Why Carlos Correa Shouldn't (And Probably Won't) Be Traded
iTalk Studios
908 followers
#mlb #baseball #sports
LG Store Link - https://bit.ly/iTalkStudios_LG
Amazon Store Link - https://bit.ly/iTalkStudios_FireTV
iTALK STUDIOS INSTAGRAM: https://instagram.com/italk.studios?utm_medium=copy_link
iTALK STUDIOS TWITTER/X: https://twitter.com/italkstudiosyt?s=21
iTALK STUDIOS SECOND CHANNEL: @iTalkStudiosExtra
VIDEO MUSIC CREDIT TO @mikhelvin AND @samuelkimmusic
Mik
► Spotify: https://spoti.fi/3jaB7yS
► Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/mikhelvin
Samuel Kim
► Spotify: https://spoti.fi/2vYKPBd
► YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/c/samuelkimmusic
► Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/samuelkimmusic
Every fan of any team at some point feels miserable or heartbroken, but there are several
teams where that feeling of miserable or heartbreak feels everlasting with no end in sight, and the
Minnesota Twins fall right into that category. Those pale bastards haven't felt pure joy since
1991. Combined not winning a championship since that year with how ridiculously icy cold it gets,
it most definitely has not been a fun time up there. This franchise has essentially become
a punching bag for the Yankees or really any team in the postseason, but especially the Yankees.
The moment the New York Yankees or any of these teams see that they're matched up with the Twins
in the playoffs, it's like a kid on Christmas morning. It doesn't matter how good or compelling
any of these Twins teams look, they never end up on top or close to being on top.
And nothing's changed with the biggest signing they've had in a long time, Carlos Correa joining.
Correa was originally expected to be a one-time Twin in 2022, a year we'd all look back at at
the end of his career and say, remember when Carlos Correa was a Twin? And that prophecy looked
to be fulfilled until Correa acted like he was on The Bachelor and couldn't choose what team he
wanted to be on. Or the other way around, actually. They didn't really want him on a long-term deal
because of the fear his ankle could explode at any moment. So it all led to Correa ending back
up with the Twins for a six-year, $200 million contract after failing to officially sign bigger
contracts with the Giants and Mets. Sloppy thirds is crazy. Well, Correa has since continued being
a Minnesota Twin, and things have been… meh. His 2023 season, the first of his new contract,
was bad, at least personally for him during the regular season. He was able to play most of the
year, although it wasn't necessarily pain-free. Correa dealt with plantar fasciitis and bulked
season, which definitely played a factor into his bad offensive year. He provided great defense per
usual but wasn't really a factor on offense until the playoffs, which was big. The Twins were back
in the playoffs, and not only that but winning their first playoff game in the playoff series
in almost 20 years. Correa turned things up a notch that postseason until it came to an end
against his old team. And as for 2024? Basically the complete opposite of 2023 for Correa. In 2024,
Correa was great offensively, unlike 2023. The Twins missed the playoffs, unlike 2023,
and Correa also missed many more games this past season, unlike 2023. Rope pulled a reverse uno
on every important aspect of the previous season, and it basically showed that nothing could fully
come together nicely. At least, not yet. Because when Correa plays most of the games and the team
goes to the playoffs, he's bad. But when he's good, and not just good but great, he can't stay
on the field and the Twins miss the playoffs. The plantar fasciitis was bad in 2024, so much
to the point where Correa was at a point where he couldn't walk without pain. That is until he and
the doctors apparently found a treatment that was so painful it brought tears to his eyes,
but it worked. It helped eventually get him back on the field at the very end of the Twins' run
at the postseason, only for that run to come crashing down as the team had a collapse for
the ages, missing out on October and leaving the fans with a dark, cold winter ahead.
So, what now? Well, it's pretty clear the Twins aren't a team that's willing to spend much money.
There's a radar to this. There's Carrie Bradshaw levels of freely spending money and then Mr.
Krabs levels of being cheap, and the Twins are more on the Mr. Krabs side. Correa and his big
contract are a big exception, and if it wasn't for his risky health and the Giants and Mets not
trusting it, the Twins would've not been the highest bidders for Correa. And even after making
the postseason in 2023, the Twins slashed payroll by $30 million for 2024. As for 2025? Well, here's
where things are different and interesting. The Twins' current ownership group is planning to
sell the team. The Polad family has owned the franchise for 40 years, and if that seems like
a long time, that's because it is. It's the fourth longest period among all active ownership
groups in MLB. And the general consensus from Twins fans seems to be the feeling of eagerness
for this to happen, which makes sense. Again, like I said, this isn't an organization known to
invest too much into the product on the field, so maybe getting new ownership will be a great thing.
