I backpacked into an archaeological site that is one of a kind in the entire world. I wanted to see if this recent discovery was everything that it claimed to be. What I found, was far more intricate and complex than I ever imagined.
DISCLAIMER: Links included in this description might be affiliate links. If you purchase a product with the provided links I may receive a small commission. There is no additional charge to you! Thank you for supporting my channel so I can continue to provide you with free content!
How did the first humans arrive in the Americas and when did they make the journey? Two questions
we've been asking for decades. Definitive answers have remained elusive even after years of
professional cutting-edge research. In 2021, a press release from White Sands National Park
brought everything we thought we knew into question. They claimed they had found and
successfully dated human footprints that were 21,000 to 23,000 years old. This has been labeled
as one of the biggest discoveries of the 21st century and if accurate, it would be. But is it
true? As I've followed this story over the past few years, I've grown concerned that mainstream media
is only presenting us with one side of the story. This discovery is not as definite as it's made
out to be. There are other explanations for what was found in White Sands and they have just as
much evidence to support them. I couldn't help but wonder, are we being fed a biased or even
inaccurate version of history? With a desire to examine the evidence and see the full picture for
myself, I made the long trip to southern New Mexico to meet up with a geoarchaeologist who's
been studying the site for years. What I learned over the course of this trip was truly surprising.
Just sitting here thinking about the unique opportunity we're going to have today to
to really go into a site that has garnered international attention. I mean this is no
this is no clickbait or over-exaggeration. These footprints have garnered so much attention
because they sparked controversy around the age-old questions of when and how people got to
the Americas. This might be common knowledge for some of you, but just to get us all on the same
page, generally speaking, the current genetic, archaeological, and geological models place the
arrival of humans in the Americas about 16,000 years ago. Beringia, the Bering land bridge that
we all learned about in grade school, is still a part of the common theory, but it's more complex
these days. Most scholars acknowledge there was probably settlement both by land and sea with the
water migration able to occur earlier because it wouldn't have been stopped by impassable glaciation
in present-day Canada. Eventually, ice-free corridors opened up that allowed people to push south
maybe some 14,000 years ago. So, when you consider this in light of the claims at White Sands, you can
see the cause for so much attention and scrutiny. The dates given at White Sands, 21 to 23,000 years
ago, pushed the peopling of the Americas back by a solid five to seven thousand years. But as exciting
as that could be, and as easy as it would be to just kind of jump on the bandwagon, I think there
are some things we need to consider before we jump to those conclusions. Part of the reason I really
wanted to do this video is because when I look at the mainstream media reports about this, a lot of
them make it sound like this is pretty much a done deal. You know, we've found these tracks, they've
been dated, they're 21, 23,000 years old, and yeah, let's rewrite the history books. But when I
read some of the academic side of things, you know, not the mainstream media, the academic side, it's like
we might be oversimplifying this. No doubt, extraordinary claims have been made about the
The most significant finding is that we can definitively say that human beings were present
here at White Sands during the last glacial maximum, and that is far older than they have
been confirmed anywhere else in North or South America. Years ago. And White Sands is one of the
places which provides just absolute, definite, irrefutable evidence of that, that they were here
in many ways forces a reset for some of the kinds of conversations that people have been having
about the people in the Americas. It's a dramatic leap. And as I say, you know, extraordinary claims
require extraordinary evidence. This is both an extraordinary claim with extraordinary evidence.
I think the old saying is true. Extraordinary claims do require extraordinary evidence.
The evidence given to the general public has been presented as irrefutable and conclusive.
But is it really? Hoping that my hike today with a local professional shed more light on this
question, I headed in this bizarre landscape. You can see all this sand piled up on the side
of the road. These are active sand dunes. And so I mean, sand is continuously covering this and
they've got to bring plows in here like you would for snow and plow to keep the road open.
All right, everybody, we are here right now with Dave. Dave, thanks for coming out with us.
Tell me a little bit real quick, Dave, about your connection and knowledge of the site.
