How The Polio Vaccine Destroyed Trust In Healthcare

NUS Medicine
8 followers
Dec 18, 2024
What would you say if I told you a doctor invented a vaccine worth $7 billion,
but didn't see a single penny?
That he tested his experimental drug on his own children?
That his vaccine would go on to save the lives of millions of people,
but that it would also lay the foundation of skepticism
towards the government that would last for well over 70 years?
Well, that doctor is real.
His name is Dr. Jonas Salk, and this is his unbelievable story.
Jonas Salk was born in 1914 in New York City
to his Russian Jewish immigrant parents.
He was a brilliant student, which shouldn't come as a surprise,
because you know that Russian Jewish immigrant doctors in New York City
always get the job done.
He breezed through school ahead of schedule
before getting into the highly competitive City College of New York
at just 15 years old, and eventually NYU School of Medicine.
It was here Jonas came face to face with actual patients
and came to realize he didn't like treating them.
He didn't want to treat a single patient.
In contrast, he wanted to treat millions.
After completing his residency, Jonas was faced with a dilemma.
The year was 1941, and America had entered World War II.
As a medical professional, he was given a choice
between enlisting in the war effort or staying home to pursue a scientific task.
He thought, why not both?
So he worked alongside Dr. Thomas Francis at the University of Michigan,
where they developed a successful vaccine for the flu,
saving countless lives of soldiers fighting on the frigid front line.
After success with one virus, he quickly set his sights on a new one, polio.
Poliomyelitis, or polio for short, can be absolutely brutal.
You see, most people who contract polio won't have any physical symptoms,
but not everyone is that lucky.
Others will develop flu-like symptoms that could clear up on their own
or lead to the development of meningitis,
or even worse, develop paralysis and death.
In fact, polio wasn't a new virus.
It was around for thousands of years, mysteriously paralyzing people
and forcing sufferers to walk with canes like in these Egyptian hieroglyphs.
In the early 1900s, polio cases in New York surged, leading to nationwide panic.
And as we all know with panic, snake oil cures are sure to follow.
Thank God TikTok wasn't around back then though.
People tried all sorts of remedies like earthworm oil and blackberry brandy.
Rumors spread about the benefits of oxblood,
so New York families actually waited outside of slaughterhouses with empty buckets.
Doctors experimented on patients by draining spinal fluid from children
while injecting their veins with salt solutions.
The treatments weren't just ineffective,
but oftentimes deadly, killing patients instead of saving them.
Polio could strike anyone at any time, and in the 1920s, it struck the wrong man.
Future American President Franklin Delano Roosevelt,
who soon found himself confined to a wheelchair.
Polio cases soared by over 700% between 1938 and 1943.
Something had to be done.
Research and development for a cure or at least a vaccine was just desperately needed.
But with a nation climbing out of the depths of a depression
and a second world war on the way, who's going to foot that bill?
Well, FDR answered the call and launched the March of Dimes,
a national drive for people to send in their pocket change
to aid in polio research.
Movie stars like Eddie Cantor promoted it far and wide,
as did American sweetheart Shirley Temple.
The thought was everyone in America, no matter how rich or how poor,
could spare a dime, and boy did they.
What resulted was basically the greatest Kickstarter campaign in history.
Men, women, and especially children furiously donated their pocket change.
In just the first three days of the campaign,
200,000 letters and 2.6 million dimes
were received by the White House.
The campaign was such a success, America put FDR's face on the dime itself.
With millions in the government's pockets, FDR now had one question.
Where and how should he spend the money?
Like a Hollywood agent looking to sign the next big movie star,
the government started asking, who's the next big name in virology?
It didn't take long for Jonas Salk's name to emerge as a leading candidate
to head polio research, and so the funding came.
Jonas was granted millions to build state-of-the-art facilities,
purchase cutting-edge equipment, and recruit a team of virologists
unlike any the world had ever seen.
Jonas Salk became the Dick Fury of medicine,
assembling his own team of Avengers aimed at one thing,
making polio, the Thanos of diseases, disappear.
Jonas and his team got to work,
devoting every waking hour and resource available for years to the task.
But Jonas wasn't alone.
Funding had also gone to a scientist named Dr. Albert Sabin,
who'd built out his own team and department committed to ending polio.
Sort of like the Justice League to Salk's Avengers.
The two doctors, however, had different approaches.
Dr. Sabin was attempting to create a vaccine using a live sample of polio,
meaning a patient would ingest a living but weakened form of the virus
in the hopes the body would be able to beat the weak virus and build up immunity,
similar to treatments that we've used for other diseases like smallpox.
Jonas was skeptical.
