Pathways to Commercial Liftoff: Virtual Power Plants Update

U.S. Department of Energy
60 followers
Jan 16, 2025
[Music]
good morning
everybody looks like we've got a a great
group with us this morning um sorry we
got a little bit of a late start there a
few technical difficulties on our end um
but we can just go ahead and kick this
right off so I am clearly not Vanessa
Chan who has promised to introduce but
she is finishing up what may be your
final meeting with the secretary this
morning I think it's going over a little
bit so uh I am her principal Deputy in
the office of Technology Transitions and
a real privilege to kick this webinar
off with the one and only Shaw uh
director of our loan programs office so
and I will do a little bit of a
opening uh quick discussion and then get
we'll we'll hand this off to the authors
of the virtual power plant report to
talk through uh a really exciting
release here that we're happy to be
talking to about this morning um so
thank you again for joining us um uh
we're going to dive into the insights
from Dewey's recently published liftoff
report on Virtual power plant vpps as
we'll refer to them uh throughout uh and
this is the uh first uh big 2025 update
that we're here to talk to you about um
which is exciting it builds on the VPP
liftoff report published in September of
2023 and includes new data on how vpps
are helping address uh the mounting
challenges that power grid that the
power grid faces nationally this update
also highlights the incredible progress
that has occupied uh that has occurred
since the initial report was published
with information on over 75 real world
examples of VPP deployments and VPP
enabling actions and information on over
60 new VPP resources from doe and the
broader industry so this liftoff update
is part of the Doe's ongoing Pathways to
commercial liftoff initiative focusing
on enhancing collaboration between the
public and private sectors to advance
commercialization of critical Energy
Solutions uh huge datadriven effort and
it starts with deep engagement with the
private sector and that involves experts
from all of due the National Labs uh to
develop a common fact base the goal is
to get everyone industry investors
inventors Academia government at all
levels on the same page so that we can
catalyze and accelerate the clean energy
transition this perspective underscores
du's vision of a private sector-led
government enabled energy transition uh
the liftoff reports are designed to be
dynamic evolving documents to reflect
new insights from industry experts and
shifts in the commercialization
landscape this 2025 VPP update is an
example of how we're building on the
original 23 liftoff report to share the
latest Market insights and resources all
liftoff reports are accessible at lf.
energy.gov where you can also find
recordings of our past webinars this
2025 BPP update is coming at a critical
time as big shifts are happening across
the Grid in particular demand growth
from data center development and AI a
surge in manufacturing Investments with
over 900 new and expanded manufacturing
facilities announced as of December 2024
and electrification of cars and
buildings meeting these Growing Power
demands while continuing to provide
reliable and affordable power to
American households is critical so with
that uh want to bring you into
this here uh can you provide a bit more
color on these challenges and how vpps
can help address them to advance a
reliable affordable and resilient Energy
Future thanks
Marcos since the original VPP liftoff
report was published the near-term
pressures on the US electricity grid
have intensified Peak demand is is
growing rapidly after two decades of
flat electricity demand Peak demand is
expected to increase from about 800 gaw
in 20124 to around 900 gaws by 2030
driven in large part by data center
development reshoring American
manufacturing and electrification of
transportation and
heating now demand growth is a good
thing it reflects Economic Development
and progress but rapid growth and
electricity demand requires solutions
that can be deployed rapidly recent
history suggests that it can take years
sometimes a decade to build large
utility grid scale assets and the demand
hitting the grid does not want to wait
at the same time the utility investments
into outdated approaches to Growing
distribution grid capacity have led to
double- digigit rate increases in
everyday citizens meanwhile extreme
weather events are placing extraordinary
pressure on Aging grid leading to power
outages for communities all over the
country and I just want to to take a
moment here to recognize the devastation
that communities in Southern California
are facing the midst of severe wildfires
and convey my gratitude to the people
and organizations that are supporting
these communities through this difficult
time these near-term pressures on the
grid require proven solutions that can
be deployed rapidly and at scale this is
where virtual power plants come in
Virtual power plants are solutions that
can be deployed in less than 6 months to
maximize the use and value of our
existing grid infrastructure at
dramatically lower cost to rate payers
and ensure a reliable resilient and
secure grid for all Americans vpps
provide valuable Peak shaving benefits
to meet Rising Peak demand because they
can be deployed to do this in less than
six months they can accelerate the
