5 Reasons why the H&K MP7 is Better than the H&K MP5

S&W
1 follower
7 Video Views·Dec 8, 2024
This is kind of a weird video for me to make as a hardcore mp5 guy. This video is the 4.6 reasons why the virgin mp7 is better than the chad mp5.
Some of you probably going to say no shit after all I mean the mp7 is a state-of-the-art high-tech submachine gun while the mp5 has been in production and service for almost 60 years.
But others of you will probably point to all the mp5's many virtues. There are some things that the mp5 does better than the mp7 for sure and maybe I'll make a follow-up video where we talk about those.
But today we're going to focus specifically on all the benefits of the mp7. Why now? Well I was recently a guest of Cellular and Bellet this past October.
I got to tour their factory in the Czech Republic. Side note they have perhaps the most sophisticated ammunition factory I've ever seen with second to none computerized quality control.
I left with a whole new respect for their ammunition. They also had several mp7's for me to use and they even arranged it so I got to participate in drills with the mp7 with Erna the only Czech anti-terrorist unit in the country.
This elite unit uses the mp7 as standard gear and at the end of the video I'll tell you why they picked the mp7 to replace the you guessed it mp5.
If you're not really familiar with the mp7 that's fine. I'll tell you what it is as we go down the list of reasons as to why it's better than the mp5.
Let's go ahead and start with the most controversial point. I can already hear you guys bitching about this one.
Because this is how you have to start talking about the mp7. The unique caliber that just does things better than the 9mm.
Now I didn't say 4.6x30mm is better than the 9mm. S&B makes two kinds of 4.6 ammo. A standard ball and an armor piercing variant.
Erna says that S&B's armor piercing version works wonders and that it's their standard issue after having problems with some other types of 4.6.
The mp7 was part of the 1989 NATO solicitation that sought a lower recoil and higher capacity longer range subgun to replace 9mm and they wanted it to defeat body armor too.
FN submitted the more powerful FN 5.7x28mm round and H&K concocted the slightly weaker 4.6x30mm.
The 4.6 is basically a steel penetrator round that will defeat a NATO Crysat target at 200m.
That is a 1.6mm titanium plate covered with 20 layers of Kevlar meant to simulate former Warsaw Pact armor which 9mm cannot penetrate.
H&K claims that the mp7 has an effective range of 300m which is 50% further than the 200m range of the mp5 because of the faster and more efficient 4.6mm round.
Is 9mm more powerful? Yes. Although some manufacturers claim that they do make 4.6mm that produces the same energy as 9mm.
Is 9mm probably the better round in the general sense? Perhaps.
But the 4.6mm definitely has greater range than 9mm and will penetrate body armor unlike 9mm.
Moving on to point number 2. Still sticking with the caliber because 4.6mm is smaller and lighter.
That means that you can jam 40 freaking rounds into an mp7 magazine versus 30 rounds into the same size mp5 magazine.
You get 10 extra rounds and that's one California mag of extra bullets buddy.
The standard magazine is 40 rounds for the mp7 but they make shorter 30 round versions and even a flush fit 20 round magazine.
Which brings us to reason number 3. The gun's just smaller and lighter.
My fellow mp5 boomers out there are going to say that isn't necessarily a good thing and that's somewhat true.
The mp7 has a lot of polymers and alloys in its construction while the OG mp5 robust hunk of steel.
There are benefits to the mp5's construction which we'll get to in just a minute.
But I think there's more value in the reduced overall footprint and weight of the mp7.
The mp7 is a mere 16.3 inches collapsed. Almost a half foot shorter than a collapsed mp5.
And the mp7 weighs just 4.1 pounds while variants of the mp5 are nearly 7 pounds in heft.
The mp7 is at least in part smaller because of reason number 4. Massively superior ergonomics to the mp5.
The mp7 uses fist to fist reloading like an Uzi.
It's more intuitive to bring one hand to another especially in low light situations and put a magazine into the copious magwell the mp7 has
than it is to plug into a barely larger hole only a few inches in front of your dominant hand.
