Mold, algae': Insurance drops SF homeowners, citing aerial footage of roof; inspector refutes claim
Dec 16, 2024 #business
#business
After the insurance non-renewal, the couple hired a roof inspector who told them their roof is good for another 20 years. "Perfect, I don't see nothing wrong with it," he said.
They sent pictures with no pointing to it, there wasn't any option to fix it.
We don't trust them at all.
Seven On Your Side investigates Liberty Mutual Insurance and its use of aerial footage to
make decisions on your coverage.
And lots of people have been dropped by insurance companies in recent years.
Seven On Your Side, Stephanie Sierra is digging into a case that's raising a lot of questions
about the accuracy of this process.
She joins us with this developing story.
Hey, Steph.
Yeah, this has been an interesting case.
Liberty Mutual Insurance says they don't use drones to assess property risk.
However, according to this report, the company obtained aerial images that were used as the
basis for dropping a local homeowner's policy.
And as the couple later found out, the reason cited turned out to be false.
Since 1976, I've never missed a payment.
Meet Karen and Tony Hoover.
Liberty Mutual has insured their San Francisco Victorian for nearly 50 years.
That's until last week, when they got this letter from the company dropping them, claiming
aerial footage found moss, mildew, algae and mold on their roof.
They sent me some aerial views that showed absolutely nothing.
I couldn't even believe that.
You can't see one mark of discoloration, anything.
Here's a close-up of the pictures Liberty Mutual provided that appear to be from Google
Earth.
All they do is show this picture, the whole roof looking down.
But like any good-faith homeowners, the Hoovers wanted to be sure.
They hired Excelsior Roofing to do a follow-up inspection, a licensed and well-respected
roofing company that's been doing business in the city for more than 100 years and has
an A-plus rating with the Better Business Bureau.
We showed up for it, and the inspector told us.
So is the roof okay?
Yes.
I don't see nothing wrong with it.
No kidding.
It's perfect.
So no mold, no algae?
Nothing at all.
In fact, he told them the roof is actually good for another 20 years.
And the report he compiled included more than a dozen photos from every angle, even close-ups
of the shingles, clear of any growth.
I've been infuriated.
So the Hoovers appealed Liberty Mutual's decision, including the inspection report disproving
the alleged problems.
But over the past three weeks, heard nothing.
That's until 7 On Your Side got involved and reached out directly to the company's CEO.
We were told by his staff, we are reaching out to Ms. Hoover directly to address her
concerns.
Home inspections have long been a standard in the insurance underwriting process, which
can include plane-derived aerial reviews.
Within an hour after our follow-up questions, the company reissued the Hoovers' insurance
policy.
7 On Your Side did an incredible job.
Thank you so very much from the bottom of our hearts.
Happy to help.
But the couple is still frustrated it took a news agency to get them answers.
After doing business with Liberty since 1976.
I just feel like it was pressure not to have bad press, that we're just one example.
Liberty Mutual has been disappointing us.
Attorney Amy Bach is the executive director of United Policy Holders, a non-profit that's
pushing for legislation that would require insurers to be more transparent with non-renewals.
So what we want insurers to do is to tell the homeowner what conditions at their property
are out of compliance.
Number two, give the homeowner a reasonable amount of time to remedy those conditions.
If they remedy those conditions, offer them a renewal policy.
Right there, the Brown House.
Just like the Hoovers, except to their disappointment, their family home right across the street
was dropped too, citing the same roof issues.
There wasn't any option to fix it.
So it's situations like that United Policy Holders is trying to prevent with their latest
proposal.
And Amy Bach says legislation is already in the works and is expected to be introduced
next session.
But what do you think about it?
It's common sense, right?
If consumers fix the issue, you'd hope you get your policy back.
But clearly that's not happening.
Yeah.
Wow.
And it seems like there was a lot of back and forth in this story.
Is there a broader issue in general with Liberty Mutual?
Yeah.
No, it's interesting.
I mean, we are seeing this with all insurers, but Amy Bach did point out Liberty Mutual
as an example with respect to the inconsistencies.
They're being very inconsistent with every homeowner policies that she has come across.
And she thinks that's part of the issue, that they don't have a clear set of rules here.