Well, my name is Dave Rochelle. I'm a professional geoarchaeologist. I've worked here in the basin
for about 12 to 13 years. I've been affiliated with the tracks and trackways off and on since
2014. White Sands Dune Field is an amazing place. It is the largest gypsum dune field
in the world. And pan around here, just see how expansive, amazing it is. This dune field formed
about 5,000 years ago during the middle hole scene, during this huge mega drought. The lake
levels dropped. We had a lot of scouring of the lake and all that sand got dumped on the leeward
side of the basin. It's about 400 square kilometers in size. And the sand sheet here
is probably around 30 to 40 feet thick. After that, you'll hit lake sediments. Most of the
tracks and trackways are in the alkali flat. And we're going to walk over there and check that out
in a little bit. And you see those swish marks? Yeah, you know, tire tracks. Or somebody with a
UTV doing rooster tails. That's just the truncated part of the actual dunes. The water table is very
shallow. So the moist part of the dune gets locked in place, but the upper part that's more dry just
keeps on moving. So it just leaves the base of the dune and the inner dune areas and the upper part
of the dune just keeps marching along. Huh. Since it's a shallow water table, if we have really,
really wet years, the dune field will flood and you can come out here and paddleboard.
Really? You can paddleboard out here? Yeah. Certain years. It's happened probably
10 times in the last 20 years. No way. Yeah, it's pretty remarkable. So just in these little,
like how far does the... It can be all the way up to where you come in at the visitor center.
No way. In 2006, it was that far up. Holy cow. Yeah, you can come out here and canoe.
You could, yeah. That's a lot. I mean, for you guys, I know you didn't drive in. I mean,
we're talking, what, a couple miles? Yes. Of inundated floodwaters. That's right. Probably
six miles or so, yeah. Wow. One thing about gypsum, though, it's not... When we look at the
basin and range of the southwestern part of the United States and we look at these areas where
we know we have had palluvial lakes during the last ice age, there's not a lot of gypsum.
So it's not that common. Here, New Mexico has a lot of gypsum because in the mountain ranges
that surround the basin, like the San Andreas Mountains and the Sacramento Mountains,
you have gypsum beds that are interbedded into that limestone. And we've had a lot of tectonic
activity which has crinkled the landscape and has exposed those beds. So when you have rain
during wet palluvial periods that you would have during an ice age, all that gypsum dissolves
and it gets swooshed down into the lake and it loads in that lake during that wet cool period.
But when the lake dries out, all of that gypsum precipitates out into thick evaporite beds.
And then the southwest northeast wind comes over the mountains. And you can see those little
saddles in the mountain range. It goes over those areas really, really efficiently, very fast,
and it scours out the lake bed and deposits all that material on the leeward side of the basin,
creating the dune field. Huh. You know, New Mexico, probably, and West Texas, has most of
the gypsum deposits in North America. And that's just because we have a lot of Permian age gypsum
beds. This is a good chance to do some quick terminology clarification. You've heard Dave use
the term tracks and trackways. In this video, those terms are used synonymously with footprints.
So if we're talking about human tracks or human footprints, it's the same thing. Megafauna are
large game animals. In this video, when we use the term, we're talking about the now extinct
ice age era animals, like mammoths, giant sloths, dire wolves, camelops, and so on. You'll also hear
Dave use the term deflation. We're not talking economics or the amount of air pressure in your
car tire. Deflation, in this use, refers to the removal of sediment particles by the forces of
wind. It's a type of wind erosion. You are a geoarchaeologist. That's correct. And a geoarchaeologist
is a specialist that uses earth science techniques to solve archaeological problems.
It's usually people that are geoarchaeologists are heavy on the geology and soil science and
geomorphology. I use soil science principles and geologic principles to help archaeologists locate
buried sites. I also assess the context of those sites. I also do paleoenvironmental work. In 2014,
I started working on the tracks and trackways. We did this project on the western side of the basin
where we excavated a baby mastodon. And the project, what was important about it,
is that we were trying to determine if people were involved, if it was a kill site.
What we found out is that the baby mastodon was about 27,000 years old. So at that time,
we were like, well, most of the artifacts that you're finding around the bones are washing in
from sites upslope, and they're not associated with one another. But that really led to my first
experience looking at the tracks and trackways. And we started doing more research on them around
where those bones were at, at all these sloth tracks. Just amazing, the biodiversity of all
these ice age animals and their prints just impressed into the gypsum. There was so much
diversity here because of the presence of an ancient lake, now known as Paleo Lake Otero.
Lake Otero was massive and covered some 1,600 square miles, larger than the state of Rhode Island.
