Non-fiction November #5 - Trollope’s autobiography!

Anthony Trollope
2 followers
Ladies and gentlemen, boys and girls, strikers, hikers and hairy bikers, welcome along to the
Joe Spivey YouTube channel where we discuss books and little else. You join me on a stunted
Tuesday afternoon here in Great Britain. That mysterious gaseous orb, known more colloquially
as the sun, has not yet made an appearance today and we have constant 100% cloud cover,
so if it is a little dark that is why. A little bit more housekeeping before we get on with our
described book review or appreciation today. You may have seen overnight, again some of my
demographic people tell me that I have a great deal of, a great deal of my audience is from
the United States and so you may not have seen. There was a gentleman a little while ago called
David Cameron, now Lord Cameron, who led this country down a complete path of despair.
He is the physical delineament, the walking talking apotheosis of
Etonian effortless success. He has had not everything handed to him on a plate. He is a
pusillanimous technocrat really, that to solve internal strife in the Conservative Party
a good couple of years ago brought the nation to its knees with a particular referendum,
which I often mention on this channel, and made a disaster in Libya and, you know, gave fodder for
many of his enemies to then use against him quite rightly and is now back. He has since been
trousering pockets, trousering millions and millions of pounds by illegally lobbying the
government on all sorts of weird financially secure loans for a private firm, again for which he's
earned millions of pounds, and Mr Sunak has brought him back as Foreign Secretary. He's given him a
lordship, he's given him a peerage and a seat in the House of Lords, so if Mr Cameron so wishes
he can park his sheep in my front garden and I can do nothing to, I can take no legal
action to prevent him. He is a knight of the realm and somebody that we have to genuflect towards.
So he's back. You've got Jack Edwards making videos about, openly telling his
acolytes and fans, his millions of acolytes and fans, to be deceitful in their everyday lives
when talking about books, but beyond that, that's about it. You join me for our, I'm losing track now,
fifth or sixth, fifth installment of Nonfiction November, the Booktube, the annual Booktube event
originally brought into being by Olive, out of the book Olive, in which, if you're a cretinous fool
and happen not to read any nonfiction at all, we are advising you here to do so, and if
you are a glorious individual that does already read nonfiction, then we are telling you to do
an awful lot more of it. I touted earlier, in my weekend video, that I would be reviewing, or at
least looking at, Hannah Arendt's On the Origins of Totalitarianism. I did mention, at the back end
of my book haul on Sunday, that it was becoming rather wordy and stodgy, and it went on like that,
unfortunately, folks. It was what most, what Steve Donoghue has very, very, very accurately
described as textbook work, which is what most people who don't engage very often in nonfiction
see as nonfiction, and that's what The Origins of Totalitarianism became. She starts off with
the origins of antisemitism, and somehow, for such a heart-rending and historically confusing and
diverse subject, made it very, very dull. I struggled to care, if you know what I mean.
I couldn't understand just what she was trying to get across, and I understand that it's riddled
with all sorts of difficulty, but she really did not do a very good job of what a nonfiction,
you know, historian should be doing, which is condensing the information and presenting it in
an entertaining way. It was garrulous and wordy and did none of the above that I wanted it to,
which is a shame, because I've loved her work till now, but anyway. So I've moved on. The TBR has
been completely ripped to bits, because essentially every single book that I've talked about has not
been on my TBR, but, you know, in spite of this, we plow on. So today we are looking at Anthony
Trollope's autobiography, written in the autumn of his career, and this is odd in and of itself.
This is nomadic, at times pedagogical, at times tendentious. It's easily the most fiery work that
I've ever read from Trollope. For somebody that is usually... I mean, he is, in sections of this,
he's also as warming and welcoming and armchair-providing as he is in his fictional works,
but sometimes you get this scathing, abrasive, critical, very assertive individual that you
might not have liked, potentially, in real life. Yeah, he's very, very... yeah, very stern.