interconnection of New Economic
Development opportunities instead of
making them wait up to 3 to four years
because they shift power demand from
peak hour to low demand hours they
increase grid utilization and the value
of these existing assets that Americans
have already paid for the business's
usual approach that worked in a world
without demand growth and extreme
weather won't work going forward
utilities Regulators policy makers and
Industry Partners all have a role to
play to adopt an innovation mindset to
accelerate the deployment of virtual
power plants and serve the near-term
needs of American citizens
thanks Sher and and we're starting to
see industry leaders really step up here
this update highlights over 75 case
studies of grid stakeholders taking
action for example energy NRG energy and
renew home recently announced plans to
launch a 1 gwatt VPP in Texas by 2035
equivalent to roughly a dozen gas fired
peer plants and doing this by leveraging
flexible demand from Smart thermostats
this announcement comes just months
after the electricity reliability
Council of Texas or urot revised its
2030 load growth forecast to 148 gws an
increase of 40 gws from last year's
forecasts and there are many other
examples I could mention but we still
need to see broader industry adoption at
all levels to address the challenges
slowing down VPP adoption today in
action is too expensive enhancing the
Grid in the near term is critical to
America's economic growth and to our
ability to retain and strengthen our
Global Leadership at the due we have a
lot of work underway both within our
offices jiggers vpps and across the
agency uh and with our external Partners
to enable VPP deployment uh and and J I
want to come back to you with another
question here can you share just a
glimpse of the programs uh I know there
are 60 or more of them U mentioned in
this report that have been underway or
newly established by Doe and our
collaborators to accelerate VPP liftoff
totally Marcos the doe and its partners
are at the Forefront of fostering an
ecosystem that not only supports but
accelerates the adoption and and
integration of vpps into our Energy
System At Doe we're taking a wraparound
approach to reach stakeholders all
around the ecosystem to reach regulators
and state policy makers our Energy
Efficiency and renewable energy office
and office of electricity have newly
enhanced technical assistance programs
which can help Regulators understand how
to integrate de and virtual power plants
into distribution and bulk power system
operations in their specific grid
context and Regulatory Frameworks often
to implement for quar
2222 to reach utilities VPP companies
and consumers thanks to the bipartisan
infrastructure law and inflation
reduction act doe has been supporting
with significant financial support as
well the office of clean energy
demonstrations selected three projects
including Dominion energies project in
Virginia to coordinate distributed
energy resources with controls software
this provides realtime safe reliable and
affordable grid support and capacity
without costly grid upgrades the grid
deployment office selected projects
including the Public Service Company of
New Mexico's project to establish a VPP
this program will provide operators
visibility and control over localized
grid constraints to help improve service
enhance grid stability and reduce
electricity bills
and when you think about what the loan
programs office is doing to provide for
large scale vpps across the country uh
we really have been at the Forefront of
that work in December we announced our
largest loan ever of $15 billion to a
Pacific Gas Electric Company a natural
gas and electric utility in California
which includes funding for battery
storage transmission upgrades and
virtual power plants throughout PG's
service area among our utility
applicants we are seeing more and more
plans for VPP enabling Investments our
funding is also providing financial
support to developers of distributed
energy resources who are deploying VPP
ready devices for example in December we
announced a conditional commitment to
Nostromo energy to deploy and aggregate
193 cold thermal energy storage
installations at commercial buildings
across California basically making ice
off peak and then blowing air over it on
Peak to cool
buildings we are and also announcing a
conditional commitment to Sun wealth to
deploy up to a thousand solar systems
and battery energy storage systems
across 27 States these systems can be
aggregated into virtual power plants to
benefit communities by lowering utility
bills and increasing energy
resilience the momentum for vpps isn't
defined just to doe external
organizations are playing a pivotal role
in facilitating a broader understanding
and a adoption of vpps across the energy
sector for instance nuk the National
Association of regulatory utility
Commissioners and nazio the National
Association of State energy officials
published a guide book on the
fundamentals of aggregated distributed
energy resources just a couple of months
ago this is part of their de integration
and and compensation curriculum an
initiative that provides regulators and
state energy officials with the
Practical guides to VPP grid Services
valuation options approaches to
compensation and detailed case studies
of real vpps and the processes States
followed to develop these programs also
