2021 Subaru Crosstrek Sport vs Outback Onyx XT - Off-Road Adventure Review

Cars Arena
18 followers
This is a 2021 Subaru Crosstrek Sport, and this is its bigger brother, the Subaru Outback Onyx XT.
Today we're going on an adventure that includes 100 miles of freeway and a segment of the
Washington Overlanding Trail to see if bigger really is better. That's coming up right now
on Driving Sports TV. Starting with the 2021 models, Subaru finally added something to the
More horsepower. Sport and Limited trims were blessed with a larger 2.5 liter boxer engine,
which bumped power from 152 horses to a much more acceptable 182. Its larger brother,
the Outback Onyx XT, comes with a turbocharged 2.4 liter engine making 260 horsepower. Of course,
the Outback is larger and heavier, but even after doing some basic math, we can figure the
Crosstrek Sport generates 111.5 horsepower per ton, whereas the Outback Onyx XT manages 133,
a significant difference in favor of the Outback. But a car is more than just horsepower. Which is
more fun? Which has better economy? And which of these two are simply more capable? That is what
we're hoping to find out today. In terms of other features, both of these cars have Subaru's
symmetrical all-wheel drive, both have continuously variable transmissions, and both have dual function
X mode. The Outback Onyx XT has a ridiculously large infotainment system, the Crosstrek a much
more humble 6.5 inch setup. Active safety features are similar, as both come with the EyeSight system.
This 2021 Crosstrek Sport is actually one of my personal cars. It has a number of options,
and is priced at $28,655 including delivery. This Outback Onyx XT is a long-term test vehicle
provided by Subaru. We built it to your specifications during a live stream last year,
and it is priced at $39,718 as you see it, more than 10 grand over the price of the Crosstrek
Sport. The first leg of our journey will be a freeway drive from Bellevue to Ellensburg,
Washington. Carlina will be driving the Outback, and I'll be in the Crosstrek. On the freeway,
we both reset tripometers so we can compare the computer's economy estimations along the way.
I just finished a 3,600 mile drive in that Subaru Outback, and I have to say it was one of the most
comfortable long journeys I've ever taken. And that's all without like, you know, fancy high-end
stuff like seat massagers. It's just a comfortable, solid car. And I even ran into some snow along the
way, and it dealt with it just fine, because of course it has symmetrical all-wheel drive. You
know, Subarus are really great just because they're not a compromise to drive every single day. You
But when the chips come down and weather gets foul, the Subaru can deal with it,
and it deals with it like a pro. And that is why I think these cars have become so popular.
For total range, I'm showing 380 until I'm out of gas.
I think my car is going to be more economical. So we'll check back in with you in a little bit.
And let's head over to Ellensburg. One of the big features of that Outback is the fact that it is
really quiet inside. And that is thanks to the acoustic glass on the front window.
This one also has acoustic glass, but it's just not as quiet. It is close though, and I think it
really comes down to the fact that they just put less sound deadening into these smaller cross
tracks because it's a different audience. What's your MPGs at right now, your average?
25.6. 25.6, huh? Mine is 31.2.
The Outback also, of course, has a massive screen in the middle. And this one only has a little
six and a half inch. I do kind of miss the big screen. Being able to see Apple CarPlay maps just
massive in the middle there. It's just kind of a nice feature to have,
but it doesn't really move me as a buyer. Case in point, I bought this car, not that car.
Okay, we've now done the first 28.5 miles and we've been doing basically adaptive cruise
control the whole time between 60 and 70 miles per hour with the auto lane centering feature.
So our driving dynamics are basically the same. What's your MPGs looking like?
Right now, 26.5.
Yeah, I'm rolling at 31.1. Economy is really going to suffer on the first leg of this trip.
And that's because we're climbing up over Snoqualmie Pass. We're going up for the first
half of it and then going down for the second half of it. But our down never quite meets up
with the amount of up that we go. So don't use these numbers as a comparison to EPA numbers,
because the EPA tests, they're on a level surface. We're not doing that today.
This first stretch is 100 miles. We're going from Bellevue, Washington to Ellensburg. From
Ellensburg, we're going to Durr Road. And Durr Road is part of the Washington Overlanding Trail.
It's a 600 mile journey from the south part of Washington to the north part,
mostly on Durr Roads. Today, we're just going to get a small taste of it.
We're coming up over the summit here. Let me check in with Carlina. We're at 43 miles.
What's your MPGs looking like right now that we've hit 43 miles and we're
cresting over Snoqualmie Pass? 24.
