"Embark on an exploration of René Descartes, a seminal figure in the history of Western philosophy and mathematics, whose ideas marked a pivotal shift in the intellectual landscape of the modern world. Born in La Haye en Touraine, France, in 1596, Descartes is often called the ""Father of Modern Philosophy."" His philosophical method, characterized by skepticism and rationalism, laid the groundwork for 17th-century Continental rationalism and influenced subsequent philosophical thought.
Early Life and Education: Descartes was educated at the Jesuit College Royal Henry-Le-Grand at La Flèche, where he was introduced to classical literature, science, and mathematics, which would profoundly shape his future works. His education emphasized a comprehensive approach that sparked his curiosity about the natural world and the underpinnings of knowledge itself.
Philosophical Contributions: Descartes is best known for his philosophical statement, ""Cogito, ergo sum"" (""I think, therefore I am""), which appears in his Discourse on the Method (1637) and more elaborately in his Meditations on First Philosophy (1641). This proposition became a fundamental element of Western philosophy, as Descartes sought to establish a secure foundation for scientific knowledge. His approach involved methodical doubt, wherein he doubted any belief that could be doubted, to arrive at a set of indubitable truths anchored by the fact of his own existence as a thinking entity.
Mathematical Achievements: Descartes also made significant contributions to the field of mathematics, notably through his development of Cartesian coordinates, which bridged algebra and Euclidean geometry. This innovation allowed for the geometric representation of algebraic equations and the algebraic representation of geometry, fundamentally changing the landscape of mathematics and paving the way for the development of calculus and much of modern mathematics.
Scientific Methodology: Beyond philosophy and mathematics, Descartes' work in physics and physiology also introduced new concepts, such as the law of refraction and theories on reflex action. His scientific method, which emphasized deduction and analytical approaches, significantly influenced the scientific revolution, encouraging a break from Aristotelian science and the exploration of the empirical world through a mechanistic framework.
Legacy and Impact: Descartes' insistence on the use of reason as the best tool for obtaining knowledge has had a lasting impact on both philosophy and science. His thoughts on dualism, the separation of mind and body, initiated extensive philosophical debates about the nature of reality, consciousness, and the mind's interaction with the physical world. These discussions continue to resonate in contemporary philosophical debates about the mind, consciousness, artificial intelligence, and the nature of human understanding.
Conclusion: René Descartes' philosophy and mathematical innovations marked the rise of modern thinking about the self and the universe. His approach to systematic doubt and the emphasis on rationality have made him a central figure in the annals of philosophy, often serving as a starting point for students and scholars alike. Explore Descartes' works to understand how his questioning of traditional doctrines and his methodological skepticism laid the foundations for the Enlightenment and radically transformed the pursuit of knowledge in the modern era.Embark on an exploration of René Descartes, a seminal figure in the history of Western philosophy and mathematics, whose ideas marked a pivotal shift in the intellectual landscape of the modern world. Born in La Haye en Touraine, France, in 1596, Descartes is often called the ""Father of Modern Philosophy."" His philosophical method, characterized by skepticism and rationalism, laid the groundwork for 17th-century Continental rationalism and influenced subsequent philosophical thought.
Early Life and Education: Descartes was educated at the Jesuit College Royal Henry-Le-Grand at La Flèche, where he was introduced to classical literature, science, and mathematics, which would profoundly shape his future works. His education emphasized a comprehensive approach that sparked his curiosity about the natural world and the underpinnings of knowledge itself.
Philosophical Contributions: Descartes is best known for his philosophical statement, ""Cogito, ergo sum"" (""I think, therefore I am""), which appears in his Discourse on the Method (1637) and more elaborately in his Meditations on First Philosophy (1641). This proposition became a fundamental element of Western philosophy, as Descartes sought to establish a secure foundation for scientific knowledge. His approach involved methodical doubt, wherein he doubted any belief that could be doubted, to arrive at a set of indubitable truths anchored by the fact of his own existence as a thinking entity.
Mathematical Achievements: Descartes also made significant c
Hello and welcome back. Today we're going to be doing another reading from the work
Ancient and Modern Celebrated Freethinkers by Charles Bradlaugh under the pseudonym
Iconoclast published in 1877. Now the book and the author is known for some pretty hot takes
on some pretty controversial figures. Now a link to the work will be provided in the description
if you want to go and read it for yourself. And with that being said, let us begin with
today's biography and examination on René Descartes. René Descartes du Perron,
better known as Descartes, the father of modern philosophy, was born at La Haye in Touraine
of Breton parents near the close of the 16th century, at a time when bacon was like the
morning sun rising to shed new rays of bright light over the then dark world of philosophy.
