Tow Truck Shortage Threatens California Freeway Rescue Services | Mark Baatz

California Insider Show
1.9K followers
989 Video Views·Dec 14, 2024
California's tow truck industry is at a crossroads. New regulations push for zero-emission vehicles, but the technology needed for heavy-duty services is falling short. Essential roadside assistance could face major setbacks, impacting drivers statewide. In this episode, Siyamak sits down with industry expert Mark Baatz to uncover how these rules are reshaping operations, why diesel restrictions are creating supply shortages, and what the future holds for critical public services. Watch now to understand the high stakes for California's roads and businesses.
*Views expressed in this video/article are opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of California Insider.
If you have ever been stuck on the freeway after a car accident or in the need of roadside
assistance to tow your car, now imagine a future where roadside assistance isn't just slow but
potentially very hard to get. California is phasing out diesel trucks in favor of cleaner
alternatives like electric trucks but unfortunately there is a catch. It's very difficult to produce
electric tow trucks and manufacturers are hesitant to make them. Today we sit down with Mark Batts,
owner of Tow Industries, one of the California's largest suppliers of tow trucks. He'll explain
what's at stake for Californians and how the towing industry is facing the challenges of
transforming to electric. By the way, you need to know that most of these trucks are not the trucks
that are towing you when you park in the wrong place but most of them are the ones that come
to assist you when you're stuck on the roadside or when there's an accident and they come and clear
the roads. I'm Siamak Karami, welcome to California Insider.
Mark, it's great to have you on, welcome. I appreciate you having me. There's an initiative
that CARB has brought up and it's impacting you guys, the tow truck industry. Can you tell us
what's happening? I'll start real quick with a quick introduction. Obviously my name is Mark,
last name is Batts, my company is Tow Industries. For 40 years we've been supplying trucks to the
roadside services that backs up police agencies in their job, that handles accidents, CHP work,
the Metro Transit Authority, the large trucks that work for the Metro Transit Authority,
Freeway Service Patrol that keeps traffic moving during rush hour. This is where our trucks end up.
Private companies will buy them? Thank you, some of them are private companies,
some of them are government owned. Another large group that we serve are AAA Auto Club and other
Auto Club service contractors. These are the people that are committed to going to help you
when your battery fails, when your car doesn't start, you're involved in an accident, many of
you are insured by the Auto Club. These are their agents of service. So all of these groups that I'm
describing and I can go on, I call them essential services and I think as I describe them you'll
agree they are essential services. And what's happened is with the CARB's effort to clean up
the air, there's a movement towards what we call ZEV, Zero Emission Vehicles. And with that,
that speaks to electric specific or hydrogen, but electric is the predominant truck. There are now
ratios in place, so many diesels are allowed on the road to how many electrics are coming to the
road. And in our particular industry, there isn't an electric truck that works. The ratio is one
electric truck for every nine diesels that are allowed into the state. So with a limited number
of electrics being produced or coming into the state, you can see how that, we don't have the
one to bring in the nine, so you're not seeing that much electric coming in. You don't see any
that serves our particular industry. There's no manufacturer right now that is making. There are
electrics being made, they don't work in the towing business specifically, and they all have
limitations through all industries in that they only go so far, they're heavy, they're expensive.
There are a number of things that make it difficult in our industry, regardless of cost.
There isn't an electric truck that works for us at this time. That next technology hasn't arrived
for us yet. So the number of diesels coming into the state has been constricted dramatically. Where
we moved, you know, 600 trucks a year last year, we might only get 30, 40, 50 trucks next year
because of the constrictions. There's not enough electric to allow enough diesels into the state.
When does this regulation go in place? Is it already in place? Regulations already in place, as of the,
as of January 1st of this year. So how would this impact us? Now the first thing that happens is, if
we're, if the number of trucks to us is restricted in a great way, we simply can't build new ones.
We can't exist with, without building new trucks. So first and foremost, the first that, the first
people that are hit is us. If we don't have the trucks to put bodies on, to put out on the road,
we'll be impacted quickly in that we won't have stuff to build first. The second piece of it is,
the entity that's doing this, these essential services that I refer to, will not be able to
buy new trucks. And that will make their business difficult. The Metro Transit Authority, for example,
or the Freeway Service Program on the road, you live in Los Angeles, it's the free service that's
on the freeway. Should you break down, run out of gas, whatever it is, it's free service on the freeway,
white trucks. Those contracts are typically three-year, four-year. As those contracts rotate out,
the demand is that they all have new trucks when they go on each and every, at the commencement
of every contract. Without new trucks, those numbers are going to be affected. They won't be able to get the contracts.
