Deploy24, Plenary 3: Grid Technologies & Virtual Power Plants

U.S. Department of Energy
60 followers
1 Video View·Dec 31, 2024
all right thanks so much everyone for
coming out uh as you might have heard
there are three Engineers here on the
stage so we are going to nerd out
heavily which is what I know you all
came to talk about no um I think one of
you know we've had a lot of
conversations over the last couple of
days and we're going to continue to have
lots of conversations about increased
low growth doesn't matter where the
growth is coming from can be from
electrification data centers um and
there are lots of great Solutions my
office works on a ton of solutions of
long-term transmission uh building which
we absolutely need to do but then we
also have to take advantage of our
existing assets as much as possible in
order to squeeze out every last bit and
both of you have been at the tip of the
sphere really looking at different ways
to do that um be it through you know
certainly through virtual power plants
and I think we'll talk about that in a
lot more depth here and taking advantage
of the fact that there are so many new
Assets in terms of batteries that people
have in their homes everyone I know
seems to have a battery in their home my
father-in-law Thanksgiving asked us to
start pricing them out for everybody in
the family so we can figure out where
they go good idea um and and so to me I
think about it as maximizing efficiency
that's my favorite uh term of art here
and I know that you're both thinking
about that as well in order order to
make sure that you're not just um
utilizing everything properly from a
nice engineering perspective but really
thinking about how that affects
consumers uh along the way as well so
I'll pass it to you first Rory on what
is New York thinking about moving
forward you you're in this place where
you have tons of growth happening
there's not as much space necessarily to
continue to physically grow different
parts of the grid I'm from Massachusetts
so that is a common problem that we have
here as well um but but you're thinking
creatively about how how we can get
through the next couple of years and I
think there's a lot that the folks here
can learn from that so you know clearly
we have a lot going on in New York and
part of it is we need to build more
generation more assets and we have plans
and policies and place to do that um
aligned with our overarching policy for
a clean energy future and Emissions free
resources so those are all well underway
through a variety of proceedings where
we're either developing renewable energy
or identifying the emissions free
technologies that are dispatchable that
are going to help meet those periods
where we need more energy and renewable
isn't available so all of that is
happening right now um what's also
happening is the other side of the
conversation which I think we're all
here to talk about today the the virtual
power plant the harnessing the actions
of individuals consumers businesses
residents uh commercial entities and
seeing how we can make them a part of
the health and well-being of the grid as
a whole and we we talk about virtual
power plants either using less energy or
or producing energy but I'm thinking
about this in the context of the state
itself becoming a virtual power plant
every single meter creates an
opportunity for engagement with a
consumer in a way that can help the grid
manage the increasing intermittency from
renewable energy and ultimately lower
costs not just at the individual level
but at the aggregate level both for
energy at the time it's being used but
also in terms of the need to build out
the grid to be bigger larger and more
robust um so all of these things are
underway and part of our thinking in New
York state U much of this started by
some of my predecessors Audrey zman
through the reforming the energy Vision
effort which I think many of you are
probably familiar with uh but much of
what we're doing today is a continuation
of that and an expansion um and it's all
enabled by cheaper Technologies better
communication and the availability of
smart meters throughout the state so I
see a a lot of potential for us to be
able to manage the Grid in these new
ways excellent and I think you know
building off of that I know Patty you
had an very exciting announcement
earlier today where I think you're
trying to implement some of those very
specific activities especially around
vpps with our friends over at Epi
through the Mercury Consortium and we'd
love to hear a little bit more about
that yeah let's break some news here at
24 yeah as we speak uh over in the UK
uh an announcement is being made with
EPI and a company called Kraken and
kraken's CEO Omar o um orad is here in
the audience somewhere uh Kraken um is
working with Epi to create um a a
platform where we can have
interoperability much like Bluetooth
back in the day became an open standard
we need that for uh electrically
communicating devices so whether it's
heat pumps or thermostats or uh EVs and
all integrating to these smart meters
and a distributed Energy Future we need
open uh uh resourced interoperability
and so we're announcing a major
Consortium today both in the UK and then
here at deploy 24 uh about the potential
for us to come together and create that
open standard so we're very excited
about what that what that enables for a
distributed connected digital grid of
the future so let's dig into that just
briefly because I think that open
standardization is something that folks
don't necessarily understand as well uh
and and maybe if you just want to talk a
little bit about what the benefits are
because sometimes we talk about
standards as being overarching and more
difficult to meet but in this case it's
really opening up for more technology to
enter yeah so compare it to um uh
Bluetooth for all of our devices we can
buy a headset from any manufacturer I
have a little portable speaker in my
office that I like to connect to my
phone all of these Bluetooth enabled
devices uh in all parts of our lives are
possible because there's an open
bluetooth standard so similarly in this
way we can have open standard
interoperability of these uh digital uh
electric devices so imagine this uh a
new um in fact we had a situation like
this uh we had a new sub subdivision
being built and it was going to be all
electric new subdivision of
homes if all of those devices can
communicate to each other we can use a
lot less energy so for example
uninterrupted our distribution engineers
and our building codes all required the
