Confronted with a nearly limitless universe billions of years old with an almost infinitely vast number of opportunities for life, the Italian physicist Enrico Fermi, sitting for lunch at Los Alamos with three colleagues in 1950, asked a question that still perplexes everyone who looks up at the night sky: “Where is everybody”? The Fermi paradox, which assumes that we should have detected intelligent life in the universe by now, remains an all-time most bedeviling lunchtime remark. It relies on four fairly simple assumptions: [Crazy solution to the Fermi paradox.]
[Music]
if intelligent life has evolved many
times in our galaxy and Beyond why have
we seen no evidence of it there are
several standard answers to this Paradox
the first is that life is actually quite
rare and humanity is the first species
to become Advanced enough to speculate
about other civilizations and another
argument is that intelligent species
have been widespread throughout history
but eventually destroyed themselves or
their environments with their own
technology such as nuclear weapons or
burning fossil
fuels yet another approach is that
advanced civilizations are widespread
and aware of our existence but hide it
for fear of disrupting our fragile
culture we have no good reason to
believe that aliens have ever made
contact with Earth there are conspiracy
theories of course but nothing credible
however in 1950 physicist Enrico fery
proposed a hypothesis known as the fery
Paradox and it Remains the key to
finding extraterrestrial life and
exchanging messages by sending signals
into
space the Earth is thought to be about
4.5 billion years old and the first life
is thought to be at least 3.5 billion
years
old the Paradox states that given the
Scale of the Universe favorable
conditions for life have probably Arisen
many many times so where are all the
culprits of a successful or not so
successful
civilization we have good reason to
believe that there must be life out
there somewhere but no one has
responded this is the problem that a
character in the three body problem a
novel by Chinese science fiction writer
Lucin wrestles with while working at a
radio Observatory the protagonist
finally receives a message from a
representative of an alien civilization
who informs him that they are pacifists
and urges him not to respond to the
message otherwise the Earth will be
attacked eventually the plot will offer
a detailed and elegant solution to the
SP me
paradoxx the second book The Dark Forest
goes like this the universe is a forest
even a
jungle each civilization is an armed
Hunter stalking through the trees like a
ghost carefully parting the branches
that block the way trying to tread
silently to deliver a
subpoena ultimately everyone hides from
each other differences in the rate of
technological progress make a permanent
balance of power impossible leaving the
fastest advancing civilizations in a
position to destroy everyone
else over time it becomes clear that in
this constantly threatening environment
those who play the game of survival best
survive the
longest we have joined a game that was
going on before we arrived and the
strategy everyone has learned is to hide
no one who knows the game will be
foolish enough to contact anyone or
respond to a
message the author has depicted what he
calls the worst of all possible
universes continuing a trend in Chinese
science
fiction he is not saying that our
universe is a real dark Forest where
one's survival strategy prevails
everywhere silence and Mortal
Danger The Dark Forest theory is also so
plausible enough to be a major Trend in
the scientific debate we can see its
potential impact in the first Contact
protocol proposed by eminent
astrobiologists Kelly Smith and John
tragan at first do nothing they conclude
because doing anything could lead to
disaster in the event of alien contact
Earth should be notified via
pre-established signals not something
improvised and we should avoid doing
anything that might reveal who we are so
shooting flares at a rocket ship is
probably not a good idea the point is
the return messages would give away
Earth's location again Smith and
traphagen don't think the Dark Forest
theory is correct benevolent aliens
might actually be out there the idea is
simply that first Contact would involve
High civiliz ation level risk this
differs from the assumptions of much of
the Soviet era Russian space
literature which assumed that advanced
civilizations would necessarily
transcend conflict and therefore share a
comradely
attitude this is no longer seen as a
plausible guide to protocols for contact
for the most part a scenario is created
ated in which there is a process of
natural selection competition for
survival however we have absolutely no
evidence of alien Behavior or
competition within or between other
civilizations this is mostly
entertaining speculation even if we
accept the idea that natural selection
can work at the level of a group much
less at the level of
civilization creatures evolve together
in interdependence
not alone parasites depend on hosts
flowers depend on birds for pollination
every creature in the forest depends on
insects the interdependence does lead to
encounters that are nasty violent and
brief but it also takes other forms this
is how forests work in our world
interestingly the author of the books
recognizes this interdependence as a
checkpoint of the Dark Forest Theory the
viewer and reader are constantly told
that nothing in nature exists alone
there are many galaxies out there and
potentially a lot of Life the author's
story uses this to explain why some
people immediately side with the aliens
even though the tickets are already sold
out and why the desire to make contact
is so strong despite all the risks for
this reason the Dark Forest solution to
the fmy Paradox is unconvincing
the fact that we can't hear anyone could
just as easily mean that they are too
far away or that we are listening in the
wrong way or that there is no forest and
there is nothing else to hear this is
why a predator civilization sounds like
creatures at the top of the food chain
that consume other living things as a
source of energy like a light bulb
consumes
energy having clarified who you are
asking about the answer to your your
question is I don't
know maybe but many other scenarios also
answer the question where are they
Predators fighting each other to the
point of species Extinction before
achieving Galactic travel capabilities
as possible but so is damage to the
planetary biosphere that leads to
species Extinction or at least makes it
impossible to develop enough technology
to achieve Galactic travel many
simulations answer some of the questions
for example aliens could travel in and
between galaxies so distant from the
Milky Way that the human race does not
