Frederick Ilchman: "Birth in Venice: Early Art Collecting in the 'Serenissima'"

ArtEcho: Exploring Art History and Critique
24 followers
Our next speaker is Dr. Frederick Ilkman,
who has worked at the Museum of Fine Arts in Boston
since 2001, where he was appointed
Chair, Art of Europe, in 2014.
He helped plan the major exhibition
on Jacopo Tintoretto at the Museo del Prado
in Madrid in 2007, and later served
as the lead curator for Titian Tintoretto,
Veronese, Rivals in Renaissance Venice.
The exhibit that took place in 2009
was organized by the MFA and the Musee du Louvre.
Frederick is now the national chairman
of Save Venice, incorporated the largest
private committee dedicated to preserving
the art and architecture of Venice.
With Robert Eccles, he co-curated Tintoretto,
Artist of Renaissance Venice, now at the
National Gallery of Art in Washington, D.C.
Although he roots for the Red Sox,
you'll find his heart is in Venice.
Yes.
Buongiorno.
What's generally the first question
of museum-goers when they walk up
to a work of art?
Who painted it?
And luckily, museums have wall labels
to tell us the name of the artist.
Or at least, a best guest.
Perhaps surprisingly, who painted it
was also a burning question nearly
500 years ago in Venice.
When enough time had passed since
the creation of this painting,
about half a century, that the attribution
was already in doubt.
The panel now in London's National Gallery,
St. Jerome in His Study, makes perfect
sense to us today as a work painted
by Antonello da Messina when he was
in Venice around 1475.
But by the 1520s, the picture's authorship
was not at all clear.
Between 1521 and 1543, Marcantonio Michiel,
a Venetian noble and aspiring diplomat,
though never really successful as a diplomat,
particularly fascinated by art and art collections,
took detailed notes on the private collections
he had visited in Northern Italy,
including 11 collections in Venice.
And that's a much later publication
for the first time in 1800.
Michiel's notes are revolutionary
in the amount of detail given to individual works,
particularly tantalizing descriptions
of 14 paintings supposedly by Giorgione.
And for the overall summaries of collections,
Michiel's notes offer far more information
than inventories which rarely supply
the name of an artist.
One of Michiel's entries, compiled in 1529,
covers the collection of Antonio Pasquilino,
whose family lived in Campo San Maurizio
in an enormous Gothic palazzo.
There's the palazzo.
Within the huge house, Michiel takes pains
to describe this small painting.
Yet, Michiel is stumped by who the artist was
and records divergent opinions.
There's the passage from Michiel.
Some believe that the little picture of St. Jerome,
dressed as a cardinal, reading in the study,
is by the hand of Antonaldo Messina,
but the majority, with more justification,
attribute it to Giannis, got that item,
or Membling, it's Hans Membling,
an old Flemish painter, so that it shows that style,
although the face is finished in the Italian way,
so that it seems to be by the hand of Giacometto.
The buildings are in the Flemish style.
The little landscape is lifelike,
minute and highly finished,
and one sees it outside a window
and beyond the studied door, and then it fades out.
And the whole work is perfect for its subtlety,
coloring, drawing, strength, and relief.
In it, a peacock, quail, and barber's basin
are all represented.
A small open letter is attached to the desk,
which seems to contain the master's name,
but notwithstanding, if one looks carefully
at it from close up, it does not contain any letters,
but is all made up.
Others believe that the figure has been repainted
by Giacometto Veneziano.
There's the painting again.
And you can see many things that Michiel had singled out,
very evident in the picture.
Michiel was an early example
of what we would call a connoisseur,
someone who cultivated expertise
and took great delight in erudite conversations about art.
Like other sophisticated editions of the day,
Michiel admired Netherlandish paintings
of the 15th century for their profusion of tiny details,
including still life passages,
convincing evocations of texture,
careful play of light, and distant landscapes
that recede into the mist.
The evident technical mastery of these characteristics
in the painting of Saint Jerome suggested to him,
and the, quote, majority of people he has consulted,
that the artist must be Jan van Eyck or Memling,
or at least someone from the Low Countries.
At the same time, the figure of Jerome,
particularly the face, seemed, to several people,
more likely to be by a Venetian artist.
Thus, Michiel tries to solve his attribution dilemma
with a common way out today, compromise condition,
and declares the picture could have been made
in two campaigns, with a figure repainted,
the figure of Jerome, repainted by Giacometto,
a Venetian painter and miniaturist,
active from the 1470s through the 1490s.
