Is it Better to Bake with Expensive Butter?

Food and Nutrition
578 followers
Butter does so many things in desserts. So we're going to look at the effects of
differently priced butters on the volume or aeration in cakes, the spread or tenderness
in a cookie, the flakiness of a laminated dough like a pie dough, and the structure of a frosting.
Now, there are lots of factors that go into determining the price of butter,
but I'm going to focus on the fat content. So generally, as the fat content increases
with your butter, the price goes up as well. So let's start with the cheapest one and the
lowest fat content. And for this, I have Costco Sweet Cream Unsalted Butter. I'm going to be
testing all unsalted butter in this experiment, and this one has 80% fat. It wasn't actually
listed on the box, so I had to contact Costco. They were nice enough to tell me it was 80%.
Let's go up to the next level of fat content and price. For that, we have a popular one.
It's Kerrygold Unsalted. This one is 82% butter fat, and because it's unsalted, it uses cultured
butter. So this is different from this, which I didn't know until I started researching, but
the gold one is the salted Kerrygold. This is sweet cream butter. This one is cultured butter.
So let me back up for a second and explain that. So there are four different types of butter that
are manufactured. There's sweet cream butter, which is basically any butter that doesn't say
cultured, like Costco butter is sweet cream butter. Sweet cream, salted, and unsalted.
And then there's cultured, salted, and unsalted. Okay, sweet cream is kind of a confusing term
because this type of butter is not sweet per se, but it's to differentiate it from cultured butter,
which is made using soured cream. So sweet and sour, right? Soured cream is a ripened cream
that has microbes added to it during manufacturing. They're lactic acid bacteria,
and these bacteria ferment the milk sugar's lactose, and they produce lactic acid, and that's
what gives cultured butter its sour flavor. It also produces a bunch of other aromatic compounds,
which make cultured butter very, very kind of like savory and delicious. This butter is cultured.
This butter is salted and sweet cream. Now, salt is normally used as a preservative. That's probably
why there's a difference. You know, like microbes preserve, salt preserves. That's why there's two
types of Kerrygold. Also, this one has a different fat content. This is only 80% fat. This is 82%
fat, and so that's also why I wanted to use this one because it's a higher fat percentage
than my minimum one. The third one up in price is Plugra, which is also 82% butter fat. The reason
that I'm using this one in addition to Kerrygold, which is 82%, is because I want to see the effects
of culturing or the acidity because this is a more acidic butter on the different baked goods.
This one is using sweet cream, so it's got a regular pH of butter, which I believe is in the
high sixes. So Plugra. Notice how this one says European style. Anything labeled European style
of butter that's labeled European style likely has a higher butter fat content. This is 80%.
This one is 82%, and the reason for that is because the European Union has different standards for
butter. Their minimum requirement is 82% fat, whereas ours is 80% fat. The next one up in price
I have, and the most expensive one, is Strauss Organic. There are a few different butters that
are in this range. This one is 85% butter fat. Let's see here on the label. Also labeled
European style. I am also going to be testing this one, Kirkland Signature Grass-Fed Butter.
This one is salted, but I did have some bakers asking me about it, so I'll probably throw it
into an experiment and see how it does. Let's look at how different butters affect aeration and
volume in cakes using my butter sour cream loaf. This recipe relies on creaming butter and sugar
to create air pockets, which expand during baking with the help of baking powder. I tested four
mini loaves, each using a different butter. Loaf one was the Costco 80%. That's my control loaf,
and it had a single clean crack, even crumb, and a neutral buttery flavor. Loaf two was the Kerry
Gold 82% fat cultured butter, and it had a very similar crumb, but a slightly larger crack and a
tangy flavor from the cultured butter. Loaf three, which was the Pugra 82% fat butter, had a split
crack, a more even crumb, and a grassy butter flavor. Loaf four, which was the Strauss Creamery
85% fat butter, had extra aeration from the higher fat, and that caused minor overflow of the cake
and a slightly denser crumb, but a flavor similar to Costco. So my key takeaways for this is that
for cakes with a creaming step, any of these butters will work well. Higher fat butters may
slightly increase the volume, but can be offset with a moister, denser crumb. So I see this working
really well with chocolate cakes, which err on the side of being fudgier in texture. Personally,
I love the tangy Kerry Gold for this particular recipe, paired really beautifully with the sour
cream. So if you have a cake like that, I think it would work really well. This created a complex,