They won't get the trucks to satisfy the contract. The trucks that are on the road
are the ones that are now being classified as dirty. Well, you're keeping the older, dirtier
trucks longer because there aren't replacements. The trucks that we put on now, of course, are to the,
it's not electric, but the diesels are the cleanest. These new trucks are the cleanest diesels
yet. So as time goes on, and we can't use these cleaner trucks, the dirtier ones stay on
the road. And we just, we don't have that next change out, call it to cleaner trucks or to the
electrics. At the end of the day, our customer doesn't have the trucks that he needs to keep his
business moving forward. And these trucks do wear out, meaning they do. So the end users, it will probably
impact them. Absolutely. They'll run short of trucks. So the, for, if there's accidents in the freeway,
it could be. You brought me right to it. Exactly. You're going to find that these, I call them
essential services, are going to be starving for the new equipment they need to keep their
communities moving and their businesses moving. You mentioned that this regulation will cause some
of the trucks to be moving out of, there will be less trucks available. Sure. And then as a result
of it, we're going to have potentially less essential services. Sure. Are there any other
challenges? There's only one other thing I didn't mention, and there are carve-outs for used vehicles
coming in from other, out of other states. If you can imagine, a new tow truck that is not compliant
in California only has to have 7,500 miles on it in order to be brought into California, and it can
be registered here. So it encourages a dealer, for example, or a builder of a truck in Arizona,
to sell it to somebody, have them run 7,500 miles on it, and then it's saleable into California.
So you can bypass all of these regulations if you're used. Right. And the California trucks
that are all coming in, the other thing that we didn't speak of was, they're all tagged with a
penalty. You pay $9,000 more for a California truck. For the diesel one. For the diesel one,
because it's being marked for extinction. There's a penalty that, so it's $9,000 more expensive than
you can buy it in Arizona. So as it becomes increasingly more difficult for a tow truck
driver, for a towing entity to buy a new truck, he can go to Arizona and buy it used,
right, if it's got 7,500 miles on it. It's non-compliant. You're bringing in a dirty truck,
and you're harming the California suppliers because Arizona is being given the business.
So nothing's been accomplished. You're bringing in, you're not getting rid of dirty trucks,
and you're not supporting California business. And it's a loophole that just shouldn't be there.
But for the California group of suppliers, we saw this shortage coming, and it pushed us
to buy in large volume trucks that are compliant today and would be compliant moving forward,
so that we could keep our business moving until there was some resolution with CARB that we
hopefully were going to achieve. So at the beginning of the year, we took on, whereas I
usually stock 50, 75, 80 trucks, I had to buy as much as 300 of them at the beginning of the year
and house them so that I had a supply to keep my business moving through the year. And we're using
them up, but that supply is running out. When is it going to run out?
Loosely, I've probably got 90 days until we're out of chassis, and then we've got a problem.
What about your peers? You said you're the largest one. Are there other companies?
There are other smaller dealers in Southern Cal, and there are other dealers in Northern Cal as
well. And along the way, they're experiencing the very same issue that I am. Did they stock up too?
They did stock up. As one of the larger ones, there's an expense that comes with this.
You're buying these chassis, you have to pay for them, you have to floor them, carry interest on
them. And of course, you have to house them. And real estate's not cheap in our part of the world.
We've taken on all of these costs this year, starting January.
And you're hoping to resolve this with CARB, right?
We're hoping for two things. We're buying time to see if technology catches up,
to see if there is, in fact, an electric. The answer that we're looking for, the one that we
believe is a CARV out, like the government has for its vehicles, so that tow trucks specifically
are exempt from these rules until that next technology comes into place.
Something that gets us more time. You said you have talked to them a couple of times,
you've met with CARB. I attended two hearings.
Can you tell us how did that go? Sure. The first hearing that I attended
was more of an introductory appearance. We were invited, the meeting was open,
and industry was not just towing and essential services, but industry was invited to give their
comments on upcoming rules. So briefly, that meeting was, you get two minutes to speak.