Now, implicit in Michiel's attributional impasse
and the length of his analysis on this painting
is that the correct artist of this painting
was not only worth knowing, but essential to know.
A work derived part of its value
from the skill of its creator,
who worked in what we now call a signature style.
In the absence of documents or signatures for the painting,
and you can imagine Michiel's frustration
when he realized that this cartelino
on the side of the desk does not contain any real words,
the correct painter should be identifiable
through visual comparisons to individual artists.
Although we might feel that Michiel is waffling
in this passage between different attributions,
he would probably say that he was being thorough,
giving us an outstanding painting,
the attention it merited.
As an aside, in terms of his own collection,
Michiel has a mixed record.
He owned 20 paintings,
including perhaps a Giorgione and a Bellini,
19 bronzes, and five marble sculptures.
A few works have been identified,
including a bronze ewer in the Fitzwilliam
with the inscription M. Antoninus,
Michiel had this made in the year 1548.
You can be sure that this permanent labeling
right on the ewer itself,
conveying both credit for the patron
and vital provenance information,
was intended to help future list makers,
that is future of Michiel's.
Michiel also commissioned
this awkward marble sculpture of Mercury
from Antonio Minelli,
based on antique originals
and complete with a circular horoscope,
you see that at the bottom,
set into a small altar.
Now in the Victoria and Albert Museum,
the sculpture bears a Latin text
noting that the work was commissioned by Michiel
and begun on 14th of February, 1527,
and the horoscope for 15 June,
15 February, appears on the bronze disk.
Now I'm not so sure that Michiel
should have tried to take credit for this sculpture,
but it's hard to,
while it's hard to attribute
what the sculpture meant to Michiel,
Jennifer Flesher perceptively noted
that this date happened to be
the month when Michiel married,
and that Mercury as a god was quote,
a useful symbol for Venetian patrician,
simultaneously interested in antiquity,
diplomacy, and business.
So if we cannot particularly praise the works of art,
at least those we can identify by Michiel,
in Michiel's collection,
we should credit him with a more distinguished collection,
the compendium of detailed notes
he had made on the collections of others.
Let's now turn to a large painting
to think more about the big picture
of art collecting in Venice.
This is Carpaccio's expansive canvas
of the Miracle at Rialto Bridge,
painted about 1496,
or a public setting,
the Scuola Grande di San Giovanni Evangelista.
We see a teeming cityscape
packed with a varied cast of characters,
many merchants of Venice
plying their trade on land,
and moving about the town by boat.
In the background lies the rickety wooden drawbridge
of the Rialto,
predecessor of the much sturdier stone structure,
stone bridge,
completed in 1591 that we know today.
Fanciful chimney pots,
church steeples,
and laundry out to dry
punctuate the pink sky of the setting sun.
In the 16th century,
Venice had some 160,000 inhabitants,
making it one of the two or three
most populous cities in Europe,
and arguably its most cosmopolitan and sophisticated.
It had a very diverse population
with large groups of foreigners.
Importantly,
unlike principalities that were governed
by a single ruling family
who would generally monopolize the best artists
and dictate taste,
Venice, as a republic,
had a much broader structure.
This is Jacopo de' Barberi's monumental
woodcut view of Venice,
dated 1500,
composed of six large blocks
and showing the city from the air.
And this is a particularly fine impression
bought about seven years ago
by the Minneapolis Institute of Art.
In Venice of this era,
patricians constituted the top 5% of the population.
These men stocked the magistracies
and councils that governed Venice.
The next layer down were cittadini, or citizens,
composed of lawyers, doctors, notaries, civil servants,
wholesale and international merchants.
So these were another five to 6%.
The remaining 89 to 90% comprised popolati,
that is professions like shopkeepers, artisans,
minor merchants, laborers, and also foreigners.
Thus compared to most other cities in Europe,
Venice had a larger upper middle class
and a much broader pool of potential art buyers.
Indeed, although copies of this map
were priced at three ducats,
that's a substantial amount,
a very large percentage of Venice
could probably have afforded one.
It is against this backdrop
that I argue something extraordinary happened here
around this time in the history of art collecting.
My assertion is that in the period
covered by the symposium,
Venice, La Serenissima Repubblica,
was just about the earliest place in Europe
that could qualify as having an art market
in the modern sense.
There are a number of instances
where Venice records the first example,
or at least an early adoption,
of many developments that we today
consider essential to the activities
of specialized art collecting
and a burgeoning art trade.
