Girsan Witness 2311 9c BRAT 2011 Gun Review

Gun Z9
3 followers
11 Video Views·Jan 6, 2025
The Gerson 2311 Brat.
Let's check it out.
Gerson has made a big reputation for making good quality firearms.
A lot of them are clones of original designs, whether it's the Hi-Power, the Beretta 92,
and the Cheetah series, their 1911s.
There's a number of different guns they're bringing in at really affordable prices.
Now they're going to the other end of the spectrum with the Witness 2311.
This is a double stack 1911 in the 2011 style with that polymer grip and of course steel
slide aluminum frame.
It brings the 1911 back up to modern standards.
Obviously the 1911 served the U.S. military for over 85 years, but the big deficit was
its round capacity.
And now with the 2011s, we're getting a double stack, full capacity handgun, and yet with
all the 1911 controls.
Gerson has a number of models of the 2311 series, but today we're going to take a look
at the Brat.
This is definitely something different.
It has a 17 plus one mag capacity.
It has a full size grip and yet a very short 3.4 inch barreled slide.
And this is honestly similar to an officer's model.
But with the leverage of the grip, this thing shoots extremely well.
And they're very reliable.
But the big deal is the price.
And while STI and Staccato made the 2011 unobtainable for most gun enthusiasts, we've seen a number
of different 2011s that have come in for better prices.
But nothing so far beats the Gerson.
Now we want to give a big thank you to EAA Corporation who imports Gerson into the U.S.
And they sent the Witness 2311 9C Brat for this review.
We're going to look at some pros and cons, and we're going to do some comparisons.
But if you really want to get into the 2011 world, and yet you just haven't been able
to afford it, this is something to take a look at.
Guys, Gerson has put out a number of different models of the 2311.
And this is the Witness 2311 9C.
And the C of course is for compact.
These are imported by the EAA Corporation.
Gerson is based out of Turkey.
So we're finding some really actually good quality guns that are coming out of Turkey
for less price.
And they're starting to really gain a big reputation.
And I think Canik was the one that really kind of started the ball rolling.
And now we're seeing a lot of companies that really kind of have their act together, to
be honest.
And the price is a big deal on this one.
We'll get into that because most of the 2011 pistols are running $1,500, $2,000, $3,000.
And the Gerson's coming in, and you're not going to believe it, but it's $679.
I've seen a number of sub-1,000 2011 style pistols, but this is definitely the lowest
I've seen.
So first thing let's do is drop our 17 plus 1 magazine, 9mm, checkmate mag, nice stainless
body.
And then we'll check the chamber and the gun is empty.
And you get two magazines with the gun.
I think this is your standard 2011 style magazine pattern.
There's a nice large mag well.
It's aluminum and this is removable.
So you can take this off if you don't want this at the bottom, but it sure does give
you a large well to be able to throw that mag in.
Also, we have some cutouts on the side.
So if we have a malfunction and we need to strip the mag, we can do that as well.
But this is the polymer grip and it has a aluminum receiver or frame.
And then we have a steel slide and of course barrel.
And of course all the other parts are typically steel as well, but this comes in 9mm.
We have 17 plus 1.
It comes in 45 and that's 11 plus 1.
Now my first experience with the Witness 2311 was their four and a quarter inch barrel.
Of course, very similar to your commander length, performed flawlessly.
It's a great shooting gun, front and rear cocking serrations, the grips full and large.
And I'll tell you at the range, we really had a great experience.
I mean, it just shot very well.
This one did come red dot ready with a Dury red dot sight on it that was installed when
I got it.
While it took off the rear sight, it has sights built in, so it still gives you that backup
sight to it.
And then we got one of the 10mm and of course there was a lot more power to that one.
And you know, we did a review.
It was very reliable as well.
It's one of the things that I've found from Gerson is they're typically very reliable.
The fit and finish is really good.
It's been a great option, especially toward the budget end.
But with the BRAT, it's not optics ready.
There's no RMR cuts.
We do have a Novak style sight on the back and we have a dovetailed front sight and it's
three dot and they're excellent sights.
And then the slide of course is all steel and it has a very nice finish to it.
Rear cocking serrations, but no front cocking serrations.
And so I've really found that these are very grippable, which is typical, but they're wide
so it makes it really easy to grab hold of.
We have a four slot Picatinny rail.
We were doing some testing with the new Phoenix weapons light and more will come of that.
But I just wanted to get some daylight shooting and this made a great host.
And I wanted to see how it would function.
Sometimes when you're adding lights and lasers or you're adding red dots, it changes the
recoil impulse.
It adds a little weight either to the slide or to the frame.
So I really like to add those when I can.
We have ambidextrous safeties and they're extended.
