Is the Mk18 Reliable? Colt/Daniel Defense Torture Test

S&W
1 follower
15 Video Views·Dec 15, 2024
The M16 introduced in 1964 is a fantastic rifle,
but with a 20-inch barrel and a fixed stock,
it wasn't ideal for close-quarter combat
and confined spaces.
In 1991, the M4A1 was introduced to special operators,
and with it, a 14.5-inch barrel and collapsible buttstock,
making it a little bit handier in close quarters
and in vehicles, even if it reduced the velocity
and thus the range of the .223 round
used by the M16 family.
If you wanted something even more compact than that,
the go-to 30 years ago was typically
the famous MP5 submachine gun, a 9mm,
which is, of course, less effective than the .223.
But around the year 2000,
the special operations community managed
to make a reliable M4 with a 10-inch barrel
if certain modifications were made
to the gas operating system.
With that, the Mark 18 CQBR,
or close-quarters battle rifle, was born,
and it took the place, for the most part,
of the 9mm submachine gun.
As an example of the superiority of the Mark 18,
a .223 round fired from a Mark 18
will drop around a foot and a half at 300 yards,
but a 9mm projectile fired from an MP5
will drop nearly 10 feet over the same distance.
Also, a study from the DoD, Department of Defense,
indicated that .556 is actually just as effective
as .308 on human targets inside of 50 yards.
FYI, I've linked all of these reports in the description,
so you can go down, read them if you want to,
and you know I'm not pulling all of this
out of my ass right now.
There are a lot of authorities out there
seeing M16 derivatives like the Mark 18 as obsolete,
and piston-operated rifles are becoming the norm.
A great example is the NGSW program
and the subsequent adoption by the U.S. military
of the MCX Spear, the SEALs using the HK416
for the past few years,
and SOCOM adopting the MCX Rattler,
all of them piston-operated guns.
Piston-operated rifles have a well-deserved reputation
for working well with a suppressor,
slogging through fouling, dirt, dust, and abuse
with more enthusiasm than the simple
and lightweight direct impingement system used by the M16.
After all, other nerds out there will remember
the controversial 2007 Aberdeen dust test
that pitted the M4 against three
competing piston-operated designs,
and the test allegedly showed that the M4
will have three to six times the stoppages
as a piston-operated gun under the same sandy conditions,
allegedly.
It's generally accepted that piston-operated rifles
do tend to be more reliable
because they trap carbon fouling
and they vent hot gases from large gas tubes over the barrel
instead of directing that carbon and gas
right back into the bolt carrier group,
keeping the main operating components
of a piston-operated gun cleaner and cooler than a DI gun.
But despite their benefits,
piston-operated guns are usually heavier, more expensive,
they use more parts than direct impingement systems,
and they often have greater felt recoil
and lower accuracy than M16 descendants.
Not all the time, though.
Are piston guns worth the trade-off for greater reliability?
To answer that, you have to ask
how reliable is the Mark 18 anyways?
Let's say if you hypothetically fired
1,200 to 1,500 rounds through one,
buried it in sand, tossed it around a little bit,
but you had no malfunctions.
Would you need something more reliable than that?
I mean, fuck it.
Let's say you did it all suppressed
with the silencer only increasing the amount of fouling,
back pressure, and gas coming back to the rifle.
What would happen then?
How long before this gun quits?
That's what we do in today's video.
A real Mark 18 in a Special Forces operator's hands
would probably be made up of a hodgepodge
of Colt LMT Daniel Defense Knight's Armament parts
to try to get as close as possible
to what would be currently used as a Mark 18.
I got the new Daniel Defense R3 Mark 18.
You guys know I love DD.
SOCOM has most recently adopted
the Daniel Defense RIS handguard,
and their 10.3-inch Colthammer forged barrels,
and while Knights is cool because it's hard to find,
even SOCOM is moving in the Daniel Defense direction.