entire panel for every residence and
then the grid that supported it to be
built for the maximum day with every
device on at its full power because we
can't control it and so you have to
build for the peak plus 18
22% every house in that case was going
to require a 400 amp panel well we
interview Ved and said wait if we have
Smart panels and we have wirelessly
communicating electric devices that can
manage what load comes on in an interop
interoperable way then all the panels
actually became 200 amp panels those 200
amp panels reduced the energy Peak
energy demand for that entire
subdivision by
50% when you're building new you've got
to build smarter and so having Open
Standards like that would enable any
Appliance in this case you have to buy
specialized appliances to make sure
everything is interoperable but when
every Appliance is enabled when every
device is enabled with an open standard
then every new construction project can
be uh reduced in half and any new
retrofit can be enabled much more
affordably it's a huge opportunity for
the industry and really for the world to
decarbonize at a lower societal cost and
that sounds so much easier than trying
to convince my father to not do laundry
at 600 p.m. amen in the middle of the
winter on a Thursday we've had that
conversation many I am sure you have and
so I think in in interweaved with this
conversation right sometimes we talk
about these all in a silo we say vpps
are great but I think talking about why
vpps are great in relationship to all
the other issues that we're facing right
for both of you you're you're looking at
decarbonization but you're also looking
at significant load growth and so by
cutting that by 50% makes a huge
difference that's one less peaking plant
that we might have to build that's one
one less um asset that we have on the
grid that we have to figure out long
term and Rory talk a little bit about
what that means for consumers because I
think there's a lot of rate pressures
happening at at this moment in time as
folks are seeing seeing costs go up in a
lot of different areas of their lives
they're very price sensitive uh when it
comes to electricity absolutely and I
mean energy is the lifeblood of our
society so the more affordable we can
make it the more robust our economy can
become
um so we're always paying attention to
the costs of any measure that we
Implement and any measure we can
Implement that can cap or lower cost is
something we aggressively try to pursue
um so we look at vpps we have a a
program currently underway in New York
uh bring your own thermostat we have
about 100 megaw of load uh flexibility
as a result of this program where we
simply manage the air conditioners of
many homes a couple hundred, homes
plusus 4° and that provides us with a
lot of flexibility and we're just at the
very beginning of that imagine expanding
that to include EVs and managing their
charging um washing machine washers
dryers dishwashers and other appliances
in the home so to the point you're
making about the the ability for this
interoperability to happen I I think
it's critically important for being able
to integrate into the grid to give
consumers the ability to manage their
energy in a way where they can lower
their costs and also help lower the cost
for maintaining and operating and
building out a bigger grid and this is
incredibly important and I I can speak
to my own personal frustrations during
the pandemic my fridge broke I bought a
new one I had to download a very
specific app to get that fridge to do
demand response um very different app
than the app I had for my air
conditioner which was different from
what I had for other appliances so that
created an ecosystem of trouble which
didn't make sense for my family to
engage in and I do this for a living so
go figure now if it's hard for me to do
it I can only imagine how difficult it
is for the average consumer which is why
I'm so excited uh about what's going to
be happening in uh the UK next few days
yeah yeah that that automation I think
is key for consumers right no one
necessarily thinks about their
electrical panel my husband excluded but
um and you want to make sure that
they're not thinking about it all the
time but it can have such an enormous
impact for the system as a whole and I
think that's what it comes back to is we
can try and make consumers think about
their electric use regularly but it's
just not going to happen unless you have
an advanced degree in all this like
everybody sitting in in this room from
all the experience that we've had Maria
let me put a couple numbers to this so
um in California uh and at in PG service
area we have a summer peak of 20 gaw our
winter Peak is 10 gaw and so today
uninterrupted we have a load forecast
that our demand is going to double if we
convert that to 40 gaw that will be
extraordinarily expensive it's not just
for the generation resources every
conductor every Transformer every Pole
every substation is all designed for
that Peak demand so today what we're
working on is making sure that we can
double that load and at the same time
only increase our Peak by
133% so 100% increase in base load 133%
increase in Peak and we're going to do
that with a much more Dynamic
intelligent grid management system we've
implemented a distributed energy
resource management system at pg& that
will help us connect all these disc
connected today devices and optimize
their usage you know you talked about
how we're all Engineers I'm an
Industrial Engineer this is like the era
of indust this is our our grand
Awakening the industrial engineers get
to reimagine the grid that we can
optimize supply and demand for the first
time ever just think about the cost
savings for customers and it's Savings
in two ways one we're not building all
that extra stuff but two we're fully
utilizing the existing assets that we
have therefore the unit cost of energy
goes down I there's a poster hanging in
our offices back from the 30s and 40s
and it
says um exciting news PG is lowering
prices again I'm like I want that poster
back we're going to lower prices again
because just like we did back in the day
we had excess energy during the daytime
the electric grid was built originally
for lighting all of a sudden we have all
these power generation resources in the
daytime that were underutilized so what
did we do electric street cars and then
appliances and then Motors and then
rural electrification we fully utilized
that grid and the entire time unit cost
of energy was going down rates were
going down we actually have the
opportunity to go back in the future and
