We Just Discovered "Dark" Oxygen on Earth - Breakthrough Explained

NatTech and Science
190 followers
The ocean can be a dark and mysterious place, and the deeper you go, the weirder it gets.
As a species, we've only explored about 5% of the cold, dark void that covers our planet,
and it just got even stranger. 5000m below the surface, in the pitch black,
a mysterious source of oxygen has just been discovered. Has the call of Cthulhu finally
been answered? Probably not, but the truth is much more perplexing and may change science
forever. And it was all discovered by accident. Back in 2013, Andrew Sweetman, a researcher from
the Scottish Association for Marine Science, noticed something strange on the ocean floor.
He was studying a region of marine ecosystems located between Hawaii and Mexico called the
As part of his research, Sweetman's team sent down machines designed to measure the oxygen
levels within this environment. Once at the bottom, these automated seafloor landers sealed
off sections of seabed with cylinders about 22cm square in size and measured how the
concentrations of oxygen in the seawater changed over a period of several days.
From their previous research in areas around the world, Sweetman and his team expected to see a
gradual decline in oxygen levels as organisms within the seawater consumed the oxygen through
respiration. The rate of consumption could be an indicator of the amount and health of marine
microorganisms in the sample and could indicate the health of the seabed overall. But on this
particular trip, something strange happened instead, that Sweetman had never seen before.
The instruments showed that the sequestered water became richer in oxygen over time. Rather
than being consumed, something was producing oxygen. This discovery of dark oxygen was
announced a couple of days ago. What is happening here and what does it mean and why on earth did
they decide to call it dark oxygen? These findings are really interesting so I want to cover how
oxygen usually works in the deep sea, what the researchers found and their leading theory as to
what they think is causing it. But first, I have to thank today's video sponsor, Shortform. For
viewers of this channel, I think you've already clocked that I'm equally fascinated by space as
approaches diffusion, why bats are so weird and how to make the world's hardest puzzle. My problem
is that I never have enough time to read about all these topics. That's why I really like Shortform.
It's like a book summary on steroids, providing a synopsis and explanation of the key ideas clearly
and efficiently. I was just re-reading Carl Sagan's Cosmos, where he celebrates the victories of
scientific endeavor and talks about some of the biggest questions humanity can ponder.
Shortform does a great analysis that breaks it down into key ideas and ideas are powerful. If
you're interested in speeding up your learning, check out Shortform with my link in the description
down below, shortform.com forward slash drben to get a free trial and 20% off your subscription.
Thank you Shortform for sponsoring this channel, now let's get into the video.
I want to start with how oxygen usually makes its way down into the deepest parts of our oceans.
Almost all of Earth's oxygen is produced by photosynthesis, carried out by plants,
algae and certain types of bacteria. You're likely already pretty familiar with this process,
it occurs in chloroplasts within plant cells which contain a green pigment called chlorophyll.
This pigment captures sunlight, splits water and carbon dioxide and produces sugar and,
importantly for life like us, gaseous oxygen as a waste product. Oxygen produced on land
is spread across the planet through atmospheric circulation, but how it gets deep into the oceans
is more complicated. At the surface, oxygen from the atmosphere can diffuse directly into
the surface of water, assisted by winds and the mixing effect that increases the water's surface
area. In the topmost layers, water can also be filled with photosynthetic microorganisms
that are producing oxygen directly into the water. In fact, some estimates indicate that
phytoplankton alone which occur in water produce around 50% of the entire planet's oxygen. However,
sunlight entering the water can only ever travel down about a thousand meters into the ocean under
perfect conditions, but usually more like 200 meters or so. This means that photosynthesis
and oxygen availability rapidly fall off beyond this depth. So how does oxygen reach deeper layers
of water? That mostly relies on the fact that gases dissolve better in cold water than warm
water, and that cold water is also denser than warmer water so it sinks. This allows polar water
to soak up and hold onto large amounts of oxygen and then be drawn down to the ocean floor, creating
a convection current called the thermohaline circulation. This drives a global conveyor belt
moving oxygen-rich waters across the ocean floor over a surprisingly long and slow process
circulating on timescales between a hundred and a thousand years. This provides a constant low
level of oxygen to the ocean floor, enabling life to thrive even if it does sometimes look a little
weird. This idea that oxygenated ecosystems are only possible through photosynthesis and that all
other ecosystems are kind of lucky to receive some of the offshoot oxygen has been the foundation of
how we understand why life has evolved the way it has on these systems and on earth as a whole.