By ingesting a live version of polio, yes, your body could develop immunity,
but also you run the risk of the virus getting stronger and killing you,
especially if you're immunocompromised.
To Jonas, it seemed like too great of a risk.
Instead, he wanted to develop a killed or inactivated vaccine,
which was much less likely to infect you because, well, it was already dead.
Salk and Sabin's teams worked neck and neck in the wake of World War II,
but they were running out of time.
In 1943, there were 10,000 cases of polio in the U.S.
By 1952, there were 59,000.
According to a national poll,
polio was the second biggest fear for Americans behind only the atomic bomb.
But Jonas wasn't afraid.
He was determined.
He logged long nights, fumed over failed tests, cried for more funding,
actually put the government into debt,
but eventually Jonas made progress.
Finally, Salk had a version of his vaccine he felt confident in,
and to prove its efficacy,
he eventually decided to test it on the things he cared about most,
his own wife and children.
One night after coming home from work,
Jonas lined his wife and three young sons up in the kitchen.
They stood there and watched him sterilize needles over the flame of the stove.
One by one, Jonas injected his family with his own polio vaccine,
which is an incredible risk to take with your own flesh and blood.
But luckily, it worked.
What followed became the largest medical test in history at the time,
where 1.8 million polio pioneers tested the vaccine,
guided by Jonas and his former mentor, Dr. Thomas Francis.
Together, they poured over the data and eventually decided it wasn't perfect,
but they had a relatively safe and effective vaccine.
A press conference was called for at the Vaccine Evaluation Center
at the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor.
And typically, scientists announcing test results
are done in dull, sterile rooms with little fanfare,
but not this time.
Salk was quoted as saying,
I actually thought I'd go to that meeting, hear the report,
read a paper of my own, talk to a few newsmen,
and return to my lab the next day.
Instead, Jonas found himself surrounded
by the largest announcement in the history of medicine.
It was April 1955, exactly 10 years after the death of FDR.
By this point, over a hundred million Americans
had contributed to the March of Dimes.
Nearly two million children had been polio pioneers.
The nation was captivated by the story of the vaccine.
500 people, including newspaper and television reporters,
crammed into the salmon-colored auditorium.
Cameras lined the walls.
Around the country, 54,000 doctors sat in movie theaters
watching the broadcast on closed-circuit television.
Department stores turned on loudspeakers
to play the radio broadcast
as crowds gathered in the streets across the world.
They shared a long but clear message.
Salk's vaccine works.
The nation erupted with joy.
Church bells rang through the streets,
factories held moment of silence for those lost to the disease,
and places of worship held celebratory group prayers.
The vaccine soon hit the market,
and parents rushed to get it for their children.
Minutes before singing on the Ed Sullivan Show,
Elvis Presley actually received the vaccine
backstage to incentivize young people.
And it worked immediately.
From 1957 to 1961, the number of polio cases in the U.S.
fell from 58,000 to only 161.
When you look at those numbers,
the rollout was an enormous success.
But it came with a side effect.
Fame.
With such an immediate decline in polio cases
and a newfound peace of mind,
Americans demanded someone to thank.
And the name Dr. Jonas Salk soon swept across the country.
Jonas found himself on the cover of magazines.
He was recognized while out to dinner with his family.
He sat across the table
from the most powerful newsmakers and television,
like Edward R. Murrow, who said,
young man, a great tragedy has befallen you.
You've lost your anonymity.
For Jonas, this was in many ways tragic.
He never set out to be a celebrity.
He wanted to work in his lab,
cure disease and save lives.
His high profile weighed on him.
It's as if I've been a public property
ever since the vaccine.
It's brought me enormous gratification,
opened many opportunities,
but at the same time placed many burdens on me.
It altered my career, my relationships with colleagues.
I'm a public figure, no longer one of them.
Along with the fame came fortune,
or it could have if Jonas had patented his work.
This would make Jonas the owner of his research and discovery,
allowing him to effectively sell the vaccine
and get paid every single time a patient was vaccinated.
It's been estimated that the patent on the polio vaccine
would be worth $7 billion, but Jonas said no.
Who owns the patent on this vaccine?
Well, the people, I would say.
There is no patent.
Could you patent the sun?
Surely a humble statement from a brilliant man,
but not everyone felt that way.
You see while Salk saved the day by delivering the vaccine,
the biggest public health disaster of all time
was still looming.
Once Salk's vaccine was proven safe and effective,
the nation went into high gear
producing as much as possible.
Five pharmaceutical companies were given the green light
to manufacture the vaccine,
including Cutter Pharmaceuticals in California.
Unlike the others, Cutter was inexperienced
with this specific level of vaccine production
and failed to properly kill the polio virus within the shot,
accidentally sending out a live vaccine
instead of an inactivated one.
