So, I just finished reading Dungeon Crawler Carl books 1 and 2, and I'll be honest,
I kind of fully expected to hate it. But here I am, about to talk about my experience with this
series that has been absolutely dominating the fantasy community for the past couple of years.
So, unless you've been living under a rock, you probably noticed that Dungeon Crawler Carl has
been exploding on booktube and beyond. I mean, it literally feels like everyone is reading and
raving about the series. And as someone who runs a channel all about fantasy literature,
I couldn't help but be curious, right? I mean, over the past few years, we've seen literally a
huge rise in serialized storytelling and niche subgenres like progression fantasy and lit RPG
taking over the community, and this book seems to sit right at the crossroads of these two trends.
So, for example, The Wandering Inn. I mean, it's a wildly popular progression fantasy web novel
where the author releases like one or two chapters a week. And in this progression fantasy,
the characters typically grow stronger and stronger over time, but it is without explicit
video game mechanics. I mean, you don't get like stats on the screen or exact numbers. It's not
like in The Wandering Inn you're watching a character gain like five points in stamina. It's
more about that gradual narrative-driven growth, or at least so I've been told. But that's where
lit RPG steps in. I mean, in this subgenre, video game mechanics are a big part of the story. So,
things like character leveling up, earning achievements, tracking stats, and battling
mobs or bosses is a huge part. And honestly, Dungeon Crawler Carl has become like the face
of lit RPG in recent times. Now, obviously, there are other big names in lit RPG like He Who Fights
With Monsters, but looking from the outside, which I definitely am, it feels like Dungeon
Crawler Carl is where the party is at. And for good reason. I mean, this series has gained so
much traction that it's literally been optioned by Seth MacFarlane for an adaptation and recently
made its way into traditional publishing in the United States. And here's the crazy part. When
book seven dropped in Dungeon Crawler Carl, it instantly shot to the top of the Kindle store,
becoming one of the best-selling books across the entire platform. I mean, that is just nuts.
So, as a self-proclaimed fantasy nut and someone who loves mother fantasy, I mean, you kind of
think that Dungeon Crawler Carl would be right up my alley, right? But honestly, I just wasn't
that interested. I mean, if you've been watching my channel for a while, you know I rarely enjoy
books where humor is the driving force. Now, don't get me wrong here. I mean, I love humor
in context. So, for example, I often use the example that I love the dark humor in Joe
Abercrombie's First Light Universe, but that works for me because that humor is woven into
a grimdark story and it's not the central focus, right? What I personally often struggle with are
the books that aim to be absurd and humorous first and foremost. And I know this kind of makes me
sound soulless, but I'm just not someone who enjoys a joke on every page. I mean, case in point
here, while I absolutely respect the genius of Terry Pratchett, I never could fully immerse
myself into this world series. The absurdity and relentless focus on fun kept me from connecting
deeply with the story. And then if you add my lukewarm experience with like the Cradle series,
which is a progression fantasy, you can kind of get an understanding why I didn't see Dungeon
Crawler Carl as a series that would appeal to me. I mean, everyone has told me that Dungeon
Crawler Carl is an absurdist humor driven story with lit RPG elements. I mean, that's basically a
checklist of things I assume I wouldn't enjoy. I mean, literally, if there was a book that was
destined not to work for me, it seemed like Dungeon Crawler Carl would be the one. So why did I pick
it up? Am I a hate reader? No, absolutely not. I mean, the honest truth is I fell victim to FOMO.
I mean, the relentless hype around this series made me feel like I was missing out. And I figured
that even if I didn't enjoy the series, I could at least learn a bit more about what's trending
in modern fantasy, which is surely valuable for someone that's literally running a fantasy focused
booktube channel, right? So let's talk about what I loved about Dungeon Crawler Carl first.
Firstly, I must say that this is definitely one of the most unique stories I have ever read.
Basically at the very early start of the story, the earth is destroyed and it's not by like an
alien invasion or because of a natural disaster, but because it's been turned into a twisted
intergalactic reality TV show. And then the survivors are then thrown into a brutal dungeon
like game where the stakes are simple. You either survive or you die. So the story follows Carl,
who is like an average guy with an, I would say above average survival instinct, who gets caught
up in this insane death game. And then he's armed with a little witty, snarky cat companion called
Princess Donut. Now the story follows Carl as he has to navigate a series of increasingly dangerous
levels filled with traps, monsters, and scheming competitors. Oh, and also to mention, this whole
thing is broadcast for the entertainment of an alien audience. So basically, Dungeon Crawler
Carl is a wild mix of genres, blending lit RPG elements like leveling up, skills, and stats,
which is then filled with humor and lots of absurdism. And I really have to praise Matt
Demonium for what he has created here, because even for someone like me, this absurd concept
has this thing with drawing you in because you never really know what's going to happen next,
which brings me to point two, which is Dinamon's ability to introduce new elements to the story.
