Alan Watts Lecture: Taoism vs. Confucianism - Understanding Chinese Philosophy (NO MUSIC)

Chinese Civilization
316 followers
The philosophy of the Dao is one of the two great principal components of Chinese thought.
There are of course quite a number of forms of Chinese philosophy, but there are two great
currents which have thoroughly molded the culture of China, and they are Daoism and Confucianism,
and they play a curious game with each other. Confucius said the goody goodies are the thieves
of virtue, meaning that to try to be wholly righteous is to go beyond humanity, to try to
be something that isn't human. So this gives Confucian approach to life and justice and
all those sort of things, a kind of queer humor, a sort of boys will be boys attitude,
which is nevertheless a very mature way of handling human problems. It was of course for
this reason that the Japanese Buddhist priests who visited China to study Buddhism, especially
Zen priests, introduced Confucianism into Japan, because despite certain limitations that
Confucianism has, and it needs, it always needs the the Dao philosophy as a counterbalance,
Confucianism has been one of the most successful philosophies in all history for the regulation
of governmental and family relationships. But of course it is concerned with formality.
Confucianism prescribes all kinds of formal relationships, linguistic, ceremonial, musical,
in etiquette, in all the spheres of morals, and for this reason has always been twitted
by the Daoists for being unnatural. You need these two components, you see, and they play
against each other beautifully in Chinese society. Roughly speaking, you see, the Confucian
way of life is for people involved in the world. The Daoist way of life is for people who
get disentangled. Now as we know in our own modern times there are various ways of getting
disentangled from the regular lifestyle, say, of the United States. If you want to go through the
regular lifestyle of the United States, you go to high school and college, and then you go into a
profession or a business, and you own a standard house, and you raise a family, and you have a car
or two cars, and do all that jazz. But a lot of people don't want to live that way, and there are
lots of other ways of living besides that. So you could say that those of us who go along with the
pattern correspond to the Confucians, and those who are bohemians, or bums, or beatniks, or
whatever, and don't correspond with the pattern, they are more like the Daoists.
Because the Daoist is really, actually in Chinese history, Daoism is a way of life for older people.
Laozi, the name given to the founder of Daoism,
means the old boy. And the legend is that when he was born he already had a white beard.
So it's sort of like this, that when you have contributed to society, when you've contributed
children and brought them up, and you have assumed a certain role in social life,
you then say, now it's time for me to find out what it's all about.
Who am I, ultimately, behind my outward personality? What is the secret source of things?
And the latter half of life is the pre-eminently excellent time to find this out. It's something to
do when you have finished with the family business. I am not saying that that is a sort
of unavoidable strict rule. Of course, one can study the Dao when very young, because it contains
all kinds of secrets in it, as to the performance of every kind of art, or craft, or business,
or any occupation whatsoever. But it does, in China, in a way, it plays that
role of a kind of safety valve for the more restricted way of life that Confucianism
prescribes. And there is a sort of type in China who's known as the old rogue.
He's a sort of intellectual bum, often found among scholars, who is admired very much,
and a type of character which had an enormous influence on the development
of the ideals of Zen Buddhist life. He is one, you see, who goes with nature,
rather than against nature. Well, now, first of all, I'm going to talk about ideas which
come strictly out of Lao Tzu's book, The Dao De Jing. And, of course, the basic
thing in the whole philosophy is the conception of Dao. This word has many meanings,
and the book of Lao Tzu starts out by saying that the Dao which can be spoken is not the
eternal Dao. Or you can, there's a pun in there, which you can't quite put into English.
You can't give all the meanings, because the word Dao means both the way, or course of nature,
or of everything. It also means to speak. So the actual opening phrase of the book,
following this word Dao, is this, you see. And this character means can be, or can, able,
something like that. So the way which can be, then give it its second meaning, spoken,
described, uttered. But it also means the way that can be weighed. Not w-e-i-g-h, but w-a-y-e-d.
