Decoding the Mystery of the Minoan Ancient Civilization

Eternal Sculpt
13 followers
I've come to realise that these early archaeologists were themselves myth makers
and so one of the fascinating things about studying Minoan Crete is that you're often
untangling the myths not only from early Greece but also the myths which have come down
from some of these archaeologists, Arthur Evans included.
We know so little about the Minoans partly because we cannot understand their inscriptions.
There is definitely a lot of work to be done, yes, for cracking the code of Linear A.
We do need some more evidence. We don't have any kind of Rosetta Stone for Linear A.
We do want to find in the Minoans what we desire, a peaceful society.
It's the most exotic in a way civilization that we've got on European soil.
Minoans have become part of our mental landscape but they
have maintained a kind of monstrous strangeness.
Get exclusive documentaries and ad-free podcasts with top historians.
Watch on your smart TV or mobile device by downloading the History Hit app.
There is a land called Crete, a fair, rich land,
beguiled with water and therein are many men, past counting, and 90 cities.
They have not all the same speech but their tongues are mixed.
Among their cities is the great city Knossos where Minos reigned.
Well Minoan is the term that archaeologists give to the Bronze Age of Crete which is from
the 3rd millennium BC to the 2nd millennium BC, so a period of about 2000 years.
The Minoans are the inhabitants of Crete based on the island of Crete who created this wonderful
civilization that has been hailed from the very beginning as the first European civilization.
But actually we don't know what the Cretans called themselves in this period. Minoan is
purely an archaeological term derived from the Greek myths, King Minos.
We know that the island of Crete was exploited by people already in the Paleolithic period,
that is we are talking of more than 30,000 years before present, but we know that around 7000 BC
people coming from the Fertile Crescent, southern Turkey and the northern Levant,
moved and colonized Crete and settled there permanently. We know that because they brought
with them wheat, goats, other domesticated plants and animals that were not on Crete before that.
And then at the start of the Bronze Age or perhaps just before, what happens on Crete is
that you have two new crops arriving, the olive and the grape, and this means that people can
start to make olive oil and start to make wine. And these are important crops not just because
wine is a kind of social lubricant, it brings people together to party, but also because they
are things which you can use to export as well. In that period of the third and the second
millennium BC, Minoan Crete really is defined by these buildings which archaeologists term palaces
and they seem to have been the central places for the people who lived on Crete at that time.
And they were impressive buildings, they had colorful frescoes on the wall,
they were places where people gathered to eat and drink, they were essentially places for partying.
And one of the things that the excavators were struck by was, if you like, the modernity of
some of the art, some of the depictions that they were coming across. So particularly at Knossos
that the frescoes were seen as almost foreshadowing an Art Nouveau style in Europe.
Well today we're here at the Ashmolean Museum in Oxford which has the largest collection of
Cretan antiquities outside of Greece. And what you can see behind me is a reconstruction of
the throne room at Knossos. The storage jars in particular show that not only was this a
place for gathering, but it was also a place for storing agricultural produce. One has an octopus
painted on it, another has a palm tree painted on it. And I think these are important because
they tell us something about how the palace is not only a place for gathering and a place for
storage, but it's also claiming to extend, if you like, over the land and over the sea and indeed
under it. And the sea was important to the palace at Knossos, the sea was a place where you could
trade over, but it was also a source of one of the most important commodities in this period,
which was purple dye. If you look very closely to the left of the octopus, you can see a murex shell
which was used to make purple dye. And this is what they were doing in the Bronze Age, spinning
thread from sheep, dyeing them with things like crocus dyes and also with this murex dye, and then
exporting them abroad in return for all of the things that you could get from across the eastern
Mediterranean. And there's one more thing in this display and that's a terracotta pipe, conical in
shape, but it reminds us that Knossos was one of the places with the first plumbing in Europe.
