Only Yesterday: Studio Ghibli's Forgotten Masterpiece

Movie Review
40 followers
When people think of Studio Ghibli, they tend to think of Hayao Miyazaki, and for good reason.
As one of the lead founders of the studio, he has gone on to make some of the most celebrated
and acclaimed animated films of all time, like Spirited Away, Princess Mononoke, and My Neighbor
Totoro. But I feel as though some people might forget he's not the only director to make films
for the studio, with the other most prominent director being one of the co-founders of Studio
Takahata graduated from the University of Japan in 1959 with a degree in French literature. He
found himself being more interested in animation and decided to pursue writing and directing for
animation instead. For the first two decades of his career, Takahata worked primarily as an anime
TV director, even working for Toei for a short while, where he would go on to meet Miyazaki.
He continued this work as a TV director until he helped co-found Ghibli in 1985, and while his
output wasn't as high as Miyazaki, he would go on to direct five films for the studio. He's mostly
known for his incredibly tragic and semi-autobiographical film, Grave of the Fireflies,
but he's also directed Pompoko, The Tale of Princess Kaguya, My Neighbor's the Yamadas,
and my favorite of his, Only Yesterday. Only Yesterday is an adaptation of a manga of the
same name. However, since the manga is really just a bunch of vignettes of the fifth-grade taiko,
Takahata originally had trouble finding an angle to tell a proper narrative.
He then decided to create a framing device where the older taiko travels to the countryside and
falls for Toshio in order to connect the events of her childhood together. Only Yesterday was
released in 1991, and it was a surprise hit in Japan, becoming the highest-grossing movie of the
year. But for about 25 years, the film was seldom seen by western audiences. This was due to the
fact that Disney had acquired the distribution rights but had an issue with a number of scenes
that referenced menstruation and wanted them removed. Disney had tried to cut out those scenes,
but Ghibli had a clause in their contract that forbid Disney from removing anything,
so the film went unseen. That is until GKids acquired the rights just a few years ago,
and even recorded a new dub that included Daisy Ridley and Dev Patel. And now that
it's widely available, I think everyone who loves Ghibli should really check out this lovely film.
Only Yesterday tells the story of a young woman named Taiko, a 27-year-old career woman living
in Tokyo. She gets 10 days off of her boring office job and decides to use that time to
pick safflowers in the countryside. While making her way out there, memories of her
5th grade self flood back to her. She begins to reminisce on her youth while enjoying her vacation,
which includes possibly falling for a nice young man named Toshio, who works on the farm.
What really struck me in the beginning of this film was the editing,
how the film without warning cuts from present to Taiko's past. I think it really reflects how
our brains quickly jump from one moment to the next, and how memories can sometimes rush into
our heads without warning. I think this is further helped by the voiceover she gives,
which allows us to understand her train of thought and how memories flow from past to present.
What's so wonderful about these memories are how specific they feel.
These moments are painfully ordinary, but that's what gives them so much life.
There was a clear emphasis on making Taiko and her family as average as possible,
at least for the time period in the film, to give a sense of relatability. That anyone could have
had these memories. I think we can all relate to having very random and specific memories
ingrained in our brains from our childhood. Things we hold onto tightly, even though others
might have completely forgotten. Things that go on to define us in some way. I love how these
memories feel that way. Taiko's first memory that comes back to her from the year 1966
was in the summer when she desperately wanted to go on vacation, something she rarely did as a
child. As the youngest of three girls, she was constantly ignored or disregarded. As she hears
about all her friends' plans to go to the countryside, the same one her older self is
currently going on, she tries to convince her mom to take her, but to no avail. She does,
however, get to take a trip to the hot springs, and jumps at the opportunity. You can see how
she embraces every moment so openly. Her other memories feel equally random, yet incredibly
relatable and distinct. The second story we see is of her and her family trying pineapple for the
first time, a rare fruit in Japan, at least at the time. I won't spoil all of it, but I really
love this scene, and the attention to detail put into it. I think it's so adorable how the whole
family gathers to try the pineapple, and treats it as a rare occasion. This is exactly the type
memory a child would remember and latch onto. Takahata does such a great job of building up the
world of the time, to feel truly alive. I feel like I have such a stronger grasp of the culture
of 1966 Japan now, spending a lot of time with the school kids' help, as we get a real look at the
youth of the time, seeing how they acted, what they talked about, and what mattered to them.
