Exhibition Tour–Look Again: European Paintings 1300-1800

Timeless Tapestry
4 followers
Look again, European paintings 1300 to 1800.
A suite of 45 galleries with over 700 works of art
is an opportunity to see our collection in a new light.
Europe is an idea in flux, a geography in flux.
There have been moments of expansion,
empire, division, and cultural exchange.
We wanted to think about our galleries
as not only a progression of style unfolding,
but as a network of ideas.
It really is an invitation to look again,
to think again, to have new favorite paintings,
to grapple with sometimes difficult histories,
and to visit over and over
and each time encounter something new.
We've organized the galleries chronologically
that will give our visitors the basic spine or backbone
in which to walk through a history of art.
But within that chronology,
you'll find moments where we spread out,
either geographically or around a given genre
of painting to ask new questions about that history.
Like, what are the limits of Europe?
What are its borders as traditionally defined,
or as we know through histories of imperialism, colonialism,
that in effect span European culture around the globe.
For visitors who have spent much time with our collection,
it's a moment to see highlights, real destination pictures,
but it's also an opportunity to discover lesser known works
that fill out the larger social and historical,
as well as creative context of European painting.
This project was prompted by a physical need
to replace the skylights,
but we also have undertaken a series
of architectural interventions,
including moving many doorways
and establishing new sight lines
that we hope will guide the visitor
through what is frankly an enormous suite of galleries.
To rehang the collection was a great opportunity as well
to look outside the department's holdings
to other curatorial departments that met,
as well as even to paintings that were made
beyond the chronological limits
and geographical boundaries of these galleries.
All of this to really underscore
that there isn't one singular way
of looking at the history of European painting.
There are many histories,
and to invite visitors to consider that.
We wanted to begin our story
by giving visitors some orientation to Europe,
both as a geography, but also as a concept,
a territory whose borders have shifted over the centuries
and are still contested to this day.
One of the things that has been mobilized in the past
to unite Europe is the idea of a shared heritage
of classical antiquity from the Mediterranean.
Our opening gallery
with the very grand and monumental works
by the Venetian painter Tiepolo
also includes a number of loans
from other curatorial departments.
Those Tiepolo paintings depict ancient Roman history,
and by placing them in dialogue with other works,
we wanted to think about the very expansive,
very complicated and global legacy
of Mediterranean antiquity.
It's not just something that belongs
to what is now recognized as Europe.
This is a tradition that has been responded to
across the world,
and that ranges from the sculpture of a bodhisattva
we have from present-day Pakistan
to an 18th century work by a Mexican indigenous artist
that depicts a story told by the ancient Roman poet Virgil.
This is a batea, a type of shallow wooden tray.
It is the work of an artist named José Manuel de la Cerda,
an indigenous artist who worked in the city of Pátzcuaro
in Michoacán in Western Mexico
in the middle of the 18th century.
It would have been displayed along with 11 other bateas
from the same series devoted to Virgil's Aeneid
in the Vice Regal Palace in Mexico City.
Starting here, it says,
Aeneas provoca a la guerra turno.
So turnos, provoked into war by Aeneas,
which leads to the founding of Rome.
This is a narrative that was adopted by the Spanish monarchy
and many other European monarchies as a legitimizing myth.
It was also used to legitimize
the Spanish conquest of Mexico.
So the whole narrative of crossing the Atlantic
was compared to Aeneas' voyage.
So it's a really, really complex object.
And I like to think that it speaks to the theme
of this introductory gallery,
in that it causes us not only to look again,
but to think again about what Europe is historically,
culturally, and even geographically.
This gallery is interesting for a paintings gallery
because there isn't a single painting on the wall.
We look at works that stood on altarpieces,
small devotional images.
Paintings were held in one's hands.
They often were companions on travel
and people returned to them time and again
in different contexts, in different conditions.
Here, we're looking at an extraordinary work by Duccio,
one of the earliest in our collection,
a work made by a Sienese artist around 1300,
looking to Byzantine icons from the East as its source.
This remarkable painting was made at a moment
where Italian artists are really coming to terms
with what it even means to be a painter.
The image of the Virgin Mary was a fairly prescriptive image.
It was established by legend
when the Virgin appeared to St. Luke and said,
here I am, capture my likeness.
What I love about this painting
is it shows a mother and her child
in a kind of tender connection
and trying to capture that spirit in paint.
It really is a spark to recognizing
how artists at the start of our story
are looking at their own place
in relation to a long history of image making.
We've placed Duccio's Madonna next to a devotional image
by the French 19th century painter Ingres.
