In this episode of THE LAW LAB, we take a deep dive into one of the core sources of international law — General Principles of Law. What are they? Where do they come from? And how are they applied by international courts and tribunals?
We’ll explore how these principles — such as good faith, equity, estoppel, and the rule against unjust enrichment — form part of international legal reasoning, especially when treaties and customary law fall short.
This video is perfect for law students, researchers, and anyone seeking to understand the foundational values that shape global legal systems.
Subscribe for more insightful legal content from THE LAW LAB!
Good day, cherished viewers, and welcome to another episode on The Law On.
Your favourite platform, The Law Lab.
As you know, here we dissect and unpack everything legal so that everybody can understand the
provisions in the law as it's practised.
We'll continue in our series on public international law, specifically a continuation on our
discussions on the sources of international law.
In our previous videos, we have discussed international treaties as a source of international
law.
We have also looked at international customary law as a source of international law.
Today we'll turn our attentions to the general principles of law recognised by civilised
nations.
When we turn our minds to Article 38 of the Statutes of the ICJ, we will see that stated
as Paragraph C, it's the fact that general principles of law recognised by civilised
nations is a source of international law, which the international courts will make reference
to in making determination to international disputes.
We will try in this video to explain what general principles of international law means,
and then we will look at some examples of general principles of law recognised by civilised
nations.
It is interesting to note that whilst Article 38 of the ICJ Statutes mentions that general
principles of law recognised by civilised nations are a source of international law,
it falls short in providing a definition for us as to what constitutes or what the meaning
of general principles of law as recognised by civilised states really or actually refer
to.
Again, when you look at legal scholars across the board, there is no uniformity in their
understanding or their explanation of what general principles of law actually mean or
what they refer to.
When we saw treaties and when we looked at international customary law, there was some
consistency among legal scholars as to what those two terms meant.
However, when we come to general principles of law, there is no clear-cut definition of
what general principles of law refer to.
However, we will try to understand or key out some, churn out some key elements or characteristics
of general principles of law that these definitions will give credence to, irrespective of what
angle they seek to define general principles of law from.
The first scholar I would want to look at is Malcolm Shaw, and I'm sure that if you've
been following our videos to date, you would realise that Malcolm Shaw is one of the scholars
we refer to often in our discussions of public international law, specifically when we treated
treaties.
Malcolm Shaw in his writings has referred to or defined general principles of law as
an affirmation of natural law concepts, which are deemed to underline, to underlie the system
of international law and constitutes the method for testing the validity of the positive or
man-made rules.
Let me take that again.
Malcolm Shaw defines general principles of law as an affirmation of natural law concepts,
which are deemed to underline the system of international law and constitutes the method
for testing the validity of the positive or man-made rules.
In other words, Malcolm Shaw is saying that first and foremost, general principles of
law are natural law, or they come or are derived from natural law concepts.
We will in a short while look at what natural law concepts are and how legal jurisprudence
has defined natural law.
He goes on to say that these principles are or undergird the system of international law
that is now practised.
In other words, it is the very foundation of public international law as we are studying
today.
And so even though there is a difficulty in defining what general principles of law really
constitute, please do not be confused in your minds how important these general principles
of law are in the establishment of public international law.
Let us now turn our attentions to try to understand what natural law is and what those concepts
of natural law are as Malcolm Shaw refers to them.
According to a natural law proponent known as Cloris, he defines natural law as a body
of immutable rules superior to positive law.
It is ideal law since it consists of the highest principles of morality towards which humanity
is striving.
It is also absolute law since it is not the result of any convention, but is discoverable
by the exercise of reason.
In simple terms, what Cloris is defining natural law to mean is law that is inherent in every
natural human being who has the power of reasoning.
If you exercise correct reasoning, Cloris is then saying that you should be able to
reason out or fashion out or determine what natural law principles are.
Therefore, we can say that natural law principles are God-given laws, all right, which every
human being must be able to come to terms with by the exercise of good reason.
You do not necessarily need to write them down as positive law would have to be written
down, but natural law is self-evident by the exercise of good reason, all right.
Another scholar or natural law proponent known as Radbrock would go on to define natural
law as principles of law that are stronger than any statute so that a law conflicting
with these principles is devoid of validity.
And so Radbrock and Shaw will agree on one important thing, that natural laws are what's
undergird or are the foundations of every legal system so that a breach of these natural
law principles would mean a defective or a faulty legal system as is practiced.
And therefore, Radbrock and Shaw will agree on the importance or the important role that
natural law plays in every legal system.
All right, scholars have also gone on to say that if we say that general principles
of law are derived from natural law concepts, then it is to say that general principles
of law or natural law possesses qualities similar to what is known as Jus Cogens norms,
Jus Cogens norms.
What then are Jus Cogens norms?
Article 53 of the Vienna Convention on the Laws of Treaty will go on to define Jus
Cogens as a norm accepted and recognized by the international community of states as
a whole, as a norm from which no derogation is permitted and which can be modified only
by a subsequent norm of general international law having the same character.
Jus Cogens is being defined under Article 53 as a norm accepted and recognized by the
international community of states as a whole.
Very similar to what we have seen as international customary law.
