How Steve Rogers Returns in AVENGERS DOOMSDAY (2026)

Chris Evans
4 followers
35 Video Views·Jan 12, 2025
Welcome back to New Rock Stars, I'm Eric Vos,
and Avengers Doomsday is confirmed to include
Chris Evans in this lineup, according to The Wrap,
in a growing cast that will include
Robert Downey Jr.'s Doctor Doom,
Benedict Cumberbatch's Doctor Strange,
Tom Holland as Spider-Man,
the Fantastic Four from Fantastic Four First Steps,
and the Thunderbolts.
Chris Evans hasn't yet been confirmed
to be playing Steve Rogers,
but just the fact that he's coming back at all
really narrows the possibilities
for what the Russo brothers have in mind
as they gear up to begin production
for this film in a few months.
I'm gonna break down everything we know
about Avengers Doomsday,
how it will connect to Fantastic Four First Steps,
and what role exactly Chris Evans will be playing,
and how this might actually resolve
the biggest unanswered question from Avengers Endgame.
And if you wanna support New Rock Stars
as we try to cover all of this big Marvel news,
we now have a channel membership.
We are starting small when it comes to perks,
but if you are able to
and wanna show off some custom emotes in the comments,
this is just a really great way
to help us keep making these kind of videos,
so thank you so much.
Okay, when Avengers Doomsday was announced last summer,
Kevin Feige confirmed that,
along with Robert Downey Jr. as Doctor Doom,
both the Fantastic Four lineup from First Steps
and the cast of the Thunderbolts
would return in Avengers Doomsday.
Then, over the months, some other news drops came out,
like Benedict Cumberbatch had already indicated
the plan was for him to return for the fifth Avengers film
in a Netflix retrospective video from last June.
I'm very much looking forward to Avengers next year,
which is cooking up a storm.
But that version of Avengers 5
was when it was still, as far as Cumberbatch knew
when he recorded that,
a movie being directed by Destin Daniel Cretton.
So we weren't as sure when, a month later,
Feige announced it was a new project
with the Russo brothers and Stephen McFeely writing it,
but in the past week, Benedict Cumberbatch confirmed
that he is still part of Avengers Doomsday.
Very much looking forward to working
with Robert Downey Jr.,
telling Japanese news outlet TV Groove this,
I'm really excited not only to work
with the Russo brothers again,
but to have Robert Downey Jr. returning as Doctor Doom.
I think there's going to be
some really cool developments ahead.
Tom Holland's return as Spider-Man
was confirmed by the Hollywood Reporter in October,
who were discussing Holland's busy 2025 shooting schedule
with Spider-Man 4, Avengers Doomsday,
and Christopher Nolan's next film.
Then, this week, The Wrap exclusively reported
that Chris Evans is returning for Avengers Doomsday,
writing, quote, Evans will be involved in some capacity,
but the extent and the exact nature of his role is unknown.
And when Deadline reported on this story,
they included the additional detail
that their own sources are relaying
that Anthony Mackie will also return
for Avengers Doomsday,
as the current Captain America of the MCU, Sam Wilson,
which they reported makes it less likely
that Evans could be back as the primary Captain America.
Not so fast, Deadline.
I think we have a possible explanation here.
But let's run through the options.
Chris Evans probably is not going to return as Johnny Storm
from the 2005, 2007 Fantastic Four movies,
as we just saw that cameo in Deadpool and Wolverine,
and that death seemed pretty definitive.
Chris Evans is presumably returning for a role
beyond his elderly form
from the end of Avengers Endgame,
which remains technically his current status
in the present day MCU.
And the Falcon and the Winter Soldier, Joaquin Torres,
floated some conspiracy theories
that Steve Rogers is on the moon,
and maybe he and Sam Wilson might revisit that subject
in Captain America Brave New World.
Actually, a recent Microsoft commercial
with footage from Brave New World
shows that Joaquin has a copy of Scott Lang's book,
Look Out for the Little Guy,
telling us that this Falcon is eager to know more
about the history of the Infinity Saga.
But I think it's possible that we get to see Chris Evans
in his old man makeup again.