Not only does this bracket the chronological span
of what we're looking at,
but I love the mirror of a work
at the beginning of our story
next to a work made 500 years later.
When we enter this gallery,
we encounter a range of faces from 15th century Europe.
Before this moment,
portraiture was primarily reserved for the aristocracy
or leaders of the church.
And what we have here is a rising upper middle class
who have new capabilities for commissioning art
and a growing interest
in having their individual likenesses captured
for purposes of commemoration,
projections of social status,
but also for devotional reasons.
These are portraits painted by the Bruges artist Hans Memling
and they depict Tommaso and Maria Portinari.
Tommaso was the branch manager
of the Medici Bank in Bruges.
And they were one of many Italian clients
who sought out Hans Memling
because of the real balance he strikes
between idealization and individualization.
Memling specialized in details of the physiognomy
like small wrinkles around the eyes
or even a scar on Tommaso's chin.
We have his five o'clock shadow.
Just as much attention has been given
to their sumptuous costumes,
which are really projecting their social status.
There's such a sense of aliveness
and individuality with these sitters
that it can kind of trick us into thinking
we actually have a better sense of who they were
than maybe we really do.
This work was painted in 1470,
likely to commemorate the marriage of the couple.
What we don't really have a sense of here
is the marked age difference between Tommaso and Maria.
He was 42 at the time they married and she was only 14.
So that real age difference and power imbalance
from the perspective of our current time and culture
is not reflected.
We have much more of a sense of them as equals.
Maria has such independence and self-possession here.
This gallery looks at an international style in Europe
from around 1350 to the first decades of the 15th century.
We call it international Gothic,
kind of court style that was a brand
almost throughout the continent.
This is a style that draws as much from sculpture
as it does from metalwork, from jewels,
from illuminated manuscripts, from religious reliquaries.
It's wonderful to think of an artist in Northern Italy
or an artist in Prague or England,
all thinking about certain questions
or even looking at similar objects
to work in their respective cultural contexts.
And it's wonderful to see the different layers
even in a small painting such as this Virgin and Child
enthroned by a painter active in Prague
in the middle of the 14th century.
This figure of the Virgin, so courtly, so refined,
so elegant, embodies all of the best qualities
of Gothic illumination.
But the structure in which she's placed
reveals an artist that understands
the sophisticated engagement with perspectival space
that the Italian artists were trying to define
in the 14th century.
The rediscovery of Rome and antiquity
in the 15th and early 16th centuries in Italy
is such a important moment to consider.
Rome was not only an important idea,
but it was also an important reality.
Its monuments could be looked at with a distance
and a recognition of that distance
allowed for an extraordinary exploration.
One thing I love about this gallery
is that it brings home in the paintings
and in the sculptures how ancient Rome
was not just quoted,
but actually lived by the Venetians at this moment.
And perhaps the figure in this gallery
that expresses this point is Venus herself.
And we're looking at the Venus Marina,
the Venus who was born of the sea.
We can identify her as Venus born of the sea
because her attribute is the dolphin.
And maps of Venice at the period point out
that the dolphin is the emblem of the city.
But what is compelling about this work
is how her kind of mellifluous form,
the way that the light picks up and shines off
of the details of her flesh,
is so much akin to the magnificent paintings
that are nearby.
It really does allow us to consider
the effects of light and form
the same way that the artists are trying to capture that
in two dimension on the flat surfaces of these canvases.
I also love when we look at this picture
between the Venus and then the warrior statuette,
we see that there is this constant tension in Venice
between the arts of peace and the arts of war
symbolized by Venus and by Mars.
There's this concept consistent in antiquity
that peace is only possible through martial readiness.
It's extraordinary to think of Venice
known as well from making bronze cannons
would also use those same furnaces
to make such remarkable works of art.
The focus of this thematic gallery
is the emergence of landscape as an independent genre
from the late 15th century to the early 17th century.
So as you know, prior to this point,
landscapes are really more seen as backdrops
to religious subject matter,
but here landscape is starting to emerge
as its own protagonist.
I think we really see that in the Patinir.
We have this just absolutely dazzling
vista into the distance.
For me, the thing that immediately comes to mind
is the vantage point that the artist has taken.
He's offering us a true bird's eye view of a landscape,
and that's something that changes by and large
as time goes on into the later 16th and 17th centuries
where artists tend to favor a much lower viewpoint
as if the artist is on the ground
and we as viewers are also on the ground,
almost like we could just step right into the landscape.
Here we have one of the iconic landscapes of our collection,
Pieter Bruegel, the Elder's Harvesters
from the 16th century.
This is a work that even if we still have
a bit of a bird's eye view,
you feel like you can step into it.