yet have the technology to detect them
another hypothesis is that aliens could
choose to transition to a non-physical
State such as existing as purely mental
beings in a dimension not observable by
our radio and Optical
sensors a third scenario is that a
species could achieve Galactic reach but
go extinct for some reason such as a
gamma ray burst the list goes on
researcher Adrien Kent suggests another
intriguing idea which is that
civilizations are widespread that they
have interacted many times in the past
but eventually compete for scarce
resources like humans for
butter when this happens the process of
evolution operating over vast time
scales ensures that the survivors learn
to keep quiet and yes that makes sense
this is not an idea that can be easily
dismissed one counterargument might be
to point to how Evolution works on Earth
it usually involves ecosystems in which
species become interdependent in complex
ways but evolution on a cosmic scale
would be very different it would have to
operate over vast distances and the
scarce resources offer offed by
habitable plants would be very rare that
is if Cosmic habitats are widely
separated and very difficult to detect
then the best strategy for a typical
species to avoid defeat in such
competitions might be to avoid entering
them by being sufficiently stealthy like
a ninja that no potential adversary
would identify its habitat as
valuable this raises important questions
about whether it is wise for Humanity to
advertise its existence in essence the
Earth with a big poster that says we are
here various attempts to send messages
to the stars have already been made and
many researchers have pointed out that
this could be a serious mistake even
suicidal however let's admit that
humanity is doing just fine without
alien Reapers yet
one can sum up the issue quite simply if
aliens are not there then all efforts to
communicate have obviously been in vain
so for the sake of argument we can
assume that aliens are there and will
probably receive messages at some point
but probably not in our
lifetime it is often assumed that
extraterrestrial life Advanced enough to
be capable of interstellar travel or
communication must be rare since
otherwise we would have seen evidence of
it by
now this in turn is sometimes taken as
circumstantial evidence that it is
unlikely that life could have evolved in
our universe at
all one is that life capable of
expressing itself on Interstellar scales
has evolved in many places but that
evolutionary selection operating on
Cosmic scales tends to eliminate species
that are open about themselves and their
habitats another reason is that whatever
the true situation intelligent species
might be right to worry about the
potential dangers of self-promotion and
therefore ER on the side of caution we
have no good reason to believe that
aliens have ever made contact with Earth
in part this is a nice idea because it
suggests that we are still in the race
to be the most impressive intelligent
being in the galaxy and certainly faster
than a snail we haven't cracked
Interstellar travel yet but the beings
that have are still working with
technology that could be knocked off
course by a speck of dust with a little
more focused effort a little reverse
engineering we could have our own
Interstellar Armada ready to go before
any alien civilizations decide to
incinerate all life recently physicists
Alexander Baris
of the national research University of
electronic engineering put forward
another potential solution to the
Paradox while this proposal has
similarities to others namely the super
Predator solution it has a Simplicity
that makes it attractive the first in
last out solution assumes that the first
life to achieve Interstellar travel will
necessarily eradicate all
competition however unlike similar
Solutions which posit a destructive race
acting out of fear innate aggression or
malice barine assumes that the
eradicating life form acts out of
ignorance yes humans do this Behavior
too in this scenario a space fairing
civilization colonizes a planet and
destroys that very life as an accidental
side effect of its own expansion they do
so because they simply won't notice much
like a construction crew demolishing an
anthill to build build a sewer system
because they have no incentive to
protect it its Simplicity requires fewer
assumptions than other Solutions we
don't have to assume that alien life
will act any differently than it will
seek to spread to any planets it can
reach other Solutions often speculate on
alien motives reasoning and access to
resources in such a way that the
hypothesis becomes applicable in fewer
situations this hypothesis does not have
that problem assuming the above
hypothesis is true what does that mean
for our future the only explanation is
an appeal to the anthropic principle we
are the first to arrive on this scene
and we will likely be the last to leave
on the other hand if we are still alive
the obvious conclusion is that we will
be the species that wipes out all other
life this means that not only will
Humanity be forever alone in space but
we will also be responsible for our
isolation there is another reason why
this hypothesis should be a concern
berzina leaves out another possible
solution it could also be the case that
despite the age of the cosmos no one has
yet mastered Interstellar travel this
scenario would also allow us to be alive
and the rest of the hypothesis the first
in last out solution to the fery Paradox
is simple plausible and requires few
assumptions while that doesn't make it
accurate theories that rely on fewer
assumptions are often considered good
ones are we alone in the
universe perhaps but we'll still be
looking up at the stars and wondering if
we're alone for a while longer unless
alien neighbors decide to show up
tomorrow just in
case but consider this given how long it
took us to send humans to the moon and
launch a couple of probes past Uranus
it's probably safe to assume that any
aliens who make it to Earth will have
technology that would be more
incomprehensible to us than a washing
machine is to a beaver from Poland the
real options are that we're either the
only intelligent beings in the vast
Cosmos or that super intelligent beings
exist but we haven't heard of them for
the reasons I've already given in any
case on a galactic scale we're here for
less than a moment it seems unlikely
that some Galactic super Predator will
wipe us all out in the 80 years we've
been alive but if it does it's even less
likely that we'll know about it before
it happens so no epic ending maybe we're
completely alone in the universe save
for a few
bacteria which would be a huge let down
but we won't know
[Music]
w
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
the
n
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]