But there are also rumors going around that they're going to want to shed payroll even more
before selling the franchise off, I guess because it's a less risky and more straightforward process
to sell the team when there's not as many contracts tied down to it. That's what I've seen be an
explanation to that. And when you look at the contracts this team is tied down to, obviously
Correia's pops out by far at number one. Then there was this Instagram post by Carlos Ballerga,
a former player, now reporter slash podcaster, who said this. This week, there have been strong
rumors that the Minnesota team could be trading our Carlos Correia, and for me, these three teams
need a player like him. They are the Yankees, the Mets, and the Dodgers. But for me, the team that
the most players would be the Dodgers. What do you think of this trade? Okay, so obviously the
Dodgers-Mets-Yankees stuff is all pure speculation. Although, if a Correia trade really was going to
go down, those three teams would make the most sense in terms of who gets him. And the twins
could do one of two things with a Correia trade, prioritize getting his money off the books or
getting good prospects. He can't have both. Another team takes on that contract, that'll be the biggest
return on their end. But if you want prospects, you're going to have to eat the money while he
plays elsewhere. Considering it's because the twins want to lower payroll, they'd be probably
doing the former and trading Correia to lose his contract. But in reality, I don't think any of
this happens. First off, you have to, of course, take so much of what you see or read with a grain
of salt. I'm sorry, but Carlos Ballerga randomly saying there's a rumor of the twins wanting to
trade Correia on Instagram doesn't do it for me. I'm not fully discrediting the guy. He has some
credibility, but I just don't really buy this, especially since no other reporters have said
anything about it. Seems more like a fantasy, if anything. There's a reason why Carlos Correia
shouldn't be traded, and there's also a reason why he probably won't be, whether we think he should
be or not. And the two reasons kind of coincide. And as for a reason as why he should be traded,
I don't really see one. Correia is only two years into a six year contract. He just showed how good
he is this past year when able to be on the field. And it's not like the twins as an organization are
in a terrible place that makes a Correia trade seem reasonable. Yes, they just had a really
awful, horrible, no good, very bad collapse to end 2024. But this twins team theoretically isn't
far at all from going back to the postseason. They still have a pretty good group of talent,
but not just that. The twins have a top farm system in baseball. MLB.com rated them as number
two behind the Rays, so there's a lot to look forward to. And having Carlos Correia and Byron
Buxton, another guy rumored to be traded to shed payroll, are the perfect players to have in a time
like this for the twins. You have what looks like a bright future. You already have some young up
and coming studs showing off like Royce Lewis, if he can stay healthy. Brooks Lee was the twins
2022 first round pick who made his big league debut this past season. You have all these young
guys. It's perfect to have Carlos Correia and Byron Buxton to be the experienced veterans to
balance things out. Correia seems to be a very beloved guy in the clubhouse, someone who's
become a real leader in there, along with Buxton. He's clearly still talented. It's not like he's
falling off in that way at all. As long as he can stay healthy, it seems like he's still one of the
top shortstops. And so you factor in all this, it just doesn't make sense for the twins to want to
trade him, even if they want a lower payroll or sell the team. And according to what looks to be
inside info, that's exactly the case. Shout out LG on Twitter slash X, his handle is Midwest Cards
Guy. And he's not a reporter, so he doesn't even tweet any of this stuff out or care to. He
addressed these rumors and said he's good friends with two different guys that are very close to the
twins organization, one of them being someone who was literally part of the organization
and the other being a writer with a direct way to contact Derek Foley, the twins president of
baseball operations. And what LG told me, I don't think would be fake because none of it was crazy
or anything that would break baseball, wasn't anything groundbreaking. And it coincides with
what seems to make the most logical sense. So I asked him what exactly they told him about Correia
and Buxton, to which he said that Buxton is essentially untouchable, even with all of his
injury issues, because he still represents the heart of the twins and moving on from him while
trying to sell the team would significantly hurt their chances of getting a sale done in the short
term. At least the fans would obviously hate that. And they want to give their big three one more
chance to stay healthy and make a run at it. The hope is that Brooks Lee matures into an everyday
second baseman. They can acquire a mid-tier first baseman as apparently they have little interest
in bringing Carlos Santana back. And they're also hoping the young pitching staff can mature
and lead this team deep into the postseason. And like Buxton, Correia is a massive piece of all
this considering his leadership in the clubhouse is unmatched and they believe it could cause some
serious issues with Royce Lewis if he's traded because he and Royce are very close and Correia
has been a big mentor to him. And the twins are also not interested in a rebuild, which again,
coincides with what seems like reality. Why would they rebuild? Yes, they had a really gross end to
2024, but there's so much positive to look at when analyzing the future of this team. So why trade
Correia, who's still pretty young himself, by the way, in the midst of all this? All this young
talent seemingly coming together? The franchise is still in a pretty damn good spot right now.
And training a guy like Carlos Correia and or Byron Buxton would imply a rebuild. And there's
absolutely no reason to be rebuilding with the current state that this team is in with the
promise that it has. So if you're a fan of another team who you genuinely feel could trade for Correia,
I wouldn't get your hopes up at all. This really didn't seem real when it first came out. And after
hearing some of this stuff from LG, stuff that, again, is all very normal sounding and realistic.
It's not like he gave me any insane rumors or anything that would break baseball. This Correia
stuff doesn't really seem to be true at all. In a couple of years, we could revisit this
conversation. But while he still has four years left, he's still one of the best shortstops in
baseball when healthy. And the twins have such a good thing seemingly forming around him, even
with the potential sale going on of the ownership. I don't think there's anything that's going to
change too drastic about this team on the field. The whole point of signing Correia was for kind
of being in the position that they're in right now to have a good young core around him. It shouldn't
happen and I don't think it will happen. Let me know your thoughts and thank you for watching.
