Why Are Compound Bows NOT in the Olympics?

Keep Archery Fun
64 followers
If there's one thing you should take away from this video, it's the understanding that
modern archery is a precision shooting sport.
That raises a very good point and unfortunately it was
kind of outside the frame of the original video.
Part of my problem is that I have to cater to different levels of archery.
Some people, of course, are regular archers who shoot different styles and know about different
things and the other audience is the kind of person who only knows archery from pop culture
and that video was explaining something at that level to the latter audience.
Of course, that raises the logical question,
why not compound?
And that is a very good question which is immediately obvious.
And unfortunately, the answer is a lot more boring because it's more organisational and
logistical and not so much the spicy, my kung fu is better than your kung fu drama,
which you might expect.
But we'll go through the answer anyway.
Before that, I want to make it clear that I'm not presenting an argument.
I'm not saying something should or shouldn't be in the Olympics.
I shoot most styles of archery, minus compound ironically,
but I promote and enjoy all styles of archery.
I'm not here to represent the Olympic Committee and say,
well, we don't want this for this particular reason.
All I'm doing is explaining why things are.
Now, you might disagree with the way things are,
but I'm just here to explain why things are the case today.
And going back to the point about target recurve,
that has evolved in a very short amount of time, comparatively speaking,
to represent the epitome of precision target shooting.
We see from the 1950s that people were still using wooden longbows
and were transitioning to simple wooden recurve designs.
From 1950 to the 1960s, we see stabilisers and sights.
And less than 10 years later, we see aluminium risers and aluminium bows.
So within around 20 years, we see this huge change of the open freestyle target division
from wooden longbows to modern recurves.
Generally speaking, that target shooting competition has widely accepted
that in order to reach the ideal goals of that particular kind of archery,
and I'll say again, that particular kind of archery,
they are opening themselves up with the tools and technology
that became available in the modern era.
And of course, in every step of the way, people diverge.
Some people don't like sights and stabilisers.
Some people don't like recurve bows.
So you see this spread of people who have a different point branched away.
But the main branch is the modern recurve division.
Which comes back to the question,
if precision is the goal, why didn't compound ultimately replace recurve?
And therefore, why compound is not in the Olympics.
While recurve ultimately replaced traditional barebow or longbow,
compound didn't replace recurve.
It came alongside it.
Compound functions mechanically differently.
The bow itself is mechanically different.
You have a let-off, you have a release aid, you have magnified lenses.
So the way a compound works provides significant mechanical advantages,
which really makes it unfair to compete against recurve.
Recurve doesn't actually alter the function of the bow that much,
because even with sights and stabilisers,
it mitigates some of the error margins,
but it doesn't change the way you use the bow.
You still have to shoot within a certain time limit.
It still requires a lot of physical upper body strength and control.
But it's not like you can hold it forever and then just shoot.
So the recurve division is very separate to the compound division,
because one, technologically different.
Two, function is different.
Three, the standards are much, much different.
And likewise, recurve doesn't compete with traditional longbow or barebow,
because again, the standards are very different.
Function is very similar, but standards are very, very different.
And as long as all these bow types don't compete against each other,
then it's a pretty level playing field.
So that's why compound didn't replace recurve,
but recurve did replace traditional.
But why is compound not in the Olympics?
Fundamentally, it's not so much a matter of skill or technology,
it's just timing.
The original archery events were in 1900 for the first event,
1904 and 1908,
and then 1920 was the last original archery event in the Olympics.
And part of the problem they faced back then was that things were not standardized.
There were different rounds, different rules,
so people competing couldn't compete on a level playing field.
Now, we fast forward to 1972,
and that's when the archery event was reintroduced into the Olympic program.
Now, that's evolved quite a bit too in terms of the round shot,
the format and all that.
Not just the equipment, but the format of the shooting competition
has changed to be a bit more spectator-friendly.
But 1972 was that kick date,
and at the time there was pretty much one serious gold standard for target shooting,
and that was modern recurve.
Compound bows were invented in the late 1960s, early 1970s.
So at the time, compound events weren't really a thing yet,
and that wouldn't be a major thing until around the late 1970s or 1980s.
Nowadays, compound is one of the two major divisions in international competitive archery.
In fact, any kind of archery.
You have compound bows, which are perhaps the bigger market in archery,
and recurve bows.
But compound is not in the Olympics.
