Immigrants in Canada are to leave Canada when their permits and visas expire. Canada immigration minister outlines the plan for canada immigration and asykum claims in Canada
............................................................................ Work With Me:
If you want to apply for the Canada Express Entry, then Get A FREE Manual [Understand Your NOC Code And How To FIND It!]: https://relocatecanada.biz/workincanada/
⚠️ Disclaimer: This video is for educational purposes only. The content of the video is provided for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal or other professional advice. Ideas and opinions expressed are mine.
hi everyone welcome back to the Channel
Canada immigration is the hottest Topic
in Canada today and if you're interested
in coming to Canada at all or you are
here and you need permanent residents
make sure you watch this video to the
very end so there's been lots and lots
of Canada immigration discussions from
the House of Commons to political
debates to opinion mongers to YouTube
channels it's breaking news every day
and the revelations are shocking
they are very shocking did you know that
almost 5 million temporary residents in
Canada could face deportation in the
next two years yes that is the stack and
sad reality another Hot Topic is Asylum
claims in Canada this one is so
sensitive because of the many
implications of the Asylum system today
we're going to talk about the Urgent
issues surrounding the futures of those
that are affected said what you can
expect and the government's response to
all of this and then all this talk about
deporting people what does this mean for
the families and communities across the
country who are affected because of all
the issues surrounding immigration the
House of Commons standing committee on
citizenship and immigration have been
doing some interviews trying to get to
the bottom of all these changes and the
plans going forward if you few days ago
the Canada immigration Minister MC
Miller was on the hot seat so to speak
they were asking him questions about the
new immigration plans the number of
Asylum seekers in Canada the number of
international students that are now
seeking Asylum and all of that and also
the government's plan to enforce removal
orders as the immigration Minister he's
expected to have all the answers and a
clear plan and personally I was very
interested in knowing what exact plans
the government had unfortunately the
minister did not have all the answers
and shockingly he does not have a clear
plan so let's watch the session together
and I will give my commentary as we go
along and please drop your own comments
on what you think about Canada's
immigration plans for the future and The
Minister's answers as well now let's
dive in Mr kit for six minutes please go
ahead thank you chair uh Minister your
department tabled uh documents with
Parliament that show that 4.9 million
visas are going to expire between
September 2024 and December
2025 um how will we know how many of
those actually wind up
leaving as you noted MP kich that when
people come here uh in many of their
visa documents they undertake to leave
uh as part of the levels plan um there
will be some visas that are temporary in
nature that will not be reviewed uh
renewed rather uh and those people when
they undertook to came here to come here
will be expected to leave uh and that's
that is simply a fact uh we'll have to
monitor that carefully Mr I wasn't
asking about whether they will leave or
not I'm asking you that how will you
ensure that a person whose Visa has
expired will leave we know that just on
study permits there are 766 th000
expiring by the end of December 2025 how
will your department ensure that at the
end of those study permit periods those
persons will leave
again uh there are many ways that people
leave the country Tom uh the vast
majority leave voluntarily uh and that's
what's expected so explain those ways
how will you ensure
it
um we work with our partners including
cbsa to investigate uh obviously and and
prosecute those who violate immigration
law if someone refuses to leave they're
in violation of the law uh and see bbsa
after due process has the legal
obligation to remove people um again
this isn't something that is taken
lightly but in the vast majority of
cases those people that uh have come
here temporarily uh and do not have the
right to stay in fact leave so for this
first question I don't know what you
think um it's not surprising that the
minister was unable to give a direct
answer to the question because he was
being asked how will you ensure that the
people whose permits are expiring the 76
66,000 International students whose
permits are expiring and of course all
the other people who who stay in Canada
is expire how would you ensure that they
leave and the minister said that most of
the people would leave voluntarily yeah
and he also of course alluded to the
fact that they work with the cbsa who
whose Duty it is to enforce removals um
so but those of us who have been in
Canada for a bit knows that the cbsa
doesn't really enforce removals as that
as much yes they do but it is not as
much as they should and I really don't
know why the minister thinks that people
are going to live voluntarily some of
these people came here to study with
intention to becoming citizens getting
permanent residents even visitors who
have come to Canada a lot of them who
have refused to leave have no intention
to live guys let me know what you think
in the comments is it that do you agree
that the minister does not have an
answer to this question in terms of how
to enforce I'm really glad that Canada
is making all of these you know plans
and all of that but you know as we go
along we'll see whether the minister
actually has like a solid plan or maybe
they are just making announcements but
they haven't come up with the solid plan