You even had a flushing toilet in the palace which amused and entertained a lot of the first
excavators. This was a very advanced building, it even had its own plumbing system in the second
millennium BC. Crete is an island in a very important position in the southern Aegean,
so it often acts as a pivot between the ancient societies of the eastern Mediterranean and
mainland Europe, which are still reasonably small scale. And over the course of the third millennium
it seems that some of these ideas, and indeed some of the objects, are starting to
come to Crete in small quantities. And so as a result of this trade, some of these influences,
such as the development of writing and perhaps even the idea of having these big central buildings
called palaces, comes from societies like Egypt and is adapted in Crete in a very local, specific
way. They develop their own writing systems, they develop their own buildings. From the very
beginning of the 20th century, when the Minoans were rediscovered, this new civilization, their
new culture, was hailed as the first European civilization. Because it was rediscovered on the
island of Crete, the early 20th century, when Crete was still part of the Ottoman Empire. But the population
on Crete, the majority of the population on Crete, were ethnic Greeks, Christian, Orthodox,
and they wanted to become part of the kingdom of Greece. And also there were European powers
were in a struggle with the Ottoman Empire to control important strategic places in the
Mediterranean. So it was important for the local Cretans and for various European archaeologists
working on the island to show that the Minoans were part of Europe, not of the Orient, not of
the East, of the Ottoman East. And I think that the local archaeologists saw Evans as a kind of
asset. He was a wealthy, influential man who was able to excavate a site which would perhaps
help to show that not only was Crete independent, but also that it maybe should have links
with Greece, which was the ultimate aim of those in favor of Cretan independence. And I think
Arthur Evans really delivered on that promise. The palace that he found at Knossos really did
seem to have links with mainland Greece. But the other thing that Arthur Evans did was he started
to develop a vision of the Minoans, if you like. He started to develop various theories about
things like Minoan religion, how the society was organized, which are still really very influential
today. The throne here is a replica of a throne that Arthur Evans found in the palace. It was
actually one of the first things that he found. He came down on this room with frescoes still on
the wall and this seat in the middle, which he immediately recognized as being the throne of a
ruler. Interestingly, at first he thought that the seat was quite wide, so that probably a woman
would have sat on the throne. But by the end of the first season of excavation, he'd sort of
changed his mind and decided it probably was a man. And then, as with a lot of the objects that
we have, if it was unique, he wasn't able to take it out of Crete. So he had people make plaster replicates.
Sir Arthur Evans, who is often considered the father of Minoan civilization, has often been
accused of creating the myth of the peaceful Minoans. There is a debate about whether the
Minoans, as we call them, were a peaceful society. And that really stems from the fact that depictions
that they left very rarely show signs of violence. And so some archaeologists have tended, if you like,
to be seduced into the idea that this was a utopian and peaceful society. I think if you look
closely at these depictions, which are often seen as signs of the peace-loving Minoans, these
athletic male bodies, for instance, either you can see them as perhaps like the later Greek depictions
of celebrating beauty, or you can perhaps see a slightly darker side, which is that these are
male bodies trained for violence. There's certainly many depictions of hunting in Crete,
marching or jumping over bulls. We tend to see them now as essentially peaceful activities,
but maybe they weren't. So in the late 1970s, for instance,
there were two excavations which found signs of human sacrifice and cannibalism.
The idea of the Minoans as peaceful people has really emerged more in the interwar period,
and even more strongly after the Vietnam War, with the emergence of flower power and second wave
feminist movement. I think this is partly linked with the idea that we do want to find in the
a peaceful society. It depends how you look at these depictions and whether you want to see a
peaceful society which is somehow more utopian than our own, or whether you want to see perhaps
the darkness which underlies a lot of societies, where violence is probably always something which
is keeping a society together. It's also linked with the idea that Minoan Crete was a matriarchal
society, or a society where women were very important, and therefore with the cliché that
women are less warlike than men. The idea of Minoan Crete as a matriarchy is partly based on
old-fashioned 19th century evolutionary ideas that stated all primitive societies were matriarchal
and then developed into patriarchal societies. But I'd like to think, I suppose as a woman,
but also because yes, there is this amazing female iconography in Minoan Crete,
that probably at least some women must have held important positions on Crete,
especially in the religious sphere. You do have signs of priestesses who could own land,
they were important figures. Famous examples include the snake goddesses from Knossos,
but you also have frescoes showing these obviously very important elaborately dressed women.
I think you can see there that women were clearly at the centre of the textile industry,
and the textile industry was incredibly important to the functioning of the palaces,
so as a result the organisers of that textile industry did have a very high status.