The first meeting is a quick introduction as to what your business is, that we are tow industries,
we've been here for this amount of time, the number of employees we have, the number of people
that we serve, those vehicles that we put out there, what's their purpose. You had to quickly
define who you are and what you did. The second piece of it was to describe how are we impacted,
and it was, we don't have the technology yet for what's being proposed, and the restrictions that
are being imposed on the trucks that we do need are very real and are going to impact us.
And I can say, I didn't hear from any group that didn't have a truly intelligent pitch
or a piece of information for CARB to hear. All of the information that came across,
I thought was legitimate and needed to be heard. And at the end, I say, then there were a group of
random callers, call-ins, that I don't think were well understood the gravity of not having
essential services on the road, and were simply yelling about air being dirty and that all these
dirty diesel trucks were causing it. And while we can all agree that we want cleaner vehicles,
it's a much more complex issue than make every truck go off the road and the air will be clean
and all will be good. That's not quite how the whole thing works. You know, these essential
services are necessary. We want clean vehicles. We're moving towards clean vehicles. You can't
just stop the world from turning. And that's what came across in some of the phone calls.
The first meeting was more a make CARB aware meeting. Okay, and that's how it finished.
How long ago was that one? In May. How the meeting ended was with a directive from the
higher-ups at the Air Resources Board to their staff to go back and research the claims that
various groups like mine were making regarding, is there truly a shortage? Is it real? I'll take
you forward now to the second meeting that I went to, which was in October. In October,
there very quickly, the CARB group all say, I was impressed that, I thought I might be going back to,
you know, the impression of industry in general is that CARB is, call it uncaring of concern.
I didn't find that. At the second hearing I was at, it was opened with, we were made aware by
industry that we do have a problem with regulation. And they spoke to the towing and essential
vehicles sector specifically and said, we're aware we have a problem. We ended that meeting
with a question. What has been done to just allow this movement to cleaner air vehicles,
to just facilitate the movement in the allowance of time for it to happen? There are other states
that have followed along with California's movement towards zero emission. And others,
Oregon specifically, has postponed and made exception to their rules to allow for time for
technology to catch up. California has, at least to my knowledge so far, is holding fast on their
agenda. And if you're asked my pitch is, a little more time is required in order for that transition
to happen. And specifically for our sector, we need that exclusion to make sure that these
essential services don't slow down. Did they tell you, is there a timeline now that they're going
to get back to you or there is no timeline? I'm not aware of one at this point. In coming to the
meeting today, I've asked what has been done because there's been conversation regarding
amendments. These amendments to the CARB regulations, they can get very complex very fast.
It speaks to how many electrics or how many new compliant vehicles have to come to the market in
order for the legacy engines that we now use. But for the number of electrics that are getting built,
it's still very small. How many electrics are there? I can't be specific as to how many
are getting built. It's allowing for 20% to pick a number less or call it 80% less diesels
to come into the state because there isn't enough electric to offset it to satisfy the ratios that
are now in place. So my understanding where the amendments are concerned is that there's
going to be some movement somewhere. But it's not going to be enough to cover this 80%? We haven't
seen any positive movement yet. So for all the discussion, we've got no notice
from the manufacturers and we represent all the large brands, Peterbilt, Kenworth, Freightliner,
International, Dodge, Ford, Chevrolet. The numbers of those trucks that are coming into the state,
we're not aware of those numbers going up. Now CARB, the board has taken the position
and I only point out what their position has been, is that there are carve-outs in the
regulations that allow for truck manufacturers through credits and other passageways
that there are ways for the manufacturers to get the supply of necessary trucks into
the state for our industry and others. But the CARB groups are pointing out that the manufacturers
may be part of the problem, that they're not supplying trucks for other reasons, like they
might be too costly. There may be other reasons, ones that I can't speak to, I'm not aware of.
CARB has a feeling as to why some of these trucks aren't coming in and it's not all directed.
They're defending that it's not all what they have. It's not their regulations that are
all the... And you guys are in the middle of it. We're in the middle of it and as I point out, many facets
to it and hard to put your finger on just exactly what's happening, what's preventing
the movement of trucks. But one thing's for sure, less of them are coming in because of these ratios
that are now in place. Now Mark, are you worried because you have three months of supply left?