You know, you'd have to invent that word. The way that can be traveled, perhaps,
is not the eternal way. In other words, there is no way in which the Dao, or following the Dao,
can, there's no recipe for it. I can't give you any do-it-yourself instructions, A, B, C,
D, as to how it's done. It was like when Louis Armstrong was asked, what is jazz?
He said, if you have to ask, you don't know.
Now that's awkward, isn't it? But we can gather what it is
by absorbing certain atmospheres and attitudes connected with those who follow it,
and from the art, and the poetry, and all the expressions, and the anecdotes, and stories
that illustrate the philosophy of the way. So this word, then, the way, or the course of things,
is not, you must understand this, some Christian missionaries translated Dao as the Logos.
Taking as their point of departure the opening passage of St. John's Gospel,
in the beginning was the Word. Now if you look up a Chinese translation of the Bible,
it says in the beginning was the Dao. And the Dao was with God, and the Dao was God.
The same was in the beginning with God. All things were made by it,
and without it was not anything made that was made.
So they've substituted Dao there. Now that may make a very funny effect on a Chinese
philosopher, because the idea of things being made by the Dao is absurd.
The Dao is not a manufacturer, and it's not a governor.
It doesn't rule as it were in the position of a king. Although the book, the Dao De Jing,
is written for many purposes, but one of its important purposes is as a manual of guidance
for a ruler. And what it tells him is essentially, rule by not ruling. Don't lord it over the people.
And so he says, the great Dao flows everywhere, both to the left and to the right.
It loves and nourishes all things, but does not lord it over them.
And when good things are accomplished, it lays no claim to them. In other words, the Dao doesn't
stand up and say, I have made all of you. I have filled this earth with its beauty and glory. Fall
down before me in worship. The Dao, having done anything, you know, always escapes and is not
around to receive any thanks or acknowledgment, because it loves obscurity. And Lao Tzu said,
the Dao is like water. It always seeks the low level which human beings abhor.
So it's a very mysterious idea. Dao then is not really equivalent with any Western or Hindu idea
of God, because God is always associated with being the Lord. Even in India, the Brahman is
often called the Supreme Lord, although that was the term more strictly applicable to Ishvara,
the manifestation of Brahman in the form of a personal God. But Bhagavan, the Lord, Krishna,
his song is the Bhagavad Gita, the song of the Lord. There's always the idea of the king and
the ruler attached, but not in the Chinese Dao philosophy. The Dao is not something different from
nature, from ourselves, from our surrounding trees and waters and air. The Dao is the way all that
behaves. And so the Chinese, the basic Chinese idea of the universe is really that it's an
organism. And as we shall see when we get onto Zhuangzi, who is the sort of elaborator of Lao
Tzu, he sees everything operating together so that nowhere can you find the controlling center.
There isn't any. The world is a system of interrelated components, none of which can
survive without each other, just as in the case of bees and flowers. You will never find
bees around in a place where there aren't flowers, and you will never find flowers around in a place
where there aren't bees or insects that do the equivalent job. And what that tells us secretly
is that although bees and flowers look different from each other, they're inseparable.
They, to use a very important Daoist expression, they arise mutually. This is one of the
great phrases from the second chapter of Lao Tzu's book, where he says, this character means
to have or to be. And this next one is a very important character in Daoist philosophy.
It means no, negative, wu in Chinese, not to be. And then this curious expression,
for which we don't have a really good corresponding idea in traditional Western thought,
so to be and not to be mutually arise. This character is based on the picture of a plant,
something that grows out of the ground. So you could say positive and negative, to be and not
to be, yes and no, light and dark arise mutually, come into being. None is cause and effect, it's
not that relationship at all. It's like the egg and the hen. So as the bees and the flowers
coexist in the same way as high and low, back and front, long and short, loud and soft,
all those experiences are experienceable only in terms of their polar experience.
So the Chinese idea of nature is that all the various species
arise mutually because they interdepend. And this total system of interdependence is the Dao.