Of course, this is a kind of watershed
in the history of European landscape
in the fact that a work of this size no less
would just show, at least on the surface,
a purely quotidian scene.
Right, unlike the Patinir,
there's no explicit religious subject matter.
There's this tension, right,
because what the artist is explicitly showing us
is a landscape that is shaped by human labor,
even we could say engineering,
so the geometric forms of the cut fields
of wheat and the bales.
When we think about this painting
as one made for a particular elite urban viewer,
I think it helps us recognize
that we're also seeing a social structuring here, right?
The very fact that the peasants
are depicted for the pleasure
of this Antwerp merchant and banker
who benefited from their labor itself
is a reminder that this isn't necessarily
an accurate depiction of what this life was really like.
Here we have a hyper-local focus
on later 15th and 16th century painting
in three cities in what is now present-day Belgium,
Bruges, Antwerp, and Brussels.
Due to the prosperity and the independence
of these very cosmopolitan centers,
we see for the first time in Europe
the emergence of a year-round art market.
The art market, with its competitive environment,
is changing the way painters are working in their workshops,
but it's also changing the subjects
that they choose to depict.
In terms of process,
we see different painters
developing particular specializations
and then teaming up to collaborate on a particular work
to produce bespoke objects
combining the artistic strengths of both makers.
A great example of that is this wonderful triptych
that's a collaboration between the Antwerp painter
Jos van Cleve, who specialized in painting figures,
and an artist whose name we don't know today,
but who was equally skillful and specialized in landscapes.
In terms of changes to the subjects that were depicted,
what we see more and more is a foregrounding of elements
that are not strictly obligatory for the religious subjects,
be it landscape or still life or domestic elements,
so-called genre elements, taken from quotidian life.
Here we have one panel of an altarpiece
by the artist Bernard van Orley,
who was based in Brussels.
It depicts the life of St. John the Baptist.
What I love about this birth scene
is that, first of all, we have it set
in what essentially is a sumptuous,
courtly, 16th-century interior,
and we're really given this view of women at work
caring for the new baby and the mother,
so this kind of combination of humble details
and also courtly elements.
You'll have seen from the other galleries
that we've put a real emphasis on looking across Europe,
sometimes even across the globe,
but sometimes where our holdings in a single artist
are so strong, we've devoted entire galleries
to one towering figure in the history of European painting.
That's certainly the case with Rembrandt.
We have one of the greatest collections
of his works in the world,
and we're particularly fortunate in being able to represent
almost all facets of his long career.
I'd say the crowning jewel of our collection of Rembrandt
is Aristotle Contemplating a Bust of Homer,
and this is a painting that you know intimately,
having conserved it for over a year.
Yes, it was a privilege to work on this picture,
and as you know, it was last cleaned in 1980, 40 years ago.
The problem that developed on the picture
is that the varnish had deteriorated
and it had lost its clarity,
and with an artist like Rembrandt,
it's so important to maintain that golden glow.
He has a very particular way of painting
and uses a very unconventional combination of materials,
but as a result of this,
there are certain chemical changes that take place.
We now have much more understanding
of these chemical changes,
and so I was able to use methods
to remove the salt deposits
which were causing the appearance of degradation.
I'll never forget coming up pretty early in the treatment,
and suddenly that pile of books
that is in the left-hand corner registered to me.
It became legible.
In a way, I have to say,
even being the curator of this painting,
I'd never contemplated that detail before,
but you absolutely brought it back for us,
and I think that's true
of so many individual passages of this picture.
He's done something wonderful with his paint
where he actually builds up the areas of highlighting
so that they become almost sculptural,
and at the same time,
he conveys an amazing sense of interiority.
We feel that we're seeing a real person lost in thought.
It's almost as though Rembrandt has conjured up
an act of thinking right before our eyes.
It's such a privileged thing
to actually work over the surface of a picture
and see every nuance of the painting,
and as you're uncovering,
it's always the most marvelous thing
to see when every single brushstroke
had an intelligence to it, which is meaningful.
Ogreco is a key figure in the history of art,
but also stands a little outside
of typical stylistic developments.
He's someone who comes from Greece.
He trains in Italy,
looking particularly at Italian Renaissance painters,
and then takes off in Spain,
where he actually has an incredibly successful career,
but then after his death,
sort of goes silent for almost two centuries
in which his work is seen as somehow outside the norm
and certainly as a neoclassical moment takes hold in Europe,
and so the result is you have someone
who's lost for a long period of time
and then comes back with a vengeance
when he's rediscovered at the end of the 19th century.
This is Ogreco's view of the city of Toledo.