as well now let's see the rest of the
video so then my my next question will
be your plan calls for a cap on
International students 485,000 2024
437,000
2025 uh there's been adjustments to
those so obviously there's a discrepancy
between the two so how many do do you
project will leave the country then at
the end of December 2025 all 766 th000
what's the proportion what are the
forast that department has you'll have
to be clear on that a discrepancy
between what and what between the number
of people who will be allowed into the
country and then the number of people
who will be on a study permit that's
expiring so those who are expiring the
end of December 2025 how many of them
will actually leave are you saying 100%
will be expected to leave or you going
to send cbsa to chase all 766 th000 you
you know that that is not what happens
there are a number of things that occur
some people actually get renewals uh
some people get post graduate work
permits and stay a longer period uh and
we do work with cbsa to monitor these
things and when statistics Canada
reports on these uh they take in to
account a a whole variety of factors in
estimating how many people are here and
how many people have
left so at the end of uh this year uh
2024 how many International students do
you expect to leave and how many have
left so far when their study permits
expired how many have left as of nove
November today we don't have 1 can you
provide those to the committee um I
don't know we could look into it well
Minister how can you not know it's in
the immigration levels plan there's a
bunch of charts on page 22 starting
about temporary resident immigration to
Canada persons who are in the country
it's in the immigration levels plan it's
in there so how can you not know what
that number would be there's an order
paper question the these government
documents that were signed by your
parliamentary secretary that were tabled
with Parliament that has the numbers so
there's supposed to be uh expiring study
permits by in December
84642387
in the month before
12734871 looking at them what I can
provide to you as a number is the
expected decrease over that period of
over the three-year period which is
about 450 the first year 450 the next
year that's net net uh incoming and
outcoming uh with a slight increase in
in
2027 so again so how are you going to
track then those whose work permits are
expiring by the end of 2025 again it's
in the hundreds of thousands you're not
giving me much confidence or Canadians
conf confidence that you have a plan cuz
we have a breakdown by month how many
student visas and work visas are
expiring and you haven't provided any
information on the means how are you
going to do it you say you have partner
organizations you're working with people
what are you actually doing what's the
process how are you going to ensure
people abide by the Visa conditions as I
said to you before uh any just like the
vast majority of people that come to the
country the on a temporary basis the
vast majority leave in some cases uh
increasingly many I will concede people
decide to choose they are in a situation
of irregularity in that case uh once
they have exhausted their remedies they
are removed by
cbsa so personally personally I feel
that the minister should have come to
this um interview all the numbers but
you know for him not to know I mean I'm
not surprised if he doesn't know how
many International students intends to
leave but to say that he doesn't know
how many have left so far I think that's
wrong because they should have the
records and he is actually right to say
that you know what in all just because
766 th000 study permits are expiring
doesn't mean that they will all leave of
course most of them are going to apply
for the pgwp especially if they qualify
uh to stay back in Canada so just
because study permits are expiring
really doesn't mean that they are
supposed to leave in actual fact but but
I feel that the minister should have the
numbers that's what I feel guys tell me
what you think in the comments below so
it's not true the vast majority don't
voluntarily yeah and the people whose
permits and visas are expiring who have
no intention of living will not leave
and I doubt that most of them will be
removed by cbsa because I don't think
there's a strong law even though the C
cbsa has that jurisdiction I don't think
that're doing as much deporting as the
minister is alluding to well that's
interesting because you have said that
tens of thousands of them are actually
International students who are staying
longer applying for Asylum and you're
claiming they don't have a legitimate
claim to make make that those are your
quotes the headlines you're generating
by doing Communications out there so are
you saying you don't have a plan that
this is part of your plan to have an
increasing backlog at the IRB to deal
with it than Minister you please
respond there are an increasing number
of international students making Asylum
claim I think with very little hope
given their conditions uh they uh
whether you like it or not are entitled
to a form of due process in this country
I don't think you would report to deny
it to them um are there things we can do
to make sure that's more streamlined I
would encourage you to uh follow the
next few weeks as we propose more
amendments to the immigration system and
the Asylum system um but let's recall
that but that every party in this house
except for the Liberal Party voted down
our Asylum reforms in the budget so
apparently what the minister is saying
here is that yes a number of
international students are seeking
Asylum claims in Canada and the reason
is obvious right their permits are
ending they haven't applied for
permanent residents and they don't want
to leave so they are seeking Asylum for
them to have more time to stay in Canada