We see Taiko's first crush, baseball games, school plays, teasing on the playground,
all the little things. The interaction between her and her crush is so adorable and wholesome,
a memory that makes Taiko over a decade later understandably giddy. I think one of the most
interesting stories from the first part of the film has to be where the girls in Taiko's class
start getting their periods. I remember this time in my own elementary school, when the girls started
maturing a little earlier than the boys, and us guys not understanding what they were talking about,
and young boys can be so dumb and cruel. Taiko, afraid of boys teasing her for having a period,
even though she hasn't had one yet, tries all she can to avoid them.
This was the plot line that Disney tried to cut out, and I'm glad it was able to stay in the film,
because it's such a distinct and important part of a girl growing up, and to skim over that would
be to ignore a defining part of a girl's youth. The emotions she's feeling are so genuine.
Quickly, I'd like to touch on the voiceover. I know voiceover can be a divisive topic amongst
the film community, but I personally am a fan when done effectively. A good narrator can
really elevate a film. And here, what I love, at least on the dub of Only Yesterday,
is that Taiko has so much love and warmth for her 5th grade memories, even though they are
not all happy memories. There's a wisdom and understanding to the stories she's telling.
She's able to separate the version of herself she used to be from the version she is. Taiko
refuses to let us pity her. Instead, she wants us to enjoy these memories for what they are,
and how they shaped her. There's a lovely juxtaposition of Taiko speaking so fondly of
her memories, where we see her as a moody little girl. The film has a very interesting pace,
as we spend the first 40 minutes mostly in flashback, with the occasional cut back to present
to see how far Taiko is to the countryside. But once she gets there, the film shifts to
her current perspective for much longer. We really get to see how much she's changed,
and also how those memories have shaped the kind-hearted woman at the center of the film.
This is also when we meet Toshio, a farmer in the area, and her love interest for the film.
He's a very passionate character, who cares deeply about farming and nature,
more specifically organic farming. He'll randomly go into these little spiels about farming that
Taiko seems to find pretty charming. The middle of the film actually spends a good deal of time
showing us the farming Taiko came there to do. We see not only the beauty of nature, but the
tedious hard work these farmers put in. And it doesn't look easy, but if it's something you care
about, it seems deeply rewarding. I think now would be a good time to discuss some of the really
wonderful cinematic tools Takahata uses in the film, most notably how great the animation is.
I think the most distinctive thing he does is the way he differentiates flashback from reality.
A lot of the flashback scenes have a much more distinctive watercolor backdrop,
with parts of them not fully colored in. This visual choice and use of negative space really
helps elicit the feeling of a memory, as we're not fully able to remember it exactly as it was.
Taika can't get every detail, but we have enough to understand the memory we're seeing.
We also get some surreal moments of animation in her flashback,
like when she starts floating in space after talking to her crush. This is beautifully
juxtaposed with the much deeper colors we see in the present, to show how things truly are.
The countryside is so beautifully animated here, and there is so much care and passion
clearly at work. The greens and yellows really pop off the screen. There's also something I
didn't realize until I started doing research for the film, but on the DVD commentary,
Takahata talks about how the characters have much more realistic facial features,
which is not common in Japanese animation at the time. This was due to the dialogue being
recorded first, not after the animation was completed, which was typical in Japan.
Because of this, the animators were able to fit the animation to the spoken dialogue.
Takahata also had the voice actors record some of their lines together,
using the footage of their performance as a guide for the design and animation.
However, a really lovely touch Takahata made was that Taiko's childhood scenes were animated before
the voice recordings, in a traditional way, in order to give a subtle contrast between the
anime style of her past and present. Just a smart and subtle little distinction.
Okay, so real quick, I actually had the video almost completely done,
until I realized there was a behind-the-scenes documentary about the making of the film
on the Blu-ray, and had to watch it. There's so much great stuff in there,
some of which I've already talked about, like the voice recording process, but I thought I'd
quickly go over some of my favorite moments. But if you like the video and or the movie,
or frankly any Ghibli movie, I highly recommend watching it, because it's really fun and insightful.
