Sandro Botticelli’s Mystic Nativity

Vintage Visions
7 followers
Botticelli's Mystic Nativity is as beautiful as it is mysterious.
With this work we venture into the realm of speculation and conjecture.
I hope you find this painting as intriguing as I do.
I, Sandro, painted this picture at the end of the year 1500 in the troubles of Italy.
So begins the inscription at the top of Botticelli's Mystic Nativity.
Alessandro Botticelli was an early renaissance painter from Florence, Italy.
Trained as a goldsmith, Botticelli worked in Fra Lippi's workshop where he received
excellent training. Botticelli had a clear understanding of linear perspective,
how to use a consistent light source, and how to model figures with mass.
And yet, in this painting, he ignores these principles.
Botticelli was under the patronage of Lorenzo Medici, the ruler of Florence.
The Medici court was a place of culture and intellectual pursuits.
Art, literature, and philosophy were esteemed.
In this atmosphere, the intelligent and sensitive Botticelli thrived.
Botticelli developed as a person and an artist with the Medici's generous support.
During the 1480s, while connected to the Medici's, Botticelli produced some of his most famous works.
Along with mythical paintings, Botticelli painted portraits and religious scenes,
specializing in Madonna and child paintings.
To begin to unravel this work, we need to better understand Botticelli's artistic style,
Florence's culture, and the religious convictions of 15th century Italy.
Botticelli embraced the philosophy of beauty.
While we don't normally associate philosophy with beauty today,
it has historically been a central branch of the study of philosophy.
The philosophy of beauty is sometimes called aesthetics, an area that addresses questions like,
What is beauty? What are the uses of beauty?
What are the proper forms, styles, and methods that produce beautiful objects?
Beauty was prized as a virtue, as highly as truth, goodness, or justice.
Beauty glorified God because it revealed aspects of who he was,
and any aspiring artist during the Renaissance
had to work hard to ensure their work could be considered beautiful.
Here is an excerpt from the Stanford Dictionary of Philosophy's entry on aesthetics.
The nature of beauty is one of the most enduring and controversial themes in Western philosophy,
and is, with the nature of art, one of the two fundamental issues in philosophical aesthetics.
Beauty has traditionally been counted among the ultimate values,
with goodness, truth, and justice.
It is a primary theme among ancient Greek, Hellenistic, and medieval philosophers,
and was central to 18th and 19th century thought.
However, as is true today, there were conflicting ideas about what was beautiful.
Beauty is in the eye of the beholder.
Great artists, however, redefined what the culture deemed beautiful,
and instilled in their audience the belief that beauty and virtue were connected.
If they paint a beautiful Madonna, her outward beauty reflects the purity of her soul.
This was the mark of a true master.
As we will see, Botticelli was such a visionary.
Now that we understand how Botticelli was shaping notions of beauty through his work,
we need to understand what ideas were shaping him as an artist.
Artists draw their inspiration from many different sources,
and during the Renaissance, it was common for artists to be inspired by writers,
and for writers to be inspired by poets, and so on.
By understanding the ideas that influence an artist,
we can better understand the choices they make in their works.
A major influence for Botticelli was Dante.
Dante was a 13th-century Italian writer best known for his trilogy, The Divine Comedy.
Lorenzo Medici admired Dante's work and wanted Botticelli to illustrate the text,
bringing to life the epic tale of a man's journey through hell, purgatory, and heaven.
Botticelli studied the text intensely, immersing himself in Dante's description
of the nine sinful circles in the inferno and the nine angelic spheres of paradise.
Today, more than 100 of Botticelli's Divine Comedy drawings survive.
His illustrations are not only beautiful but symbolic,
as they represent the theological themes of the text.
It would be hard to overstate the influence that Dante's poem has had on Christianity.
Many modern Christians owe more to their understanding of heaven, hell,
angels, and Satan to Dante more than they do to biblical sources.
Artists like Botticelli helped bring Dante's work to life,
disseminating his story visually while also shaping it through his artistic choices.
Illustrating Dante's important work did not just shape Botticelli as an artist, however,
but also as a person.
Thinking deeply about the theology embedded in Dante,
paired with the political turmoil of the late 15th century,
led to a period of profound spiritual crisis for Botticelli.
These ideas and events all shaped his great work, The Mystic Nativity.
Remember New Year's Eve 1999?
Even if you were not alive, you may have heard stories about fears people had
with the turn of the millennium.
People throughout history have feared the turning of years, decades, and especially centuries.
As the year 1500 approached, many people feared the end of the world was upon them.
Botticelli himself believed that Christ's second coming was imminent.
This belief was called Molinarianism, I think, and it was gaining traction throughout Europe.
People believed that they were living in the in-between times,
described in the biblical book of Revelation.