in the bipartisan infrastructure law and
inflation reduction act there were tax
credits to reduce the cost of
distributed energy resources for
consumers through programs such as home
Energy rebates and
weatherization Assistance programs
administered by our state and local
programs similarly rmi's virtual power
plant partnership or vp3 has made
significant contributions in developing
utility VPP case studies through their
VPP flip book analyzing the emissions
reductions benefits of vpps publishing
policy principles and more a nonprofit
published a model tariff and model
legislation to support state Regulators
policy makers and Utilities in
implementing VPP supportive regulatory
mechanisms after this Gap was identified
in the 2023 VPP lift off report the
topics the topics that vpps uh cover are
vast and the breath of organizations and
programs working on accelerating
adoption reflects
that yeah thank you uh and and
wow it's there's so much going on both
at due and in the broader ecosystem uh
really impressive uh and really exciting
uh and and and therefore extremely
relevant for us to be updating this this
VPP liftoff report now um I know seeing
in the in the chat there's some
questions about that we will soon be
handing it off some of the experts who
help draft the report run through some
slides um just uh closing out on a few
more points here uh the National Labs
are are also providing analytics that
are foundational to to this ecosystem um
for example the market and Retail rate
knowhow of the energy transition or
Market initiative is studying vpps
including developing a publicly
available inventory publishing 30
strategies to simplify VPP enrollment
and sharing the key barriers and
solution is to FK order 2222 compliance
um all this progress reflects a couple
broader Trends in the VPP Market the for
shadow what's to come first industry
acceptance that's what it's all about
it's clear that utilities are embracing
bpps bpps are becoming integral to how
we run our Distribution Systems in some
parts of the country and there are some
Innovative models of how this can happen
such as Green Mountain poers partnership
with Tesla which allows customers to
lease batteries providing customers of
backup power option and the utility a
critical resource to shift and shape
demand especially in times of peak load
uh second continued interest in
distributed energy resources individual
households and businesses continue to
install distributed energy resources for
their own use and are increasingly
recognizing their secondary use to help
the grid and they're getting paid for it
according to Wood McKenzie de capacity
is expected to grow by 217 GW in the
next 5 years across de types
um tapping into these resources that are
already on the grid or expected to be
deployed is just common sense there's
definitely more work to be done to
increase access to those de utilities
are using Innovative Financial
mechanisms to make de more affordable
one example is Duke Energy which is
offering customers lowcost financing
options for heat pumps so their improve
and save program we can expect to see
more and more of that finally more
standardization efforts in targeted
areas Um this can reduce complexity and
cost of implementation increase
reliability of performance and ensure
cyber secure systems incredibly
important for example Electric Power
Research uh Institute ERI and Kraken are
just uh about to announ of just
announced the Mercury Consortium which
rationalizes and increases adoption of
standards for flexible demand Services
devices rather flexible demand devices
to improve Communications between VPP
platforms and de
it's incredible to see the breadth of
activity happening in this market from
the deployments in Industry to the loans
that lpo has provided to the programs
and initiatives e and and many other
offices uh uh are leading around the
building here at due it's clear that
action in the BPP space is accelerating
uh and there's more work to be done um
thank you uh for such an
insightful discussion and I'm thrilled
uh to be introducing Sali razdan um who
was until very recently uh in the loan
programs office and just hopped over to
our uh office of Technology transitions
team but we're all one big team here at
due um but grateful for that onramp
Jinger uh sonali is going to
share some insights from the liftoff VPP
from the VPP liftoff report gathered
from interviewing over a 100 industry
stakeholders and dozens of due experts
her presentation promises to spark
further Dialogue on scaling at vpps for
a reliable affordable and resilient
Energy Future uh Sali take it
away yeah thanks so much Marcos and
thank you for such an insightful
start to this webinar um hello everyone
my name is sonali rasdan I'm a senior
advisor with the loan programs office
and the office of Technology transitions
At Doe and I'm super excited to be
speaking to you all about virtual power
plants today while I do recognize that
it's worthwhile to read all 100 pages of
the report that we just released um I'll
use the next 25 minutes or or so to
share the major highlights and I'm glad
to hear that a lot of you want to see
slides because we have a lot of slides
that we're going to review over the next
25 to 30 minutes um really talking about
the criticality of virtual power plants
especially given the near-term grid
pressures that and Marcos
mentioned earlier sharing real vvp