the minister is saying that yes they are
seeking Asylum and their claims will be
heard yeah I think that is one of the
things that is causing the delays with
Arabia and all of that if someone does
seek Asylum they have a right to have
their claims heard which is what the
minister is saying it is their right to
have their claims heard and that is the
part of the system that probably this
committee is probably asking about why
do they even have like that chance to
make Asylum claim
honestly these are human beings right
whether someone is making a false Asylum
claim or a real Asylum claim yeah they
should be given a right to have their
claims heard if you're saying that
you're going to put some laws or
anything in place to make sure that
their claims are refused or whatever
well that's fine but you know these
students that are seeking Asylum they
have a right to have their claims to be
heard so there's been lots of talks
about Bad actors the Prime Minister
alluded to Bad actors in his own video
and there's been a lot of you know
videos you know and you know accusations
about these Bad actors and I'm so glad
about this question because I have been
wondering who are these Bad actors who
are they is the government part of the
Bad actors chair um Minister you know a
few weeks ago the Prime Minister put out
a uh a great video or propaganda piece
that he was trying to uh outline his
future plans he mentioned Bad actors
it's been about two weeks since that
video has come out can you elaborate on
who those Bad actors
are there are uh as you know uh because
you are familiar with some of them mpana
uh immigration Consultants that uh do
not act properly and are giving false
advice to people in the uh false hope of
being able to stay here there are
institutions for example that are
relying uh on International students and
not providing the proper education and
making FAL false promises about their
perspective employment there are uh in
the labor market impact assessment world
that I know you're familiar with um
there's a lot of money exchanging hands
uh where labor market impact assessment
shouldn't cost anything uh so there's
lots of people that are responsible here
um it isn't simply about people that
have committed fraud it's about the
ecosystem as well that's been created
which has been an incentive in and it
may be a $ 31 billion industry when it
comes to international student but
chasing short-term gain with a lot of
long-term pain and I mentioned that
earlier with respect to the cost of what
Asylum seek would cost coming out of an
international student system that was
supposed to breed Excellence uh and and
not Asylum
claims okay and are you missing anyone
else off that list are you I know it's
been a while but any anyone else you're
missing do you think one this should be
considered a bad actor I know you have
your view on it so why don't you share
it the minister of immigration has
clarified the Bad actors uh like the
immigration Consultants that have been
giving these International students
bogus promises that they will become
citizens the corporations that are you
know exploiting the lmia system and of
course the biggest corporates are the
institutions right the colleges or
mushroom schools that are taking lots of
money from International students you
know but they are not providing the
education and it's not just the mushroom
scho I think most if not all colleges
and universities in Canada are
exploiting international students so
this is the ecosystem that has been
built and this is an ecosystem that has
given room to these Bad actors to
actually do their bad acts take
advantage of temporary workers in Canada
or those who want want to become
temporary workers as well as
International students in Canada and
like I said in my last video I don't
think that the government is free the
government is one of the Bad actors
because they have enabled this ecosystem
they are the ones that have given these
institutions the license to even be
mushroom schools or whatever and they
are the ones that were approving
International students visas to come to
Canada to school in this same school so
the government is one of the Bad actors
guys let me know what you think in the
comments below do you think that there
are any other Bad actors or do you agree
that the government as well is a bad
actor in this movie of Canada
immigration that we are watching so who
was responsible for the 211% increase we
saw when it came to International
students since 2015 who was the
government in charge that signed off on
that and there he has just echoed my
thought in terms of Minister don't you
think the government is a bad actor
because you guys were the ones that
increased the levels you increase the
number of temporary residents that could
come into Canada so you are not
completely innocent of all of these
things that are happening in Canada with
regards to tempor Residents with regards
to Canada immigration or even with
regards to Asylum claim those are two
different questions let me also say this
and you know this the federal government
is the only one that doesn't make any
money directly from this the provincial
government Ontario for example makes
about $1,000 ahead on every
international student and has abused
this system in bringing in people to
study institutions some very reputable
some that are the pride of this country
U but some that pretty much didn't exist
uh and so that's something we've had to
reign in you can just speak yourself to
Mayor Brown about what he's living
through in Brampton uh and I think you
would know exactly who I'm talking about
Minister you it looks like you're
passing the buck and you're blaming
other Bad actors but the population
growth we saw of 300% the highest it's
ever been since 1950s is a federal
responsibility you are the one that is
signing off on these approvals it is
your government that is responsible for