This period was described as times and half a time.
Many people interpreted this to mean that time meant 1000 years,
and so half a time meant 500 years.
Thus, the year 1500 was considered significant.
Because Florence was experiencing wars, famines, and plagues,
just as the book of Revelation foretold, many thought the end was nigh.
Had the devil truly been unleashed?
Into this troubled world came a charismatic religious leader, Fra Savaranola.
A Dominican monk, Savaranola preached boldly against the excesses of Florentine society.
The monk denounced worldliness, godless arts, scandalous writings, and corruption in the church,
claiming to be a prophet who could hear God's voice and see visions.
He gained an immense following.
Many who were starving and the poor found solace in his message of deliverance.
But even wealthy Florentines saw the error of their ways and donated their vast wealth to his cause.
It may come as no surprise then that he challenged the ideas of beauty,
prized by artists and patrons alike.
Savaranola demanded that Florence, in all of its opulence, repent and return to God.
He promised them that by rejecting their worldliness,
God would reward them and Florence would become the new Jerusalem.
Unfortunately for the Medicis, the political and cultural anchor of Florence,
and artists like Botticelli, art that was considered excessively beautiful,
sensual, or insufficiently pious, was deemed worldly and subject to purges.
Savaranola prophesied that a new Cyrus would invade from the north and reform the church.
Cyrus, in the Old Testament, was a Persian ruler whose invasion of Babylon
and contact with the Jewish exiles there led to his freeing the Jews and rebuilding the temple.
In Botticelli's time, it appeared that Savaranola's prophecy was coming true
when Charles VII invaded Italy from France, bringing with him 10,000 soldiers.
Florence expected to be sacked and burned.
But Savaranola went out to meet Charles, successfully negotiating for Florence's safety.
As a result, Savaranola's followers drove the Medicis out of the city.
Savaranola established a republic government and began his pious reforms.
He and his government ruled Florence from 1494 to 1498.
One reform, in particular, shaped the art and culture of Florence.
Savaranola decreed that all worldly objects that did not glorify God
must be destroyed in a giant bonfire.
His followers willingly tossed precious books, art, mirrors, combs,
other valuables into the towering flames.
Among these treasures were many of Botticelli's own works, lost to us forever.
After four years, however, the Florentines grew tired of Savaranola's strict rule.
Public opinion turned against him and he and his two closest allies were convicted of being heretics.
Savaranola, while being tortured, admitted that he had made up the visions.
All three men were hung and burned to ensure that there would be nothing left
for his followers to turn into holy relics.
Though he only ruled for four years, his regime challenged ideas about beauty and art.
So how did these traumatic events and new ideas shape Botticelli's Mystic Nativity,
a painting that was lost for nearly 300 years?
With no additional documentation, the painting has required art historians to act as sleuths
to uncover clues about the work's meaning and purpose.
In 1500, after the flight of the Medicis and the fall of Savaranola,
Botticelli found himself in a vastly different position than he had a decade previous.
The turmoil questioned understandings of beauty, truth, God, and art itself.
Botticelli was struggling spiritually and doubting his life's work.
Was his art glorifying God or was it a vanity?
Was it beautiful?
And if so, what made it so?
Had his intellectual philosophical pursuits led him astray?
Was he in danger of falling into one of the circles of hell
that Dante had described and he himself had illustrated?
Was Christ's second coming at hand and was he about to be judged?
It is at this pivotal moment of crisis that Botticelli painted the Mystic Nativity.
And fun fact, this is the only work Botticelli ever signed.
Is this a clue to what's important to Botticelli?
If so, why did he hide the painting?
Botticelli's Mystic Nativity visually represents
Savaranola's sermon about the second coming of Christ.
The painting was done on canvas, which was unusual,
since Botticelli normally painted on wooden panels.
A painting on canvas allowed it to be rolled up and concealed,
suggesting that even before he finished the painting, Botticelli intended to hide it.
This is perhaps because he knew that a visual record of Savaranola's sermon
would have been dangerous now that Savaranola had been declared a heretic and executed.
In fact, Savaranola's followers were searched out in an effort to root out
the lingering political threat against the Medici family and the current Pope.
Botticelli couldn't risk being associated with them.
There is no known commission for this work, implying that Botticelli made it for himself.
As such, he may have intended the small painting as a personal devotional work.
If the painting were commissioned by a supporter of Savaranola, however,
that patron would likely have wished to remain unidentified.
The question for our sleuths remains,
why would Botticelli sign a painting and then hide it away?
Maybe he saw the new shape his style was taking and wanted posterity to know the work was by him.