But yes, so this charts his early childhood, which was, as is a common prerequisite,
essentially, of any Victorian writer, was a complete hellhole. His father was impecunious
and a little bit irresponsible and careless, and sunk his capital into all sorts of nonsense,
landowning, which meant that he didn't have the proverbial pot to urinate in by the end of his
life. And so Trollope was a social pariah at school, was bullied and lynched and hit by
tutors, and was easily recognisable from a mile away, wore ragged clothes, had to walk,
I think it was, 12 miles a day to get there and back. And yeah, he was very, very aware of the
miseries of his life, and all of a sudden those vicissitudes started to normalise,
and he had a horrid, horrid childhood. Meanwhile, harbouring some, obviously, rather quixotic and
dewy-eyed literary ambitions, which would then go on to motivate him to be
one of our favourite Victorian writers. His mother was rather literary, that was something I
did learn from this book that I had no idea about. She went across the pond to you guys over in the
United States, when you weren't quite the economic superpower that you are today,
and she wrote, the name is going to evade me, but quite itself a scathing and abusive
account of American, you know, daily life. But yeah, that was very successful, and that,
Trollope says, put the shoes on her children's, you know, his and his sibling's feet, and a roof
over their heads when his dad was, you know, sort of cantering around in a dalliance. And then he,
you know, sort of weird nepotistic turn, is then given a job at the post office. I believe it was
a, an in-law that was either already there or had connections, so he's then given a job at
the post office, goes over to Ostend in Belgium with his father for a bit. Yeah, very, very nomadic
early on, and yeah, essentially continues to talk about how he does harbour literary ambitions,
and then eventually goes on to realise them. The reason that this isn't, I don't know,
this has been held against Trollope, I think, his entire life, or after it was published, because
he essentially converts the art of literature into something metronomic, something done by
an automaton, some product and some quota that you spit out every single day, rather than the
rather romantic view, the sort of, you know, the poolside gentleman that's in a silk tunic,
that is, you know, gripped with grief from childhood, and is therefore going to very
slowly and very precisely etch out his thoughts. That was not what Trollope was doing. He was
sitting for three hours before he would go to his post office work as a letter carrier,
and he would be just Flintlock style, just cantering out all sorts of stuff that we all
love, but he was making sure that he would get his writing done within an allotted time. Yeah,
he has what the horrid modern neologism would term a grind set. Mr T definitely did have a
grind set, but I've got a few lovely pages to highlight for you. It all comes with that usual,
typical Trollope joviality, and that excellent turn of phrase, and the prolonged examination of,
one or two issues that is typical of somebody of his heft and height. So yes, we'll talk about
earlier, it talks earlier on about his ridiculously difficult childhood, and so I will go into that
just now. So he is made very aware earlier, he's very introspective very early on. I don't know
just how much that is typical of autobiographical work, you hear all the time about,
oh I knew when I was 15 that X, Y and Z happened, when of course when you're 15 you didn't know that,
you're a completely different person when you're 50, but nonetheless I think this stands up. So
this is Trollope again about the shame directed towards him in early childhood. Something of the
disgrace of my school boys has clung to me all through life, not that I have ever shunned to
speak of them as openly as I am writing now, but that when I have been claimed a school fellow by
some of those many hundreds who were either with me at Harrow or at Winchester, I have felt that
I had no right to talk of things for most of which I was kept in estrangement. So yeah, he's
continually aware that his childhood was really, really difficult, and of course this is the same
with a whole host of other of the Victorian daguerreotypes of literature. The next section
that I wanted to highlight was when he is very, very obviously a very imposing figure, and he
seemed to apply that to all practice. So he managed to keep up a decent social life, he managed to
write in magazines for... write reviews in magazines, he managed to do non-fiction in
the West Indies, Australia and America, he managed to ride three times a week and hunt,
all whilst doing 250 words a minute for three hours a day. So if you folks think you're a
little tired or burnt out or burning the candle at both ends, Mr T and myself are hereby announcing
that you are not, sadly. But this is his attitude to writing. But as I had made up my mind to
undertake this second profession, I found it to be expedient to bind myself by certain self-imposed
laws. When I have commenced a new book, I've always prepared a diary, divided into weeks and carried
it on for the period which I've allowed myself for the completion of the work. In this I have
entered, day by day, the number of pages I've written, so that if at any time I've slipped into
idleness for a day or two, the record of that idleness has been there, staring me in the face
and demanding of me increased labour so that the deficiency may be supplied. According to the
circumstances of the time, whether my other business might be then heavy or light, or whether
the book which I was writing was or was not with speed, I have allotted myself so many pages a
week. The average number has been about 40. It has been placed as low as 20 and has risen to 112.