this but it looks like to me that you're
just literally pointing fingers at
everyone else but yourself and your
predecessors uh in Canada do you not
think it's right for you to take some
responsibility uh for these actions that
have taken place do you not should
shouldn't you put Mark or Sean Fraser on
the list as well of of some of those Bad
actors that you know have been a part of
the problem Sean Fraser is one of the
guys who counseled me to do this and we
all bear our resp after creating the
problem have you there's lots of
responsibility to go around ARP and I
think you'll know that uh immigration is
a shared responsibility provinces
institutions of any of various
descriptions come to us and ask us for
different programs we have a very
important role in making sure that we
get it right uh and now the minister is
saying that immigration is a shared
responsibility so the government has a
part to play institutions have a part to
play and he also said that it was his
predecessor um Sean Fraser that advised
him on all of this remember that Shan
Fraser was immigration Minister before
mcmiller and Sean Fraser did a lot of
reforms and updates of the international
student program it was during his tenor
that you know like The Floodgate for
international students was opened a lot
of international students came into
Canada it's like he caed this uproar you
know open the flood Gat and then he now
handed over to McMill who is now wearing
the crown and having to you know answer
to most of the questions and most of the
pains that were caused by the decisions
that were made by Sean Fraser But
ultimately everybody has a part to play
because it is a shared responsibility
okay so this part of the video is like
one of the most important part of this
entire video now let's see the rest of
the video you last week your officials
confirmed to us that you're seeing
skyrocketing uh Refugee Asylum claims um
with a weight time of 44 months for some
of them um what are you doing to bring
those numbers down in terms of weight
times and to make sure that these cases
are heard as soon as possible well if
you looked in the last budgetary
exercise we put a substantial amount of
money in making sure the IRB could
process more volume it's you know they
are uh an independent body so there's
only so much uh pressure that we can
exert on them I want to reform the
system it's not working in the way it
should um that's a function of volume
but also a function of efficiency um the
growing claims that we see now Inland U
are not unexpected they're ones that we
saw with people having increasingly
fewer hopes to stay in Canada and being
counseled to file I think unjustly
Asylum claims where they don't uh where
they shouldn't have the ability to do so
thank you Mr chair and thank you to
officials um so you're requesting $ 1.2
billion of extra money in this update
out of the 1.2 billion 1.1 billion is
for Asylum Seekers people that have
crossed our broken and weak border and I
want to understand exactly what benefits
Asylum Seekers get so if an asylum claim
arrives at the Montreal Airport will
ircc pay them for a hotel um Deputy
minister so chair uh the way the Asylum
system works is that as soon as the uh
there is a claim on Asylum uh it is
assessed by uh CBS or ircc depending
upon where the claim is and accordingly
established as bases of
claim so so yeah so the hotel is covered
then is that what you're saying uh once
that's once the claim has been applied
once they've applied so uh if you you if
there is in Montreal I'm just giving you
a full answer about this if there is in
Quebec there is a uh there is a uh
possibility that Prada will probably
house up to 1150 and if there is an
overflow we will house them in the hotel
do they receive a food
allowance um I think uh Su if you can
yeah thank you um so it is not an
automatic um allowance that uh people
Asylum claimants would get just because
you are an asylum claimant um there is
the right to claim Asylum and then there
is they would have to identify whether
or not um they need um shelter and as
part of that if they end up in an ircc
Hotel then uh there would be food uh as
part of uh being at the
hotel okay so they they can get food um
what about transportation is there
Furniture is there uh household items
allowance as
well uh no that would not be covered
because they are in the hotel so there's
um no furniture that would be
required our silent CLS eligible for um
uh Deputy Minister for health benefits
Deputy Minister um yes the Asylum
claimants are eligible for the first
three months as uh um for the interim
federal health program and then um it is
determined whether the provinces will uh
further give them the uh necessary
coverage
um talking about Asylum Seekers how many
Asylum seekers in the queue are former
International
students um I think uh uh at the at the
at the risk of quing a number uh I think
uh what has been seen lately is uh that
there is there's been an optic of uh um
students who are actually uh seeking
Asylum compared to 2023 I guess I'm
looking for a number do you not know the
number that are students uh not uh onand
uh um chair and we can provide so so you
wouldn't know how many are arrived as
International students or who were
originally International students and
became you wouldn't know those
numbers we we would we would actually
know the uh we would know how many have
arrived and uh the actual point is that
if we count who have actually exhausted
their postgraduate work permit and then
have applied or the ones which have um
which are the students uh who have
without even completion of their study
they have applied so we'll have to
separate them out so if you could
provide this to to the committee uh how
many arrived as International students
how many were originally International
students but then transition to the