So if you're thinking about planning a Mark 18 build,
the Mark 18 R3 Upper that I'm using here
is probably better and easier to find
than anything else out there.
We mated the DD R3 Upper with a pretty beat-up
full-auto Colt Lower from an actual M4
to get what would be pretty much an identical copy
of a real Mark 18.
To up the ante, the gang at Silencer Shop
sent me a silencer that was just adopted by the FBI,
the Huxworks Flow 556K.
Really excited to work with it.
The Flow's a 3D-printed 17.4 stainless steel silencer.
Claims to be full-auto rated, uses flow-through technology,
which theoretically sends more gas downrange
instead of upstream back into the rifle
and towards the operator.
So we put that to the test,
and I frankly set out to destroy the Flow 556 in this test.
I mean, it's not my can, I don't really give a shit.
They're really hard to get right now,
but if you're looking for a Flow 556,
then I would check out our guys at Silencer Shop.
Homies at Ventura Munitions sent me
a thousand rounds of Wolf Gold
to run through this gun as fast as possible,
and to help me with that task,
I enlisted the Pensacola Police Department.
PPD was kind enough to not only let me participate
in their monthly SWAT drills with the Mark 18 in full-auto,
but they also helped me run an absolute brass train
on this gun when training was over for the day,
using their own ammo to burn the Mark 18 up
in addition to mine.
I didn't clean or lube this gun the entire time,
so when did it fail?
Obviously, running it a couple of hours in drills,
no sweat for a Mark 18.
After maybe 250 to 350 rounds in semi-auto and full-auto,
we didn't have one problem.
But when training was over,
about a dozen SWAT officers stayed behind
and waited in line with full magazines
to dump one after the other,
turning money into noise,
getting some pics for the gram, whatever.
We ran my thousand rounds of Wolf,
plus the ammo the PPD guys shot through the gun.
We lost count.
In total, no less than 1,200 rounds,
and Ryan and I guessed it was more likely around 1,500,
somewhere between 40 and 50 mags worth.
Surprisingly, the Mark 18 and the Flow 556 got after it,
surviving mag after mag after mag.
It didn't take long before we had to wear gloves
just to hold the gun.
Related to that, the suppressor got so hot
that it burned my blue force gear sling attachment.
It started a small grass fire
that we didn't catch on camera,
and it burned through my glove
and gave my thumb a pretty nasty blister
when I accidentally touched the tube.
The gun would even get too hot to hold
even if you had gloves.
Because it was radiating heat,
like you could feel it on your face
when you held the gun up to shoot it.
So we cooled the gas block area and suppressor down
with water a couple of times,
and some Red Bull once,
just in case the gun was getting a little sleepy.
Incredibly, the gun and suppressor kept working,
actually sounding pretty good,
even though we were starting to blow flames
out of the end cap.
We had no malfunctions until...
Might be ammo.
Really shitty batch of Wolf ammo.
You know, that's what happens
when you get the cheap stuff.
So after the 700 or 800 round mark,
we started getting light primer strikes on Wolf.
We weren't sure if the problem was with the cheap ammo
or if it was an issue with the gun.
Then we started to get more light strikes
with both Federal and Wolf.
That's when my buddy, Brian Marshall
of the Star Training Academy,
asked me if I remembered
to drop the correct Mark 18 heavy buffer in the buffer tube.
Of course I did.
We're running a Colt M16 lower on here,
non-transferable, of course, government property.
So that means it had a shitty old spring
and a regular buffer in it.
So we were having some light primer strikes,
plus we're shooting Wolf ammo,
not really known as being the most reliable.
We just put the Daniel Defense spring and buffer in here.
So it's an H1 buffer.
That seems to have fixed the issue,
but let's double check.
Yeah, so I would say so.
I think the issue has been fully resolved.
Now with the H buffer and the proper spring,
I totally forgot.
And why does that matter?
Without getting too involved into a discussion
about dwell time and gas tube length,
the Mark 18 typically runs a heavier buffer
than the standard 14 or 16 inch M4s.