deployments that are providing real
benefits to the grid and to communities
um and these proven Solutions can be
adopted and adapted Nationwide to
accelerate flip off so let's dive in as
we mentioned earlier in the discussion
the near-term pressures on the US
electric grid have intensified and this
primarily comes down to a couple of
different factors first rapid growth in
electricity demand is impacting
reliability because the grid needs to be
able to balance supply and demand
traditionally this meant having enough
Supply to meet rapidly growing
demand second affordability growing
Capital invest ments especially on the
transmission and distribution grids are
placing upward pressure on customer
costs this is while one in4 households
are already struggling to pay their
energy bills and finally resilience
increasingly common extreme weather
events are impacting resilience causing
power outages for households and
businesses across the country the
culmination of these challenges
necessitate historic Investments to
shore up our electric grid cost that may
fall on rate payers already burdened by
Rising energy bills so recognizing each
of these great pressures what do the
data actually tell us well starting with
grid reliability Peak demand is growing
and it's growing faster than we're able
to
anticipate on this page you'll see
projections for us summer peak hour
Demand by year between 2023 and
2030 peak hour demand is the maximum
point in time demand that the grid must
serve
from 2024 to 2030 according to Nerf's
latest projections from December of 2024
Peak demand is expected to increase from
about 800 gaw to 900 gaws this is a
massive increase of 100 gws over the
next six years driven by growth in
energy intensive data centers domestic
manufacturing and electrification of
transport and heating but that's not all
not only is Peak demand growing is is
going faster than we're able to predict
as you can see Peak demand forecasts
keep getting revised upwards over time
the 2030 forecast jumped by 50 gws just
in the last year so clearly there these
forecasts are continuing to evolve
rapidly this uncertainty increases the
importance of prioritizing the most cost
effective and flexible resources such as
virtual power
plants for affordability Capital
investments in transmission and
Distribution Systems are growing to meet
Rising load growth and to replace aging
assets on this page you can see the
annual Capital expenditures by sector
over time while these Capital costs have
historically been generally stable or
following inflation distribution costs
in particular have grown rapidly in the
last 10 years outpacing all other grid
Capital costs from 2022 to 2023 just in
one year distribution Capital
Investments grew by close to
15% and they're expected to continue
growing according to the annual energy
Outlook from the eia transmission and
distribution prices are expected to
continue growing by another 12% between
2023 and 2030 this is after accounting
for inflation and while total
electricity prices
declin these Rising energy costs Place
pressure on households especially
low-income Americans who are already
struggling to pay energy bills
today and while there are challenges for
meeting grid reliability and
affordability the Aging infrastructure
of the grid itself is being placed under
immense pressure by increasingly
frequent extreme weather events the
number of billion doll climate and
weather events has doubled over the last
10 years in 2023 alone the US
experienced a record 28 separate billion
doll climate disasters that cause $95
billion of damage in injury the majority
of out outages close to 80% are due to
these extreme weather
events so it's clear there are a lot of
near press near-term pressures that the
grid is facing against the backdrop of
this virtual power plant are among the
critical solutions that can address
these near-term CH challenges and build
a reliable affordable and resilient grid
for all Americans why well because basic
virtual power plants are quick to depl
they can be launched in less than 6
months to meet rapid low growth they are
low cost both on the bulk power grid and
on the distribution grid because they
help defer necessary upgrades and
maximize utilization of the assets we've
already paid for all while they provide
backup power options to communities
during emergencies such as extreme
weather
events before diving into each of these
in more detail let's take a quick moment
and pause to recall the definition of a
virtual power plant as mentioned in the
2023 liftop report virtual power plants
are aggregations of distributed energy
resources or deers like rooftop Sal
solar with batteries EVs and Chargers
smart appliances and flexible commercial
and Industrial loads these aggregations
help balance both demand and supply for
additional background on bvps De their
business models take technology
deployment potential please reference
the 2023 bppp liftoff
report so as mentioned before basic
virtual power plants are quick to
deploy they can be launched in less than
six months by tapping into de that are
already on the grid or expected to be
deployed wood McKenzie estimates that
2117 gwatt of De capacity is expected to
come online in the next 5 years this EX
existing and expected capacity can serve
as the foundation for fast launching
large scale virtual power plants in
comparison traditional approaches to
increasing grid capacity such as utility
