Port strike shouldn't have immediate impact on retailers: Fmr. Target Vice Chairman Gerald Storch

Financial Freedom
10 followers
Jan 1, 2025
Gerald Storch, Storch Advisors CEO and former Target vice chairman, joins 'Closing Bell Overtime' to talk retailers preparing for a port strike, holiday shopping trends, and more.
So for more on how a port strike could impact retailers,
let's bring in Storch advisor, CEO, Gerald Storch.
He's also the former vice chairman of Target
and the former CEO of Toys R Us.
Jerry, happy holidays.
Good to see you.
Thank you.
So Jerry, I've been talking
to some of the biggest logistics companies.
They're telling me big retailers,
like a Walmart and a Costco,
they're shifting over to the West Coast ports.
They're also bringing things in early
to try to mitigate a port strike.
So I want to ask you, besides a one or two week strike,
when will we start to see the impact
when it comes to these major retailers?
What are the signs for investors
that it's having a negative impact?
Well, certainly it's going to be a lower impact
whatever happens than it would have been last fall.
This is a pretty low volume time of the year
when you put it in perspective.
And, you know, frankly, the retail didn't do too well.
They don't mind if it's a little bit delayed
because they might have too much inventory already.
But the strong retailers, as you pointed out,
they pulled forward inventory.
They saw this coming, you know, months away
and they shifted to other ports, other modes,
and in some cases to air freight where that made more sense.
So it really shouldn't be a drag on business right away.
Hopefully the whole situation won't drag on too long.
Obviously if it does, costs will increase
and you'll have some shortages.
There are things you just can't bring in early.
The famous example of bananas
where how long can you store a banana?
And certainly there are problems for automobiles
coming from Europe into the East Coast ports.
So eventually it could become a problem.
But smarter retailers don't just put this
in its own category.
They put it together with, look, look, the threat of wars.
Look what's going on in the Red Sea with the Houthis.
Tariffs and all the uncertainty that provides.
The pandemic, you mentioned that earlier.
So there are so many issues with supply chains
that the old thinking that just in time was best
has been thrown out the window
and people are saying,
let's build flexibility into our system.
And that's what the best retailers have already done.
So they should be able to handle this
unless it just drags on for a month or longer.
All right, so you're saying
that they're able to handle it logistically,
but what about their financials?
I mean, what about a margin impact?
What about EPS impact?
When we talk about shifting supply chains,
that costs money.
When we talk about holding inventory longer
by pulling ahead, that's a higher carrying cost.
So how do you see that impact in these retailers
when it comes to earnings after the holiday season?
Well, you're right.
It's something, but in the broader scheme of things,
I just don't feel that it's a red.
You know, it's a yellow type thing.
You know, green, red, yellow, red.
This is yellow right now.
It's not red.
I think they have much bigger issues.
The winners and the losers here in retail are pretty stark.
And the people that are winning are winning by so much.
And the people that are losing are losing by so much
that there's still gonna be winners and losers.
Jerry, one of my favorite stats of the day was from Bespoke,
where they said that the most correlated stock to Apple
in the S&P 500 over the last year has been TJX.
And I wonder what you think that says
about the state of retail right now.
Look, there are some, you know, people say,
oh, the consumer had a good holiday.
Okay, you know, all boats did not float.
For over a year now, I've been recommending four companies
as being best on strategy and best run.
They're Walmart, TJX, which you just mentioned,
Costco, and Amazon.
And they have just done phenomenally,
both in the stock market
and in terms of gaining market share.
And frankly, I think that's what's gonna continue.
Retail hasn't changed that fast.
The consumer doesn't change that fast.
They love those companies just as much as they hate
some of the more traditional retailers,
like department stores or some of the aging apparel chains.
So is the fate of department stores just over?
Can they turn it around?
I mean, this has been a year of many headlines
in the department store world.
Macy's closing stores amidst activist pressure.
You've got Nordstrom Family
taking the company private again.
I mean, is there a light at the end of the tunnel here
or is the business model just over?
Well, the way they're running it right now,
I don't think it's gonna work.
The change just isn't significant enough
to resonate with consumers,
particularly younger consumers.
Look, your mother or your grandmother
may still love shopping at department stores,
but you don't and your children won't.
And that's what's going on right now.
It's almost a generational shift.
To change it, they have to totally change
how they do business,
become a much more desirable place to shop.
And people might say, oh, look, Walmart and Costco,
those stocks are way the heck up.
I can't buy those.
Would you rather buy the stock of a company
that's mired in strategic disarray
and operational weakness?
I don't think that's a very good bet either.
So I think there's a tough row to hoe
for the retailers that have been losing share.
And I wouldn't put my money with any of them,
whether it's Costco or, I'm sorry,
whether it's Kohl's, Costco I love,
whether it's Kohl's or whether or not it's Macy's,
whether it's anyone in that bracket.