So mine has dropped as well. Of course, it's because we're going up a very steep
climb for many miles and I'm down to 27.8. However, both of our MPGs are definitely
going to increase once we start going down the other side. So I'll check in again with you once
we get closer to Ellensburg. One thing that I really like about the Subaru Outback is that it
has LED headlights. This one, you still get the old school halogens, which for 2021, I think is
kind of a weird omission to use such low output headlights. However, not all is perfect with those
LEDs. When I was driving across the plains of northern, where was I, northern Nevada,
every single trucker would flash their high beams at me as though I had my high beams on
when I didn't. That's the Outback. You can see how bright those headlights are right now even.
So far, we've been driving close to 100 miles and this one definitely is not as comfortable
as the Outback for long-term journeys. The shorter wheelbase, the slightly tighter suspension setup,
it just makes for a jumpier driving environment. It's also slightly louder and all those things
add up to making this not as enjoyable for really long trips. Doesn't make it bad, it just means
that like if I'm going to do 3,600 miles again, I'm going to pick the Outback over the Crosstrek.
Now let's see how MPGs are doing now that we're getting close to 100 miles of range here. We've
now gone up the Cascade Mountains and slightly down it, although we've definitely gone more
climbing than we have descent because we're at about 2,000 feet here and we started at sea level.
Okay, we're entering Ellensburg and what's your MPGs looking like? 27.2. 27.2, really?
What do you have? 31.7, so not quite as big of a delta as I would have expected and I think the
real issue is that climbing up the mountains because you have more power so your vehicle
does it easier. Drove that vehicle 3,600 miles recently and I was not being quite so subtle with
23 miles to the gallon overall but of course that's a lot more accelerating, decelerating,
higher speeds and all that other kind of stuff. Well, we all know you also have a left foot.
This is true. So the Crosstrek has better MPGs a bit when mountains are involved but it's also
not quite as comfortable to drive as the Outback so I'm actually going to give this segment of the
trip a win to the Outback because it is clearly the better choice and though, yeah, you are going
to get awful MPGs in the Outback if you really let your throttle down. Basically, if you get
into that boost range where it's putting out maximum power it is going to give you much lower
MPG. However, if you're gentle with the throttle and you're just cruising along you can get 27
miles to the gallon even climbing up a mountain and that is pretty awesome. This one, 31.9,
nothing to sneeze at so this one's good but I think for freeways, the Outback, that one's still great.
Now we are outside of Ellensburg on Der Road. Now this is actually a classic stagecoach road
from the 1800s. Yeah, it was a paid road. Now this is the craziest story. Some dude,
enterprising guy, said, you know what, I'm going to shave 10 miles off of people's journey across
those snowy mountains and I'm going to do it by building a toll road. He charged 25 bucks in the
1800s. I did the math. That is insane. It was roughly $700 by today's dollars to go over this road
and the crazy thing was stagecoaches couldn't fit up the switchbacks so we had these crazy turn
styles that the stagecoach would enter, it would rotate and then go up to the next switchback and
so today we have much more convenient means of getting up there. We have the 2020 Subaru Outback
Onyx XT which is on loan to us from Subaru and then we have my personal Subaru Crosstrek Sport
with the larger 2.5 liter naturally aspirated engine. So, Carlina, you've seen kind of the
road that we're on. Yeah. We're kind of in the middle of nowhere here. Yeah, we are. What do
you think? I think it's gonna be a fun adventure. I don't think we're gonna get stuck this time
unlike all the other times but it's a bit cold so we might get, you know, encounter some ice,
some slippage here and there but I don't think we'll have it as rough as they did back in the
day in their stagecoaches. Yeah, and if we do encounter rough conditions that's where we'll
be able to test out dual function X mode which is on both of these vehicles. That one has it,
that one has it. Which is better on an old stagecoach road? That's what we're gonna find out.
Let's talk about what overlanding is. Overlanding is not extreme off-roading. The two are very
different. Overlanding is typically going on a journey to a location off the beaten path,
sometimes off the grid, usually on some kind of like personal journey. Like you're trying to
discover not just a new location but also discover a little bit of yourself in the process. It's
something you do when you're looking for bigger meaning in the world. So overlanding can mean
something slightly different to everyone. However, the typical thing that you think of are really
rough roads, remote locations, snow-peaked mountains. We're not going to be camping,
we're not going to be doing all the other stuff, and we're not going to be, you know, out here for
days. This is really just a taste of what overlanding is like and I'm really kind of
curious how well this vehicle does compared to its larger brother, the Onyx XT. Now I have pre-run
this first quarter mile with the Outback, so I have some idea what we're getting into, but not
exactly. Already I can tell the suspension is stiffer on this Crosstrek than it is on the Outback.