scale batteries and gas peer plants are
facing lengthening delays whether that
be due to clogged interconnection cues
or lengthy permitting timelines or long
lead times due to supply chain
delays rapid demand growth requires
rapid Solutions such as virtual power
plants deploying bvps can bias time for
the construction of higher capacity
assets and increase the value of grid
assets that Americans have already paid
for as one example of a bvp that has
deployed quickly National Grid launched
its successful connected Solutions
program in less than four months which
now provides up to 250 megaw of peak
shaving
benefits in addition to being quick to
deploy bvps are lower cost Solutions
when comparing the net cost of providing
400 megaw of resource adequacy bvps
could be lower cost than procuring the
same capacity from a natural gas peer
plant or a utility scale
battery these savings as well as reduced
distribution and transmission costs acre
to all rate payers not just vvp
participants Beyond these system
benefits for all rate payers customers
enrolled in the vcp can also acrew
additional benefits in the form of
incentives as a real world example Con
Edison deferred a $1.2 billion
substation upgrade in 2014 instead
spending 200 millionar on deers and
demand reduction measures as part of the
Brooklyn Queens demand Management
program and of course as mentioned bpps
also build resilience for communities
for example Green Mountain powers Z zero
outages initiative combines traditional
resilience approaches with energy
storage deployment through batteries and
micr
grids so now that we've recognized the
value of EVPs in addressing the
near-term grip pressures what is the
scale that they can get to by
2030 while deploying 80 to 160 gws of
bvps by 2030 or roughly 10 to 20% of
peak load could support rapid load
growth while reducing overall grid costs
meaning the trifecta grid reliability
affordability and
resilience today if you look at the
left- hand side of this chart the height
of the first bar indicates that bvps
serve roughly 30 gaw of the 800 gaw of
us Peak electricity to n between today
and 2030 roughly 100 gaw of old power
plants are expected to
retire between the same time period
demand is also expected to increase by
100 gaw from 800 to 900
gaw so if we do some quick math we can
see that 100 gwatt of demand growth and
100 gws of potential retirements implies
that roughly 200 gaw of coincident Peak
demand must be served with new resources
added to the grid by
2030 bbps could serve a lot of that by
tripling in scale to meet 80 to 160 gaws
at the 200 g of peak demand needs this
is while reducing grid costs improving
grid reliability and building Community
resilience by growing vpps to that scale
we could meet 10 to 20% of peak load
while saving on the order of 10 billion
dollar in Grid costs from peer plants
tnd upgrades and fuel this translates to
savings for rate
payers so what will it take to actually
get
there the pathway to commercial liftoff
for V DPS requires progress along five
imperatives first expanding de adoption
with Equitable benefits second
simplifying bppp
enrollment third increasing
standardization in BPP operations and
this standardization will help integrate
vvps both into utility planning and
incentives or the fourth imperative and
wholesale markets for the fifth
imper now for the rest of our session
today I'll talk briefly about each of
these imperatives and give real world
examples or updated Market analyses of
proven solutions that can be adopted in
all of your
jurisdictions but this will be just a
small glimpse of the over 75 case
studies included in the full 20125
update so starting with the first
imperative expanding de adoption with
Equitable
benefits even though de capacity is
expected to increase rapidly de adoption
today is still a fraction of its
potential for example only 3.5% of
households have rooftop solar and 133%
have Smart
thermostats low de adoption will limit
the available capacity for virtual power
plants and reduce the speed at which
bpps can be
deployed to expand de adoption and
ensure the benefits are enjoyed by all
communities we need deers to be more
affordable High upfront costs and
limited lowcost financing options today
limit who is able to purchase a de which
in turn limits who can benefit from De
ownership through low lower energy bills
backup power improved air quality
outcomes and
more various industry actors are
implementing Solutions today that can be
replicated to address these
barriers for example San Diego Community
power launched the solar battery Savings
Program a couple months ago
this VPP uses upfront incentives to
lower the initial cost of purchasing
solar and batteries for all customers
for income qualified populations in
particular Community power worked with
state and local programs to make sure
their incentives could stack with other
programs and cover the entire cost of
solar and storage through available
incentives Community power is able to
use these batteries every single day for
two hours to reduce Peak Demand on their
grid while saving costs for their
customers the program has been so
successful that they hit their budget
cap in just three months due to high
customer interest it's clear that
customer want these assets for the lower
energy bills for the backup power
options and in our full update we
include 13 case studies that share