And as page is an ambiguous term, my page has been made to contain 250 words, and as words,
if not watched, will have a tendency to straggle, I have had every word counted as I went.
You can just see how he seems to very easily and very counterproductively sap all of the fun out
of writing, or sap all the fun out of the appreciation or somebody's take on writing.
So if you, can you imagine if you had read for, you know, 10 and 20 years, all of the
Barchester novels, all of the Palliser novels, The Way We Live Now, all of these
intricately plotted and yet quite, you know, at times sensual, obsessed with romance and love
often, engaged in some really artful dialogue, and all of a sudden you just realise that this
bloke's sort of, I don't know, just churning stuff out like a printer. There is a huge,
there is a stark and alarming contrast between the beauty of his work and the method undertaken
in order to produce that beauty. It's, yeah, this is what this work is touted as, and that
absolutely rung through to me. Let me just highlight, what else have I highlighted for
y'all? So we've got a, it's third autobiography, third style guide, and a final third as a some
sort of wider societal analysis of many of his contemporaries and many of the contemporary
criticism. So he talks about some of the justice in literary affairs. I'd always felt an injustice
in literary affairs which had never afflicted me or even suggested itself to me while I was
unsuccessful. It seemed to me that a name once earned carried with it too much favour. I indeed
had never reached a height to which praise was awarded as a matter of course, but there were
others who sat on higher seats to whom the critics brought unmeasured incense and adulation,
even when they wrote, as they sometimes did write, trash which from a beginning would not have been
thought worthy of the slightest notice. Yeah, so he talks about the sort of bias of fame and how
he deems lots of his contemporaries as being carried along by, being critically carried along
by their already canonical handsome and by them having not to really reinvent themselves or
work very hard on their output in order to be significant. So yeah, he's really very good.
Talks much more about his contemporaries and criticism which I will find here. So he ranks
really suitably and quite instructively. He does a sort of hierarchy of his contemporaries. So he
is, well it's not his closest rival because he doesn't rank him as, he doesn't rank himself as
top, but he says that Thackeray is the most important writer of that generation. He goes
on to talk about George Eliot. At the present moment George Eliot is the first of English
novelists and I am disposed to place her second of those of my time. She is best known to the
literary world as a writer of prose fiction and not improbably whatever of permanent fame she may
acquire will come from her novels. But the nature of her intellect is very far removed indeed from
that which is common to the tellers of stories. Her imagination is no doubt strong but it acts
in analysing rather than creating. Everything that comes before her is pulled to pieces so
the inside of it shall be seen and be seen if possible by her readers as clearly as by herself.