Because the magazine is integrated into the grip of the mp7 that means that the barrel can be further back as well
giving you a 7 inch barrel on a 16 inch gun versus a 9 inch barrel in a 22 inch gun.
The controls are also better. Reloads are much faster with the mp7.
The mp7 is fully ambidextrous. It's fire selector switch is easily reached with the trigger finger or the thumb.
The selector also has a shorter throw than the mp5 selector switch.
But really, really, the big lederhosen in the room is the fact that the mp5 doesn't have a last round bolt hold open
making reloads that much slower.
The official process for reloading an mp5 is to shoot it until it goes empty
pull the charging handle all the way to the rear locking it open in order to prevent the bolt from resisting a new loaded magazine
inserting said fresh magazine, making yourself a plate of spetzel, slapping the charging handle
which, let's face it, is the fun part that you don't get with the mp7
and then go to work. Total time elapsed, 12 to 12 and a half minutes.
The mp7, last round bolt hold open, bolt release lever that's very easily accessed with the trigger finger
making reloads much faster, smoother, easier.
And now for reason 4.6, which is my cute little way of saying that this is kind of a half-assed bullshit reason
while making the list on point thematically, you know, like 4.6 reasons.
So reason number 4.6, reduced recoil. Kind of. In the theoretical sense.
Like with 5.7, 4.6 is a bit of a wonder cartridge. It performs very well in spite of being a cartridge for ants.
High speed, low recoil, like a mini 5.56.
5.7 claims to have 20% less recoil than 9mm and I believe that completely as someone who owns both calibers.
Accordingly, 4.6 has even less recoil than 5.7 and HK specifically says it has practically no recoil.
That's all well and good, but remember the mp5 is a big old chunk of steel with a perfectly balanced cyclical rate
that keeps this gun on axis. Really, if you've never shot a full auto mp5, what are you even doing with your life?
Along with the UZ, one of the best guns on the planet, on the switch, ever.
The mp7 is smaller and lighter, but smaller and lighter means more recoil.
Accordingly, when we went to S&B, we went out on their ballistic testing range and we pitted the mp7 against the mp5
with a bunch of competent shooters and here's what happened.
mp7 and mp5 from Heckler & Koch.
mp7 is quite a new design of a weapon.
It is in 4.6x230mm and mp5 is, as you can know, in 9mm Luger.
For me, I prefer the mp5 more over the mp7.
Why is that?
This is because the 9mm Luger has better stopping power.
This is one thing.
And the second thing is it has a lower rate of fire.
And for me, it's more comfortable than the mp7.
On the other hand, the mp7 has the magazines for 40 rounds, so you have more place to miss the shots.
Okay, so what we're going to do then, we will get the mp5, the mp7.
We're going to go out in the S&B range, here at the ballistic testing range.
We're going to shoot side by side, full auto, and we're going to see which one we shoot better.
Okay, let's do it.
So, this is interesting.
mp5, I will effing take that all day.
Holy crap, that's like an entire mag dump, almost all in the A, from 15 yards.
Here, I'm actually, like you're seeing a similar pattern.
And look how much smaller the holes are, by the way.
Either it's me or maybe the sights.
But this was just a little bit low to the left.
I mean, if this group shifted up and was here, it would be just as good or better.
Dude, I'm wondering if we...
A little low on left.
Yeah, I wonder if...
Oh yeah, you definitely got everything on paper.
I mean, it looks great.
But this is kind of the same for me as for you, where it's like we had the mp5 all in the center.
Maybe the optics a little off, or rather the iron sights.
I think even the group's about the same.
mp5, mp6.
And again, I think this might actually be a sight issue because all three of us have done exactly that.
In any event, good grouping here.
Our optics a little off.
And then mp5, about the same.
Which one did you like better?
Actually, the mp5.
Why is that?
It's easier to re-aim during the shooting.
So you shoot, you see that you hit the target so well, then you can correct it between hits again.
