Judicial Decisions | International Law

General Principles of Law
24 followers
2 Video Views·Dec 3, 2024
Welcome back everybody to our studies in public international law.
This lesson is carrying on looking at the various different sources of international law
and we're going to spend a very brief amount of time talking about judicial decisions
because really we utilize judicial decisions at all points and at all stages throughout this
series of lessons and throughout all of our lessons on all of international law.
It is one of the things that international law has been particularly good at. Fundamentally
we have various different tribunals, we have various different court structures and judicial
institutions and as a result of which we have a variety of different sources of jurisprudence
that we can rely upon to essentially add a certain amount of meat to the bones when it
comes to the development of the explanations for the reasonings and rationales behind the
development of international law. And so I want to just briefly draw our attention to
the concept of judicial decisions and their place within the sources of international law
before moving on to a couple of subsidiary principles of international law which relate
to the sources. So we're going to talk a little bit about Erguramne's obligations as well as
and this idea of and the relationship to and the relationship between international law and
international relations because of course there is a key indication that there is a conflict
between the two. So like I said this lesson is going to examine the law of judicial decisions
as a subsidiary source of public international law. Now essentially and fundamentally it is
viewed that in international law one can consult the decisions that are made by various different
judicial organs and really unlike other areas of law like municipal or domestic legal systems
you will actually find that the number of judicial bodies and institutions that exist
in a domestic legal system is dwarfed by the number of judicial institutions that exist within
the international legal system. You have the ICJ, you have the ICC when it comes to international
criminal law. In addition to the ICC for international criminal law you also have
the variety of ad hoc tribunals and historical tribunals that have been established.
So the ICTY, the ICTR, the Nuremberg trials etc etc all of which still to this day provide
rationale justification and understandings on international criminal law. In addition to that
you have a variety of other tribunals. You have the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea Tribunal,
you have conventions that you have tribunals that are more regional in nature. So for example the
European Court of Justice when it comes to the European Union, the European Court
on Human Rights when it comes to the ECHR. You have also ad hoc tribunals that are established
in various different instances and that provide relevance to various different specific subjects
of law. So for example the Eritrea Ethiopia Claims Commission which is of course of particular
contemporary relevance when we look at international humanitarian law. And you also have of course
legal domestic systems. Supreme courts and higher judicial institutions and authorities
from domestic legal systems that provide information and provide implications to
the ways in which international law operates. And speaking of domestic legal systems and speaking
specifically of the United States Supreme Court, I would like to draw your attention to the
Pacabana case from 1900. So we're talking about a case that not only predates the United Nations
and the International Court of Justice, but it's a case that predates the League of Nations
and the Permanent Court of Justice which existed prior to the UN. So this is obviously a very old
case within international law. If we talk about the sort of stages of international legal development
this is in one of the earlier stages. This is a very important authority when it comes to
international law as well as specifically the ways in which judicial decisions are operationalized
and it comes from the US Supreme Court. They say quote international law is part of our law.
It must be ascertained and administered by the courts of justice of appropriate jurisdiction
as often as questions of rights depending on it are duly presented for their determination.
In addition to this quote where there is no treaty and no controlling executive or legislative act
or judicial decision, resort must be had to the customs and usages of civilized nations.
Of course we remember back to previous lessons where we don't exactly
utilize the language of quote civilized nations anymore. Carrying on they say quote and as
evidence of this to the works of jurists and commentators who by years of labor research
and experience have made themselves particularly well acquainted with the subject of which they
treat. Now you might find in fact that there is some resemblances to the wording that we see here
in this case and the wording of the specific provisions of the ICJ statute which outlines
the sources of international law. If you remember talking about the works of jurists and publicists
and commentators these are examples of sort of sources of international law that provide us
with evidence of experience and research which essentially gives us an indication of what the
law is and how the law ought to be considered in these circumstances. And essentially this is where
judicial decisions come into it and it is sort of paradoxical and it is sort of
it is sort of reflective in the sense that what we're doing here is talking about judicial
decisions as being a source of law and as specifically a source of international law
and as evidence and authority of judicial decisions being a source of law with
quoting from judicial decisions. Very very interesting. But fundamentally we have been
citing quite heavily and quite consistently judicial decisions and the relationship between
judicial decisions and international law throughout this series of lessons and when
we go into some of the other not necessarily sources of law but subsidiary factors relating
to the sources of law like for example the concepts of things like Ergaronne's obligations
and Yuskogun's obligations we shall be citing of course judicial decisions throughout as well.