It's a painting he painted around the year 1600,
and this is an imaginary view, actually, of the city
that's charged with a kind of emotional intensity
that a more topographical view might have lacked.
One of the most incredible things about this painting
is the way that Ogreco engages the full range
of the surface of the painting itself
in this kind of faceted effect
and ricochet of light and shade.
The painting next to it is a work by Paul Cézanne.
It's a work from the 1890s.
Cézanne was really interested in Ogreco from the 1880s,
a period during which he's actually copying
the work of Ogreco that he can see in collections in Paris.
I think this is really an opportunity
to try to see through the artist's eye
what was it that Cézanne was seeing there.
Of course, it's about context.
It's about the actual link of Cézanne standing in a room
in front of a painting,
and that's all historically documented,
but what, in terms of kind of indescribable
visual characteristics, links these things
is something that can only happen in the gallery
in sort of lived space by the visitor
and their emotional reaction to those two paintings
hanging next to each other.
So our galleries are really rethinking Spanish painting
of the so-called Golden Age.
One of the ways we're doing that
is to think of Spain in its capacity
as a remarkably multiracial society in the 17th century,
also one that is connected globally.
The portrait of Juan de Pareja by Diego Velázquez
represents a man of African descent
who was enslaved by Velázquez for over 20 years
in his studio before Pareja,
the man you see in this painting,
became a painter in his own right at the end of his life.
What attracts me about the portrait
is not just the familiar way
in which Velázquez had betrayed his assistant,
but also the way in which,
by being an assistant to Velázquez,
Juan de Pareja would have been in charge
of stretching the canvas
and applying those preparatory layers.
And so, clearly, he had a contribution
in the making of his own portrait.
One of the things we really were trying to lean into
with the reinstallation was to ask
how the introduction of things
that had not traditionally been in these galleries
allow us to rethink what a European tradition
might even mean.
This is the first time that the museum
is showing artworks from the Viceroyalty of New Spain,
New Granada, and Peru together in one room,
which really gives us the opportunity
to have wider conversations
about their relationship to European art
and their differences with these European canons.
It also allows us to have a conversation
of the development of the art of painting
as a global phenomenon, rather than a European one.
Perhaps one of the most dazzling pictures
in this gallery is this representation
of the Virgin of Alfanera from the Cusco School in Peru,
dated to the 1770s.
It's quite interesting in the use of an iconography
that comes from Spain by a community
of people from La Rioja province
to venerate images of their local virgins.
One of the light motifs that you see in Cusco School
is the use of brocateado, this brocade-type technique
in which gold leaf is applied onto textiles
that could be in order to represent dress statues
or things like polychrome statues
with esgrafito motifs.
It's about texture and this idea of representation
more so than accuracy that you would think
in a term of perspective.
That's what's fascinating is to identify geographies
and periods in time in which the assumed goals
or priorities are not necessarily what they were
in, say, Paris or Rome or Madrid.
And that's such a refreshing way
to look at the history of painting.
One of my areas of curatorial responsibility at the Met
is 18th-century British painting.
And I was excited with this gallery
to have the opportunity to complicate the geography
of what we consider 18th-century British art.
We've included a pair of very generous loans
from our colleagues in the American Wing
that are paintings made by artists
who are now considered founding figures
in the history of American art
but who were actually working in London at the time,
which was the destination for ambitious painters
from North America at the end of the 18th century.
As many times as I've seen this painting,
I never can get over how wonderful the cocked elbow is.
That's fabulous.
That's a motif that goes right back to the high Renaissance.
Copley has clearly studied it,
and also its different permutations in the work
of artists working in England like Van Dyck, like Reynolds.
It conveys so much swagger, so much confidence,
but at the same time, he's so young.
He's so fragile-looking in many ways.
He's about to embark on this very dangerous career
as a midshipman in the British Navy.
And I think that Copley has so skillfully captured
that mixture of youth but also courage.
And also, I think it's important to say
he is a child of great privilege.
You know, he's serving on the ship of his father,
and he grows up to become a rear admiral as well.
But I agree with you.
There's just that wonderful sensitivity.
And of course, Copley is seen as the most important painter
working in the British American colonies
because he can capture this intensity
of character, personality.
There's a really living quality to his figures on canvas,
but also what this character, this young boy,
conveys in terms of it being a product of empire,
in a sense.
This massive history painting by John Trumbull
gives our presentation of 18th century British
and Anglo-American painting a real jolt, I think.
It's an image of imperial warfare, an image of death.
It's an image that celebrates the heroism,
the nobility of British soldiers,
and by extension, the British empire.
And I think that that context becomes a little more clear
when it's shown surrounded by other British
as opposed to American paintings.