The inscription on top of Botticelli's Mystic Nativity is in Greek, and it reads,
This picture, at the end of the year 1500 in the Troubles of Italy,
I, Alessandro, in the half-time after the time, painted according to the 11th chapter of Saint
John in the second woe of the apocalypse, during the release of the devil for three and a half
years, then he shall be bound in the 12th chapter and we shall see him buried as in this picture.
The work appears at first to be a joyous celebration of the nativity.
In fact, the angels circling at the top had been used on many Christmas cards.
However, as we move down the painting, darker elements appear,
perhaps influenced by Dante's concepts of heaven and hell.
At the bottom of the frame, there are demons disappearing into the ground as
angels rustle with humans. This is not a Christmas card nativity scene as we know it,
but a representation of spiritual struggle. While there is joy in celebration, there is also pain.
Let us start at the top, the 12 circling angels and the gold dome.
The number 12 here is thought to represent the passage of time, either the 12 hours of the day
or the 12 months of the year. Botticelli's training as a goldsmith is evidenced here,
as he has applied gold leaf to create an opening into the heavens.
Gold does not decay or tarnish, so it was the perfect choice to stand
for the eternal time of heavenly spaces. As the surface of the canvas is uneven,
the gold is uneven as well, which produces a glittery, reflective surface.
It is believed that this representation of an opening to heaven is a memory from Botticelli's
childhood. Theatrical religious plays were quite popular at the time, and for the Annunciation
play at the Church of St. Felix, the architect, Brunelleschi, created a circling dome that
featured children dressed as angels that spun slowly, suspended from the ceiling.
It must have been quite a spectacle, and one that was likely witnessed by Botticelli.
The angels dressed in white, red, and a burnished green circle the opening.
They carry olive branches and scrolls. Crowns are suspended above, twirling with them.
This image of angels is repeated several times in the painting, always in red, green, and white
robes. These signify faith, white, hope, green, and charity or love, red. The green is a true
green in most of this painting. However, in this top section, the angels' robes have been
burnished with gold, so they're no longer the pure green. It has been suggested that Botticelli
altered the color because, now that the angels are closer to heaven here, hope is no longer needed
because it has come to fruition. The crowns in the painting were mentioned in Savonarola's
Assumption Day sermon. Though they may appear blank to the naked eye, there is also writing
on the scrolls woven throughout the angels. Using infrared technology, art historians have
uncovered the following words, Glory to God in the highest, and on earth peace, goodwill toward men.
Savonarola also expanded on the 12 privileges of the Virgin Mary. And again, using infrared
technology, these privileges are listed on the scrolls. You will notice that the angels are also
holding olive branches, the symbol of peace. Interestingly, in the 1500s, what is now celebrated
as Palm Sunday was then called Olive Sunday, as the Prince of Peace was entering Jerusalem and
carried an olive branch with him. Olive branches appear throughout this painting. See if you can
spot them as we continue to travel down the canvas. And does their location comment on the
Below the circle of angels appears the Holy Family. They are gathered in a stable that is enclosed by
a cave. The juxtaposition of the stable and cave is an artistic device that had been in use for
several centuries. While the biblical narrative speaks of the birth of Jesus occurring in a stable,
during this time, caves were also used as stables. Caves were also used as tombs, so picturing the
birth of Jesus near the site of his death tells the story of his journey on earth. Layering these images
brings together Christ's coming, his birth, with Christ's purpose, dying for humankind's sin.
At the center of this trinity of figures is the baby Jesus. Mary is bending toward him adoringly.
She is not cradling the newborn, but worshiping him, demonstrating that Jesus is both her son
and her Lord. The baby Jesus is naked. Typically, this choice reminds the audience that God took on
flesh through Jesus. However, here we see that Botticelli also chose to depict the naked baby
lying in his swaddling cloth, which has literally been kicked aside. Instead of an immobile baby
swaddled tightly in clothes that resemble the wrappings of the dead, or a baby naked and
vulnerable, this baby has freed himself from his restrictions, kicking his feet and raising his
hands and communicating Christ's eventual victory over death. Mary's clothes are also important.
She wears the traditional red dress, which is the color of blood and signifies her humanity.
Covering her is a blue cloak, which suggests the blue of the sky or heaven and divinity.
In Mary's clothing, we have a visible reminder that she, a human, has carried the divine within her.
Mary and Jesus are both painted according to heretic scale, meaning their size emphasizes
their importance. Both figures are extremely large. Even kneeling, Mary barely fits inside the stable.
While we can only see Joseph's back here, we can assume that he is sleeping.
Joseph is often painted as an older man who poses no threat to Mary's virginity.