postgraduate work program and also how
many transition to some other Stream So
how many Asylum claimants were students
but transition to another stream uh if
you could do that within the next two
weeks that would be great thank you um
and is it true that Asal claimants also
get a work permit yes um uh chair that
it is true that they get work permit so
does this policy incentivize people to
claim asylum in order to to be able to
work in Canada legally um we actually uh
have a policy where uh we allow the
Asylum claim and while their Asylum
claim is being processed that they are
able to support themselves and integrate
uh uh in the society and that is uh why
it is meant for that it's not supposed
to be a pull factor your department
previously released Asylum claims by
designated learning institutions up to
2022 uh in the total was less than 5,000
for that year and of course now we're
seeing more than that every month um can
you table with this committee an updated
numbers the updated numbers to that
table so Asylum claim it's by designated
learning institution um up to the end of
October 2024 on the students MH okay we
will uh we will actually go back and and
try to get that information just to be
clear I'm referring to a a report that
you published a couple years ago it was
very that's the information it had and I
would just like it to be updated um and
uh if you could provide that within the
next two weeks that would be great
number one the Prime Minister says that
those who are Inland that's those who
are inside Canada and are applying for
Asylum claims are doing that because
they have no hope yeah so if it's an
international student their pgwp is
expiring or someone on an open or closed
work permit their permit is expiring
you're saying that after their permit
hasir they have to leave Canada they
don't want to leave and because they
don't have hope yeah because they don't
know what to do a lot of them are
turning into Asylum claims and it's
simply because they I mean they don't
know what to do so it is understandable
I can just put myself in their shoes if
I was in that position maybe I would
also apply for Asylum claim because many
of them don't want to go back home many
of them can't even go back home because
they have probably sold everything they
came to Canada with the hope of staying
in Canada so obviously they can't go
home so they applying for Asylum and
that's why the number of international
students that are applying for Asylum
has increased but surprisingly they did
not have the numbers I'm surprised that
they don't have the numbers you couldn't
provide the numbers of international
student that seeking Asylum either by
institution or just by you know the
number month by month basis they didn't
have these numbers and you're coming to
a Committee hearing but he did not have
the numbers well I hope that they are
able to get the numberers so that we can
see things clearly and then this part of
the video also outlin the process of
those who come to seek Asylum and the
benefits that they get so you seek an
asylum your claim is assessed yeah if
you say you don't have somewhere to stay
you put in you know maybe a hotel or
maybe you know one IRSC guest house or
Asylum house and then if you are put
there of course then it comes with food
you know they also get like health
benefits and they said for the first
three months and of course they get a
work permit so even if someone's pgwp is
expiring they still get that work permit
as Asylum claimers and they can continue
to work until their claim is heard or
until their hearing period and the
question is does this incentivize people
to claim Asylum because I mean look at
it which is one of the things that
Canadians are kicking against that these
Asylum Seekers are treated too well it's
like you're are incentivizing them to
become Asylum Seekers but at the end of
the day these are human beings these are
people like you and me these are people
who have lost hope these are people who
don't know what to do especially
International students that are seeking
Asylum but I'm really surprised that the
minister is saying that they will leave
voluntarily I just hope that the
government goes back you know have a t
with thems and come up with a plan of
probably look for ways that you can
probably give this International more
time to work in Canada to gain the work
experience or you create another pathway
like the trtpr that was created in 2021
so that people can easily you know
become permanent residents because
really I don't see how the cbsa is going
to move out all these people whose
permits are expiring how are they going
to do it I I I don't see they don't seem
to have a plan but anyway this is what
is happening um in Canada in terms of
Asylum seekers in terms of immigration
number and in terms of plans that Canada
has moving forward when it comes to
immigration especially Asylum Seekers so
if you're out there trying to claim
Asylum this is what you need to expect
if you are so desperate and your permit
is expiring you don't know what to do
you want to claim Asylum it is always
good for you to know what it involves
what the repercussions might be if you
refused but you know my heart goes out
to all the international students
everybody out there whose permit is
expiring and they don't know what to do
I'm just praying that the government
comes up with a plan that is a win-win
for both the government Canada and also
for those who are affected especially
families who are affected so guys thank
you so much for watching don't forget to
leave your comments and your thoughts in
the comments below uh and let's get this
discussion going because lots and lots
of people are affected by this okay and
before you run away check out the other
videos on my channel don't forget to
subscribe so that you can get
notifications when we post and I will
see you in the next one bye