additional levers that stakeholders can
consider these levers range from
improving de access for multif family
buildings to in Innovative Financial
mechanisms that increase access to
lowcost financing all to achieve the
objective of expanding Dr adoption with
Equitable
benefits next we need these de to
actually participate in Virtual power
plants and to do that enrolling these de
into available programs and simplifying
the vvp enrollment process is
critical now Dr capacity is expected to
grow and grow rapidly and this growth
isn't limited to any particular state in
fact every state across the US is
expected to see some growth in De
capacity th though the magnitude of that
growth and the types of De that come
online will vary from state to state for
example if we look at California over
here they have EV Chargers and fuel
generators and batteries that comprise
the majority on the other hand Maine has
about 50% of its dispatchable capacity
coming from fuel generators
alone de capacity growth is great and
important but on its own it could strain
existing aging Distribution Systems that
are already near maximum capacity during
Peak events instead enrolling these DS
into virtual power plants would
integrate these resources into system
planning effectively managing impacts to
the distribution system while unlocking
additional reliability affordability and
resilience value for for rate
payers with a baseline forecast of De
adoption and demonstrated best-in-class
vvp enrollment rates bvps can actually
meet lift off of 10 to 20% of peak
Demand by
2030 looking at this chart starting from
the left hand side today we have roughly
30 gaw of bbp capacity serving the
git if we were to continue enrolling
deers into bvps at the current
enrollment rate we would expect another
25 gwatt of
capacity the interesting scenarios are
the next two on this page implementing
no regrets and high impact enrollment
Pro practices can enroll an additional
25 to 100 gwatt of capacity to meet 10
to 20% of peak
demand to unlock these higher enrollment
scenarios stakeholders need to
prioritize implementing these no regrets
and high impact
actions for no regrets actions even
strategies as simple as improving
Communications to highlight the benefits
of enrollment especially the financial
benefits are a low effort high impact
action that cooperatives such as Mota is
is
adopting to achieve higher enrollment
rates as we see in the third enrollment
scenario strategies such as point of
purchase enrollment and automatic
enrollment with OP out can dramatically
improve
conversion for example a a study by
uplight actually found that over 60% of
eligible customers purchasing a smart
thermostat would enroll in programs when
they offer the option at the point of
sale and this utilities are actually
adopting these practices such as Arizona
public service that has an online
Marketplace for their cool Rewards
program making it as simple as possible
for consumers is critical this way these
assets can not only serve customers but
also provide critical benefits to the
Grid in our full update we have nine
additional case studies that showcase a
variety of other strategies that are
helping to simplify bvp
enrollment next we need more
standardization and bppp operations so
that VB models that work in one
jurisdiction like the few that we've
already referenced today can be rapidly
replicated across the country there has
been a ton of innovation in Virtual
power plants in the derss that they
aggregate in the grid services that they
provide and the increasing frequency of
dispatch but the flip side of that
Innovation is complexity among DVP
providers luckily doe and other industry
actors have launched or expanded efforts
to standard V to standardize various
areas of vvp
operations from the communication
protocols between bpps and utilities all
the way to cyber security for deers
there are various standardization
efforts
underway this type of standardization
could accelerate integration of virtual
power plants both into how utilities
operate and how wholesale markets
operate as an example of a
standardization initiative Epi launched
flexit to deliver the technical
specifications necessary for providing
de
visibility and to establish standards
for the core utility to VPP interaction
required when providing gr
Services these standardization efforts
and the other nine referenced in the
report are critical to reducing complex
complexity and accelerating
deployment in the report there are more
detailed descriptions of each of these
efforts alongside the information
technology and operational technology
configurations or it and OT
configurations that enable three
successful utility Le bpps in this
country
now increased standardization will
facilitate integrating virtual power
plants into utility planning and
incentives for investor owned Utilities
in particular State policy makers and
Regulators can play a key role and are
playing a key role in integrating
virtual power plants into utility
planning and compensation models as part
of their role in directing and
overseeing grid plans and investment
strategies
and the value of the role they play is
clear across the US bvp deployment has
been highest in the states where State
regulators and our policy makers have
implemented vvp supportive
actions on this map if you look at each
of the states the number in each state
indicates the number of VPP deployments