The mother of Descartes died when he was but a few days old, and himself a sickly child,
he began to take part in the battle of life, but without little appearance of ever possessing the
capability for actions on the minds of his fellows, which he afterwards so fully exorcised.
Debarred, however, by his physical weakness from many boyish pursuits, he devoted himself
to study in his earliest years, and during his youth gained the title of the young philosopher,
from his eagerness to learn, and from his earnest endeavors by inquiry and experiment to solve
every problem presented to his notice. He was educated in the Jesuits' college of La Flèche,
and the monument erected to him at Stockholm informs us that having mastered all the learning
of the schools, which proved short of his expectations, he betook himself to the army
in Germany and Hungary, and there spent his vacant winter hours in comparing the mysteries
and phenomena of nature with the laws of mathematics, daring to hope that one might
serve as a key to the other. Quitting, therefore, all other pursuits, he retired to a little village
near Egmont in Holland, where spending twenty-five years in continual reading and meditation,
he effected his design. In his celebrated Discourse on Method, he says,
As soon as my age permitted me to leave my preceptors, I entirely gave up the study of
and resolving to seek no other science than that which I could find in myself,
or else in the great book of the world, I employed the remainder of my youth in travel,
in seeing courts and camps, in frequenting people of diverse humours and conditions,
in collecting various experiences, and, above all, in endeavouring to draw some
profitable reaction from what I saw. For it seemed to me that I should meet with more truth
in the reasonings with which each man takes himself in his own affairs, and which, if wrong,
would be speedily punished by failure, than in those reasonings which the philosopher makes
in his study upon speculations which produce no effect, and which are of no consequence to him,
except, perhaps, that he will be the more vain of them, the more remote they are from common sense,
because he would then have been forced to employ more ingenuity and subtlety to render them
plausible. At the age of thirty-three, Descartes retired from the world for a period of eight years,
and his seclusion was so effectual during that time that his place of residence was unknown to
his friends. He there prepared the meditations and discourse on method, which have since caused
so much pen-and-ink warfare amongst those who have aspired to be ranked as philosophical thinkers.
He became European in fame, and by invited by Christina of Sweden he visited her kingdom,
but the rudeness of the climate proved too much for his delicate frame, and he died at Stockholm
in the year 1650, from inflammation of the lungs, being fifty-four years of age at the time of his
death. Descartes was, perhaps, the most original thinker that France had up to that date produced,
and a contemporary with Bacon. He exercised powerful influence, or the progress of thought
in Europe, but although a great thinker, he was not a brave man, and the fear of giving
offence to the church and the government has certainly prevented him from making
public some of his writings, and perhaps has toned down some of these thoughts which,
when first uttered, took a higher flight, and struck full home to the truth itself.
The father and founder of the deductive method, Descartes still proudly reigns to the present day,
although some of his conclusions have been overturned, and others of his
thinking have been carried to conclusions which he never dared to dream of.
He gave a strong aid to the tendency of advancing civilization, to separate philosophy from theology,
thereby striking a blow, slow in its effect, and effectual in its destructive operation
on all priestcraft. In his Dedication of the Meditations, he says,
I have always thought that the two questions of the existence of God and the nature of the soul
were chief of those which ought to be demonstrated rather by philosophy than by theology,
for although it is sufficient for us, the faithful, to believe in God, and that the
soul does not perish with the body, it does not seem possible ever to persuade the infidels to
any religion, unless we first prove to them these two things are by natural reason.
Having relinquished faith, he found that he must choose an entirely new faith in which to march
with reason. The old ways were so cumbered with priests and bibles, that progression would have
been impossible. This gave us his method. He wanted a starting point from which to reason,
some indisputable fact upon which to found future thinkings. He gave us the detailed
history of his doubts. He has told us how he found that he could plausibly enough
doubt of everything except his own existence. He pushed his skepticism to the verge of self
annihilation. There he stopped. There in self, there in consciousness, he found at last an
irresistible fact, an irreversible certainty. Firm ground was discovered. He could not doubt
the existence of the external world and treat it as a phantasm. He could doubt the existence of God
and treat the belief as a superstition, but the existence of his own thinking,
doubting mind, no sort of doubt was possible. He, the doubter, existed if nothing else existed.