They're nice.
One thing about this handgun in particular, a lot of times you have the extended safeties,
frame safety, and you rest your thumb on it and it will get you right here.
It just seems to wear on your hand.
With the BRAT, I felt like that it gave me a very comfortable grip to it.
And this just helps to mitigate the recoil.
And then when I wrap my hand around it and get that full thumbs forward grip.
With this length, it makes a huge difference.
And with this shorter slide, which is less mass coming back in your hand, again, it's
just a very soft and flat shooting firearm.
And it does give you that full grip of the 2011.
Now personally, I've loved the 1911 for a long time.
I still do.
I love to shoot it.
I love the balance.
But again, it is a less round capacity and this just gives me a little more confidence,
which mag release jettisons the mags out, which is nice.
The texturing on the grip is very well done on the back strap, on the mainspring housing,
and on the side panels.
And then you have your G for Gerson, has the diamond pattern, which was a traditional Colt
design on your 1911s.
But the grip's really solid and of course it gives you a full grip in your hand.
Then we have the grip safety, a very high ride beaver tail, sweeps up and then you have
your memory notch to be able to depress it.
And then we have a skeletonized hammer.
Now one thing about the grip safety is that it is a passive safety and it's an old holdback
from the original 1911, which was required by the US government.
So unless the grip safety is deployed, there's no action to the trigger.
But for most shooters, it's been the standard for any kind of 1911 design.
Not only does it keep you from getting hammer bite or slide bite, it also takes the surface
and the recoil across the web of your hand and it just gives you more surface.
And it really does make a huge difference.
I've shot a lot of 1911s with just the original little kind of a nub right here.
You put a beaver tail on it and it's a world of difference.
And this has really become the industry norm is to have that beaver tail, but this one
really sweeps up.
Now with the bull barrel, it is fit to the slide.
You can see how it's thick.
And then again, we have our recoil spring and guide rod, which is a full length guide
rod.
I like that because it actually aids in making this even more smooth, whether it's racking
the slide or firing the pistol.
There are a lot of dynamics that go into recoil management and definitely that's one of the
things I really like to add.
Safety's very positive.
It's just a good solid safety.
And then if I want to bring it down, it has a nice click to it.
Trigger skeletonized.
It is polymer.
One of the things about a 1911 is the straight pullback with the single action.
So it makes it a really nice trigger pull.
So here we have a little bit of take up, hit a wall, a nice break.
Now this is not a super crisp break like on a lot of 1911s.
It's not bad.
It's better than most of your polymer striker fire triggers.
But it's one of the things when you're really spending a lot of money on a 1911, typically
the trigger is very well tuned.
Reset right there.
Resets really fast.
We're going to check the trigger pull weight with our Lyman trigger gauge from Brownells.
Six pounds, 2.2 ounces, five pounds, 14.1 ounces.
So we're looking at right about six pounds.
And so while this is a great entry budget 2011 style or double stack 1911, it does have
a few downsides and that's just going to be part of the price.
One of the things about a 2011 or even a 1911 is it takes a lot more hand fitting, barrel
to slide, slide to frame.
I mean, to make a really high quality 1911, it's the reason why the prices are as high
as they are.
With the Garcon, and we're just going to pull back on the slide.
I mean, it's nice.
It's not bad.
A little bit, I can feel a little bit of binding with the springs.
But overall, again, this has been extremely reliable and accurate.
And so if you want the refinements, then you're going to have to spend more money.
But if you just want something that is really a solid performer, then this could be a great
option.
It's like the Bull Armory, and this is the Ultralight.
I've just reviewed this handgun.
It has a little bit of a shorter, more compact grip, but it still holds 16 plus one in the
magazine.
Slide coming back, it's empty.
It's just super smooth.
And that's because there's been a lot of hand fitting that has gone into this.
The price though reflects that, and we're looking at more of $1,750.
Again, with the Garcon, we're looking at $679 retail.
It's really difficult to expect the refinement that you're going to get with a more expensive
2011 style or double stack 1911, but you're getting what you're paying for.
But yet this is still a very solid handgun, and really for a third of the price.
Now this is still a 2011 or a 1911 style handgun, so this can be upgraded with the trigger job
and other things, and it's one of the things that Cosaint Arms actually specializes in
is the Garcon Witness 2311s.
They do a number of different services, and the owner of Cosaint actually worked for Staccato.
So just on his own, they produce some really nice 2011 style pistols.
But if you get your Witness, and you want a new trigger job, or you want the action
smoothed up or whatever, this gives you a great resource.
And weight on the Garcon Brat, 29.37 ounces.
And guys, we have just revamped our website at suitsgear.com.