As the climate changed, the lake eventually dried up, but it supported life for thousands of years.
If we were here some 20,000 years ago, these now extinct animals would have been a daily part of
our lives. Sometimes for the better, providing us with food or materials. Sometimes for the worse,
preying upon us or acting as competition while hunting. It's around the shoreline of this ancient
lake that the footprints in question are found. And today, that's where we're headed.
This is big science. This really is. This is a hot spot for archaeology, peopling of a new world.
They were located maybe 2009-ish, but things weren't published until 2021. Is that accurate?
Well, I mean, the story really begins in 1932 and they had this trapper out here and he started
finding prints. Oh, really? Okay. But he confused a lot of the sloth prints as being Bigfoot prints,
right? Because they are big. Yeah, I've heard that part of the story. I didn't realize it was back
in the 30s, though. Yeah, and then they probably found them in 2010. I came out here on this side
with the park service in 2015. Man, so 1932. Yes. A trapper finds Bigfoot out here.
So yeah, they've known about them for quite a while. Most of the tracks and trackways,
as far as like the megafauna tracks go, they really got studied a lot in the early 2000s by
the New Mexico Bureau of Geology. I think people were kind of iffy about the human tracks at first.
About just of like, we don't know how old these things are. Yes. Like, we don't really.
The problem is that at that time, all you would find are, they'd be on the surface of this
deflated, of the deflated alkali flat. And it's really hard to date surface prints. You don't
how old they are. I mean, they could be 21,000 years old, but they also could be a decade old.
We don't know. So you have to find them buried. Break that down for just the average person like
me. The problem with surface tracks is that there's been so much erosion. It's not uncommon
for the surface to be deflated and buried again and then deflated again and re-exhumed.
So you always have this possibility that you could have more recent tracks superimposed on top of
older tracks. That's always on the table when you're dealing with surface tracks.
When they're buried, as far as you know, they're sealed off and they have really, really great
stratigraphic context. Now, dating them, that's a whole different thing. That's a hard...
And we're going to get into that later. Yeah. It's very hard to date them.
Talk to me about how the footprints would have been created.
Okay. So like the megafauna tracks, I mean, these are big animals. A mammoth would weigh
anywhere from 8 to 12 tons. And they're walking across soft, moist sediment. And as they press
into the sediment, they leave behind a print that's in the mud, right? Over time, that print
gets buried and filled in with sediment and it's covered up. Well, when it's covered up,
there's some process that lithifies the print, right? And it makes it harder than the surrounding
sediment. Then you go through a period where you have a lot of wind erosion, all of the soft
sediments removed, and that cast of the print is exhumed, and oftentimes it's pedestaled.
So the original land surface that both the people and the megafauna walked on
is gone. And all you're seeing is the subsurface cast at the surface has been inverted. So a lot
of these prints are in a positive relief. So they're little bumps in the landscape,
and the original surface has completely been removed by erosion. And you find human footprints
near these megafauna tracks, but oftentimes the human footprints are pressed into the mud
while the surrounding megafauna tracks are inverted little pedestals. So they're not
associated with one another. We see these images and they're, you know, they look like human
footprints with toes and they're very compelling looking. But when you're out there wandering
around on the surface, what you're seeing really just looks like a blob, right? Whether it's
a human track, a giant sloth. That's correct. Yes, they're blobs. They don't really have that
digit morphology that you see. And they could be human footprints, but they're not very detailed.
Yeah, and I think that's important just for everybody to understand is it's not like there's
these perfectly articulated footprints out there that all of a sudden we just happen to stumble
upon five, ten years ago. That's correct. The thousands of them that are out there are just
little blobs that have no digits. One of the criticisms of the prints at Locality 2 is that
we don't really know how they're excavated. They have not provided photos before and after, so
we don't really know what they look like before they are carved out. And that's important
because archaeology is about controlled excavation. You know, we document everything we do. We dig a
test unit and we go down a level, we take a photograph, go down a level, we take a photograph.
And we just don't know how those things were excavated. And that gets into like sloth tracks,
right? Some of these footprints are probably misidentified sloth tracks because if you don't
have digits on a human and you don't have the claw on the sloth, they look the same.
Dave was telling me that there's been no rigorous scientific protocol created to discern the
difference between a sloth track, a human track, or just some naturally occurring blob. I think
that's important for us to know because it's not always an obvious distinction out here.