This searching analysis is carried so far that in studying her latter writings one feels oneself to
be in company with some philosopher rather than with a novelist. And anybody that's ever read
anything other than Middlemarch, even though Middlemarch does dabble in that type of stuff,
Ramola, I've done a bit of Daniel Deronda since I picked it up a couple weeks ago,
and much of her, I think she did a bit of non-fiction, you do get at that. She can often go
on and be a little bit too incisive. Then he goes on about Dickens. He's very very rude as one might
imagine. Of Dickens, well he gives him credit but adduces the criticism that myself and others have
in the past which is that none of Dickens' characters seem real, even though he's touted
as a realist. And then he talks about his style. Of Dickens' style it is impossible to speak in
praise. It is jerky, ungrammatical and created by himself in defiance of rules, almost as completely
as that created by Carlyle. To readers who have taught themselves to regard language it must
therefore be unpleasant. And then later on, no young novelist should ever dare to imitate the
style of Dickens. If such a one wants a model for his language, let him take Thackeray. So yeah.
And then he goes on to detail more of his writing routine. Given that he grew up in poverty and
destitution, he was clearly somebody for whom material well-being was of paramount importance
to him. He never had much money in his life until I think midway through his career when he started
selling advanced copies for thousands of pounds, which were actually tens and hundreds of thousands
of pounds in today's money. But yeah, it was never about opulence or never about one-upmanship
or never about notoriety or prominence or fame. It was simply about, it wasn't about accruing
riches. It was just about warding off those early wolves of his life. He didn't really care about
the big houses. All he wanted was to ensure that most of his family were able to go to school
and equated very often the writing of books to whatever, the construction of plumbing pipes
and the laying of electricity cables these days or the building of a brick wall or any other
dull administrative or manual task that we would hate today. He equates literary writing to that,
which is probably why Chorlop has gone down in canonical estimations ever since,
because you don't get the sense of somebody that really loves their art. You don't get the sense
of somebody that was a particularly family man. He doesn't mention that an awful lot. There are
many, many times in this book where he will give you a little bit of a flake of mundanity and
something really specific, you know, about him going somewhere or meeting somebody or having
a chat with a significant person, talks a lot about Disraeli, and then will just completely
dispose with that. And when you think, no, give me another page of what you said to Disraeli or
what it was that brought the idea or what brought Mrs Prouty to you or how did you work on your
Palliser novels? What was it like in Beverley when you were running for government? You know,
give me a little bit more. This should be a thousand pages long from Chorlop. He should
have spent two years of his life doing an absolute, you know, blockbuster, a mega buster,
a toe crusher for us, but instead it's a rather thin and cadaverous thing. But yeah,
that was Chorlop's autobiography. I loved it and I felt it lacked a little bit of
the usual Chorlopian panache, but he was, yeah, he's, you know, flagrantly critical of many of
his time. And yeah, if you like Chorlop, you're still going to enjoy this because there's
lots of descriptions of how he came to acquire his characters and how he lived with characters.
Tells you to focus on characters rather than plotting. So yes, that was Chorlop's autobiography.
The next thing that we will be doing for Non-Fiction November, again, the TBR has
completely gone to the dogs, but nonetheless we press on. I have what I showed you in my,
another of my book hauls last week. We have William Shearer's The Rise and Fall of the Third
Reich, which as you can see is a toe crusher in and of itself. I've read the introduction to this
and could barely prize my eyes away from its pages. And so I think I'm obviously going to
have to split this into at least two parts, probably three. So this may class as Joe Spivey's
first proper read-along. There is the much-awaited for Byron read-along, which I think I'll save for
the new year where we go through biography and works, but this is going to be absolutely, it's
going to be, yeah, almost insurmountable. I mean, look at the size of the bloody thing. But we've
talked about length on this channel and we're not going to do that anymore. So yeah, that's going to
be the next one that I read. Hopefully by the end of the week then that will be out, or at least the
first video will be out for this baying mob of fans that I have now on the internet. But yes,
that pretty much does me, Booktube. I'm sorry that it's so dark. It looks as if I'm doing this in
some sort of Iranian bunker. It is ridiculously, it is ridiculously dark, but try and being me.
I'm the actual person that exists here in the cold and the gloom. But yes, I'm going to go for my
afternoon walk. I'm going to take another sip of water and I'm going to say goodbye, Booktube.