It involves certain other things that go along with Dao, but this mutual arising
is the key idea to the whole thing. And it is, if you want to understand
Chinese and Oriental thought in general, it is the most important thing to grasp.
Because you see, we think so much in terms of cause and effect. We think of the universe
today in Aristotelian and Newtonian ways. And in that philosophy, the world is all separated.
It's like a huge amalgamation of billiard balls. And they don't move until struck by another,
or by a cue. And so everything is going tock tock tock tock tock tock tock tock tock tock
all over the place. One thing starting off another in a mechanical way. But of course,
from the standpoint of 20th century science, we know perfectly well now that that's not the way
it works. We know enough about relationships to see that that mechanical model which Newton devised
was all right for certain purposes. But it breaks down now, because we understand relativity.
And we see how things go together in a kind of connected net, rather than in a chain of
billiard balls banging each other around. So in the philosophy of the Tao, it is said,
it's always being said, this is, you read this in every art book about Chinese art,
that in Chinese painting, man is always seen as in nature, rather than dominating it.
You get a painting entitled, Poet Drinking by Moonlight. And you see a great landscape.
And after some search with a magnifying glass, at last you see the poet
stuck away in a corner somewhere drinking wine. Whereas if we painted the subject Poet Drinking
by Moonlight, the poet would be the most obvious thing in a picture. There he would be,
dominating the whole thing, the landscape off somewhere behind him. But all the Chinese
painters put man, I mean, the painters of the great classical tradition, there are Chinese
painters who specialize in family portraits, and do these very formal paintings of someone's
ancestor sitting on a throne. It's quite a different category. But the Taoist inspired
painters, the Zen inspired painters, have this view of man as an integral part of nature.
Something in it, just as everything else is in it, flowers and birds, and not their
ascent into this world commissioned by some sort of supernatural being to come into this world and
farm it and dominate it. So then, the whole conception of nature is as a self-regulating,
self-governing, indeed democratic organism. But it has a totality. It all goes together,
and this totality is the Tao. So then we move to a second term that is extremely important.
The expression, Ziran, is the term that we translate nature when we translate Chinese.
But this term expresses this whole point of view. It doesn't say nature, natura,
which means, in a way, class of things. It means, literally, self-so. What is so of itself?
What happens of itself? And thus, spontaneity. And in the Tao Te Ching early on, Lao Tzu says,
the Tao's method is to be so of itself. Now, we might translate that automatic,
were it not that the word automatic has a mechanical flavor.
Ziran, as this is called, or Shizen in Japanese, means spontaneous, yes.
It happens as your heart beats. You don't do anything about it. You don't force your heart
to beat. You don't make it beat. It does it by itself. Now, figure a world in which everything
happens by itself. It doesn't have to be controlled. It's allowed. Whereas, you might
say, the idea of God involves the control of everything going on. The idea of the Tao is the
trusts all the people to conduct their own affairs, to let it all happen. So,
this doesn't mean, you see, that there isn't a unified organism and everything is in chaos.
It means that the more liberty you give, the more love you give, the more you allow things
in yourself and in your surroundings to take place, the more order you will have.
We now join Alan Watts in part two of Taoist way of dropping out from karma.
It is believed generally in India that when a person sets out on the way of liberation,
his first problem is to become free from his past karma. The popular theory of karma,
the word that literally means action or doing in Sanskrit, so that when we say that something
that happens to you is your karma, it's like saying in English, it's your own doing.
But in popular Indian belief, a karma is a sort of built-in moral law or a law of retribution,
such that all the bad things you do and all the good things you do have consequences which you
have to inherit. And so long as karmic energy remains stored up, you have to work it out.