All right Dave, so where are we at right now? This is the Alkali Flat. This is the former or
the lake bed of Paleo Lake Otero. It's a massive salt pan now and this is where most of the tracks
and trackways are located. Tons of them. Anywhere from proboscidian tracks, which is the most common
tracks. That's the scientific name for a mammoth essentially. That's correct, yes. They're the most
common and that would make a lot of sense because it's a very big animal so it's going to leave an
impression. Probably the second most common would be sloth tracks, camel tracks. You can find felid
tracks and direwolf tracks and all of them are pressed into this salt pan surface. And a lot of
human tracks and trackways are out here as well. Lake Otero is pretty big. During the last ice age
it filled up most of the basin. More than likely it was a salt lake. I don't know if it was fresh
and a lot of people kind of go back and forth on that but it was probably a salty lake. Very similar
to the Great Salt Lake in Utah. Okay. You can see how we've got essentially sand dunes here,
sand dunes, and then bam, it ends right here. This is essentially the edge of that ancient lake basin.
Really fascinating to try and imagine what this place would have looked like 10-15,000 years ago.
Try to picture in your mind's eye an ancient lake out here, megafauna, mammoths, giant sloths,
all of it walking around out here. It's pretty remarkable how the dunes seemingly stretch
forever and then all of a sudden they're gone and the landscape becomes more or less open and flat.
Now, I know there's been a lot to wrap your head around. Speaking for myself, it's challenging to
comprehend it all, but given the possible magnitude of this discovery, I think it's worth the time and
effort. So now that we're in the area where all the tracks are found, let's briefly recap. The footprints
have been known about for decades. They were Bigfoot originally, but for most of that time,
people were only aware of tracks on the surface and Dave explained how challenging it is to date
a surface print. Sometime in the 2000s, the National Park Service identified an area out here that had
buried tracks. That opened up a whole new realm of possibilities. They proceeded to dig a trench
and found human footprints in various stratified layers. They looked for some sort of organic
material in those layers that they could radiocarbon date and what they found and subsequently dated
is a plant known as rupia. It was the radiocarbon dates from that plant that dated the tracks to 21
to 23,000 years ago. This was the cause of the initial press release in 2021 that made
international news. Hopefully you're still with me and that's where we'll pick up the story.
So the plant that's been used to get these 21 to 23,000 year old datings is a plant called rupia.
So Dave's got a few examples of that so that we can just see it in person. So rupia is a
submerged aquatic plant and it doesn't pull in carbon dioxide from the atmosphere. Instead it
pulls in carbon from the groundwater and that groundwater carbon is very old because we have a
lot of limestone in the basin and it incorporates that old carbon into its plant tissue as it grows
and when it dies, you radiocarbon date it, the plant will come back older than what it's supposed
to be. We've dated modern plants in the basin and we would get an age range of anywhere from 2,000
to 8,800 years for a modern plant, which is just insane. But it's also a very mobile plant.
It's designed when it flowers it breaks apart and all of the stems and seeds float and once that
happens it becomes the tumbleweed of the lake and it can get pushed from one side of the lake to the
other and if that happens it'll get pushed onto shore and wave action will roll it into balls.
This is a rupia seed ball or also called a lake ball. When you find these what it's telling you
is that the seeds were transported into the site and what that does is it creates a unique scenario
where you could have artificially aged material being deposited in younger sediment right and
what that'll do is make whatever's in the sediments appear older than what it really is.