Sweetman's discovery that actually there may be a source of oxygen on the ocean floor potentially
could rewrite our understanding of what is possible on our planet. Initially, when Sweetman and his
team actually retrieved their data, they actually thought that the sensors they were using were
faulty because every study ever done in the deep sea has only ever seen oxygen being consumed
rather than produced. They put the result down simply to bad data and moved on with other
experiments. It wasn't until eight years later in 2021 that Sweetman went on another research cruise
and again found the same result. For this experimental run however, the researchers
had used a different measurement method. So now two independent approaches had produced
datasets that both showed the same result. It was at this point that Sweetman realized that for the
last eight or nine years he may have been ignoring this hugely groundbreaking process
occurring 4,000 meters down on the ocean floor. Further still, the amount of oxygen being produced
wasn't insignificant. The concentrations in these chambers began to exceed the oxygen level normally
observed in surface waters rich with photosynthetic organisms. So what was actually going on here?
This is where a unique feature of the Clarion-Clipperton zone comes into play. In this
area of the Pacific, the seafloor is covered with small rock-like clusters rich in metallic deposits
called polymetallic nodules. You may have heard of these clusters before. They are the resources
often targeted by deep sea mining companies as they're full of valuable materials like cobalt,
manganese, and nickel, critical for various industries from battery technologies to
consumer electronics. These polymetallic nodules were unique to the Clarion-Clipperton zone that
Sweetman was studying, suggesting that these rocks may have an important role. In September of 2023,
Sweetman contacted his colleague Franz Geiger, a professor of chemistry at Northwestern University,
to discuss possible explanations for this oxygen source. The result of this work was the pair
coined the term dark oxygen because, like all good scientists, when faced with a mysterious
phenomenon that can't be explained, you just prefix it with dark. Geiger though did have
experience investigating novel oxygen sources and had previously found that under certain conditions
salt water in the presence of rusted metal can generate small electric currents. Could it be
that these metallic nodules were performing a simple form of electrolysis, splitting water into
its components of hydrogen and oxygen through some rudimentary form of naturally occurring battery?
To understand what was actually happening, the team recreated the conditions found on the sea
floor in a laboratory on board their ship. The researchers began by sterilizing their samples to
remove possible oxygen producing organisms from the samples of nodules and seafloor sediment
to ensure that no other sources of oxygen generation existed in their experimental equipment.
By enclosing the samples in airtight containers they monitored the oxygen levels over a period
of several days. Consistent with their observations on the ocean floor, the team observed again that
the oxygen levels slowly increased in the containers despite no photosynthetic life
being present. Interestingly, oxygen levels increased to three times the background
concentration, ultimately then slowly plateauing after a few days. To provide a deeper analysis,
the pair then shipped crates of samples to Geiger's laboratory at Northwestern University
and what they found was shocking, literally. From the surface of a single nodule, the team
measured voltages of up to 0.95 volts. For context here, it takes about 1.5 volts of electricity,
about the same as a standard double-a battery, to split seawater through the process of
electrolysis. So here we have some kind of interesting facts starting to come together.