And what the sage endeavors to do is a kind of action which in Sanskrit is called
means without passion or without attachment, karma, action. And so whatever action he does,
he renounces the fruits of the action so that he acts in a way that doesn't generate future karma
because future karma continues you in the wheel of becoming, samsara, the round,
and keeps you being reincarnated. Now then, in that case, when the time comes that you start
to get out of the chain of karma, all the creditors that you have start presenting
themselves for payment. In other words, a person who begins, say, to study yoga is felt that he
will suddenly get sick or that his children will die or that he loses money or all sorts
of catastrophes will occur because the karmic debt is being cleared up. And there's no hurry
to be cleared up if you're just living along like anybody. But if you embark on the spiritual life,
a certain hurry occurs. And therefore, since this is known, it's rather discouraging to start
these things. The Christian way of saying the same thing is that if you plan to be,
to change your life, shall we say, to turn over a new leaf, you mustn't let the devil know
because he will oppose you with all his might if he suddenly discovers that you're going to escape
from his power. So, for example, if you have a bad habit, say you drink too much,
and you make a new year's resolution that during this coming year you'll stop drinking,
that's a very, very dangerous thing to do because the devil will immediately know about it.
And what will happen will be this. He will confront you with the prospect of 365 drinkless days.
And that will be awful, you know, just overwhelming. And you won't be able to make
much more than three days on the wagon. So in that case, you compromise with the devil and say,
just today I'm not going to drink, you see, but tomorrow maybe, you know, we'll go back.
Then when tomorrow comes, you say, oh, just another day, let's try out, that's all.
And the next day you say, oh, one more day won't make much difference. So you only do it for the
moment, and you don't let the devil know that you have a secret intention of going on day after
day after day after day. But of course, there's something still better than that, and that is not
to let the devil know anything. And that means, of course, not to let yourself know. One of the
many meanings of that saying, let not your left hand know what your right hand doeth, is just this.
And that was why in Zen discipline, a great deal of it centers around acting without premeditation.
As those of you know who read Herigel's book, Zen in the Art of Archery,
it was necessary to release the bow string without first saying now. There's a wonderful
story you may also have read by a German writer, von Kleist, about a boxing match with a bear.
The man can never defeat this bear, because the bear always knows his plans in advance,
and is ready to deal with any situation. The only way to get through to the bear would be to hit
the bear without having first intended to do so. That would catch him. And so this is one of the
great problems in the spiritual life, or whatever you want to call it,
is to be able to have intention and act simultaneous. By this means, you escape karma,
and you escape the devil. So you might say that the Taoist is exemplary in this respect.
That this is getting free from karma without making any previous announcement.
Of simply, supposing we have a train, and we want to unload the train of its freight cars.
You can go to the back end, and you can unload them one by one, and shunt them into the siding.
But the simplest of all ways of unloading is to uncouple between the engine and the first car,
and that gets rid of the whole bunch at once. And it is in that sort of way, you see, that
the Taoist gets rid of karma without challenging it. And so it has the reputation, you see,
of being the easy way. There are all kinds of yogas and ways for people who want to be difficult.
And one of the great gambits of a man like Gurdjieff was to make it all seem as difficult
as possible. Because that challenged the vanity of his students. If some teacher,
some guru says, really this isn't difficult at all, it's perfectly easy.
Some people will say, oh, he's not really the real thing.
We want something tough and difficult, and when we see somebody starts out giving you a discipline
that's very, very weird and rigid, people think, now there is the thing. That man means business,
see? And so they flatter themselves by going to such a guy that they are serious students,
whereas the other people are only dabblers and so on. All right, if you have to do it that way,
that's the way you have to do it. But the Taoist is the kind of person who shows you the shortcut
and shows you how to do it by intelligence rather than effort, because that's what it is.
Taoism is in that sense what everybody is looking for. The easy way in, the shortcut,
using cleverness instead of muscle. So the question naturally arises, isn't it cheating?
When in any game somebody really starts using his intelligence, he will very likely be accused of
cheating. And to draw the line between skill and cheating is a very difficult thing to do.
You see, the inferior intelligence will always accuse the superior intelligence of cheating.
That's its way of saving face. You beat me by means that weren't fair.