We know so little about the Minoans, partly because we cannot understand their inscriptions.
In the second half of the second millennium BC, Mycenaean Greeks developed a script called Linear
B. Linear B is a script that developed from earlier Cretan writings called Cretan pictographic,
also known as Cretan hieroglyphic, and Linear A. Linear B was relatively easy to decipher
because it's a known language. With Cretan pictographic and Linear A,
we may be dealing with languages that we don't know.
So I am Ester Salgarella, I am a junior research fellow at St George's College in Cambridge,
and I am working on Bronze Age Aegean writing systems, namely Linear A and Linear B.
I look at the palaeography of these writing systems, which is basically the way in which
signs are drawn, and the way in which one system, Linear B, is developed out of the other, Linear A.
When I was a kid, around six years old, I tried to learn some kind of Egyptian hieroglyph by myself
and putting post-its of hieroglyphic signs all over the place and all over the house.
But then, when I went to university, I started to get interested in the Bronze Age and the earliest
attestation of writing and the creation of writing. So Linear A was used to write this
still undeciphered minor language, while Linear B, that was basically developed out of Linear A,
was used to write a form of Greek which is called Mycenaean Greek and is the earliest
Greek dialect attested in writing.
I think there are not too many people working on this field, however, we are a group of
scholars and I'm just one. Each of us is looking at Linear A from slightly different perspectives.
I am looking at it more like palaeographically, so the way in which
signs are written and the people behind the writing.
Arthur Evans first came to Crete in search of seal stones because he had
seen an early form of writing on them and as he travelled around the island in the late 19th
century he bought many more examples. You can see that some of them are only a couple of centimetres
across but they're carved with these amazing intricate designs of people and animals and
actually they tell us something important about Minoan society because they were used in the
administration system of the palaces. People would probably wear them around their wrists
and then when they came into contact with the palace they would press them into clay to show
that a certain transaction had happened. So they're both amazing miniature pieces of art in their own
right but they also tell us something important about the way that Minoan society worked.
Most Linear A documents are made out of clay and these are records of palatial administrations,
so they come in the shape of little small page-shaped tablets and they were used in the
palatial centres for the daily bookkeeping, so they are basically records listing the inflow and
outflow of goods like cattle or vessels or wool, textiles, so they are shopping lists in a way.
Sometimes you can also see the imprints and the palm prints of those who manipulated clay to make
the tablets, so you really have got the feeling of being in touch with these ancient people.
I am a bit obsessed with Linear A and becoming a bit nerdy as well. I made some replicas of
Linear A tablets and these are actually to scale, so the way in which scribes used to write basically
on Linear A tablets was by making these palm-shaped tablets and just putting it in the palm of the
hand and write on top of it. So they change a lot and this may also give us a bit of an idea of the
different habits of different people. What is kind of nerdy at this point is that I made a replica
of this tablet from Kania and actually I made the pillow of the tablet from Kania to have Linear A
rings on it. And in order for me never to leave without Linear A, actually I decided to entertain
myself by making a tote bag. So this is an actual tablet from Zakros and this tablet is written
on both sides. So this is the front of the tablet and, sorry, this is the front of the
tablet and this is the back of the tablet. And actually the tablet fits well into a bag.
The language, of course, is still undeciphered but by looking at the tablets, the clay tablets
contextually, we can actually make sense of some of the words written on the tablet surface.
For instance, the word for total has been worked out and we know that it's spelled like
the word for deficit most probably, which is
and then there are many personal names and place names.
Signs are usually subdivided into syllabograms and logograms in both Linear A and Linear B,
meaning that syllabograms stand for syllables like
while logograms are picture signs that stand for a referent or an object in the actual world.
We've got, for instance, vessel shapes. We've got also pictures of animals, cattle, livestock,
and also, interestingly, a cat face. So the cat face is read as ma and ma is supposed to be
an onomatopoeic sound mimicking the sound that a cat makes, so
If you're using cryptographic methods to decipher a script, you need a big, big sample.
For Linear B, we have thousands of descriptions. For Linear A, we only have a few hundred.