I just think there's gonna be a lot more to his role.
Because this return of Chris Evans
in an Avengers movie directed by the Russos
and written by Stephen McFeely
brings up a debate over the exact logic
of the ending of Avengers Endgame.
How exactly did elderly Steve Rogers end up on that bench
after he went back in time to return the Infinity Stones?
According to the Russos,
they adhere to the film's internal logic
in which significant changes to the past
create branch histories in the multiverse,
and that this version of Steve
lived out his life with Peggy Carter
from the 1940s onward in an alternate timeline,
and then at some point in the future of that timeline,
he traveled back to the 616 universe
to give the shield to Sam.
It would mean that this old man knows someone
who knows how to travel through multiversal portals.
I know, he seems pretty old
to have just figured out that journey himself,
but who knows what life he lived
and who his friends could have been.
Then again, according to the screenwriters
of Avengers Endgame, Stephen McFeely
and his co-writer, Christopher Marcus,
that's not what happened.
They say that their intention
was that when Steve Rogers went back to Peggy in the 1940s,
he lived out his life within the 616 MCU
in the background of that history we've known,
just, I suppose, keeping a low profile.
And then after the dust settled
after the Battle of Earth in Avengers Endgame,
he showed up to give the shield to Sam Wilson.
So we have one version of the film's logic
that stays true to its own rules about branch timelines,
but suggests that there is some alternate branch universe
out there in which Steve Rogers' Captain America
was alive in the 1950s and 60s and beyond,
who went to free Bucky from HYDRA,
and then at some point in the future
of that alternate history,
he used some multiversal technology
to travel back to the 616 universe
just to give that universe's Sam Wilson a shield
and make him Cap.
That seems like a lot for a whole different life
that you left ages in the past,
unless there was some specific reason why.
We'll talk about it in a second.
But we have this other version of Endgame's logic
that suggests that for the entire MCU we had been watching,
there was some old man who knew about all the bad things
that would be happening in this history
and just let it all happen.
And that's why I have always sided with the Russos on this,
even if my personal preference in general
for time travel storytelling
is closer to Marcus and McFeely's explanation,
which seems somewhere between
like Back to the Future bucket approach
and like Prisoner of Azkaban interstellar lost approach
that implies changes to the past rewrite history
to be the way it has always been to begin with.
But I think this whole messy conflict
might explain what the Russos and McFeely have in mind
with Avengers Doomsday
and with Chris Evans' involvement with it.
Maybe even why it's just McFeely coming back
to write Doomsday and not Marcus as well.
I admit I am really speculating
when it comes to why Marvel contracted one writer
to do the latest draft on the script and not both of them.
It's probably just the case
that these two very successful screenwriters
after Avengers Endgame took their money
and went on very different paths in their careers.
And all respect goes to them for doing that.
But I think for Avengers Doomsday
to be a true sequel to Avengers Endgame,
starting with the unanswered questions around Steve Rogers
is exactly where you need to start
and exactly how you connect the events of Endgame
to the broader multiverse saga.
I don't know if you've ever tried
to doing anything without energy,
but it doesn't work.
Time oozes by slowly and you feel like you're in a thick fog
just trying to respond to emails.
One-shot energy chews fix that.
Whether they're part of your morning routine
or something you keep in your pocket
for when the doldrums hit,
one-shot energy chews can give you the energy you need
right when you need it.
And to prove just how much energy
is in a one-shot energy chew,
we conducted a scientific experiment.
How much of our studio equipment
could we power off a single energy chew?
Yay!
All of one-shot energy's products
are plant-based and naturally sweetened
without a bunch of fillers and chemicals.
They've got energy chews, voice drops, and focus chews.
It's a hat trick for hosting.
And we thank one-shot for making our jobs easier.
Get started with one-shot energy today
by going to oneshotenergy.com slash new rock stars
for 10% off your order.
Now to make it clear,
Marvel Studios has already indicated
that they are very interested in Steve Rogers' journey
through time from the events of Infinity War and Endgame
from a season two episode of What If?