And I completely forgot to install the Mark 18 heavy buffer
on the M4 lower we were using.
We swapped it out, put the H buffer in,
and not only did the gun start running 100% again,
but the recoil was lighter
and the ejection pattern became more consistent as well.
Lookers on, passerby, and shooters alike
were all amazed at how well this gun was running,
having no malfunctions other than the ones caused
by me being an idiot.
I mean, it's still running.
We started to run out of ammo.
The Mark 18 wasn't giving up,
so we decided to up the ante a little bit,
have some fun with it, see if we could make it fail.
We completely buried it in sand,
which some say is a weak point for the M4,
but I picked it up, racked the charging handle
off to the races with no malfunctions.
We even tossed it around the range a little bit
to see if we could induce any failures or breakages
from what would be a pretty unreasonable amount of abuse.
And still nothing, the gun ran just fine.
Ready, one more?
Can't believe that.
I mean, this thing's been running,
we treat it like shit all day today.
It smells like ass, to be perfectly honest.
So I've been really impressed with this combo all day today.
Right before we walked off the range,
I did choke slam this Mark 18 into the sand.
So when I go to charge it,
the top round took a bunch of sand in with it.
I had to mortar it to clear the chamber,
racked it a few times, got one chambered,
and we were back in business
for the last few mags of the day.
Oh, dude, we have got this thing fucked up now.
It actually, it charged.
All right, here we go.
There we go, just needed a...
In summary, we ran anywhere between 1,200 and 1,500 rounds
through a Daniel Defense Mark 18 upper, Colt lower,
with the Huxworks Flow 556K suppressor installed,
full auto, virtually nonstop,
and the only failures we had were light primer strikes
when I forgot to replace the buffer.
So that was on me.
And then the one time where I slammed the gun into the sand
with an open dust cover, face down.
Frankly, I was really impressed with the results,
and I'm not sure that civilian LARPers like us,
or even special operators,
need something more reliable than that.
And my conclusion seems to jibe with the consensus
about the M4 and the Mark 18 out there.
If you remember the 2007 Aberdeen Dust Test
that I cited above,
well, yeah, the M4 did have more malfunctions
than the FN SCAR, the HK XM8, or 416.
It was still less than 1.5% of the time,
and that's just a plain Jane mil-spec M4,
not the DD Mark 18, which I would assume would fare better.
In that theme, in 2013, Naval Surface Warfare Center
think of this as like the Navy SEAL Laboratory,
they released an extremely detailed study
and found that firing the Mark 18 suppressed
and unsuppressed, alternating,
led to a 0.65% failure rate in guns using PMAGs
after 12,600 rounds.
Funny enough, standard aluminum GI mags
were half as reliable as PMAGs.
To be fair, the guns were lubed every 600 rounds
and cleaned every 1,200 rounds,
so that should be considered, obviously.
But tell me, what do you think?
Bear in mind that in 2006,
the Center for Naval Analysis, CNA,
they polled over 2,000 operators
who used the M4 in combat in the Middle East,
and 89% of them said they were satisfied
with the M4's performance.
So before you pop off in the comments
from your Xbox controller,
remember that regardless of what all the studies say,
all the testing says,
the guys who actually used the M4 in the field
had overwhelmingly favorable impressions.
But go ahead and tell me what you think in the comments.
Guys, we don't take money
in exchange for favorable reviews.
Please think about supporting us on Youtreon, Patreon,
Subscribestar, whatever.
Check the link below.
We give away free guns, we give away free swag,
we give away gear to say thank you,
so please consider supporting us,
helping us out a little bit.
Thank you, as usual, to Ventura Munitions
for sending us the ammo we used in this test.
And if you wanna pick up some Daniel Defense,
make sure to check out our sponsors at Top Gun Supply,
your online shooting sports superstore.
But thanks again for watching.
Take care.