There is definitely a lot of work to be done, yes,
for cracking the code of Linear A if ever possible. We do need some more evidence,
something which may actually help us a lot with decipherment would be to find a bilingual text,
so a bilingual inscription. For instance, we don't have any kind of Rosetta Stone for Linear A.
In collaboration with a computer science researcher, I started to develop an online
digital resource, which is a database of Linear A inscriptions that were only available in print
before. And for instance, you can see all the shapes of all the signs that are tested in Linear
A. You can also look, for instance, for specific signs in isolation and in the bigger context.
So let's say I want to see all the ways in which the cat face has been drawn in Linear A,
from all sites and from all periods. So just by inputting the name of the sign in this database,
I can see all the paleographical charts displaying this variation.
It's open for everybody and the database is supposed to be an educational tool as well.
It's very easy to use and you don't need to be an expert. You can build your own knowledge of
Linear A little by little by doing some research and maybe, I don't know,
some nice ideas can also come from the public.
One of the problems for archaeologists studying Minoan Crete is that although we do have texts
which have been deciphered, the Linear B tablets, they don't actually tell us much about the
structure of this society. We know that there was a man in charge, a figure called the Wanax,
and we know that there were certain important female figures called priestesses in the Linear
B tablets. But there's very little information about, say, ruling families or really any sense
of history which you get in some of the other contemporary writings in the Eastern Mediterranean.
Well, Arthur Evans was the keeper of the Ashmolean. He first visited Crete in 1894
because he was interested in writing. He had started to see evidence of writing in these
small objects called seal stones, which he had found out came from the island of Crete.
And so he was determined to visit to find more evidence for this, what he saw as a very early
writing system. When he visited Crete, he was shown the excavations of a local scholar called
Minos Kalakeranos, who had excavated Knossos in the 1870s and had actually found the building
that we now know as the palace. And so Arthur Evans was able to buy a share of the land
on which Kalakeranos' excavations stood. And then when Crete became independent at the end of the
19th century, he was then able to buy the rest of the land and to start excavating. This is a
portrait of Sir Arthur Evans, painted in 1907. There is a typical Edwardian gentleman wearing
his linen suit. So he worked here, the Ashmolean, from 1884 onwards and started excavating Knossos
in 1900. And he's painted by one of the famous portrait artists of the day, William Richmond,
actually in London. So he's surrounded by some of the objects which he was able to export from
Crete, or indeed some of them are replicas, such as the lampstand in the foreground. And I think
it's an important reminder that what we think of as the Minoan civilisation was partly pieced
together by people like Sir Arthur Evans. And I think that over the last 20 years, archaeologists
have started to wonder whether he also was imposing some of his typically 19th century views
on the Bronze Age Cretan past. So really there's been something of a backlash against Sir Arthur
Evans, because he does come across as a colonial figure who was able to excavate on Crete because
he was from an imperial power. He was a wealthy man, he had the means to do so. And people have
started to wonder whether actually some of the ideas which we still think are current really
come from Arthur Evans's background. And so they're in need of re-evaluation. Now of course,
I work at the Ashmolean and every day I work with the collection which Sir Arthur Evans
brought to Oxford. And so although I do think that certainly many of his ideas need re-evaluation,
he still made an important contribution to the archaeology of Crete. He kept very good records
of what he did. He published them fairly promptly. So even if we now want to go back and
tear up some of his ideas, at least he gave us the materials to do so.
When Sir Arthur Evans started digging at Knossos in March 1900, he didn't really have
much excavation experience, nor I think was he fluent in modern Greek. So in order to
run the excavations of Knossos, he needed a person with these skills. And he found a perfect person
in Duncan Mackenzie. He is a kind of, if you like, an unsung hero of Knossos because
he always remained in the shadow of Evans, his employer. Duncan Mackenzie was a Scottish
archaeologist who had acquired these skills because at the end of the 19th century,
he had excavated a prehistoric site on the island of Milos, the site of Philakopea.