We were originally having a contest to find out who had the strongest muscles.
And you know, we were pushing against it like this, this, this, this, this.
And this would prove who had the strongest muscles. But then you introduce some gimmick
into it, some judo trick or something like that, you see, and you're not playing fair.
So in the whole domain of ways of liberation, there are routes for the stupid people
and routes for the intelligent people. And the latter are faster.
This was perfectly clearly explained by Huineng, the Sixth Patriarch of Zen in China,
in his sutra, where he says the difference between the gradual school and the sudden school
is they both arrive at the same point, but the gradual is for slow-witted people
and the sudden is for fast-witted people. Can you, in other words, find a way that sees into
your own nature, that sees into the Tao immediately? And at the end of this morning's
talk, I pointed out to you the immediate way, the way through now, when you know that this moment
is the Tao, and this moment is considered by itself without past and without future,
eternal, neither coming into being nor going out of being, there is nirvana.
And there is a whole Chinese philosophy of time based on this. It hasn't, to my knowledge,
been very much discussed by Taoist writers. It's been more discussed by Buddhist writers,
but it's all based on the same thing. Dogen, the great 13th century Japanese Zen Buddhist,
studied in China, and he wrote a book called Shobo Genzo. Hiroshi recently said to me in Japan,
that's a terrible book because it tells you everything.
It gives the whole secret away. But in the course of this book, he says,
there is no such thing as a progression in time. The spring does not become the summer.
There is first spring and then there is summer. So in the same way, you now do not become
you later. This is T.S. Eliot's idea in Four Quartets, where he says that the person who
has settled down in the train to read the newspaper is not the same person who stepped
onto the train from the platform. And therefore also you who sit here are not the same people who
came in at the door. These states are separate, each in its own place. There was the coming in
at the door person, but there is actually only the here and now sitting person. And the person
sitting here and now is not the person who will die. Because we are all a constant flux,
and the continuity of the person from past through present to future is as illusory
in its own way as the upward movement of the red lines on a revolving barber pole.
You know, it goes round and round and round and the whole thing seems to be going up or going
down, whichever the case may be. But actually nothing is going up or down. So when you throw
a pebble into the pond and you make concentric rings of waves, there is an illusion that the
water is flowing outwards. And no water is flowing outwards at all. Water is only going up and down.
What appears to move outward is the wave, not the water. So this kind of philosophical argument says
that our seeming to go along in a course of time, it doesn't really happen. The Buddhists say
suffering exists, but no one who suffers. Deeds exist, but no doers are found. A path
there is, but no one who follows it. And nirvana is, but no one who attains it.
So in this way they look upon the continuity of life as the same sort of illusion that is produced
when you take a cigarette and in the dark whirl it and the illusion of a circle is created,
whereas there is only the one point of fire. The argument then is, so long as you're in the present,
there aren't any problems. The problems exist only when you allow presence to amalgamate.
There's a way of putting this in Chinese, which is rather interesting. They have a very interesting
sign, this. It's pronounced nyan, in Japanese nen. And the top part of the character
means now, and the bottom part means the mind heart, the shin. And so this is, as it were,
an instant of thought. In Sanskrit, they use it, they use this character as the equivalent
for the Sanskrit word shana. Then if you put, if you double this character, put it twice,
or three times, and I'll write the Chinese for ditto.
Nyan, nyan, nyan means thought after thought after thought. Now the Zen master Joshu was once asked,
what is the mind of a child? And he said, a ball in a mountain stream.
What do you mean by a ball in a mountain stream? He said, thought after thought after thought,
with no block. So he was using, of course, the mind of the child as the innocent mind,
the mind of a person who's enlightened. One thought follows another without hesitation.
The thought arises, it doesn't wait to arise. As when you clap your hands, the sound issues
without hesitation. When you strike flint, the spark comes out. It doesn't wait to come out.