So it's quite possible that these seeds which are really really unreliable that they're using to
date the prints are making the footprints appear older than what they really are by how much we
don't really know. I mean isn't that that's like a crucial point that people watch and should
understand right? The hard water effect in rupia that's it's it's a it's a scientific fact that
that happens it's not just rupia any submerged plant is subject to that. If it's pulling its
carbon in from the groundwater and not the atmosphere it'll come back thousands of years
And you said anywhere from two to eight thousand right? In the basin anywhere from 2,000 to 8,800
years. 88 wow. One thing else we found is we went out and we dated the plant every few months over
its growing cycle for a year and the age of the plant can of that grove that we dated that meadow
can fluctuate by 6,000 years in a matter of months. It's extremely unreliable. I think for the average
person like me to to grab like to wrap our heads around it all it's it's challenging. Yes it's
complicated. You know that's that's partly why a newspaper article or you know some article online
that says hey these are 23,000 years old uh yeah there's a little controversy around it but yeah
this is what we found. I mean that's part of the reason why that's maybe so captivating is because
we don't really know any better we don't know the questions to ask. Okay what do we have here? These
are the same kind of balls but this these formed in Canada and it's Sandoff Lake. Huh. Since I
published a paper I had this guy send me these balls he's a lake ball nerd. Who would have thought
lake ball specialists. Yes but that's it's all rupia. Yeah. Formed by wave action mixing. Dave
just dropped a lot of knowledge on us. If you only take away one thing from this section it's that
rupia is notorious for being an inaccurate dating method because of the amount of carbon it absorbs
from groundwater and its ability to be easily transported by natural processes. But it's by
dates derived from this plant that some are attempting to rewrite history. To be fair it's
much more complex than just rupia and carbon. If you've been following the story over the last
couple of years you're probably wondering about the report released in the fall of 2023 where
National Park researchers published new findings in response to the criticism about their use of
rupia. In this new report they describe two additional dating methods used and they claim
confirm the 21 to 23,000 year old dates of the prince. Dave and his colleagues have responded
with a follow-up academic article where they raise compelling questions regarding the accuracy of the
second round of methods. Since then there have been more back and forth articles. You know the
Tularosa Basin isn't some random basin in Nevada that no one's at. This is a place that has been
surveyed. It's been studied from an archaeological perspective for 50 years. In this basin 1 million
acres have been surveyed. 500,000 square meters of excavation has occurred. Thousands of hearth
features have been dated. So how could we have missed thousands of years of human occupation?
To me it's going to take more. We need physical archaeological records. We need
lithics. We need a hearth. You have footprints but you have nothing else and then when you go
and look for something nearby that is a lithic artifact or a hearth feature and if you're able
to date it, it comes back a couple thousand years old. I don't know. I'm skeptical and I think to
really put this to bed we need a site and that will end the debate. Dave's referring to the fact
that nothing remotely close to a 21,000 year old artifact has ever been found in the Tularosa Basin.
The oldest known artifacts here are a few Clovis points, so roughly 13,000 year old lithics.
Just recently a rare archaeological discovery was made nearby, also along the shores of ancient Lake
Otero. The site has been named Gypsum Overlook and what makes it significant is its age and level
of preservation. But even it only dates to 8,800 years ago. So to Dave's point, if humans were here
23,000 years ago, we're missing over 10,000 years of archaeological evidence for it. I mean in a
perfect world what I would like to see is a hearth. A 21,000 year old hearth with some kind of
organics associated with occupation. I would definitely love to see a defined lithic tool
set of some kind. I mean if you have that many footprints and they're all over the place,
where's the site? They should have that. I mean it's kind of weird that you would have
people living 21 to 23,000 years ago and all they left behind was human footprints. I mean
we leave trash everywhere. It's a characteristic of being a human. There has to be, if it's
legit, there should be a hearth. There should be artifacts. There should be a defined stone or
lithic technology. We can definitively say that human beings were present here at White Sands
during the last glacial maximum. White Sands is one of the places which provides just absolute
definite irrefutable evidence of that. And as I say, you know, extraordinary claims require
extraordinary evidence. This is both an extraordinary claim with extraordinary evidence.
Well my friends, there you have it. Is the evidence that human beings were here 20 plus
thousand years ago definite, irrefutable, and extraordinary? I don't know. Each of us is going
to have to make that decision for ourselves. This is a very complex topic with huge implications for
world history. In this video I largely focused on the argument against the antiquity of the White
Sands footprints. It's the side of the debate that has been virtually ignored by mainstream media
and I think that's a disservice to us all. No doubt this debate will continue with more evidence
being published by both sides, which is good. A healthy respectful debate and discussion is how
we advance our knowledge. I think reading both perspectives is valuable and I will link academic
articles from both sides of the debate in the video description. A big thank you to Dave for
taking his time to hike with us and teach us all something. I think one thing we can all agree upon
is the beauty of the landscape preserved here at White Sands National Park. I'm grateful for all
those past and present whose hard work has ensured we can continue to enjoy and learn from these
landscapes. They are truly national treasures that contain national treasures.