Okay, so to start, Miyazaki was a producer and heavily involved in the film. He never really
looked at sales or scripts, trusting Takahata. For the film, he was more involved in making
sure people met deadlines, that they didn't go over budget, and dealing with producers to make
sure that the film was able to stay in the truest form. Miyazaki originally wanted to direct it,
but couldn't crack it, and is quoted saying he believed Takahata was the only person who
can make this movie. It was really interesting seeing the whole assembly process of an animated
film, how there are so many complicated and tedious steps that it takes for every little
aspect of the film. It really makes you appreciate animation on a whole new level,
and the talent everyone is bringing to the table. One artist spent a whole year just drawing flowers.
Also, very interesting to see what a director like Miyazaki does when he isn't directing,
that these artists have so many responsibilities.
It was also really nice to see the relationship between Miyazaki and Takahata on screen.
I know we're used to seeing Miyazaki portrayed as this tortured artist who is always miserable,
but at least here he is cheery and joyful. He has so much love and enthusiasm for the work,
and just wants to make the best movie possible. There's a lovely scene of him explaining to new
artists how they need to observe human behavior in order to draw, and it's really great. There's
also a scene of him dancing at the wrap party that's amazing. Takahata speaks very highly of
Miyazaki, and talks about how much he appreciates him and how they work off each other so well,
because they both are talented at different things, even if they also fight
often over creative differences. Takahata seems to be a very dedicated and caring artist.
I loved that he took a chunk of his crew to the actual farmlands to see the safflower fields they
were portraying, because there needed to be a level of authenticity. The attention to detail
for everything was something to behold. There were a few other little things I loved,
like how the narrator talked about how Miyazaki is a genius and legend for films like Nausicaa
and Totoro, and like, he's not wrong, but it's very funny to have that in a documentary you're
financing for your own company and movie. Also, watching some of the animators fall asleep at the
first screening was very funny. Alright, back to the video. The film is also quietly rich with
themes, most notably about a modern woman's place in society and nature versus city life.
As we see from her flashbacks, Taika was a strong-willed and impassioned young girl,
but her strict father, siblings who look down on her, loneliness, struggles with school,
and other various things shape the more isolated woman in the present. That doesn't mean she's a
bitter person. Quite the contrary. She's rather sweet and kind. We see how even though she kept
some of her stubbornness, she uses it towards things she's passionate about, like working a
job independently and finally being able to farm in the countryside, something she wasn't allowed
to do in her youth. A small touch I love is how she mentions talking to her sisters, and these
memories we see. It's a sweet touch to show that even though they fight and bicker in the film,
they've all matured to be close to one another and look back fondly at their respected youths.
In a little pamphlet that comes with the blu-ray, Takahata talks about how despite
being a well-adjusted young woman, Taiko struggles with her own self-identity. It was a very conscious
choice by Takahata for her to go to the countryside so that she can be one with
nature again, and use that time away from her busy life to find herself. He says,
And though we see both the beauty and the genuine hard work it takes to maintain that,
Ghibli as a whole is no stranger to stories about the environment. Almost every movie they make
thematically ties into preserving nature in one way or another, and here the angle Takahata takes
is very effective in showing us the mindset of our protagonist. It's clearly something Takahata
wanted in the forefront of the film, but it's never overbearing. He allows Taiko and her story
The second half of the film is intercut between more memories of her youth and Taiko and Toshio
on the countryside. The conversations they have with one another are a joy to watch.
It's not a terribly complicated film, but it really is so sweet. It's truly a lovely little
slice of life that elicits such a strong sense of nostalgia and benefits from its simplicity.
If I had any qualms about the film, I think it would be that I never fully bought Taiko
and Toshio's relationship. It's not a deal breaker or anything, and they clearly have a
strong connection, especially when talking about farming. But in terms of chemistry,
I don't think it was handled as well as it could have been. But I will say though,
the ending is beautiful. When the credits roll and that song starts to play, absolutely beautiful
stuff. Only Yesterday is a really special film that's able to take the mundane and show how
much beauty can be mined from it, and that we should appreciate the ordinary things in our life.
I think everyone should watch this movie, especially fans of Ghibli.
I really hope you guys watch and enjoy it.
Hey guys, I hope you enjoyed the video. If you did, I'd love it if you could like and subscribe.
It goes a long way. If you've seen Only Yesterday, let me know what you think of it down below.
And if there's another movie you'd like me to discuss, leave that down below too.
See you next time, guys. Thanks.