It is in other world archery international events,
and most national events or any kind of event, but not in the Olympics.
And the simple reason why is that it's much harder to add more events into the Olympics.
If there's one thing to get from this video to debate about perhaps,
it's that the Olympic Games is an international multi-sport exhibition event.
A very prestigious international multi-sport exhibition event,
but it is nonetheless a multi-sport exhibition event.
That means that the people who run the Olympic Games, the IOC,
don't actually run the sports.
They pick the sports to be showcased at the Olympics,
and the events to be used at the Olympics,
and they'll nominate the organization which runs that particular event.
So that's why you have World Archery in charge of archery.
You have FIBA in charge of basketball.
You have FIE in charge of fencing and so on.
So each sport is represented by their particular organization.
Within their own organization, they run their own events,
many of which are not in the Olympic program.
So when you see World Archery, for example,
they do have the World Championships,
the World Cup Series, the World Indoor Series,
which I shot at the other year.
You have other events like the Field Championships,
the 3D Championships,
which include different formats of archery.
Some of which are a lot more exciting than Target Archery, to be honest.
And of course, they allow different bow types.
They do allow compound and recurve.
They do allow barebow.
That's become one of the three main divisions in Target Archery.
And then you have even longbow,
is defined as a classification in Field and 3D.
Not Target at the moment,
definitely Field and 3D at world level.
And below that, you have national organizations
or state organizations,
which have their own rulesets,
some of which are derived from World Archery.
But many national organizations do, in fact,
have a longbow or traditional category.
So depending on what level you're competing at,
there may be plenty of access points for you
to compete in that particular field.
And I want to point out here,
there are multiple archery organizations,
not just World Archery,
because there are other forms of archery.
There's the International Horse Archery Alliance,
there's IFAA,
the International Field Archery Association,
and other traditional associations,
which coordinate international archery.
Some larger than others,
some are more organized,
they run more events than others.
But the point is that there are multiple organizations
for these events.
There are even casual organizations.
For example, the largest traditional event is,
I think, ITAR in the US.
Or there are Asiatic archery meetups in America,
in Eastern Europe.
So there are plenty of events
which people can organize and attend,
some competitive, some friendly,
but there are multiple events.
They exist.
And I really want to emphasize that,
again, modern archery isn't only
that modern recurve of weird things sticking out,
that people still shoot trad today.
A lot of people do.
And I would say most people who do archery today
are more inclined to be either compound or trad,
recurve being a bit of an oddity in the middle.
Point being, though,
is that whoever runs the event chooses the rules.
In World Archery events,
it's World Archery rules.
In the Olympic Games,
it's not their event.
They are chosen to organize the event,
but they don't run the Olympics,
which means that they are under
a different set of limitations.
If World Archery, hypothetically,
wants to make a trad-only event
or have a combined event,
and in fact, they have.
Conquest Club 2020 was the first Conquest Club,
which is normally a traditional event.
They also added in the compound and recurve events,
and that was officially organized by World Archery.
So they do, in fact, have multi-sport
or multi-discipline events.
But they can do that because they run archery,
and they can coordinate with other archery clubs
and organizations to do that.
The Olympic Games runs under different limitations
and different rules.
And the big part is, of course,
that the Olympic Committee has to balance
the cost-benefit of adding more archery events
because World Archery doesn't bear the cost.
The host city mostly does,
with funding and sponsorship, of course.
The host city is the one who pays for the events.
And as the Olympic Games becomes wider,
more expansive, I should say,
and many cities are finding the financial burden
of hosting Olympic Games to be not worth it,
it is very challenging to add more things
to the Olympic program.
Now, I'm not the IOC.
I can only speculate why they haven't added events
like compound or barebow
or other archery competitions like field or 3D.
Venues are one thing,
but there are plenty of venues
for this sort of thing everywhere.
So it's not really an issue,
and you can make them.
And a lot of archery venues
don't require that much investment to do.
A good example is actually the World 3D Championships,
which is basically in the middle of the city.
And they put foam targets at key locations,
which is actually very scenic.
But it's not hard to do.
The main reason I think
that it's hard to get more archery events,
and they've tried,
is because it's hard to justify to the IOC
the additional costs of bringing more athletes
and support staff.
If you add compound,
that's another 128 athletes,
plus support staff,
plus volunteers to run the events
to the Olympic program,
which means more combination needed,
more costs to run the events.
And if you add barebow,
that's another 128.