And what Trumbull has chosen to focus on,
certainly the drama of the fight, the battle,
the incredible sky, even the rock of Gibraltar,
you know, is illuminated by those flares.
And the focus on this very poignant death
of this Spanish officer who is resisting the assistance
offered by the British.
So this homage to, of course, the pain of war,
but also the nobleness of the cause,
even though they're on different sides.
And I think it underlines the point
that we're talking about colonial societies, right?
I mean, so this is the British-American,
Anglo-American narrative in art history and geopolitics.
And I think when you see this in dialogue
with the often very placid or tranquil grand portraits
of British aristocrats that we also have on display,
it makes clear some of the historical context
that was undergirding the flowering of British culture
and power in the 18th century.
One way to think about the last sequence of rooms
in the European paintings galleries
is to understand the rise of France in particular,
and also within France, the Salon exhibition.
This is a annual exhibition put on by the Royal Academy
that really dominates not only French painting,
but by the mid-18th century,
dominates European painting more generally.
This gallery in particular looks at the 18th century
when the Salon as an exhibition space
and the French Academy really structured artists' lives
almost completely, and eventually in the public exhibition
of works of art.
Artists are painting specifically for exhibition,
not necessarily even with a patron.
This is a new phenomenon.
It's not painting for a church,
it's not painting for a given collector,
but rather for publicity and the critics.
It becomes all of the groundwork
for thinking about the 19th and the 20th century,
but also for how we view art today,
even the phenomenon of art museums.
The idea that works are there for your enjoyment
as a public, the idea of a public art viewing
being part of urban culture.
This is Adelaide Labillard's self-portrait,
a monumental work that was shown at the Salon of 1785,
and she depicts herself before the easel
with two of her pupils.
And it's really seen as a kind of manifesto
of women's art education and role as professional painters,
which she shows with great accomplishment and gusto here
in this ambitious self-portrait
that includes herself dressed really to the nines.
And this is very typical of artists in this moment
as they try to establish themselves as respectable,
as a profession that was akin to the liberal arts
rather than just a kind of manual activity.
They often showed themselves as people
who'd achieved a certain place in the world.
And clearly between the furnishings and her dress, her hat,
all of these things are making that clear.
With the French Revolution, the number of women
who would participate in public exhibitions exploded.
And the Met is really fortunate
in that we have an extremely strong core group of works
by women painters from the 1770s onward.
But this kind of image shows you the public visibility
of women as painters at the end of the Ancien Regime.
One goal that we had for our reinstallation
was to show off the many recent acquisitions we've made
that allow us to tell an expanded narrative
of European painting.
And one of my favorites among these recent acquisitions
is this fantastic portrait of the Dutch artist,
Raoul Rous, that Rous painted as a collaboration
with another artist, Michiel van Musser.
We actually know about the collaboration
not just because the two hands are visible,
but because there's a poetic inscription
on this opened album of floral studies.
And it roughly translates along the lines of,
behold how Rous made her brush shine
when Musser painted her from life.
And it's a fascinating moment
of a kind of gentle competition, rivalry,
perhaps between the still-life painter and the portraitist.
But what the poem makes clear
is that Rous was the much more famous painter at the time.
And I think it should open our eyes
to the celebrity of a woman artist
and also the prominence of the genre of still-life painting
in the late 17th century.
Still-life has often been dismissed
as somehow lesser than history painting
than scenes from myth or the Bible.
But we see here a consummate artist at work in her studio,
having tribute paid to her by her colleagues and friends.
We wanted to put this work on view initially
to think again about a subject matter
that has been a constant in European painting.
And that is paintings that reflect
on the identity of the artist,
of what it means to be a painter.
And how does art get made?
What is the space of the studio?
One thing that will be striking to visitors
to this particular gallery
is that a lot of the work expands the geography
and the chronology of our department.
We have self-portraits by 20th century artists.
And by including the work by Kerry James Marshall,
we have a major 21st century allegory of art making.
All of these things are to emphasize
that this tradition of investigating
the conditions of art making
is something that is very much going on today.
We hope visitors will approach our galleries
with a sense of creativity, a sense of possibility,
and a sense that they can make connections
across our 45 galleries
and return to these dialogues again and again.
We think of these galleries as experimental spaces,
as playful spaces,
places where you can tell multiple
and sometimes conflicting stories.
We wanted to signal that we are open
to discussing new questions and themes
issues and concerns
that traditionally haven't been addressed in this space.
To explore the nuances, the more subtle questions
that allow visitors to get a much broader sense
of what European paintings are
and how we might consider them today.
