirety of somebody's plan
and really trying to smooth things out. And to me, that's something that really is worth looking at
as a simpler type of way. And then using that in my preferred way that I would say is doing it
right in my view, where we ideally take that information and kind of put it into a guardrails
type framework, where we say, okay, here's when we're going to increase our spending,
here's when we're going to decrease our spending, so that we actually have a plan going into
retirement. And we've kind of predefined the levels that we would do that. And one benefit
is that it can give people a lot of peace of mind if they know, hey, I've got a million dollars in
my portfolio today, but risk levels in my plan aren't going to get too high until my portfolio
falls to $600,000. And then once it gets there, I know I need to cut back and here's the adjustment
I need to make. If somebody knows all that, and they know what the adjustment is, and that they
can tolerate that adjustment, suddenly going through scary downward markets, I think is a
lot less scary with that peace of mind. So that's kind of my overall approach is, I love simple,
I love to keep it as simple as possible, but sometimes trying to get that risk picture right
is important. And unfortunately, the 4% rule, even the RMD type of approach that you mentioned,
that's going to create too much spending volatility, and I think still be a little
excessively cautious. So for me, it's really more that total risk approach that I prefer.
So one thing that I know that you've written about is this idea of helping an investor
pre-identify how comfortable they are with variability, that this will kind of differ
by the household, by the individual, the extent to which we're comfortable making these course
corrections. What should people be thinking about there when trying to decide where they
are on that spectrum? Say they're just embarking on retirement, what are the key questions to ask
themselves? Yeah, I think one of the real big questions to ask yourself is how much do you want
to try and avoid downward adjustment? If you start spending at a certain level, how kind of averse are
you to maybe running into a scenario where you'd have to course correct and cut that back? Because
that starting spending level is really one of the biggest levers we have to pull in terms of trying
to play with that lifetime overall risk level in a plan. So if we want to reduce the risk that
somebody would ever need to make an adjustment, the best way to do that is to start spending at
a lower level. So that's really kind of the most powerful way that I think that we have. So that'd
be a big question I'd ask myself is how comfortable am I with cutting back? And of course, that comes
from understanding your budget and what your needs are, needs versus wants, and all the kind
of typical budgeting type of information. But that's a real big one for me is just kind of
understanding that. And then from there, understanding maybe also where kind of a floor
is related to that, but you know, what sort of income level might somebody really want to
stay above? Then you can start to run the numbers and really play around with it to get
an answer in terms of does a total risk type of plan fit within the parameters that somebody's
shooting for? Yeah. So moving away from the technical aspect of this problem of figuring
out how much you can safely spend in retirement, I often encounter retirees who talk about that
transition from being a saver, being someone who's working and continuing to sock money away
into someone who's spending from a portfolio. And I understand that that transition can be
psychologically really difficult for some people. I'm wondering if you have thought about that
problem, if you encounter the same thing, and if you have any strategies for people who need to
kind of help themselves over that hump so that they're actually not short shrifting their quality
of life in the interest of preserving that portfolio that they worked so hard to build?
Yeah, it's a great question. It's something that I do see a lot of people, especially people who
are really good at planning for retirement, really good at saving, setting aside. When
it comes time to actually make that shift into spending mode, that can be really tough,
especially if they're maybe even spending when they've heard about the 4% rule and maybe they're
saying, oh, I actually need to take 6% in these first years of retirement. And that can be
a real scary type of feeling. I do think there are ways that, at least theoretically,
tools like annuities could help with some of that in terms of, I think, people look at spending like
a pension-like income or an annuity-like income stream differently than they do from pulling from
their portfolio. The challenge there as well, though, I think is, in my view, some people will
also look at that initial annuity contribution as a spend in itself. And so that might be scary
to try and overcome that. And I think that's where we get the whole annuity puzzle and why aren't
people actually wanting to take lump sums and put them into these annuity products at the rates that
a lot of research would indicate could be beneficial for retirees.
So I think part of it is that same sort of it's hard to spend. I think getting a good
plan in place, however, if somebody wants to approach that, is often
one of the most comforting things we can try to do. And playing out some of those scenarios,
and especially in a kind of a risk-based framework, like I've been talking about,
where you can see, OK, here's some different paths. Here's where I would have adjusted.
Here's where I would have cut spending or I would have received a spending increase.
And especially running that through some of the worst times in history, kind of stress testing,
OK, if I went through the dot-com bubble or I went through the Great Recession or the Great
Depression and just see what that would have actually looked like and see, OK, could I
tolerate that? That's really one of the best ways I've found to try and build some of that peace of
mind and confidence that somebody could feel like, OK, yeah, I can do this. I can spend at this level.
But it's certainly a very real challenge for many retirees who have been good savers.
Yeah. And of course, a big wild card in this, and I think one reason why retirees often do
underspend is if they don't have insured long-term care expenses, if they're planning to use their
portfolio in case they have a long-term care need. I think that is where some of the reticence can
come in. Like, how much will that be? What if I end up being one of those people who needs
long-term care for a very long period of time? Do you have any thoughts on how to address
that consideration in the context of a retirement spending plan?
Yeah, absolutely. I think that's it is one of those fears that's there. And even if somebody
has insurance, you know, if there's a cap or maximum that's going to be paid out on their
insurance, it can still be a concern. OK, well, what if I'm in a very prolonged type of situation
where I say my body is healthy, but my mind is struggling, and that's really what's causing the
need for that care? So it's a real challenge. I do think some planning around maybe even earmarking,
let's say somebody, long-term care insurance just was never an option, not something they pursued.
They still might want to look at a portion of their portfolio maybe as earmarked for those
expenses down the road. And if they can kind of carve that out, you could even create kind of
this total risk type of framework I've been talking about where you could say, OK, I have
this 300,000 that I'm setting aside as really something that's here as an asset that I want
to be able to preserve that possibility down the road. And I just want to spend a prudent risk level
based on the other assets that are in the plan. So maybe carving something out like that could
be helpful for somebody that doesn't have some coverage in place. Of course, getting coverage in
place could also be very beneficial. And I know it's not super common, but even some of the
products out there that might provide really truly kind of a lifetime type of protection
instead of more of a capped benefit could be something to look at as well if somebody's
really trying to find that maximum level of comfort with that risk. OK, Derek, I love your
work on retiree spending. Thank you so much for being here with us to discuss it.
Thanks so much for having me. Here are the key takeaways for me from this conversation.
One is that retirees should feel comfortable spending a bit more from their portfolios in
the early years of retirement for a few key reasons. First, people spending changes throughout
their retirement years, and often it trends down. In addition, the early years of retirement are
often the high spending ones simply because many people delay Social Security. And when they start
receiving Social Security, their spending declines. In addition, research from Derek and others points
to the value of potentially changing up spending based on how your portfolio has performed. But
it's helpful to take a close look at your budget to figure out where you would cut your spending
if you needed to. That can help you figure out whether a dynamic spending system is appropriate
for you. Finally, one of the wild cards in a lot of retirees spending plans is whether they'll
confront long-term care costs later in life. If you don't have long-term care insurance, I love
the idea of setting aside assets for it and segregating them from your spending portfolio.
The book How to Retire goes even deeper on retirement spending with experts Wade Pfau,
David Blanchett, Jonathan Guyton, and Ramit Sethi. Thanks so much for being here. I'm Christine
Benz for Morningstar.