While this ended up giving people protection,
it simultaneously gave some people the actual illness.
To make matters worse,
Cutter's vaccine actually caused a more severe case of polio
than the one occurs naturally.
This meant the children who received Cutter's vaccine
were more likely to be paralyzed in the arm
where they received the injection,
more likely to suffer permanent paralysis,
more likely to require the assistance
of an iron lung to breathe,
and more likely to die
than if they hadn't been vaccinated at all.
The Cutter incident resulted in 40,000 cases of polio,
leaving 200 people paralyzed,
most of them children, 10 died.
Jonas was distraught over the accident,
despite the fact he wasn't even to blame.
When manufactured properly following his strict instructions,
Salk's vaccine was safe and effective,
but poor direction from the federal government
and inexperience on the part of Cutter combined
were to blame.
Regardless, Jonas said,
that was the first and only time in my life
that I felt like dying.
There was no hope.
While this mistake was alarming,
it was discovered and rectified quickly.
The affected batch was pulled from the shelves,
weeks after launch,
and to this day,
it's estimated that 1.5 million childhood lives
have been saved thanks to Dr. Salk.
According to vaccine expert, Dr. Paul Offit,
who you've seen on this channel.
The Cutter incident was a painful lesson
about the fact that we needed much better oversight.
And it's actually why we enjoy a level of vaccine safety
unmatched by any other medical product.
But somehow the drama continues.
Understandably, the Cutter incident
caused a significant spike in distrust
of medical institutions
and public pressure mounted in such a way
that the US government pivoted off of Salk's vaccine
in favor of the one created by Dr. Sabin.
Let me emphasize how wild this is.
The Salk vaccine was safe and worked,
but because one company made a manufacturing mistake,
it caused the public to demand the vaccine
to be replaced by the one
that was actually more dangerous.
Sabin's live vaccine became available in the early 60s
and could be taken orally in the form of a sugar cube.
That made it ideal for developing nations
where a child might only visit the doctor
once in their entire life.
So polio rates continue to plummet
with all natural cause polio in the US
being fully eliminated in 1979.
Success!
Polio was officially gone, right?
Not so fast.
Remember, because Sabin's vaccine was live,
it always carried a chance of infection
with about one in every 750,000 children
becoming paralyzed after receiving the vaccine.
That's why there were still six to eight cases of children
becoming paralyzed by polio every year,
despite the naturally caused cases being zero.
Literally it was because we overreacted,
we ended up creating more cases of polio
than if we used the original Salk vaccine.
Jonas couldn't stand this.
He knew the Cutter incident was isolated
and that his inactivated vaccine was safer.
Vaccine-caused polio was just unacceptable to him.
This ignited a decades-long back and forth
between Salk and Sabin.
The two were bitter rivals.
Salk was angered by the world's use of the live vaccine
and the subsequent infections it caused,
while Sabin no doubt was jealous
of Jonas's enormous celebrity.
According to a survey conducted in 1958,
Jonas was one of America's top two
most well-known living scientists,
alongside J. Robert Oppenheimer,
who developed the atomic bomb.
When Sabin was awarded a National Medal of Science
by Richard Nixon,
he corrected the president's speech
by declaring he has not developed a vaccine,
but the vaccine.
That's a bar that even Kendrick and Drake
could be proud of.
However, Jonas never backed down
and continued railing against the use of Sabin's vaccine
until the 90s,
when at long last,
the United States finally came to their senses
over the Cutter incident
and switched to using Salk's vaccine exclusively.
Albert Sabin's live sample polio vaccine
is actually no longer available
in the United States of America.
However, it is still in use around the world
and together both vaccines have helped us isolate
the few remaining polio cases
to just remote pockets of Afghanistan and Pakistan.
Jonas spent the rest of his life
working at his Salk Institute for Biological Studies
in Southern California,
where he developed treatments for AIDS
and other conditions,
never breaking from his commitment to saving lives.
He died in 1995 at the age of 80 from heart failure,
never fully escaping the relentless pursuit of his celebrity.
And perhaps he shouldn't.
His work is responsible for saving millions of lives
and he did so without accepting a single penny,
though he did put a few dimes to good use.
While he may be gone,
I'm left remembering one of his more powerful lines
about science, medicine, and the human spirit.
And if I think of evolution as an error-making
and error-correcting process
that we're constantly learning from experience
and to choose an activity or a life
that is of value not only to yourself,
but to others as well.
Dr. Ignace Semmelweis not only made
the remarkable discovery
that washing your hands save lives,
but he was also murdered for it.
So click here to learn that story.
And as always, stay happy and healthy.