There's a lot of different suit swag over there, patches, t-shirts, but there's also
a lot of my favorite products are there.
We also have the suits deals where we find all kinds of deals and offer those to you
guys at some of the best prices.
Another thing that we do is a lot of the videos that were taken down by YouTube, which we
call our contraband or banned videos, and all that's over on suitsgear.com, so check
it out.
Give a big thank you to Fiocchi for sponsoring the ammo, all made in the USA.
One of the biggest suppliers of ammunition in the country.
One thing about the Lula loaders, we tended to pop back on this.
I don't know if it's because of this wide body, but I love my Lula loaders, but we're
going to do it the old-fashioned way, which I enjoy.
I like this.
Well, we have the EAA Witness, and this is their 2311 series.
This is the BRAT.
It has a short barrel with a full-length grip, 17 plus 1.
It's similar to the G19X.
This has that full grip, short slide, you've got a short recoil system coming back, it's
very soft-shooting.
And you have that 2011-style pistol, so that polymer grip, which kind of absorbs some of
the recoil.
Very controllable.
And putting your thumb on that safety forms kind of a ledge, just to rest your thumb,
so it makes it really soft-shooting.
But EAA has been putting out some really nice, those 2311s, for the price, it's just really
a great way to get into a 2011, because they're typically very expensive.
And no malfunctions whatsoever, it's just been a really good shooter.
And again, that longer grip, it definitely mitigates a lot of the recoil, gives you a
lot of control over the firearm.
Now as far as disassembly, drop your magazine, check to make sure the gun is unloaded.
Now you see this little notch?
We're going to put it right toward the slide stop.
So we're just going to bring it back.
Here on the other side, we have the takedown lever.
And so you're just going to push that through.
Now because the 2011-style pistols have a very thick frame, it's a little tough to get
this out.
There it comes.
Next, bring forward your slide.
Just keep your thumb on that recoil spring, just to double-check that it should stay in
place.
Now this is a little different.
It does have the full-length guide rod.
Some, you push all the way through and put a tool in there to hold it.
This is a little different.
So make sure your barrel link's pushed back.
Push or compress your recoil spring and then lift up.
Just like that.
And I caught it with my thumb.
You got to be real careful because that will spring out.
So you just want to lift it up and just pull it right out.
Full-length guide rod and spring.
Now this is just really more like your traditional guide rod, except that it's usually about
a third this size or half.
And so this gives you a full-length, but yet somewhat of a traditional style.
Now right under the dust cover, there is a sleeve and you can actually push it from the
front like that and it'll come out.
Next, take your barrel link, put it in the down position, and then we're going to pull
the barrel right out of the slide.
Again, we have a 3.4 inch barrel.
It is a bull barrel design at the end, and then that mates up to your slide and that's
what gives it just better accuracy.
The better the fit.
Of course, if it's too tight, it can cause unreliability.
But the tighter it is, the more accurate it's going to be.
So there is a really good balance.
But overall, a very small, short barrel, about the size of an officer's model Colt.
Nice polished feed ramp.
And here we have the slide, very nice polish.
Seems like it's no tool marks or anything.
Just nicely finished.
Then here we have the frame, and of course right here is all aluminum all the way back.
And then we have the polymer that's attached to the aluminum.
And you do not need to take this part off of your frame.
And guys, that's all you need to do for field strip and maintenance.
Reverse order.
We're going to put in our barrel.
Then we're going to take our little cup here.
There is a small cutout in part of the flange, and we're just going to put that on the downside,
actually facing upward on the slide.
Now bring up your barrel link, take your recoil spring and guide rod.
This is a flat recoil spring.
And so this typically helps mitigate the recoil.
For some reason, it's just the physics.
It just allows this to be a little more springy.
So we're going to go ahead and put it into the dust cover area and then just compress
the recoil spring until you get it past your barrel link.
There we go.
So then it fits right here, and then we're going to take our barrel link and push it
forward.
Go ahead and put it back, put the slide back over your frame.
Now you're going to want to start looking for your barrel link to appear, and then we're
going to put in our slide stop.
Just like that.
Now go ahead and raise up your slide stop and just kind of get it placed, and then we're
going to bring back our slide and we're going to match it with that first notch where the
slide stop is.
We want to make sure we clear the grip and come down on the low end, just like this,
and then push in and up, just like that, and it snaps in.
There's a small detent and you've got to get past that.
Release it, check for function, and we're good to go.
Now keeping your firearms maintained and cleaned is vital.
Otis makes some of the best cleaning equipment out there.
They make a number of different kits that are dedicated for different rifles, pistols.
They also have Shooter's Choice, which makes excellent CLP and bore solvent and different
cleaning materials.