These include the invention
of the oil on canvas easel picture
and the format of the gallery painting,
the beginnings of the secondary market,
new attention to the creation
of household collections
which encouraged artists who served this niche,
a taste for contemporary art created elsewhere,
art connoisseurship as a specialized skill,
published art criticism,
the illustrated collection catalog, and more.
Now, these are a lot of firsts or early examples,
so we'll touch upon just a few of them.
The subject of this conference
is a story of objects, people, and spaces.
These categories of Venetian Renaissance objects,
people, and spaces intersect
in the case of this Saint Jerome painting.
We've got a remarkable picture,
a literary description by a pioneering art historian,
several plausible candidates for the painter,
and inside the painting itself,
a clue to the original settings
for such small pictures, a studiolo, or study.
Just as Jerome sits in a specially constructed desk
raised off the chilly floor
and surrounded by his books,
so would a precious painting like this,
like the Antonello,
might have been displayed in a space akin.
Such rooms were intentionally intimate,
sequestered spaces where treasures
could be kept securely and admired privately
or with a close friend or two.
Studies, that's schedulatoi and studioli, et cetera,
and similar rooms for running a business
or for pursuing intellectual pursuits
are the first of two key spaces
within Venetian buildings.
A studio could also be called a camerino, a little room,
and there are also other names like that.
As argued by Peter Thornton,
such spaces were derived from monk cells
where reading and writing took place.
It took the combination of two traditions,
the cleric cell and the secular treasury
of a wealthy family,
in the 15th century they came together
to produce the studiolo.
Special shelving and cupboards,
as we see in the Antonello,
soon become de rigueur.
Eventually, such a room full of treasures,
what's subjected to an organizing principle,
would become a wunderkammer or a kunstkammer,
and eventually called a museum,
a seat of the muses, but we're not there yet.
A study could be carved out of a larger bedchamber,
as seen in this drawing by Lorenzo Lotto.
As discussed by Elizabeth Curry,
the presence of a bed for a nap,
quote, combined with a cluttered field
of so many belongings amassed together,
produced a sense of comfort,
that, for some, was a vital characteristic
of the ideal study, end quote.
This concept is still with us.
Surely we all feel the important reassurance
when we're surrounded by our books.
In this cleric study, we see medals,
bells, candlesticks, scientific instruments,
vessels in a variety of sizes,
and paintings and sculptures.
The smiling cleric clearly loves his possessions.
They not only allow him to feel at home,
they define home.
At the same time, the plethora of objects
has outgrown his space,
and makes it hard to rank their importance.
Indeed, what is this man's best friend?
The book in his hand, or the dog on the foreground cushion?
To be sure, studioli were not unique to Venice,
and its territories.
Small rooms that functioned as offices
and refuges for solitary contemplation and reading
were found in homes of humanists across Italy.
Now it stands to reason that the existence
of studioli and cabinet as intimate spaces
would not only be logical places
to display small works of art,
this very category of room would spur the collecting of,
and even creation of works,
specifically for such settings.
So Venice was far from unique
in having intellectuals possessing studioli.
The city was distinct in two aspects
of collecting for these small rooms.
The first was a climate that allowed painters,
who were not court artists,
to focus solely on the very top echelon
of private clientele.
Giorgione most famously largely eschewed
altarpiece and government commissions
in order to concentrate his brief career
on producing small format easel paintings
destined for the studies in bedrooms of connoisseurs.
Giorgione helped create a new category
of poetic pictures, elusive in meaning.
His clients were very much word of mouth.
Isabella d'Este, the same collector
we heard so much about yesterday,
remember she resolved to obtain a painting by Leonardo,
regardless of subject matter,
so it's another new idea of collecting.
The artist is more important than the actual subject.
She wrote a letter on the 25th of October in 1510
to her agent in Venice.
She was asking him to track down a painting
by Giorgione of una nocte, night,
meaning probably nativity.
The agent soon had to admit
that although he'd been able to track down
two paintings of that subject
in private collections in Venice,
neither owner wished to sell, even at high prices.
Moreover, since Giorgione had recently died,
nothing could be done.
A second characteristic of Venetian studio collections
compared to other parts of Italy
was a strong predilection for Netherlandish paintings.
Michiel records works by van Eyck,
van der Weyden, Bosch, Memling, and many others.
And this is the famous Memling diptych
that Michiel said was owned by Pietro Vembo.
Although inventories rarely named individual painters,
the school was often noted in inventories.
A painting would be called Di Stile Greco,
for an icon, or Fiamingo, for a Netherlandish painting.