So he was an experienced excavator and he was very, very good with the workmen. He was very,
very good at languages generally. His role at Knossos was basically what nowadays we would say
the field director of the excavation. He was in charge of the day-to-day proceedings,
and most importantly, he was in charge of keeping a record of the day-to-day progress
of the excavations. Mackenzie's records of the excavations are fundamental because without them,
Evans himself wouldn't have been able to publish his own reports. I mean, one of the reasons why I
decided to write a biography of Mackenzie was because I realised how important his contribution
was. And also, if you like, I was interested in the social history of archaeology. I mean,
Evans was from a very, very rich family. Mackenzie was the son of a gamekeeper in the
islands of Scotland. The palace at Knossos is destroyed and that is the last palace standing.
And so when Knossos comes to an end, this is seen as the end of the Minoan civilisation.
It ended both with a bang and a whimper. The bang is the famous eruption of the Santorini volcano
in the middle of the second millennium BC, but it was not the direct cause. Some people have
suggested that Minoan Crete was weakened somehow by the explosion of the Santorini
eruption and the Mycenaean Greeks took advantage of this situation and started
ruling all over Crete. And so Minoan culture became subsumed into Mycenaean culture
and then slowly disappeared. But I think you can really ask what you mean by the end of the
Minoan civilisation. Because actually, even after the palace at Knossos comes to an end,
yes writing disappears from Crete, yes these colourful frescoes disappear, but people still
carry on as they were before. They were still making pottery, they were still visiting the
same religious sites in Crete. And so I often think that although we're somehow disappointed
that this civilisation has come to an end, maybe the people who were endlessly taxed by the palace
at Knossos weren't that bothered by that. And so actually it could be that their lives were better
off by not being part of this civilisation. The Minoan civilisation is a failed civilisation. It
was perhaps an experiment in a way of living. Obviously they didn't see it as an experiment,
but we can certainly look at it in that way. And so you can think that this civilisation produced
some amazing things, some amazing artwork. It was a place where writing was being used,
you have a plumbing system at Knossos, but actually civilisation in Crete was ultimately
too complex. And really at the end of the Bronze Age, people went back to
a different way of living, which perhaps was more sustainable.
It's fascinating to see how all kinds of people were influenced or took inspiration from
the Minoans. Avant-garde artists of the early 20th century to couturiers. For example,
Karl Lagerfeld, a Greek fashion designer called Sophia Kokosalaki, who is the person who produced
the costumes for the Athens Olympics. And some of these costumes were inspired by the Minoans.
Dramatists or even psychoanalysts. I mean, Sigmund Freud, for example, was fascinated
by the Minoans. This idea of having an early society where women were particularly important
suited some of his ideas about the development of human psyche. And we have writers, poets.
Aldous Huxley wrote a poem inspired by a Minoan find, and so did Cecil Day-Lewis. D.H. Lawrence
has also written a poem to do with the Minoans. Famous British composer Harrison Birtwistle
used Minoan elements in one of his operas, the Minotaur. Other musicians that were fascinated
by the Minoans is a San Francisco rock band called Giant Squid, who produced an album called
The Minoans. I think because of the imagery attracts them.
I think I first became interested in the Minoans because of the sense that they are somewhere
between myth and history. But then as I've carried on studying Minoan archaeology,
I've come to realize that these early archaeologists were themselves myth makers.
And so one of the fascinating things about studying Minoan Crete is that you're often
untangling the myths, not only which have come down from early Greece, but also the
myths which have come down from some of these archaeologists, Arthur Evans included.
Honestly, I like the Minoan civilization as a whole because it's the most exotic in a way
civilization that we've got on European soil. I like the way in which we look at the Minoans
through the lenses of writing. And that, of course, is my field of study, because writing
opens a door to the people behind the signs. So it has to be combined with archaeological
research, of course, but still it gives you an idea of how people, for instance,
try to put on clay their own thoughts. Of course, there is still so much that needs to be done on
this field. An English writer, Rose McCauley, said something that really resonated with me.
She said that the Minoans have become part of our mental landscape, familiar landscape of our mind,
like the Hellenic and the Roman, but they have maintained a kind of mysteriousness
and monstrous strangeness that gives them the uneven quality of dreams. You think you remember
them and then they've gone. And there is something like that, I think, about the Minoans. They're a
bit like a dream. Thanks for watching this video on the History Hit YouTube channel. You can
subscribe right here to make sure you don't miss any of our great films that are coming out. Or if
you are a true history fan, check out our special dedicated history channel, historyhit.tv. You're
going to love it.