Absolutely. The problem is right in front of us and what do we do in the event that we can't
get them? You can only weather so much time with no activity in your business
and ours is a very active place. Trucks coming and going all the time. Without being able to
build new ones, without having the chassis, we need to move them forward. Starts with us, you'll see that
the people that supply these services are going to start to starve for new equipment to keep their
fleets current and then the people on the street are going to feel it in how that they're served,
in response to accidents, in trucks that are available for police activity, you name it,
those services are going to hurt not too far down the line. And this regulation doesn't apply to
government trucks? Specifically, there's a carve-out and exemption for government vehicles, government
owned vehicles and my only speculation on that is when these rules were designed, I think the
designers assumed that most of these essential vehicles were being operated by government
entities as opposed to private services that serve government and that's where I see the failing.
So an exemption or an exclusion for these essential vehicles, tow trucks, is the fast answer
to include us with the government exemption that's already in place. Have you talked to any of
your representatives because this is a big issue that your whole industry is impacted by this?
Sure, you're asking for, have I spoken to my local representation? Yes. My local assembly
person Blanca Rubio has visited us and taken a keen interest in our issue so I'm very appreciative
to Blanca and as I said earlier that's why I voted for her again. She has certainly made,
brought our issue forward. We were a little late getting to when, for when our issue could be heard
and we expect that it will be heard again towards the, I believe it's early in the year when
these issues are open for discussion again. How long do you think you will last after your
inventory is gone? If we don't have trucks to build, our purpose is essentially finished,
that is our business. We are a dealership of sorts, only when we think dealership,
we think car dealership. We sell an essential truck but like a car dealership, it's new trucks,
it's used trucks, it's parts service, it's warranty and our business specifically because
we're very active in the community as well and we work so closely with roadside assistance,
with the towers themselves and the safety in that industry. So we have a cause that's a lot more,
not to make too much of it, of course we're a business for profit but there's a community
aspect to our business that's very real. When we can't build new trucks and can't sell them,
which is our primary purpose and our primary revenue driver, we don't have more than 90 days
before it'll be, I mean, depending on how deep your pockets are, you can stay there as long as
you wish to but when the writing's on the wall and you don't have trucks to build, I would say
a prudent businessman would stop quickly to avoid further losses. We are honored to be sponsored by
Shen Yun. I've been attending Shen Yun performances every year as they change the choreography and
music. Shen Yun takes you back in time to the magical world of ancient China with unique blend
of brilliant dancing, beautiful costumes and legends coming to life. Overall, it's a very
meaningful performance with a lot more than just entertainment to offer. Make sure to go see it
this year. Go to Shenyun.com and book your tickets today. I highly recommend it. People nowadays go
to the doctors, the psychiatrists for pills, for antidepressants. This, this is the antidepressant,
the best. I knew it was going to be good. It's a billion times better than I even thought it would
be. I've heard people say you don't want to miss this and I would fully agree. I'm going to tell
everyone to come see it. You have to. Definitely going to come back next year. Totally inspirational.
You have to go see this. It's a once in a lifetime must see that will change their lives forever.
You guys are facing this regulation, but the government can buy these trucks without regulation,
right? That's right. They're allowed to bring in vehicles and they are, they are exempt from the
rules at this point. Correct. Do you think this industry can be replaced by the government? No,
not at all. Not at all. The government for, for, for these essential services that I described,
a very small percentage of them are owned by government. Very small, like less than 5% of
these towing and transport trucks are, are government operated. Almost all of them are
independent businesses, small, many of them family businesses like mine, or, you know, small, smaller.
I call us a medium sized business at this point and a good number of our customers are as well.
These businesses will suffer as this thing moves on. Do you have a message for people at CARB?
I appreciate being heard on the issues and that I was given the opportunity to speak first. Second,
I do think that CARB, I give some credit to CARB, that I think we were heard on,
there's a problem with, I call it our industry first because we are essential in my view,
and I think many would agree. And then there's the trucking business at large, but in our,
at our business specifically, this restriction of vehicles is going to not only affect us as a
small, as a small business first and as a dealer, when our supply slows up, you know, obviously we
can't continue on. But the long-term effect is we, we're not going to have these emergency service
vehicles that are needed until that technology comes to, comes into play. But by that point,
are we hanging around until that comes to pass? And the answer is we don't have the ability
to hang around and wait for the technology to pass. We need that exemption in order for,
or time for us to continue serving until that next product is available. And at that point,
again, we are the agent of change that'll take the dirty ones off the, off the road and put
the new cleaner ones on. So we come back to the production area. This is where the trucks come
together. These guys are more than likely on break right now. That's why it's a little quiet,
but you see how these trucks start. They come in as a chassis. Exactly. And you'll see how they
finish something like this. Obviously they're different sizes. Okay. So we move everywhere
from what is a class five truck to a class eight. So specifically we can start with one of each.
