Archaeology in Paradise (Park, Jamaica): Investigating Jamaica's two Pre-Columbian Cultures

Golden jewelry
10 followers
27 Video Views·Nov 20, 2024
Hi, everyone.
It's a pleasure to be with you tonight.
I'm Bill Teague, and I'm curator of Caribbean archaeology
at the Florida Museum of Natural History.
I want to thank Phil for inviting me to give this talk
and mention that his timing is impeccable.
My retirement takes effect next June 30th.
Many of my final projects involve Jamaica.
First, last year I learned that the Florida Museum
had the remains of at least five individuals
from a site at Rio Nuevo, and we are
in the process of preparing these for return to Jamaica.
Second, because Leslie Gail Atkinson
was using the data from Paradise Park in her PhD dissertation,
I held off preparing the final report,
although all the field and lab notes were sent to the JNHT.
Now that Leslie Gail is Dr. Atkinson,
I am working on a more comprehensive report on the work
that we did there, and here's some of that today.
And last, my final issue of the Journal of Caribbean
Archaeology is devoted to a collection
of articles on Jamaica, and Leslie Gail is editing that.
So still lots of things to do, but I'm
looking forward to sitting back and watching
the next generation take charge.
Paradise Park is located on the southwest coast
on Bluefields Bay between Savannah Lamar and Ferris
Cross, and the image on the right,
it's that box right above where it says Paradise Park.
I'm going to apologize in advance for some of my images.
The technology was not up as good 20 years ago
as it is today, and so some of the things,
some of my photographs and slides
haven't withstood the test of time.
The drawing at the top shows Paradise Park and some
of the environments within the park,
and the bottom left is a aerial photograph of the park.
You can see Bluff Point sticking out and then Bluff Point also
on the map above it.
Paradise Park was a dairy farm when we worked there,
but in the 1970s, it was a tourist destination
with bull riding and golf course.
During an environmental survey of the property,
a number of pre-Columbian pot sherds
were found on the surface.
The late Tony Clark, managing partner, contacted the JNHT.
Roderick Ebanks then visited the area,
excavated five test units, and prepared a very comprehensive
report on his work.
Unfortunately, his responsibilities
as director of archaeology for the JNHT
prevented him from doing more.
Tony called me in 1998.
If you had ever met Tony, you'd know
that he didn't take no for an answer.
I was working in the Turks and Caicos at the time,
and he'd gotten my name from Marsha Pardee, who
was arranging to ship feral donkeys from Grand Turk
to greener pastures.
Six of them were there to greet me
when I arrived in Paradise Park.
I used to joke with Tony that I'd
worked with a lot of donkeys over the years,
but these were the first to get me a job.
I owe a great debt to Tony and his son, Eric,
also known as Busha, for their unwavering support.
The project would not have been possible
had they not opened their farm to us
and provided logistical and moral support.
In addition, we could not have accomplished
as much as we did without teams of Earthwatch volunteers,
and especially our collaboration with JNHT archaeologists.
And the folks from JNHT showed up every day
and worked diligently, despite the frequent appearance
of Busha's large rottweiler.
And that's Tony on the right, and I
have no idea who that young kid on the left is.
Paradise Park is on a low-lying coastal plain
with the deeply-weathered Chubutu Karst Hills to the east.
The seaward margin is a series of arcuate, subparallel,
former beach ridges aligned to the present shore.
The coastal zone presently is prograding,
as indicated by mapping undertaken in 1971
and again in 1991.
In fact, the first dune along the shore
apparently formed in the past 500 years.
Shovel tests and walkover surveys
failed to reveal any evidence of indigenous activities,
which only occurred on the second dune
along the old road where Roderick
had conducted his research.
There is a fringe of red mangroves along the coast.
The soils are alluvial, and mangroves
swamp loams and clays with medium-to-coarse,
moderately-sorted carbonate sand of marine origin.
Burrowing land crabs are active in the area.
In fact, the archaeological sites
were found because crabs had moved artifacts
to the ground.
Sites are located in an undeveloped area
near the Sweetwater River along the old road that connected
Salve and Cave Settlement.
And the road isn't apparent here, but the two blue stars
indicate the approximate location of the two sites.
We started in 1998 by excavating 50-centimeter-square diameter
shovel tests at 20-meter intervals
along the old road for a distance of 1.5 kilometers.
Phillip Allsworth Jones brought a group of students
from UE to watch, and there's a couple of them
in this picture helping, along with Peter Harris, who
came down as part of the project.
I'm sorry I don't have a picture of Phillip,
but when he saw his after picture, he made me burn it.