The Ripcord is one of their signatures and there's a whole system based around it.
They are suppliers to the US military.
Check out Otis Technologies, highly recommended, and we want to thank Otis for being a sponsor
of the channel.
We get a hard case, and of course we get the handgun.
It is in closed foam padding, and we get the extra magazine lock and a bore brush.
And of course, you get your owner's manual, and again, CoSaint Arms is a resource to be
able to get your EAA really just tuned up.
Again, the retail price, $679.
I've seen nothing even close to that.
And you do get an extra magazine, which has typically not been the case with your Witness
2311.
But let's talk about pros and cons.
First off is you're getting a 2011 style or a double stack 1911 for under $680.
And that is, to me, the lowest I've seen anywhere for any style, even some of the live free
armories and different ones, the platypus.
This is getting it down to an extremely reasonable price.
You got 17 plus one in the magazine, gives you a lot of capacity.
Has the longer grip and the short slide, but this grip really leverages your recoil and
it gives it a very nice shooting experience.
These are very reliable.
That's a big deal.
A lot of times when you get budget firearms, they can be a little hit or miss.
This one for me has been just super reliable.
It has all the bells and whistles with the beaver tail, the Delta style hammer, the ambidextrous
safeties, Novak style sights.
One ding I would have to give it is there's no optics cut.
Whether you're running optics or not, it's nice to have that plate.
But with the way Gerson runs it, they would have to remove that back sight.
To be honest, if I'm not going to run it, I like that sight.
If I wanted to, I could replace the front sight with a fiber optic.
It's all black.
I mean, it's really blacked out.
And to be honest, again, the finish on this is really well done.
The molded grip, very textured.
And I mean, it really fits nice in your hand.
Trigger pull is fine.
It's just a little heavy.
And I think some of the early Gersons had a little more heavier trigger pull.
I think that they're bringing it down.
Now, again, guys, this is a $680 2011 style pistol.
That is very reasonable.
Yes, it's imported by Turkey, and that's one of the reasons why we can get some quality,
and yet the price is lower.
But it's not quite as smooth as a lot of your 2011s.
The slide to frame coming back, the trigger pull is not quite as nice.
But again, you're paying about a third of the price of even some of the lower double
stack 1911s.
So there's give and take.
It's really good, but it is a budget firearm.
But for a budget firearm, it's not bad.
So I'm really impressed.
In fact, this one in particular, I really enjoyed shooting it.
Even more than the four and a quarter inch.
To me, this is one of my favorite double stack 1911s.
The Bull Armory Ultralight, this is, to me, the ultimate.
Even compared to the Staccato, it matches, to me, the same quality.
But again, it's $1,750 retail.
Which one am I going to pick?
Well, if I didn't have the money to purchase this one, but I still wanted to experience
the 2011, this would definitely be in the running.
In fact, I really like this handgun.
So it's a matter of preference, and it's a matter of your budget.
What do you want to spend?
If you like the 2011 platform and you're not willing to pay this kind of price for it,
this is a great gun.
And it's very reliable.
And to be honest, if you really wanted to, you could spend some time to upgrade this
to get those refinements.
But as far as it is, out of the box, right here, it's very shootable.
I enjoyed it.
The range day was great, and it gave me good accuracy.
All the controls were there.
The standard 1911, it gives me a high round capacity with two mags.
I personally think it's a great option.
But let me say this, guys.
If you do have a Staccato or you have even the Bull Armories, and you're thinking, well,
I want to budget just because it's a lot cheaper, you're not going to be as happy with it.
But your pocketbook will, and it's still a great gun.
Guys, the 2011 style or double stack 1911s have been extremely popular, and we're seeing
more and more offerings.
But if you've really wanted to get one, but they're just so expensive, check out Gerson.
Their Witness 2311s, very reliable, have all the same features of your standard 2011, and
yet, just for a very affordable price.
And again, a big thank you to EAA Corporation for sending the Witness 2311 9C Brat for this
review.
Be strong, be of good courage.
God bless America.
Long live the Republic.
And this is honestly, officers, 2311 I did a review on was the, what is this?
But over the past few years, we've seen it.
I like that.
I like what I'm doing, but that's just not going to work.
And this is a, I don't know what it is.
You are such a brat that a steel frame would, okay.
I like it.
I really enjoy this.
Okay, let's not lie to the audience.
Why not?
I don't.
I used to do this all the time, even though I hadn't lived in New Orleans.
That ought to be weird.
Doing that freeze thing I have to do with the wind blowing.
Today, we're going to take a look at this.
We're going to take a look at the EAA or European American Armory Corporation Brat.
They have a good name.
It's a long name.
It's a short name for a gun, long name for a company.