So this truck is a class five truck. This is a truck for, that's used for day-to-day towing.
An auto club service provider would use this. Somebody servicing somebody with a CHP contractor
would use this truck. This is a very common truck. You'll see it all the time. The next size
up was the truck beside. This is a class six truck or it's 21 feet long. This is a truck again,
that's it's a little bit better suited to hauling two cars, has a wheel lift on the back. You'll
again, find this, you'll see this one's painted auto club colors, like the AAA. So for AAA. This
one will be with a, with a, with a AAA service provider, for example, and they likely do CHP
work as well and could very well be doing police work in their area also. Now we move to something
a little more exciting. This truck here, that's a 50 ton rotator. That particular truck is,
is on the road for heavy duty use. So this truck, for example, the boom will rotate from side to
side. It has the ability to do the recovery of a heavy duty truck off the side of the freeway
without obstructing lanes of traffic because the boom will swing sideways. This truck was sold to
big customers, longtime friend, customer of ours, Dave McClure with Roy and Dots,
and he's also a FEMA contractor. So most of these contractors that are buying from you,
that are doing all these essential services are private companies. Thank you. The most of them,
most of them are privately owned companies doing work that serve all community. Correct. Is there
any electric that you have here? Nothing. We don't have one available. Manufacturers are not? The
that we've been able to put into service. And the number of diesels has been limited as a result
of the push towards electric, which we're in favor of. We just don't have the technology yet.
Our net is closer to 2%. So we sell the expensive item, but our margins are certainly,
I mean, we earn a living, of course, but we operate on tight margins. You get a glimpse
at the back. There's more as you go back. So these are all inventories? That's it. That's
all brand new equipment towards the back here. Once the current supply of combustion engines
that are acceptable into California run out, the public will be affected. Bill Salazar is the owner
of Royal Coaches, a family-owned towing business that has been in operation for 55 years. For
example, we have a tractor-trailer that's rolled over on a major thoroughfare, on a major freeway,
blocking all lanes. And our heavy recovery equipment would not be able to go out because
we just don't have electric recovery heavy-duty trucks. Or we get out there on the scene and the
current technology, we wouldn't be able to do the job. We wouldn't have enough electricity and time
to upright this tractor-trailer. And basically, the freeway's blocked, costing millions and millions
of dollars every minute that goes by until this freeway gets opened up. Or how about, say, you,
your daughter or your wife breaks down on the side of the road, and they need to get picked up by a
tow truck and towed into a repair facility. Well, what's to be of that if there's no compliant
equipment to be able to provide that service? And it goes on and on and on with the domino effect.
As we're seeing currently, is that the manufacturers of the equipment and the
distributors, such as Tow Industries, once their supply of chassis that they would use to mount
their recovery or tow truck equipment on, once that compliant chassis runs out,
which is anything built after 2024, we don't know where we're going to go. All the hundreds of tow
truck companies in California and of service providers, as this starts affecting us, what is
going to be used to be able to get a disabled vehicle off the freeway, to transport a tractor
trailer that supplies food to the supermarkets where we buy our food? So the trickle effect is
just going to start broadening out and out and out. Up until the time that we have the technology to
be able to support our industry. I spoke to CARB. I told them how long we've been in business, that
we're a family business, how many employees we employ over 75 people, how they're going to be
affected. And my feel is, is that they are listening. They understand that there is a problem and they
are looking to work with us, but it just doesn't seem like it's happening fast enough. It seems like
there's talks, but then we don't see any solutions coming down the line and time is running out.
And that's what has us so worried, is that we're up against these new laws that constrain our
industry, but we're not getting any relief as of yet. So our hopes is that the governor, that CARB
is listening and that they're going to make some changes to be able to to give us the relief that
our industry so desperately needs without having to worry day in and day out what is going to be
of tomorrow. We do want clean air. We do want to comply, but we need more time. And to get that time
we need an exemption as an emergency vehicle. Let us know what you think of this story and if you
like our coverage at California Insider, make sure to check out the Epoch Times. This is a
newspaper that started by a group of Chinese Americans because of human right abuses in China
and we are part of the Epoch Times newspaper. Also, make sure to reach out to me at
siamakatcaliforniainsider.com with any story ideas that you may have. Thank you.