that have been launched the darkness of
the color indicates the total vbp
related policy and Regulatory actions in
that state
so states such as New York Texas
Massachusetts North Carolina California
are some states that have a significant
amount of both deployments and policy
and Regulatory related actions and you
can see that there's a general
correlation between the two so clearly
regulators and policy makers have an
absolutely critical role to play in
accelerating DVP deployment and
achieving upop and there are a variety
of ways that they can approach
supporting
deployment example include establishing
utility cost recovery methods for vbp
related investments just like vermonts
Public Utility Commission did by
allowing Green Mountain Power to include
certain customer lease deers as part of
their capital investment
plan other examples include developing
de aggregation models and deployment
requirements like the Texas pu has done
to establish an aggregated de pilot
program and enable third-party
aggregation of
DS and there are many other examples
included in this report state byst state
regulators and policy makers will have
different policy contexts and starting
points of regulatory Frameworks that can
be used or adjusted to encourage virtual
power plant
deployment these example actions
discussed in more depth in the report
provide a menu of the 22 real world
options that can be tailored to help
State regulators and policy makers meet
their State's context and grid
objectives while reducing costs for rate
rate
Pairs and finally let's turn to
wholesale markets as of 2020 the six
Regional wholesale power markets that
are regulated by the federal electric
reliability Corporation or FK are
required by order 2222 to allow
participation by aggregations of DVS in
other words bvp
that means it's no longer a matter of
whether wholesale markets will allow
virtual power plants but rather when and
how implementation plans across the
various markets uh have had a lot of
different uh approaches so if we look at
ISO RTO compliance uh they really vary
by market based on region specific
challenges tyo niso and ISO New England
are leading implementation while pjm
myso and spp are seeking to implement
much of their compliance several years
later of the market operators only kaiso
and ISO New England have fully complied
with the requirements of for per order
2222 when we actually look at the
compliance plans uh a lot of them
exhibit individualized disperate
approaches to wholesale Market
participation for
de this results in a patchwork of rules
and requirements that really make it
difficult for aggregators to scale
across jurisdictions and replicate
proven
models while some variation is expected
the degree of variation across regions
is introducing delays and adding
costs one industry analysis estimates
that standardizing ISO and RTO metering
and settlement approaches alone could
create 775 billion dollar in savings due
to reductions in data Computing storage
and management CS so it's clear that
there's still a lot of work to be done
to integrate virtual power plants into
wholesale markets but there are several
emerging solutions to address some of
these challenges both domestically and
internationally in Market operators
utilities State policy makers and
Regulators all have a role to play in
advancing those in the report we've
included six case studies of various
options Market operators can consider as
well as three levers for State
regulators and policy makers to consider
to more fully integrate virtual power
plants into wholesale
markets the potential Solutions I've
highlighted involve a particularly wide
range of stakeholders on the consumer
end of the value chain we need
involvement of community organization
financial institutions de developers
retailers and more on the great
operations side we need utilities to get
involved National Labs Regulators State
policy ERS and Market operators to step
up and of course as the department of
energy we have a critical role to play
in our report we have included over 60
supportive actions that doe and our
collaborators are taking to support
virtual power plan deployment ranging
from lowcost financing for projects
through our low loan programs office
grant funding for grid resilience or
technical support for regulators and
much much more
tripling the scale of virtual power
plants to meet 10 to 20% of peak Demand
by 2030 will not be easy but it's urgent
it's time to move Beyond pilots and
Patchwork deployment to vpps at scale
the great news is we have all these Pro
proven solutions that we can pull from
over 75 examples highlighted in our
update so we do not need to start
scratch adopting and adapting these
demonstrated best practices and you
using the tools and resources we already
have available in front of us can
accelerate action to address near-term
grid needs and Achieve lift
off unfortunately we will't be able to
take questions during this time but
thank you all so much for tuning in
early on a Wednesday morning if we've
been successful at peing your interest
we do hope you check out the full 2025
update at lift off. energy.gov
vvp we at the department of energy look
forward to hearing from you we do very
much welcome feedback as well as working
with all of you to accelerate virtual
power plan deployment and reach lift off
thank you all so much for joining and
have a wonderful week ahead
[Music]