I would suggest that admiring the art
of other places and cultures,
in addition to the artists of your own local school,
is another sign of a more modern art scene.
If the studio was really a pan-Italian phenomenon,
a second key space within Venetian homes, the Portico,
was much more specific to the Senanissima.
Let's return to the façade of Palazzo Pasqualego,
once home of the painting of Saint Jerome.
So here's the façade.
This side of the palace, seen from Campo San Maurizio,
is actually one of two main façades.
There was a second façade overlooking the quay and canal
on the opposite side.
Generally, the entrance of an important building in Venice
faced a canal where the water entrance was.
From the fenestration, we notice immediately
the building is composed of four main floors.
So, first, the ground floor, down here,
generally used for storage or rented out to shops.
There's currently a shop here on the left,
probably more in the 16th century.
Above the ground floor can be seen a narrow floor here,
a mezzanino or mezzanine, holding offices
and sometimes studies.
Above that is a floor with much higher ceilings,
the Piero Novelle.
This was the principal floor, with a large single space
for banquets and other festivities,
as well as smaller rooms for receiving guests,
taking regular meals, and then the bedrooms.
Palazzo Pasquilego is tall enough
that it is the second Piero Novelle, up there,
with somewhat lower ceilings under the roof.
Now, this palazzo is characteristically Venetian,
with most of the windows clustered together
along a central vertical axis.
Given the extreme urban density in Venice,
central courtyards, so important for bringing light
and air to the interior rooms in palaces in Florence
and Rome, for example, are very rare.
Instead, these clustered windows illuminate
a long and narrow room that runs
the whole depth of the building.
This long room, called a portico,
is a constant in Venetian architecture,
whether the building was built circa 1430,
as you see in the Cadoro, in the Gothic style,
or constructed in a late 17th century
and completed in the 1750s, in the Baroque style,
as we have seen in the much larger Carazzonica.
The portico has been the focus of study
by a number of scholars in recent years,
including Monica Schmitter, Margaret Morse,
and Christina Henry, who will give the next paper today.
The architect and theorist, Sebastiano Serlio,
noted in the 1540s that the use of such rooms, portighini,
is, quote, the universal custom of the city.
This is a generic floor plan of a Venetian house,
and so these are windows up here.
Notice the four parallel little bearing walls,
one, two, three, and then four.
These are perpendicular, they separate the plan
and divide into three axial spaces
perpendicular to the facade, this being the main facade.
The portico takes up the entire inner axis.
The other two wings are composed of smaller rooms,
here and here, which would include bed chambers,
sitting rooms, kitchen, and sometimes a study.
In Venetian practice, the portico was mostly a passageway,
leading to more intimate spaces.
It could be transformed, however,
for receptions, performances, and banquets.
Its size and extensive walls, with only doors,
no windows, along the two long walls,
made it an obvious place to situate furniture,
display arms and armor, and exhibit family portraits.
These portraits would have covered the walls of a portico,
and in last autumn's Tintoretto exhibition
in the Palazzo Fucale, I recreated a portico
in a private Venetian home,
filling this rather awkward space in the Palazzo Fucale
with many of Tintoretto's finest portraits.
As Monica Schmitter has persuasively argued,
these long and large rooms seem to have called
for a new format of picture, the, quote,
quadro da portico, that is, a portico painting.
It has often been observed that Venetian canvas pictures
grew steadily in size during the 16th century.
One explanation for this trend is the preponderance
of large rooms, portighi, where smaller-sized pictures,
those for cabinet and studioli,
were simply too little to make an impact.
Big rooms inspired large paintings.
Now, quadro da portico is a rare term,
but nevertheless a period term.
There is, for example, the inventory
of the studio contents of the painter
Paolo Il Vecchio in 1528.
In this, he described, the inventory describes
one painting as a portico picture on wood
with Christ and the 12 apostles
and two women half-finished.
This must refer to a painting now in academia,
Christ and the Woman of Canaan,
which seemed to have been started by Paolo
and completed by another artist.
Indeed, that's how we have the half-finished part
is explained.
If this is a typical example, a portico picture
might be defined as a horizontal format
with plenty of figures and narrative content.
As confirmed by 16th century inventories,
certain subject matter predominates
in the horizontal paintings for these rooms.
Destined for public spaces within private homes,
the pictures were often religious
or had religious overtones, reinforcing the piety
or political alliances of the family.
Thus, a large battle scene, which reinforced
the military character of the arms and armor
often displayed in these rooms,
might indeed be a conversion of Paul.
Or a feast and dining picture,
which emphasized the occasional banqueting function
of these large rooms, could be a supper at Emmaus.