But instead of watching, I put them all to work.
Phillip got to work with my long-term partner, Betsy
Carlson, and at the end of a long day digging test bits,
all he could say was, that Betsy is a machine.
The most interesting artifact from the shovel test
was this pottery foot, and we didn't
find anything else that looked anything like it
in all of the excavations that we conducted.
The shovel test indicated that there were actually
two archaeological sites along the old road.
The two sites are situated, as I said,
on the second dune from the coast,
with freshwater morass, or swamp, to the north and south.
But when the sites were occupied,
they were probably directly on the shore.
The dune is quite narrow, averaging only about 60 meters
in width, and it's only one to one and a half meters
above mean sea level.
The vegetation is natural sea level coastal tropical forest
and is dominated by large trees.
We returned to these sites over the next four years
for a total of 17 weeks of field work.
Working there was something of a Disney-esque adventure.
The first year, we loaded onto a cattle cart
and then upgraded to the jitney in this picture
for the trip from the great house where we lived,
across the river, and onto the site.
And I will say that the great house itself
was a bit of an archaeological feature.
The roof leaked, the floors were warped,
and it hadn't been put to much use
since the clubhouse closed more than 20 years earlier.
The first site, called Sweetwater,
begins 900 meters west of the Sweetwater River
and extends for about 220 meters.
All of the pottery is either plain
or has Montego-based style motifs, which fit
within Rouse's Maicoid series.
The site is on slightly higher ground,
supporting mostly tropical hardwoods,
including an eight-foot-tall ceiba tree,
which you can see on the left.
A total of 82 square meters were excavated,
primarily in two large block excavations
of 41 and 35 square meters each.
The deposits ranged in depth from 20 centimeters to a meter,
and the site was radiocarbon dated to AD 1430,
but was occupied in historic times,
as indicated by Old World rat bones, ratus ratus,
encountered to depths of 70 centimeters in the site.
The site contains pottery in a single style,
a few shell ornaments, plate chert,
a greenstone or jadeite wedge, and a conch shell stel.
Animal remains included small fish, birds,
and a few hutias.
Mollusks were incredibly abundant.
There are far more clamshells in the site than at the other,
and many of them showed evidence for use as scrapers.
I'll come back to this.
Use of shells for scrapers may reflect the change
in food processing over time and between the two sites.
And those of you who know Jamaican archeology,
you can see my pointer, sort of on the right center,
is the then director of archeology, Roderick Ebanks.
So even Roderick didn't get a pass
when he came out to the field.
After a 240 meter gap with no cultural materials,
we encountered the second site called Paradise.
The Paradise site is in a swamp,
swampy grove of royal palms.
It was occupied during a period of lower sea level,
as indicated by deposits below the water table.
This is a redware site with materials distributed
along our transect for 400 meters and dated to AD 850.
A total of 29 square meters were excavated
in two block excavations.
Area 300 was on the back slope
of the southern side of the dune,
and area 400, pictured here, is 100 meters to the east
and about 20 meters higher up on the dune.
The site contained pottery of a single style,
mollusk shells, especially conch shells and olive shells,
some of which were cut into beads and tinklers,
and chert or flint flakes were common in the site.
The most spectacular finds were an agate ear spool
and a dog god pendant.
And in this picture, you can see the very red redware.
The upper right is our dog god pendant.
It's the bound figure.
Bottom left, I'm sorry for the blurry photo,
but you can see that there's an abundance
of conch shells, sea turtle bones,
and other materials within the excavation units
that my volunteers, Ralph and Mary Lou Pax, are working on.
The final remains at the site
were predominantly sea turtles and fish.
There's no obvious evidence
of cultural mixing at either site,
the implication being that the Paradise site
was abandoned before the Sweetwater site was occupied.
The only feature at either site
was a possible post stain at the Paradise site,
but efforts to find associated stains were unsuccessful.
Given the swampy conditions,
it is possible that houses were built on stilts,
like at the Los Buchelones site in Cuba,
something to keep in mind.
And given the narrow width of the dune,
multiple houses would have had to have been aligned
along the dune, as is the case in the Bahamas
along the coast, in contrast to more circular,
oval, or grid plan settlements
observed elsewhere in the Caribbean.
The two sites provided an opportunity
to examine cultural change,
as first indicated by differences in pottery styles
in a shared environment.
Scientific comparisons typically are conducted
under the assumption of all else being equal.
For example, environmental differences
are often used to explain cultural differences,
one of the reasons we don't hunt polar bears in Jamaica.