So while I did end up finding several sections to be quite repetitive, I must say that overall,
I think Dinamon did a phenomenal job at keeping the story fresh. I mean, I was really surprised
how the story constantly introduced totally new elements or world building mechanics that made me
want to continue reading. I mean, I must say that there were several moments where I was very,
very close to feeling bored, but then suddenly something new happened that was able to keep me
engaged and immersed again in the story. Now I heard that as the story progresses, the plot takes
even more wild turns and twists, which I think is definitely something that is needed to keep
a series like this engaging throughout. Also, additionally, Prince of Donut is brilliant. I
mean, in my opinion, Donut is definitely one of the highlights of the story. And then I also just
want to praise Dinamon. I mean, he's clearly a talented author. I mean, if you're looking for
a story with lots of humor, leveling up mechanics and stuff like that, then I really think you
should check out Dungeon Crawler Card because I think it is incredibly well executed. And also
just a side note, I do think that this series could really work as a palette cleanser. So if
you're in the middle of like a lot of huge series, then maybe read a Dungeon Crawler Card book in
between the bigger series you're reading. And I do appreciate that it might be a bit crazy to call
the series lighthearted because the oral concept is incredibly dark, but really the tone of the
story is fun and absurd. And then I also just have to say that probably the highest praise I can give
the series is the fact that I kind of expected to give book one and two, probably one or two stars,
but ultimately I ended up giving both books three stars. So just the very fact that this series
exceeded my expectations by a quite a high margin is really, really high praise. Oh, and also the
audiobooks are phenomenal. But yeah, as you probably guessed by now, this didn't end up
becoming a new favorite for me. So let's talk about what didn't really work for me. First off,
I want to acknowledge that I am probably not the target audience here, right? And I must say,
I don't really think it's fair for me to critique too harshly the series for that. I mean, it's a bit
like going to watch an Adam Sandler movie when you already know that this style of humor doesn't
work for you. I mean, it wouldn't really make sense to criticize a movie for being what it set out to
be. Now, I knew going into Dungeon Crawler Card that it was packed with elements that typically
do not appeal to me. I mean, absurd humor, lit RPG mechanics, and so on and so on. And yes, that
turned out to be true. So I do think it's safe to say that this was never going to be a five-star
read for me simply because of the nature of the story. But again, the fact that this story
exceeded my expectations speaks volume about the quality of writing here. That said, let's break
down what didn't work for me. Now, while I did praise Dinamon's ability to introduce new and
interesting elements to the story, the heavy focus on stats, leveling up, and progressing through each
dungeon level, I mean, it started to feel repetitive. I mean, there's definitely like a
clear formula to the whole story, and even with all the creativity, I must admit that it did become a
bit predictable. And then speaking of stakes, I mean, this is where the story kind of lost me a
bit. So on the surface, right, the stakes are incredibly high. I mean, Earth has been destroyed
and everyone is fighting for survival in a brutal death game. But for me, it didn't really feel like
the stakes were that high. So for example, I never really truly believed that Carl or Pinstone at
were in a serious danger. I mean, the series is literally called Dungeon Crawler Carl. So it's
obvious that Carl, he's never going to die, right? At least not in the first two books. And no,
that's not a spoiler. But because of this, I found myself becoming less and less invested in the
tension of the story. So this combination of humor, absurdity, repetitiveness, and a sense of
armor made me start losing interest about halfway through book two. But the fact that I made it this
far and I still didn't hate it was shocking to me, considering my initial expectations of actually
expecting to hate the story. Now I read the first two books, but I wouldn't really say that you need
to read the first two books to know if the series is for you. For me, book one and two weren't
dramatically different. So if you don't enjoy the first book, I doubt you would enjoy the second
one. That being said, I'm genuinely glad I read these two books. I mean, they've given me a greater
appreciation for lit RPG as a genre, and I kind of better understand now why so many people love
the series. And as someone who runs a fantasy-focused channel, those insights are incredibly valuable.
But as personally to answer, will I be continuing the series? I don't think so. But I will definitely
be recommending it to some of my readers. I mean, if you enjoy absurd humor, lit RPG mechanics,
and a wild and unpredictable twist and turns in a story, then this might be a perfect fit for you.
But if you're looking for amazing book recommendations from amazing booktubers,
check out this video. Oh, you're still here and you want more? Well, the good news is that I have
a Viking book club on my Patreon. If you join my Patreon, then you get access to an exclusive book
club where every single month we read one book together, and the book can be put forward by you.
If you join tier three or four, then you can put a book forward, and then I randomly choose a book
from the pot that we end up reading together. And throughout the month, we discuss the book on the
Patreon chats, and then we also have Zoom hangouts, which honestly are some of my favorite times of
month. This month we're reading this book, and next month we're going to be reading this book.
Also, since I launched my Patreon, I basically spent my money back into the channel on video
editing. I've had more than 40 videos professionally edited, so if you want to support what I do here,
and also help me upload more consistently, then I'll leave a link in the description down below.