And that means that there's no block. So thought, thought, thought, nyan, nyan, nyan,
describes what we call in our world the stream of consciousness. Blocking consists in letting
the stream become connected, chained together in such a way that when the present thought arises,
it seems to be dragging its past or resisting its future, saying, I don't want to go.
When then the connection, the dragging, it's better to call it, of these thoughts drops,
you've broken the chain of karma. If you think of this in comparison with certain problems in music,
it's very interesting. Because when we listen to music, we hear melody only because we remember
the sequence. We hear the intervals between the tones, but more than that, we remember
the tones that led up to the one we are now hearing. And we are trained musically to anticipate
certain consequences. And to the extent that we get the consequences we anticipate,
we feel that we understand the music. But to the extent that the composer does not adhere to the
rules and gives us unexpected consequences, we feel that we don't understand the music.
And if he gives us harmonic relationships, which we are not trained to accept, that is to say,
to expect, we say, well, this man is just writing garbage. But of course, it becomes apparent
that the perception of music, the ability to hear melody, will depend upon a relationship between
past, present, and future sounds. And you might say, well, you're talking about a way of living
that would be equivalent to listening to music with a tone-deaf mind, so that you would reduce,
you would eliminate the melody and have only noise. And so in your Taoist way of life,
you would eliminate all meaning and have only senseless present moments. Up to a point,
that's true. That is, in a way, what Buddhists also mean by seeing things in their suchness.
What is so bad about dying, for example? It's really no problem. When you die, you just drop
dead. That's all there is to it. But what makes it a problem is that you're dragging a past.
And all those things you've done, all those achievements you've made, all these relationships
and people that you've accumulated as your friends, all that has to go. See, it isn't here
now. I mean, a few friends might be around you, but all that past that identifies you as who you
are, which is simply memory, all that has to go. And we feel just terrible about that. But if we
didn't, if we were just dying, that's all, death wouldn't be a problem. So likewise, the chores
of everyday life, they become intolerable. When everything ties together, all the past and the
future, you feel it dragging at you every way. Supposing you wake up in the morning, and it's a
lovely morning. Let's take today, right here and now, here we are in this paradise of a place,
Big Sur, and some of us have got to go to work on Monday. Is that a problem? For many people it is.
It spoils the taste of what's going on now. When we wake up in bed on Monday morning and think of
the various hurdles we've got to jump that day, immediately we feel sad and bored and bothered,
whereas actually we're just lying in bed.
So the Taoist trick says, simply live now, and there will be no problems. That's the meaning of
Zen saying, when you are hungry, eat. When you are tired, sleep. When you walk, walk. When you sit,
sit. Rinzai, the great Tang Dynasty master said, in the practice of Buddhism, there is no place
for using effort. Sleep when you're tired, move your bowels, eat when you're hungry. That's all.
The ignorant will laugh at me, but the wise will understand.
And so, also, the meaning of this wonderful Zen saying, day, that's the character for the sun,
day, that is, good day. Every day is a good day. On condition, you see, that day-day is like
they come one after another, and yet there's only this one. You don't link them.
This, as I intimated just a moment ago, seems to be an atomization of life. Things just do what
they do. The flower goes poof, and people go this way, go that way, and so on, and that's what's
happening. It has no meaning, it has no destination, it has no value. It's just like that.
And when you see that, you see, it's a great relief. That's all it is. But then, when you
are firmly established in suchness, in that it's just this moment, you can begin again
to play with the connections. Only, you've seen through them. But now, you see, they don't haunt
because you know that there isn't any continuous you running on from moment to moment who originated
at some time in the past and will die at some time in the future. All that's disappeared.
So you can have enormous fun anticipating the future, remembering the past,
and playing all kinds of continuities. This is the meaning of that famous Zen saying
about mountains are mountains. To the naive man, mountains are mountains, waters are waters.
To the intermediate student, mountains are no longer mountains, waters are no longer waters.
In other words, they've all dissolved into the point instant to the Kshana.
But for the fully perfected student, mountains are