Of course, we probably shouldn't hunt polar bears anyway.
At Paradise Park, I could argue
that the environment was essentially the same,
or at least offered no substantial differences.
If the two sites contained different materials,
then it was people who were responsible.
Comparing the two sites, I should first note
that both had large numbers of Floridonta land snails,
both alive and dead.
I'm undecided as to whether these were collected and eaten,
but we did our harvest and eat a few.
They were essentially tasteless,
but at only four grams of meat,
it would take a lot of them to make even an appetizer.
There were substantial numbers of flint
and chert flakes at both sites.
It looked to me like there were differences
in the flakes being produced at each site.
The Paradise site seemed to have selected
a more yellow-looking chert.
The flakes were larger in size.
Sweetwater site had a darker colored chert,
and many more smaller flakes and micro flakes.
All of the flint seems to have come
from the Sweetwater River, or at least upstream
in the Sweetwater River.
Not being an expert, I engaged a student
who specialized in lithics to compare them.
Unfortunately, he, as I say, flaked out.
More recently, I got Reniel Rodriguez-Ramos
interested in studying the collection.
Reniel is the expert on lithic tools in the Caribbean
and has documented significant differences
in the lithics used at Archaic Age,
Salidoid, and Wacoid sites in Puerto Rico.
Unfortunately, by the time he had time,
COVID-19 brought everything to a halt.
There are also significant differences
in the animal remains at the site.
Sites.
The earlier Paradise site contains lots of sea turtle bones,
but these are virtually absent from the Sweetwater site.
Such extirpation of sea turtles also was observed
at early sites in the Bahamas
and elsewhere in the Caribbean.
As the largest single package of meat,
and given their vulnerability during nesting,
it is not surprising that sea turtles
were targeted by the earliest inhabitants of the area.
Excavations in areas with clay soils
necessitated the use of water screening.
And if any of my Jamaican colleagues are here,
that is Audine Brooks on the left
and Ricardo Tindale helping Mike Amones in the screens.
Water screening was especially important
for recovering small fish bones,
lithic micro flakes, and beads.
Both voucher samples were collected
from each of the excavation units.
Our main effort in the lab involved cleaning,
sorting, and weighing of mollusk shells.
And here you can see my JNHT colleagues
helping me in the afternoon in the lab.
The mollusk echinoderms told an interesting story.
A total of almost 4,000 shells
were identified in the Paradise site.
Conch shell was abundant, as were clams,
but predominantly in the cardeid family, the cockles.
Cardeids prefer free-circulating seawater
and cannot feed where there is a high sediment layer.
In contrast, the more than 10,000 shells
of the Sweetwater site were mostly clams
that thrive in silty waters,
especially those in the Lacinidae family,
along with mud conchs in the Melanginidae family.
And there were far fewer queen conchs
or other strombidaceous shells at Sweetwater.
We interpreted this shift as a product
of increasing siltation of Bluefields Bay.
This likely resulted from the increase
in land clearance over time,
resulting in increased sediment loads
in the Sweetwater and Deans Valley rivers.
This process is continued as evidenced by a new dune
in front of the dune
on which the archeological sites are located,
a prograding shoreline recorded
between surveys conducted in 1971 and 1991,
poor visibility in Bluefields Bay,
and a dying coral reef.
Although many earlier projects
documented environmental degradation on land,
this was one of the first to show
that pre-Columbian peoples had significant impacts
on large-scale marine environments.
In the bottom left,
you can see some of the clams from the excavation.
These are Kodakia, as well as Lucina pectinata.
And it's a small sample,
but there's a whole variety of ways
these shells were broken for use as scrapers.
So there were a whole variety of uses
to which the shells were put.
Finally, there's a small flooded sinkhole
across the main road near the entrance to the property.
Given the then discoveries
that lie late in the Dominican Republic
and at blue holes in the Bahamas,
David Fenley, Joe McKnight, and I
made an exploratory scuba dive.
The shallow sinkhole has deep, silty sediments
that reduce visibility to zero in a matter of seconds,
and nothing was found during our exploration.
So that, in a nutshell, is the Paradise Park story.
But before I finish,
I want to briefly place these sites
in their wider Jamaican and Caribbean context.
You may have noticed that I used
the Jamaican pottery style notes.
I prefer Redware or Little River
and White Marl, Montego Bay, and Morant Bay
to Rouse's Osteonin and Mayakam sub-series.
I found that some investigators used the broader terms
to conclude they know more than they actually do
about indigenous history.