However, Jus Cogens are those things that are so inherent in state practice that everybody
recognizes them as principles of law which cannot be derogated from or which cannot be
departed from. Everybody is bound to respect those principles of law.
And it goes on to say that they are so superior that they can only be modified by a
subsequent international law or a subsequent Jus Cogens of a similar character.
In other words, if we are looking at how law or legal systems are established, Jus Cogens
or natural law is then of paramount importance and must be paid attention to.
Whilst we've established the natural law and its influence on what general principles of
law is, it is important to state here and now that it is not every scholar or every
legal expert who recognizes the importance of natural law in the establishment of general
principles of law.
There are some scholars who depart from it, especially those scholars who align with a
school of thought that law is positive law only, that is man-made law and not any other
law. Those categories of peoples or proponents of positive law would depart from this
understanding or this, of us equating general principles of law to natural law
principles. They would depart from that.
But what is important for us to know that even though they depart from it, what is common
between such legal scholars and the legal scholars like Malcolm Shaw we have seen
previously, who equate general principles of law as, you know, with natural law
concepts. The three things seem to be similar or common between these two schools of
thought. The first thing is that general principles of law are usually unwritten legal
norms of a wide-ranging character.
They are unwritten legal norms of a wide-ranging character.
And so they do not specifically address one particular legal issue.
They address several legal issues, and they may not be seen in law books written down
by, like, clorals who say they will be derived from the exercise, there will be self
evidence from the exercise of good or correct reasoning.
Number two, what is common between these two schools of thought, those who equate general
principles of law with natural law concepts and those who choose not so to do, is
that it is recognized in municipal laws of states.
All right. So that even in developing laws or national laws for sovereign states, they
give some credence to the existence of these general principles of law.
And last but not the least, they are transposable at the international level.
Whilst we say that they give credence to these general principles of law at the national
level, it is also important to note that these principles are transposable or they can be
reflected at the international level in the practice or as evidence in the practice
between states.
Now, in international law or public international law and the adjudication of
disputes between international states, what role would general principles of law play
in the determination of disputes?
There is some acceptance by all international lawyers or by all parties in
international in the international playing that whilst international treaties and
international customary law are the two main sources of law in international
practice, there may be instances, however few they may be, where a dispute arises
between two states where there is no international treaty that spells out or provides
for how these disputes must be settled.
There are also instances where whilst there is no international agreement to settle a
dispute, there is also no existence of an international customary law for the courts or
the international courts or tribunals to rely on in adjudicating a matter.
When this happens, it creates a situation which is known in law as non-liquid.
All right. And when there's a non-liquid situation, what that means is that the law
would have no laws, the courts would have no laws to rely on in resolving a dispute.
Therefore, general principles of law as recognised as a source of international law is
to help the international courts avoid situations like this where there are no laws or
international treaties regarding a dispute before them.
And there are also no international customs that relates to the dispute or help to solve
the disputes as exists between the two states or the parties before the courts in a
dispute. In such instances, Article 38.1c of the ICJ statute would say that the judges
would have to turn their attentions to general principles of law to help to resolve this
dispute. And so, like we've already seen, general principles of law play a very critical
or vital role in the resolution of disputes between states.
Last but not the least, we turn our attention to some examples of general principles of
law as is practiced between states.
The first and the most important or the most common one that is usually referred to is
the Latin phrase pacta sunt servanda, which simply means that parties must be responsible
for the things or the promises they have made to other states, which therefore means that
if you enter into an international agreement or you promise to carry out certain
obligations in respect of another state, you must act in absolute good faith in ensuring
that you perform the obligations as expected of you by the other states to whom those
obligations are owed.
And so if you enter into a contract as sovereign states to do certain things in respect of
each other, pacta sunt servanda would say that you must respect the promises and
obligations you've entered into in respect of other states and carry them through.
There are those, there's another general principle of law, which is known as the
separation of powers, where locally on the national level, we would say that the
executive realm of government, the legislative and the judiciary are separated and they
all have distinct roles they play in the governance of every state.
These same principles are transposable in the international level, where in
international, public international law, there must necessarily be separation of
states, separation of powers, pardon me, even in the relation of one state to another.
There's also the general principle of law, which is known as due process, that is due
process would encompass a number of principles of law.
The fact that a defendant, all parties in a dispute must be heard.
If any party is unable to afford a lawyer, a lawyer must be appointed for such a party
by the courts.
There must be no breach of natural justice.
You must not, you cannot be a referee in your own disputes and so on and so forth.
These are but a few examples of general principles of law, which would help the
international courts to make judgments in matters or disputes that come before us, that
come before them.
Right.
Cherished viewers, this brings us to the end of yet another discussion on the sources of
international law.
Particularly in this video, we focused on the general principles of law as recognized by
civilized states.
We've tried to explain what they are.
The role they play in adjudicating matters.
And we've looked at a few examples of general, of some principles of law that are
important in the international realm or the international level.
Again, I hope that you found these videos interesting and educative and useful in your
understanding of public international law.
My name has remained Adamu Ben Mahmoud and I would want to urge you to subscribe to the
Law Lab, like our videos, turn on the notifications and do well to share our videos
with your friends who are also embarking on a legal education or are just interested in
understanding the principles of law as we discuss them here.
Until next time, I hope you have a good day and see you soon.
Bye bye.