We have evidence of some voltage generation. The oxygen produced in their experiment plateaus,
which could indicate that the energy that drives the splitting of these water molecules
becomes somehow depleted, so maybe the team is correct and that somehow there is a form of
geological battery in operation. Polymetallic nodules are pretty strange structures, typically
forming over millions of years as metals from seawater precipitate onto a nucleating point,
usually something like a fragment of shell, a bone, or a rock, and most of the estimates that
I've seen say they grow at a rate of 1 to 10 millimeters per million years. In the paper,
they hypothesize that the dark oxygen production may have partly resulted from seawater electrolysis,
with the necessary energy coming from the potential difference between metal ions
within the nodule layers, leading to an internal redistribution of electrons.
They go on to say that the geobattery hypothesis is further supported by the link between the dark
oxygen production rate and the average surface area of a nodule. What does that mean? That just
means the bigger these nodules get, the more oxygen they seem to produce. This connection
could be due to an increased abundance of anode and cathode sites, or a greater abundance of high
nickel or copper dendritic porous layers in the larger nodules. However, that kind of opens up
more questions, like why didn't this process deplete a long long time ago? A battery in
practice is actually a very hard thing to get right. I appreciate here that this is still very
early work, but this feels like kind of a weak argument to me because many mechanisms could be
surface area dependent. At the moment, we just don't really know what is actually happening here.
One point I did find interesting though was that there was a theory put forward by the researchers
that potentially the initially very high oxygen production rates that ultimately then plateaued
may have been related to the bow wave of the landing vehicles removing sediments from the
surface of these nodules and exposing electrochromically active sites. This again is
kind of surprising to me and I'm not entirely sure that I'm convinced by that as an explanation.
In my mind, the rate at which these nodules grow is so incredibly slow that the idea that sediment
deposition or removal of that sediment is ultimately the rate limiting step just doesn't
really feel that reasonable to me. But as of yet, we have very little further information.
We do know though that oxygen, it looks like, is being produced and actually that's a really
awkward realisation for the deep sea mining companies that partly funded this research.
If we do find that these polymetric nodules provide essential sources of oxygen for deep sea life,
but potentially also for our planet as a whole, then maybe mining these deposits for resources
could turn out to be a really bad idea. In response to this study, Patrick Downs,
a representative of the Metals Company, one of these deep sea mining companies that funded the work,
said he has serious reservations about the findings, adding that his own analysis suggests
Sweetman's results are due to oxygen contamination from external sources, which would be very
convenient say if you were a mining company that didn't want its operations to ultimately be
disturbed. Apparently a rebuttal article is on its way from this group, so we'll just have to
wait and see. However, this is something we should take seriously. Back in 2016, marine biologists
visited sites that were mined in the 1980s and found that not even bacteria had recovered in
the mined areas, whereas in unmined regions nearby, marine life continued to flourish.
Why such dead zones persist for decades is still kind of unknown. However, this should put a major
asterisk onto strategies for deep sea floor mining, as the faunal diversity on nodule-rich areas
is actually even higher than the most diverse tropical rainforests. A deeper understanding
of how these oxygen generation mechanisms work, and if they are significant to oxygen levels on
our planet, either now or at any time in our past, could be influential to understanding not only how
life evolved on our planet, but also how we look out to our universe to determine if what we are
seeing out there are actually signs of life. If oxygen can be created easily and commonly without
the need for life, our studies looking for molecular oxygen on exoplanets might turn up nothing
more than just a bunch of space rocks. This is a really fascinating and deep topic, and if you are
interested in it, we actually did a video very recently with literally one of the pioneers of
research in this field looking for signs of alien life that are out there in the universe. I'll leave
a link somewhere or down in the description so you can find out more. I want to know what you think
about this breakthrough. I think at the moment there are very little credible other theories
being put forward, but I don't entirely believe this battery argument because the mechanics and
complexity of actually making working batteries that don't instantaneously deplete themselves is
pretty tricky to get right. What else could be causing this? Tell me what you think in the comments
down below. Do you agree with this geobattery hypothesis? Personally, like I said, I'm not convinced.
If you guys really enjoyed this video and you'd like to support the channel more than you already
are by watching, feel free to check out our Patreon page that we literally just launched.
Thank you as always for tuning in. See you guys next week. Goodbye.