If you add more classes,
that's 128 each,
assuming they're in the same format
of 64 male, 64 female.
You have the ranking rounds,
and you have the knockouts.
Can it run?
Yes, but it will drive the cost up.
And when you have a committee and a city
which don't want to expand the cost,
they want to keep the cost down,
they will cut out events which are not popular.
They will add events
which are currently more trendy or more popular.
That's why you see the rise of sports life,
a lot of the BMX sports,
skateboarding, sport climbing.
And a part of this too,
is to showcase events
which aren't normally seen by the general public.
Most people will never ever watch
a sport climbing event
or a skateboarding event
unless you're already doing that kind of sport.
Archery is already well known.
So people say compound, they say recurve.
What's the difference?
Who cares?
It's still shooting a target.
That's kind of where things kind of fall down
in terms of adding more archery events.
How do you convince the organizer of an event
that doesn't actually run the event
that this is worth doing?
And I think that's why.
Again, this isn't my opinion.
This isn't my argument.
I'm just speculating why compound
is not in the Olympic Games.
And that sadly is perhaps
why compound is not in the Olympics.
It doesn't mean it will never be the Olympic Games
and hopefully with more pressure
and more support,
it will be included in the Olympic program.
But as it stands,
it's not likely to be the case.
And unfortunately,
that also means that other kinds of archery,
particularly barebow,
modern barebow at least,
that's not likely to make headway
unless something changes
with the way it's organized
and the popularity of the sport.
So on that note,
this isn't really about favoritism.
It's not really about
this bow is better than this bow
or this bow isn't a real bow or real archery.
I think there's a vocal minority
who want to make it out to be sniping other styles
and attacking other archers
for not doing real archery.
I think that's a vocal minority.
By and large,
the archery community loves archery of any kind.
We love watching traditional archers.
I'd love to do traditional archery.
And as much as we would love to see
everything in the Olympic Games,
we don't choose that.
Fortunately, there are plenty of other events
and venues where you can do these things.
So while you might not see field archery
or horse archery or 3D archery
or pole archery in the Olympic Games,
the fact that they exist somewhere, someplace,
means that you can enjoy these particular events.
And that comes down to the final point,
which is true for most sports, in fact.
The Olympic Games is not the premier event.
Now, it is for those who have been chosen
to be in the Olympic program,
but it isn't the main event
that people necessarily look forward to.
So other sports like basketball,
the Olympic Games is a nice side mission,
but it's not the main goal.
It's like the NBA championships
is the most prestigious event.
You have football or soccer.
The Olympic Games is not the premier event.
It's nice to win it,
but there are a lot of rules and restrictions
of professionalism,
and you don't really see the best athlete
at the Olympic Games.
You see them in the World Cup
or the Club World Championship.
That sort of thing is kind of the same
in archery as well.
The Olympic Games is probably
the prestigious event for Rika of archery,
but for everybody else,
there's their own competition,
the World Cup or the World Championships.
So just keep that in mind
that the Olympic Games isn't everything.
It is a brand name
which carries a lot of historical prestige,
but it isn't what people necessarily go for.
So just because something isn't in the Olympics
doesn't mean it's not important.
And in many cases,
some things only become relevant
every four years because of the Olympics.
So with that in mind,
not being in the Olympics
isn't the be-all and end-all of archery.
Other styles are completely legitimate,
very competitive in many cases,
and people who do them are very passionate about it.
And don't let not being in the Olympics
take away from the validity
or the legitimacy of what you do.
And that's my explanation.
A little circular and rambly, unfortunately,
but the reason why
it's not because it's real archery
or not real archery,
it's because of timing.
This particular bow was the main bow
used in competition at the time
and that was chosen.
Should the archery event have been included
15 years later,
maybe a compound would have been the main event.
Who knows?
And things might change in the future.
Nonetheless,
no matter what kind of archery you're doing,
I hope you've been enjoying it,
especially during these hard times.
If you haven't done archery before,
then I encourage you to investigate
and find out where you can do archery
of any kind you want,
whether traditional or modern.
Every archery has an appeal.
People who are passionate about archery
are doing it for the right reasons.
And we don't have to tear each other down
and say one's fake and one's not real.
Everyone can enjoy archery the way it should be.
Anyway, I'm NUSensei.
Thank you all for watching.
Hope you're staying safe where you are.
Hopefully, I'll see you next time.