In other words, we think that Osteonin in Puerto Rico
is the same as Osteonin in Jamaica,
when all we really know
is that they made similar kinds of pottery.
Going forward, we need a greater focus
on local styles and local assemblages
to advance our understanding of cultural diversity
throughout the Caribbean.
When I first came to Jamaica to do archeology,
my first trip actually was in 1973
when I went scuba diving in Montego Bay.
One of the issues concerned the transition
from Redware to White Marl.
The only reason this was an issue
is because Rouse's culture history
posited a transition from Osteonoid to Mayakoi.
He later subsumed both pottery series
as sub-series of Osteonoid
to reaffirm his belief in a singular line of development.
Thus, Osteonin begat Mayakam.
If a smooth transition in decorative styles did occur,
and I'm not convinced it did without substantial influence
from peoples living in Western and Central Venezuela,
then it occurred about AD 500 to 600
in the Savao Valley of Central Hispaniola.
We should not expect to observe this transition in Jamaica.
After all, what are the chances
that Osteonin was transformed into Mayakam
in exactly the same ways,
independently, in Hispaniola and Jamaica?
The question we should be asking
is why did Redware suddenly disappear in Jamaica?
And if you look at these,
these are sort of just general pottery motifs
associated with Osteonoid and Mayakoid.
Osteonoid tends to be a very smooth surface,
red painting, it has lugs and projections.
In contrast, the Mayakoid is usually fired
in a less oxidizing environment.
Zone and size cross-hatch incisions,
applique like the cross-hatch applique punctations,
various kinds of applique like the sigmoid shape
on the right-hand side with the cross-cutting incisions.
Very different styles of pottery
and difficult to accept, on my part at least,
that these one evolved into the other.
My explanation for the historical sequence
is that Osteonoid, broadly speaking,
reflects the increased use of pottery by Archaic Age peoples.
Pottery is made by Archaic Age peoples in Cuba
in small quantities for 2,000 years
before the advent of the Ceramic Age.
The advantage that pottery offered
was the more efficient preparation of heated liquids.
Two types of comestibles probably obtained
first through exchange with the newly arrived
Ceramic Age peoples of Puerto Rico and Eastern Hispaniola
likely encouraged them, Archaics and others,
to make greater use of pottery vessels.
One is the preparation of maize as porridge,
which has proved to be an amazing weaning food
that has substantially reduced infant mortality
around the world.
The other is the preparation of alcoholic beverages
from maize and Mayak.
If these were previously unknown,
I would expect their rapid adoption
and a concomitant increase in the use of pots.
Whether or not the increasing use of pottery
represents the next stage of Archaic development
or the next wave of Ceramic Age expansion from the East
is not that important.
What is important is that Osteonoid peoples
were the equivalent of frontier folk,
the first wave of expansion
into the previously unoccupied islands
of Jamaica and the Bahamas.
They settled along the coast
and exploited a pristine fauna,
including sea turtles, iguanas,
bush and ground-nesting birds, and untouched fisheries.
They lived in small groups,
and when the best resources in the area were depleted,
they moved on to the next virgin territory.
The Paradise site fits this scenario.
Its 400-meter length
probably does not reflect a single occupation,
but multiple episodes of abandonment and reoccupation.
We see exactly the same pattern in the Bahamas.
The Redware peoples were followed within a few centuries
by a new wave of immigrants, probably from Hispaniola.
This Maicoid migration was affected by larger,
more sedentary farming communities.
Marcio Villas Maggiolo notes at least an initial preference
for mangrove habitats like the one at Paradise Park.
However, over time,
Maicoid settlements were increasingly located on hilltops
above the coastal plains of Hispaniola, Cuba, and Jamaica.
The sites in the hills above Kingston
are an excellent example.
Where Hutia dominate the faunal assemblage
at the sites near Kingston,
the Sweetwater site reflects an emphasis
on marine resources.
Because the site was occupied
until after the arrival of European rats,
we see a longstanding complementary settlement pattern
in which some communities were located
to take advantage of agricultural land
and defensive positions,
while others produced marine foods for exchange.
And living in a swamp by itself
provides its own defensive advantage.
And this is a pattern that we also see
in north coast of Cuba.
I mention defense because tribal societies around the world
are often in a near constant state of warfare.
But think of this like you would think
of the Republicans and Democrats in the United States.
It's not the type of conquest warfare
that was practiced by modern states.
All right, I'm gonna move briefly into human biology,
and I'm offering a trigger warning.
If anyone objects or is upset
by seeing images that include humans,
then please turn off your screen
or look away for the next slide.