Possibly it's because of weight, so this vehicle responds with much more jumpiness and much more
harshness, but the Outback, it kind of smooths this road over a little bit more. And there is
something else that I have to really point out. First thing is that we are running stock tires
on both of these. I want this comparison to be as equal as possible. Both these vehicles are as you
get them from the showroom floor. I have done nothing to this vehicle. I have not even added
underbody protection, which might be a mistake. I'm hoping it's not, so I have to be super careful
on this trip or my wife will not be pleased. Now it's crazy to think that this road I have read
is even better than it was back when it was a stagecoach route. This is actually smoother and
easier to cross, which is just blows my mind what people went through back in the day to get where
they wanted to go. Usually, you know, looking for opportunity or looking for a better life or, you
they would head out west and they would get into a wagon and they would cross just in what today we
would think were impassable locations, and they did it. So far, it's rough and it's narrow,
but it's not too bad. This is doing fine. Of course, we're going downhill, so we have gravity
at our back. We have not aired down the tires, although these rocks are kind of on the sharp
side. I might consider doing that just to reduce the opportunity for a puncture. I'm curious how
Carlina's doing back there. I know there's so many old parts of Washington that I've never been to,
so much history that I don't know about this state, and I honestly love history.
So this is extra special to me to be out here on this old pioneer wagon road. This is awesome.
Our wagons are a little bit different, so we'll see how they might fare in this journey as compared
to, you know, stagecoaches. Just driving through this area, it is so beautiful.
Kind of desert vibe to it. You got a bunch of sagebrush, which is my favorite.
I can't even imagine going through this on back in the day on your stagecoach. That'd be so cool.
How you doing back there? Are you getting rattled yet? It is not as bad as I was expecting.
Earlier on the highway, I was saying it's such a smooth ride, and I was curious how this was
about to go. So far, so good. Very impressed. I can tell you right now you're having a smoother
ride than I am. Oh yeah. The zigzags over there, that was the original wagon trail that they used,
that they went up with the stagecoaches. As we go around the corner here, oh wow.
Nah, you couldn't pay me enough to go up that in a wagon. Heck, I wouldn't even go up that in a car.
Now, when I was looking at the travel guides, they said that this road is one of the more gnarly
sections of the Washington Overlanding Trail. And there are big rocks, but so far, this is easy.
And I feel kind of confident that, you know, with the Subaru here, I don't have to worry about...
Actually, some of these rocks are really big. Gotta keep active eyes on what we're doing here.
If I'm not paying attention, a single rock here will totally take out my oil pan.
Luckily, they are spaced far enough apart that I can get around them no problem.
Okay. And this is tight, that's for sure. So far, not a big deal.
That is rolling. Oh, that's a big rock. Gotta pay attention. Like, I want to look it up here,
but I gotta keep my eyes down here because of all these big boulders in the way.
Nice little old-timey bridge over a river we got going on here.
At the bottom of the ravine, we found some mud, which was a great opportunity
to have some fun with a little game of follow the leader.
So how did that feel to you? Fine. I mean, I still got a spine. How about you?
Yes, I do. Thank you very much.
To see how each car handled this differently, we switched vehicles and
ran through it a couple more times. Oh man, this is so much smoother. Oh, bigger too.
It definitely has a lot more momentum as you hit those big divots in the road.
Yeah, I think that in this condition, the Crosstrek is much better. I mean, this is okay.
This is fun, but it's not as quick. It's not as easy to drive on this stuff because it's just big.
Slip, sliding everywhere. Oh, this is fun. I love this.
We still had a lot of rough miles and unknown challenges ahead of us,
so we got back into our original cars and pressed forward.
Appear to be a little rougher than the first half. To go to the right. This is a steep climb.
Actually, surprisingly rough. It would not take a Camry on this.
Okay, now we're getting into a really rough terrain. This is a little more brutal than before.
Oh boy, there are some big rocks here. Watch, make sure we're straddling appropriately.
So what's our fuel economy looking like now? I'm at 26.6. I'm only at 23 even.
Oh, it's interesting how the changes in what it's doing don't really seem to impact it as much.
This is going to get real. Oh boy, there's a crosscut, but it doesn't really look that bad.
Yeah, it's enough to lift a wheel. Okay, this is where I'm going to switch it into X mode.
So I'm going to hit the button down here. I think just regular snow dirt is fine,
and away we go. And power is redistributed around the system, and up we go.
Do you know how X mode works? I'm finding it out right now.
Okay, snow, dirt, snow. Just snow dirt is fine. Okay, just put your foot in. Keep your foot in.
Keep your foot in. The throttle will figure itself out. Okay.
Fine, just keep it going. Keep it going. Keep it going.