slightly acidic sweetness in my orange cranberry mini loaves. Now let's discuss how different
butters affect cookie spread using my brown butter chocolate chip cookie recipe. So off the bat, I
noticed that the higher fat butters also made browning a little bit easier because fewer milk
solids were sticking to the bottom of the pan. And since my last video, I can brown butter with my
eyes closed, and all these butters browned very well. I then added these brown butters to separate
cookie doughs, and the results for this one were interesting. I was thinking that the higher fat
butters would have more spread, but the Costco 80%, Plugra 82%, and Strauss 85% fat butters
all spread to the same size, about 8.5 centimeters. The Kerry Gold cultured 82%
butter spread less. And if you watched my black cocoa video, you may already know why. As I said
earlier, Kerry Gold uses soured cream, which is slightly acidic. Acidic ingredients in cookies
prevent them from spreading, which is why these cookies ended up being a little bit chubbier and
taller. They are about 7.5 centimeters. This makes me think of around last year when bakers were
saying that something was wrong with Costco butter, and that when they used Kerry Gold, their cookies
spread less. I wonder if that had to do with the acidity. Anyways, my takeaway for this experiment
is that if I want to make one of those tall, chunky, Levin style cookies, maybe I'll try a
Texture-wise, all of these cookies were indistinguishable. So fat content-wise, there's no
sense in spending more money on butter unless you prefer one's flavor over another. Next, how does
the type of butter affect the tenderness or sandiness of a cookie? I tested this using my
rollable shortbread sugar cookie hybrid recipe. This method involves mixing dry ingredients,
adding softened butter, and thoroughly coating the flour in butter fat. This process prevents
gluten formation and creates a sandy, melt-in-your-mouth texture while allowing the dough to roll out and
hold shapes beautifully. All the cookies maintained their shape regardless of fat level. The Costco 80%
butter had a nice crumbly texture. Kerry Gold delivered a noticeably better sandy texture,
as did the Kirkland grass-fed butter, which I tested in this recipe. The Plugra 82% butter
produced a wonderful sandy crumb, and the Strauss 85% butter offered a slight increase in sandiness.
The most significant textural improvement was between 80% and 82% fat, with diminishing returns
after that. And shortbread cookies like this really highlight the butter's flavor, so pick
one that you love. My favorite was Plugra. It made a cookie with a classic, rich, buttery flavor and
sublime sandy texture. Next up is laminated dough using my all-butter pie crust. Laminated doughs
rely on cold butterflakes dispersed throughout the dough. As the dough bakes, the butter melts,
and the water creates steam, pushing up thin layers of crispy, flaky pastry. I cut the dough
into circles before baking so that we could observe the layers. The Costco 80% butter produced
nice flake, but shrank more significantly than the others, and I think this is likely due to
the higher water content, which is interacting with the flour's gluten. With Kerry Gold 82%
fat butter, the layers became more distinct, with visible spaces between them. It was very similar
with the Plugra 82%, more layers and nice space between the layers. The Strauss 85% fat butter
was more challenging to work with. The butter crumbled instead of forming flakes, and I didn't
think it was going to work out, but it baked beautifully. It had these delicate, crispy layers
that shattered when you bit into it. The flavor, however, was very similar to the Costco butter,
whereas the Kerry Gold and Plugra had very distinct flavor profiles. And as someone who's
always used Costco butter for my pies, my family loves pie. They're actually a pie family, not a
cake family, which is kind of surprising. This experiment was eye-opening for me. While the 80%
butter worked really well, splurging on the 82% or even the 85% butter elevates that flaky pastry
significantly. Finally, let's talk buttercreams. I tested my American Dreamy buttercream because
it's an emulsion that also requires dissolving powdered sugar in the water content of the butter.
Since I work with buttercreams often, I had some expectations going in. Butter's crystallized fats
play a huge role in giving buttercreams their stability and solid texture. However, increasing
the butterfat content didn't show any noticeable improvement in quality or stability. So here's my
key takeaway. For American buttercreams, which rely heavily on powdered sugar, stick with the 80%
butter for its higher water content. It's going to help dissolve that extra sugar a little bit
more easily. For other buttercreams like meringue-based ones or custard-based, any butter works.
So you can choose based on flavor. If you need a white buttercream, however, look for the whitest
butter. So you're going to avoid grass-fed options because those can have a yellowish tint. Though
generally speaking, I think splurging on a high-fat butter isn't totally necessary here.