Additionally, since Joseph is both a man and a sinner, he is often painted sleeping during the birth,
preserving Mary's modest purity as well. In addition to the figures of Mary, Joseph,
and Jesus, we see the animals who are traditionally present at nativity scenes,
the ox and the ass, or the donkey. The presence of these animals alludes to a verse in the book
of Isaiah that states that the ox and ass will know their master, as even the animals will
recognize their king when he appears. Additionally, the ox, which is considered a clean animal in
biblical times, and the ass, which was considered an unclean animal, are thought to represent the
union of the Israelites and the Gentiles, Gentiles being non-Jewish people. Their presence together
signifies to the fact that the Messiah was intended not just for the Jews, but for all of humanity.
Moving outward from the central depiction of the Holy Family are adoration scenes on either side.
The Magi, or wise men, are on the left. Pictured, however, without their regal finery or gifts.
Instead, they bring only their devotion. Traditionally, the Magi were painted in elaborate
clothes to emphasize that even the most powerful rulers will kneel to the king of kings. We can see
here the influence of Sabinola's teachings, who cautioned against such vanity. In Botticelli's
depiction of these figures, the beauty is in the act of adoration itself, not in the clothing worn
by the wise men. The shepherds mirror the wise men on the opposite side. With each group is an angel
who gestures with an arm toward the infant. Each angel also holds an olive branch, and from each
branch unfurls a ribbon that once read, Behold the Lamb of God which taketh away the sin of the world.
On one side, the wise men represent the rulers of the world. On the other side, the shepherds
represent those who are ruled. Both groups are equally in need of the peace and reconciliation
that the Christ child brings. Moving into the foreground or the bottom of our painting,
we encounter the most mysterious feature. Here we have three men, each paired with an angel.
The angels have olive branches with the ribbons streaming out that say, Peace on earth to men of
goodwill. Who are these men, and what are they doing? There are many interpretations that can
help us answer these questions, and each of them draws on a piece of the historical, cultural,
and biographical context that we've been discussing. One, the three men could represent
Sovereign Rolla and his two companions being raised up in the last days with the angels,
a redemptive arc for the heretic. Two, they're unknown martyrs that are being raised up at Christ's
Three, they might represent the great philosophies of the world that are ceremonially
wrestling with angels that represent God. Four, reading this depiction from left to right and
taking the path that runs in front of these figures, we can view this scene as one in which
the angels are helping the men to kneel rather than pulling them up. From left to right, each
man is getting closer and closer to kneeling, which is the only proper position to approach
the scene in the manger. And fifth, or finally, the angels are pulling people out of a state of religious
limbo. Remember Dante's purgatory, which is perhaps where Botticelli feels that he is during this
spiritual crisis. Below these mysterious figures are the demons that we've mentioned earlier.
They're easy to miss, as they're escaping in the cracks into the earth and down to the pits of hell.
Christ's presence has caused them to flee, and a few seem to be falling onto their own weapons,
admitting their defeat. Let me reiterate that Botticelli was a Renaissance master who valued
beauty and balance in his work. Yet, Botticelli's mystic nativity rejects standard rules of
perspective and creates dissonance and destabilization. The three levels of the painting
don't connect naturally and flow together in the landscape in a way that makes sense.
When we view the work, we don't identify lack of perspective as the issue. Instead,
we are left with an uneasy feeling that has been skillfully created. This dissonance emphasizes
that we are at a time of transition and transformation. The nativity and the
second coming change everything. When God breaks into human history, it is disruptive
and destabilizes the world as we know it. While much of the early Renaissance was focused on
rendering the body and space naturally, Botticelli was always occupied with the stresses of the soul.
His strong religious beliefs and struggles became more and more evident in his art
until his works became highly emotional pictures with intense religious themes.
Eventually, Botticelli would give up painting altogether. It is thought due to his spiritual
struggles. This seems exceedingly sad to me. The mystic nativity is primarily about peace,
that through Christ's coming, both his first and second coming, evil has fled and peace reigns.
I read this work as a message of faith, hope, and love, just as the repetition of the angel's
colors are meant to remind us. It is a message of the eventual triumph of good. Yet, I'm not
sure the message reached Botticelli and his struggling soul. A man who could paint such
beauty, struggle with questions of faith, and offer others the hope that Christmas brings,
should have been able to be at peace with his artistic gift and been able to enjoy it
and the beauty he was able to create. It is a good reminder for us this Christmas time.
Botticelli lived in a turbulent time, pulled many directions at once, afraid of many things,
war, death, plague, famine, and the state of his eternal soul. Yet, what Christ came to give was
primarily the gift of peace, peace with God and peace with men, peace on earth and good will
toward all men. Thanks for watching. Make sure to like this video by giving us a thumbs up below
and make sure to subscribe so you don't miss great commentary on classic works of art.
KellyBagdanoff.com is your source for great content and curriculum as well as devotional
materials using the medium of art. Make sure you visit and subscribe. Pablo Picasso said,
So, take a moment to share this video because art is too important not to share.