And then I'll let you know when the following slide is up.
In the study of indigenous facial morphology,
my colleagues and I recognized that individuals
from Jamaica, Hispaniola, and the Bahamas
formed a single cluster that differed from both Puerto Rico,
ceramic age Puerto Rico, and archaic age Cuba.
We noted that the one thing all three had in common
was Mayacuey pottery.
And we suggested a migration to Hispaniola by Caribs
from Western South America, beginning about AD 500.
As I showed earlier, Mayacuey pottery
is significantly different from Austinite pottery.
And it suddenly appeared in Hispaniola
with this distinct set of motifs
executed as parallel line incisions,
applique, punctations, and built adornos.
It closely resembles pottery associated
with the South American Caribs,
and its appearance in Hispaniola occurred
at the same time the Caribs were expanding
their territory in South America.
Facial morphology has an underlying genetic component,
so these differences merit further study.
And if you look at the skull, you can see numbers
which indicate the different measurements
that were taken to characterize the facial features.
And this is a simple dendrogram.
Everything's connected because that's what
the statistical package would produce.
Florida and Panama were outliers
that weren't really related to the others.
But Cuba and the Yucatan produced very similar results.
Bahamas, Hispaniola, and Jamaica
produced very similar results.
And Colombia, Puerto Rico, and Venezuela
produced similar results.
We had hoped that evidence would come
from a recent DNA study to support this,
but we did not receive any direct support.
But as I'm going to mention,
there is evidence for genetic substructure.
And Alfredo Copa, who studies dental morphology,
has noticed similar morphometric differences
among populations in Hispaniola, Puerto Rico, and Cuba.
As I said, we hoped that evidence
would come from a recent DNA study.
However, the study found that all of the ceramic age
peoples who colonized the island
exhibit a remarkable degree of genetic homogeneity.
This is the slide from Daniel and Kendra's
multi-coauthored paper that appeared at the end of last year
and shows some of the genetic substructure
within the Caribbean,
although everything is pretty much traced in the islands
to A, which is the Caribbean ceramic clade.
There appears to have been only one ceramic age migration
from South America,
and that there was no genetic evidence
for our proposed care of migration, as I mentioned.
Nevertheless, there is genetic substructure
within the islands.
For example, the only two samples from a Maicoid site,
and that's here, Haiti-Maioc,
the Diyal-1 site in Haiti,
show the only evidence for substantial admixture
with the preceding archaic age groups.
And the Bahamas and ceramic age Cuba form a subclade,
as does the Southeastern Dominican Republic.
You might have an older version of the image here.
Both of these subclades probably result from bottlenecks
in the transmission of genetic materials
at their point of origin.
The largest gaps in the DNA data right now
are Jamaica and Haiti,
and we can't hope to understand
the biological relationships in the Western Caribbean
without samples from these countries.
Genome-wide and haplogroup data from both
are essential to decipher relationships between islands.
For example, although the Bahamas are characterized
by a single genetic subclade,
we do see mitochondrial DNA evidence
for the movement of people into the Bahamas,
first from Hispaniola,
but later, in prehistory, also from Cuba.
Examining individuals from redware
and white marl populations
should provide evidence for where they came from,
how they interacted,
and why the latter replaced the former.
Finally, I truly believe it's imperative
for archaeologists to disseminate their work to the public.
We're very fortunate to have visits
from the Paradise Park Preparatory School, shown here,
and the Jamaica Tourist Product Development Company
also sent an email to spend the day with us.
Two days worth.
I have learned an amazing amount
from being asked questions that many people preface
as, this is probably a stupid question,
but then, I couldn't answer it.
My motto has always been,
I was right, everything I do know is wrong.
While working at Sweetwater,
I noticed the director
of the Tourist Product Development Corporation
staring at the nearby ceiba tree.
When I asked her what she was looking at,
she said that the tree was smoking.
Indeed, the crown of the tree seemed shrouded in smoke,
despite the clear, beautiful day.
I moved closer to investigate,
but did not find any explanation.
It was at that moment I understood a duppy,
or perhaps a Taino opio was scrutinizing our work.
Fortunately, it did not throw heat.
There's much in this world that we still don't understand,
and so much to be learned.
And I want to thank you for inviting me to speak tonight.
Archeologists love to talk about their research,
never hesitate to ask one of us.
And I especially want to thank everyone
who contributed to this work.
The great archeologists
of the Jamaican National Heritage Trust,
the Earthwatch Institute volunteers,
and the University of Florida
and Florida Museum of Natural History
who supported me for 35 years now.
So thank you all.