Okay. And that's the funny thing with X mode. It feels like you're not doing the right thing,
but in fact, you are. So the interesting thing about seeing Carlina's car there,
and maybe exterior footage will prove me wrong, but it seemed like the Crosstrek made a better
job of that challenging position. When the one wheel was completely lifted off the ground,
the Crosstrek was able to get out of it very quickly. Even after Carlina turned on the same
single mode X mode, which is just the deep snow and dirt, it had to think longer,
which is interesting. Now, granted, not all traction situations are identical,
and the longer wheelbase on that vehicle might have changed the dynamics. So we have to keep
that in mind as well. Can you just imagine what it was like to take a carriage up a road even
rougher than this in the 1800s, knowing that there is no other way to get where your destination is?
And in fact, you may not have had a home to go back to the other way you had to get through.
It makes our little journey with symmetrical all wheel drive and X mode just seem so
easy by comparison. In fact, it kind of like, it blows my mind how far we've come.
You might be thinking, well, this isn't really overlanding because we're not
staying the night. We're not going to a place that nobody has ever been.
You know, it's, it, this is really overlanding light. And I understand that what we're really
doing today is just showing some of the capabilities, you know, doing some of the
stuff that the vehicles will encounter in the real world. If you were to attempt an overlanding trip
and between these two vehicles, I would absolutely take the Outback over the cross track.
If I was, you know, going to an off-grid area, it's just, it's a more comfortable vehicle in
those conditions. I like the extra horsepower, but I have to say I'm not really missing horsepower.
I like the horsepower specifically for highways, which there's always going to be highways in the
United States, but when it comes to like this off-road stuff, this has plenty of power now.
And that was not the case with the old cross track. The old cross tracks, a little two liter
engine was fine, but it was not good. It was the absolute basic. This one is exactly what you need.
You know, it's, I have not once thought I need more power. It's a little obstacle there. Not too bad.
Well, I feel like we're on top of the world now. I wonder where this goes. Okay. So in that case,
I guess we are overlanding because I have no idea where I'm going. Yes, other people have been here,
but I never have. You see how far that antenna array still is? I thought we were like there.
That looks like we got a ways to go. Okay, well quit slowing us down there, Carolina.
Sorry, I'm just enjoying the views. It's pretty cool out here. It feels like we're the only people
out here at all. Like there's nobody for hundreds of miles, which I'm sure isn't the case since the
This doesn't feel to me like Washington. I've done a lot, a lot of exploring.
I was driving like random back roads out in the middle of nowhere like this.
But this one is insanely unique. And I'd still feel that way,
even if it didn't have all the snow that which we are approaching.
Big boulders on either side. Make sure I don't bump them and scratch
and get shunted into them. So my only complaint really is that the suspension's a little on the
stiff side. That's it. So you know how I gave you a kind of hard time for bringing
snow boots along today? Well, looks like you're maybe going to need them.
See, whenever I come out here with you, I always have to be prepared because you never know what's
going to happen. The towers came closer and closer, and it was becoming apparent that we
really lucked out with our timing of this adventure. A week sooner and the snow drifts
across the trail would have been near impossible to cross safely. But even in the face of these
hazards, both Subarus were really up to the challenge. Would I recommend doing this without
a skid plate? No, not really. It only takes one misplaced rock to puncture an oil pan.
And though the Onyx XT does come with a full size spare, the Crosstrek Sport does not,
making it overall less suited for this type of an adventure from the factory.
Several hours after starting the adventure, we finally made it to the pass.
Both the Crosstrek Sport and the Onyx XT came through what was more a drive testing rugged
endurance than anything else. If there were two things I would wish for here, it would be
additional ground clearance and more aggressive tires. If Subaru could deliver a car from the
factory with those features, I think it would really open the door to even more amazing adventures
to a much wider group of buyers. Yeah, that's it. I don't know. It was fun.
So what did we learn today? In spite of the vast similarities between these two vehicles,
they're actually quite different when you start driving them. And that's not just because of
the size and the weight, but also decisions that Subaru made regarding suspension tuning.
Am I glad that I bought the Crosstrek? Yeah, of course, because I also have a 4Runner. So
I kind of have the vehicles that are on both sides of that Outback Onyx XT.
One a little bit bigger, more off roady. This one is a little less off roady and smaller.
It's kind of a great combination. Thanks for watching. I'm Ryan Douthit. This has been our
look at the Outback Onyx XT and its smaller counterpart, the Crosstrek Sport. Is one better
than the other? Well, no. One will be more appropriate depending on how you want to drive
and where you want to go. For the trails like today, I would say that the Outback would be
the better choice. It's just more comfortable. And of course, it has more space. You can carry
more gear with you. This one's a little limited if you want to try the actual overlanding,
because basically you throw a cooler and sleeping pad and a sleeping bag back there
and you're pretty much full. What do you think? What would you take? Would you take this Crosstrek
Sport or the Outback Onyx XT? Post a comment below. Thanks for watching. We'll see you again
right here next week.