Maybe because of that slower cyclical rate, huh?
Here's the mp5.
Now, this is a really interesting point.
Because bear in mind, this is the first time that Jan shot both of these guns.
mp5, this is pretty solid.
But remember, the rear iron sight was off on the mp7.
And would you look at this.
I mean, that's almost perfect.
You had a couple out here, a couple out here.
But almost every single round here in the Blackwood.
So which one, don't think about the target.
Which one did you like shooting better?
Honestly, both guns are excellent.
100% controllable.
It's 50-50 for me.
You like them both the same?
Yeah, exactly.
They're both comfortable.
They're both extremely, you know, pick whichever one you like.
They're both fantastic.
With everyone shooting the mp7 and the mp5,
no one had any preference as to recoil, as to either.
The mp5 and the Stauder 9mm,
with its slower cyclical rate of 800 rounds per minute,
was equally controllable as the mp7,
which was 3 pounds lighter,
but with a zesty 950 rounds per minute cyclical rate.
However, the mp7 is so light and so easy to shoot
that accurately shooting mag dumps one-handed
is both possible and slightly gangster.
Now, this is kind of a half-assed reason
because both guns are really equal for recoil.
But if the 4.6 were the size of the mp5,
it would be much lighter recoiling.
Conversely, a 9mm in the same size and weight as an mp7,
say like a Mini Uzi or a Micro Uzi,
is much harder to control,
especially at the high cyclical rate of 950 rounds per minute.
Thus, the advantage here
is that the lighter recoil of the 4.6
allows the mp7 to be much smaller and lighter
while still being just as controllable as the mp5.
Now, to close this video out,
I asked the guys at Erna
why they switched from the mp5 to the mp7,
and this is what they said.
You had previously the mp5s.
That's what you told me before the camera was rolling.
Yes.
How does this compare to the mp5?
Because the mp5 is legendary.
It's legendary.
It is.
It is also like 50, 60 years old.
The gun is great.
The gun is big.
The cartridge is a pistol cartridge.
If you want to suppress it,
we got some mp5s SD.
It's a huge, huge gun,
and there is no speed in the ammo
because the barrel is ported and shortened,
so it really doesn't fit the barrel.
The mp5, if you compare it size by size,
you get 4.16.
You may as well have this.
5.56 short barrel, same as mp5.
Sure, so at that point, why even have it?
Yeah, much better in the car, on the bike,
or in the plane plots.
Now, a lot of people say maybe the 4.6 is a little underpowered,
like it's a weak round.
What would you say in response to that?
What's your perception of the performance of the 4.6?
You can easily have 40 rounds of 4.6.
You can easily hit on 50 meters
if you compare it to a pistol.
And as I said, it's more about shot placement than about the caliber.
I wouldn't say there is no recoil,
but the recoil is minimal.
It's easily, as you experienced, to shoot it on full auto
if you have use for that, of course.
And you put on suppressor,
it's easily suppressed cartridge.
I think it's neat, it's compact, it works great.
No muzzle flash at all.
If it fits your needs, as it does sometimes with ours,
it's a great gun.
As usual, you guys can tell me what you think in the comments.
You can disagree with me, you can be wrong.
It's your right to do so.
But me, James J. Reeves, I'm going to be polyamorous,
I'm going to be polyglamorous
with both guns, the MP5 and MP7.
Me, a sub-gun pansexual.
Thank you guys, as usual, for watching.
If you enjoyed this content, we didn't get any money from S&B,
or from HK, or anybody to make this video.
Consider supporting us on Patreon, Utreon, Subscribestar.
It helps us cover our expenses,
and it helps us do cool shit, like go to the Czech Republic.
If you support us on Utreon or Subscribestar,
you can win one of four free guns that we give away every month,
courtesy of Top Gun Supply, your online shooting sports superstore.
And if you want to buy some S&B,
make sure you head over to Ventura Munitions to pick it up.
I'm just glad you're watching, as usual. Take care.