In the 1602 episode, we saw another branch timeline
in which Steve had cracked the time stone
on Thanos' gauntlet, altering the time stream.
It had all of us asking a lot of questions again
about Cap's return journey with the Infinity Stones.
How exactly he placed all of them
back to where they were in history?
How he was able to return the Soul Stone on Vormir?
And what his life really looks like with Peggy,
the life that Sam asked about
and Steve responded cryptically,
So viewer, here is my theory.
I think Avengers Doomsday will be
a Doctor Doom-centered story that sets up a conflict
between at least two alternate Earths in the multiverse,
the 616 MCU as we've known it
and another ideal Marvel universe
with an equally or even more attractive lineup of heroes.
This alternate universe could be the universe
of the Fantastic Four in First Steps.
It could be that undetermined X-Men universe
that Monica Rambeau ended up in
in the post-credits scene of the Marvels
or hey, maybe even those could be like the same universe.
I think Avengers Doomsday will, in part,
answer the question of what happened
to Steve Rogers after Endgame
or really in between those final scenes of Endgame.
With the Russo brothers and McFeely returning,
I think the Russos will want to firmly settle the argument
and explore Steve's life in an alternate Marvel universe,
a universe where the 20th century would play out differently
with a Captain America in it
as opposed to being an ice for all of it.
Think about it, rather than spending the 50s and 60s
in Arctic ice, missing out on the Cold War
and the space race, Steve Rogers would be there for all of it.
We could actually end up in an alternate Marvel universe
where there is a Captain America, Steve Rogers,
active in 1960s New York along with the Fantastic Four
and a Spider-Man and the X-Men
as they were in the Marvel Comics Silver Age.
I think Marvel Studios wants to introduce
with Fantastic Four First Steps
an alternate hypothetical of the way the MCU
could have looked if Marvel had the legal rights
to everything.
A Silver Age Marvel universe set in the 60s
with all the trappings of a proper Marvel New York
and in this universe, many of the familiar faces
we knew from the 616 MCU will,
due to the randomness of quantum mechanics,
return in this universe
but with different names and identities.
In this universe, because Victor Von Doom
looks like Steve's longtime frenemy of Tony Stark,
that might even create a unique relationship with the Steve
after he'd gone through the events of the Infinity Saga.
So according to this theory,
Chris Evans is returning to play Captain America,
the Captain America Steve Rogers
from the Marvel Studios films from 2011 to 2019,
just following him on that alternate history
after he got that last dance with Peggy
where he might meet the Fantastic Four
in an alternate Doctor Doom.
And when that universe faces an incursion crisis
with the 616 universe, our Captain America, Sam Wilson,
and Doctor Strange, and Peter Parker, and the Thunderbolts
will encounter not just the familiar face of Doctor Doom
but literally the same Steve Rogers
who left them after the Battle of Earth.
And they will see him
in perhaps an alternate 1960s Captain America suit
with maybe even upgrades from his buddy Reed Richards
like a proto-Adamantium shield.
And it's going to be Steve's relationship
with that multiverse expert, Reed Richards,
that will explain how in the distant future
this old man traveled back through the multiverse
to get back to Sam.
And we are gonna learn that that old man Steve
gave Sam Wilson that shield to give the 616 MCU
a fighting chance in an incursion conflict
that Steve knew would be coming.
And so it wasn't just to keep Peggy close to the vest
when he played coy with Sam in Endgame,
he was really sparing us some spoilers
for Avengers Doomsday and Secret Wars when he said this.
You wanna tell me about her?
No, no, I don't think I will.
Now, you may have noticed
I've been wearing this awesome Winter Soldier shirt.
You can get one of these at nerdriot.shop.
It's a great way to support New Rock Stars
and to get that special nerd in your life
a great holiday gift option.
Please comment down below with your thoughts.
Follow me at EA Voss.
Subscribe to all three channels
of the New Rock Stars Network
for breakdowns and news coverage of everything you love.
And if you really wanna support what we do here,
hit that join button right by the subscribe button
to support us with a membership.
Thanks for watching and I'll see you next time, bye.