In this magnificent example by Paolo Veronese,
the abundance of portraits within the composition
recalls the frequent use of a portico
to display portraits of family members.
Or in Titian's Ecce Homo,
the giant canvas, well more than two by three meters
for the Donna family, we see a gripping crowd scene
which refers, perhaps, to contemporary struggles
between the Ottoman Turks and the Habsburg Empire.
You see that in the flags, the costumes, et cetera.
The prominent diagonal staircase and the platform
mean that the figures are arranged at varying heights.
In the words of Monica Schmider, quote,
Titian here has risen to the challenge
of the quaderno portico.
How to compose a long, large scene
that maintains interest and draws the viewer's eye
across space.
In each of these three paintings,
the Tintoretto, the Veronese, and the Titian,
the sky visible at top would also have served
to open up the room, making the space feel larger.
We began with Marc Antonio Michiel's effort
to record artistic treasures in private halls
in the 1520s.
To conclude, I'd like to shift a century later
to 1629, towards the end of our period of the symposium,
to discuss briefly another Venetian innovation,
the illustrated collection catalog.
We know quite a lot about the Vendermine family in Venice,
particularly known for the magnificent group portrait.
We know that in the 14th century and earlier,
Andrea Vendermine presented the Reliquary of the True Cross,
seen here at the far right of the painting,
to the Scuola San Giovanni Evangelista,
and I showed you Carpaccio's Miracle of Rialto Bridge,
which depicts one of the miracles caused by this relic
further in the lecture.
Another Andrea Vendermine is the white married man
at the center of Titian's group portrait.
To his right is his younger brother,
Gabriele Vendermine, owner of Giorgione's Tempesta,
and a renowned collection of antiquities
that he arranged in his study.
A later Vendermine, Andrea Vendermine in 1627,
decided to record on paper his encyclopedic collections,
which ranged from minerals, gems, and other natural wonders,
to ancient ceramics, Egyptian rings, scarabs,
as well as the usual classical marbles,
paintings, and metals.
What is special is that these handwritten catalogs
boast illustrations in brown ink and watercolor.
Vendermine's antiquities were subdivided
into six categories, other catalogs described as paintings,
Venetian coins, books, manuscripts,
and the collections of natural history.
Overall, only six volumes today survive in total
in the libraries of London, Oxford, and Berlin.
Now, many of the illustrations
of the paintings are captioned.
Thus, this volume, now in the British Library,
may be the earliest surviving illustrated collection
catalog of paintings, a format that is still central
to art history today.
So we see here Giovanni Bellini,
there is a nice Titian portrait of Bellini,
and its own meaning Giorgione,
and then we've got a special of Piombo,
and then a portrait of Titian by himself,
that's kind of doubtful, at the bottom.
And then, very nice, David with the head of Goliath there,
by Giorgione, so this would be perhaps an early example
of a Portico painting.
And then a Giovanni Bellini,
a portrait of a woman at the bottom.
Alas, these are just some of the many pages.
Alas, only a handful of the paintings recorded
in Andrei's catalog can be identified
with surviving works today.
Now, even if some of the attributions
seem overly optimistic to us, or kind of ludicrous even,
Andrei Evanderian's catalog of painting,
like so many inventories from the 16th and 17th century,
provides a sobering reminder of just how many works of art
have been lost over the generations.
What has come down to us is a mere fraction
of what was originally produced.
I've tried to show how Venetians offer the first example,
or at least an early adoption, of many developments
we today consider essential to a specialized art collecting
and a burgeoning art trade.
These include the invention of the oil and canvas
easel painting, and the format of the gallery picture,
the beginnings of the secondary market,
new attention on the creation of household collections,
which encourage artists to serve this specific niche,
a taste for contemporary art created elsewhere,
art connoisseurship as a specialized skill,
and the illustrated collection catalog.
That these advances happened in the same city
should not be a surprise.
Venice's pioneering role in modern art collecting
seems to be a combination of La Serenissima's great size
and cosmopolitan nature,
abundance of international commercial activity,
and a particular social structure
with an unusually large upper middle class,
providing many potential collectors and art lovers.
Perhaps akin to Silicon Valley today,
where an astonishing number of tech innovators
and entrepreneurs are concentrated in the Bay Area,
and thus innovations foster further innovations,
Venice in the Renaissance similarly benefited
from its sheer size and remarkable concentration
of artistic objects, spaces, and people.
Together, such factors deserve credit
for this birth in Venice.
Thank you.