do it again today because of data
centers because of EVS which are the
best of all because they're so Dynamic
and flexible and and uh electrification
generally we can decarbonize the economy
and lower unit cost of electricity while
we do it as long as we don't just add to
the peak so the whole commitment to
Virtual power plants the whole
commitment to a dynamic digital energy
grid is fundamental to actually enabling
decarbonizing of the economy amazing
that we could end right there but we
have five more minutes and I would be
remiss if I didn't ask when you have a
commissioner and a utility sitting here
that don't aren't regulated and related
to each other what do you think that the
other entity could continue to be doing
to better enable uh more of this
technology well I'll say
this the relationship is there and it's
always going to be there and we're going
to have to work together um with
utilities throughout the state to
achieve this goal there's just no other
way to do this and so we want to engage
we want to be trans arent and we want
equivalent transparency back um but it's
going to require some degree of UNC
discomfort um we're doing things in a
different way uh but I think when you
look at the history to your point you
look at the history of the grid the grid
is not a static monolith it's been
changing every decade
forever and this next evolution is
something I think we can do hand inand
with our Utility Partners uh as long as
we get the incentives right up and down
the value chain we have to make sure
consumers are in a position to take
advantage of what we're doing businesses
industry Etc we need to ensure that we
can work with the utilities to do
planning uh proactively rather than
reactively because to be frank someone
can go out and buy as many EVS as they
want and connect them to the grid but is
the grid going to be capable of
providing that service at that time uh
so we need to be able to look ahead and
understand how do we change the plans
that we've had in place for 20 30 40 50
years and be prepared for this new
future um where people are going to be
demanding things that the grid is not
yet provided uh so a lot of that is work
that we have ongoing we have dozens of
proceedings which I will spare you the
burden of listing um but this is
something the commission is looking at
constantly and through these various
proceedings we establish a planning
process through which we try to address
these various issues and work with the
utilities to find Solutions ahead of
their becoming a problem because at the
end of the day we want to be good
economic Regulators we want to ensure
that we are supporting the economic
development the state and not a
hindrance through slow deployment of
policy yeah so I would say um ditto on
you know we have to work together and I
have infinite respect for my Regulators
they have a very challenging job there
are a lot of voices as we like to say we
regulate out loud in California there's
a a lot that happens in a regulatory
proceeding and uh uh our uh CPU works
very hard to be fair and transparent and
and be that economic regulator I think
for all of us having more visibility
into the future and having courage to
invest in the future because if we're
too late we derail the electrification
strategy so we have to build it in
advance now the the good news is there's
more and more visibility to that demand
and that new increased demand so another
uh plug for uh Epi the Electric Power
Research Institute uh we have a a
consortion calls called e to scale and
Eevee to scale includes the large uh
Fleet operators it includes the
utilities it includes some Commissioners
in fact the one of the Michigan uh
Commissioners is on in the Consortium
and on the executive committee and we we
need to have better forecasting of where
that load is coming and so the big Fleet
operators who want to put a distribution
center and have an entire fleet of
electric vehicles that can be 50 to 100
megawatts of new load can show up in a
day are providing their forecasts and
their plans so that our commissioners
can have more confidence that the
forecast is not just our forecast as the
utility but it is in fact the forecast
of the customers and so where more and
more we can create transparency to those
forecasts and do planning together the
better we can be prepared uh for that
future and make sure that we're there
when it comes but I I'll just give you
an example of a case where uh Tesla
wanted to put in a supercharger they
wanted 3.8 megaw in one location for a
Supercharger and my distribution
Engineers did their normal thing and we
told Tesla you can have your
supercharger in four years from now
which as you might imagine Tesla's not
very patient and they did not like that
answer but the reality was my
distribution Engineers only had a tool
that said what is Peak Plus
18% and if you can't serve that you
can't serve it well when we gave them
new tools where they could see which
hours of which days can they serve 3.8
megawatt 360 days a year we could serve
3.8 megawatts with no incremental
investment so we could enable that new
load but then on those five days our new
derms distributed energy resource
management system actually has control
so the the grid operators don't have to
worry that we have to count on someone
to take action we actually can control
that load on those days and in four
years they can have 3.8 megawatts
whenever they want it but for now they
can still add that new demand to the
grid and serve electric vehicles so the
digital tools that enable virtual power
plants that enable digital uh
optimization and management of the grid
so that we can both have reliable energy
but lower cost energy those tools and
and equipment and technology is now
available in commercial ially accessible
so we can actually do these things that
we've been dreaming about for years and
years so that's a perfect way to end to
say that we're really grateful to all of
you that have applied for grip Awards
here out of the grid deployment office
many of you who are uh working very
closely with both your regulators and
your utilities and I hope that you
continue to do that moving forward
because I think the partnership aspect
is so important so I want to thank these
two Visionary leaders who are just
amazing creative thinkers for being here
with us today to share some of their
insights on on the future of the grid
and in particular how they're thinking
about using our existing assets so thank
you so much for being here and
appreciate your time thank you Marina
thanks Rory
