Investment Strategist Sam Stovall On The Adage To Sell In May

Invest Insight
9 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis discussion examines the traditional Wall Street mantra \"sell in May and go away,\" questioning its validity in the modern market. While historical data suggests lower returns during the summer months, experts argue that tax implications, the dominance of AI-driven tech stocks, and the specific nature of presidential election cycles make a blanket exit strategy impractical for most investors.
For decades on Wall Street they used to say, and in the City of London,
sell in May and go away. Those were the days because at this time of the year traders will
be getting ready for a summer in the Berkshires or the Hamptons going off to the Borscht Belt.
And the idea was that you sold the stocks that generally lagged between June and September
because markets were so quiet. It might be tempting after the Nasdaq just posted its
best month since 2020. Analysts at Deutsche Bank are not so sure. They advise against it
based on historical data of European stocks. Apparently it's a bad idea because
Sam Stovall is the Chief Investment Strategist at CFRA Research. You and I both grew up with
that mantra, sell in May, go away. I don't know anybody who ever actually did it,
but everybody said somebody else should. Well Richard, yes, everybody talks about it because
historically from World War II the May through October period gained only about 2% for the
overall market, but up 7% from November through April. And so at least it's something that sounds
interesting and it advises investors don't let your emotions rule your portfolio's action.
Just be aware that there could be volatility in these coming six months. So if there's no
real justification for the old idea of sell in May, go away. The problem is, A,
if you're selling stocks now at higher levels to the capital gains tax issue in many cases that
you've got, particularly if you look at Nvidia and those big ones. And secondly,
what do you do with the money instead? Now that's a stupid question at one level. You put it into
cash, you put it into bonds or whatever. You park it somewhere. But then you're going to have
the uncomfortableness of just watching the market go up and up and up. Well you're right,
and also really it's only the midterm election year of the four-year presidential cycle in which
the sell in May adage actually works because in that period since 1990, the S&P lost 1.5% on
average and also fell more frequently than it advanced. So typically investors rotated
into the defensive areas of food, beverage, tobacco, and healthcare as they waited out this
volatility, but then dived back into the more cyclical sectors like tech come the beginning
of November. Do you think that's a strategy worth following today? I think it's something that
for nervous investors could be a good way of staying in the market, in a sense,
rotating rather than retreating. But this technique has not really worked over the last
six or seven years, mainly because technology has just driven the markets so dramatically.
So a question I'm asking for most of our people like yourself who know what they're talking about,
before we went into the war there was a definite obviously story and feeling that the market was
overvalued, the AI hype, etc., etc. That to some extent has abated as we've got numbers,
but the truth is that the market is still tech AI dominated and that could still be
regarded as precarious. Or am I being old-fashioned and somewhat backward?
No, I think you're right that investors are concerned because valuations do matter,
whether it's technology stocks or any other stocks on the market. And prior to the recent
sell-off, the tech stocks were trading at a 20 percent premium to their five-year average
valuation. And today they're still around a 9 percent, 9, 10 percent discount. So
some investors would say that there is upside momentum ahead.
I'm good. Good to see you, sir. Thank you very much indeed for joining us.