The existence that was revealed to him in his own consciousness was the primary fact,
the first indubitable certainty, his famous cogito ergo sum, I think, therefore I am.
Proceeding from this certainty of his existence, Descartes endeavours to
rind other equally certain tacts, and for that purpose presents the following doctrine and
rules for our guidance. The basis of all certitude is consciousness. Consciousness
is the sole foundation of absolute certainty, whatever it distinctly proclaims to be true.
The process is, therefore, rendered clear and simple. Examine your consciousness. Each distinct
reply will be a fact. He tells us further that all clear ideas are true, that whatever is clearly
and distinctly conceived is true, and that these lie in the vitality of his system,
the cause of the truth or error of his thinkings. The following are the rules he gave us for the
detection and separation of true ideas from false, i.e., imperfect or complex.
1. Never to accept anything as true, but what is evidently so, to admit nothing,
but what so clearly and distinctly presents itself as true, that there can be no reason to doubt it.
2. To divide every question into as many separate parts as possible,
that each part being more easily conceived, the whole may be more intelligible.
3. To conduct the examination with order, beginning by that of objects the most simple,
and therefore the easiest to be known, and ascending little by little up to knowledge
of the most complex. 4. To make exact such calculations,
and such circumspections, as to be confident that nothing essential has been omitted,
consciousness being the basis of all certitude. Everything of which you are clearly and
distinctly conscious must be true. Everything which you are clearly and distinctly conceive
exists, if the idea of it involves existence. In these four rules, we have the essential part
of one of Descartes' systems. The other, which is equally important,
is the attempt to solve metaphysical problems by mathematical aid. To mathematics,
he had devoted much of his time. He it was who, at the age of twenty-three, made the grand
discovery of the applicability of algebra to geometry. While deeply engaged in mathematical
studies and investigations, he came to the conclusion that mathematics were capable
of a still further simplification, and of a much extended application.
Impressed with the certainty of the conclusions arrived at by the aid of mathematical reasoning,
he began to apply mathematics to metaphysics. His ambition was to found a system which should be
solid and convincing. Having searched for certitude, he found its basis in consciousness.
He next wanted a method, and had hoped he had found it in mathematics. He tells us that
these long chains of reasoning, all simple and easy, by which geometers used to arrive at their
most difficult demonstrations, suggested to him that all things which came within human knowledge
must follow each other in a similar chain, and that provided we abstain from admitting
anything as true which is not so, and that we always preserve in them the order necessary
to deduce one from the other, there can be none so remote to which we cannot fully attain,
nor so obscure, but that we may discover them. Acting out this, he dealt with metaphysics as
we should with a problem from Euclid, and expected by rigorous reasoning to discover the truth.
He, like Archimedes, had wished for a standing place from which to use the lever,
that should overturn the world. But having a sure standing place in the indubitable fact of
his own existence, he did not possess significant courage to put forth the mighty power. It was left
for one who came after him to fairly attempt the overthrow of the world of error so long-existent.
Cartesianism was sufficiently obnoxious to the divines to provoke their wrath, and yet,
from some of its peculiarities, it has found many opponents among the philosophical party.
The Cartesian philosophy is founded on two great principles, the one metaphysical,
the other physical. The metaphysical is Descartes' foundation stone, the I think,
therefore I am. This has been warmly attacked as not being logical. Descartes said his existence
was a fact, a fact above and beyond all logic. Logic could neither prove nor disprove it.
The cogito ergo sum was not new itself, but it was the first stone of a new building,
the first step in a new road. From this fact, Descartes tried to reach another, and from that,
others. The physical principle is that nothing exists but substance, which he makes of two kinds,
the one substance that thinks, the other substance extended. Actual thought and
actual extension are the essence of a substance, so that the thinking substance cannot be without
some actual thought, nor can anything be retrenched from the extension of a thing
without taking away so much of its actual substance. In his physical speculations,
Descartes has allowed his imagination to run very wild. His famous theory of the vortices
is an example of this, assuming extension to be the essence of the substance. He denied the
possibility of a vacuum by that assumption, for if extension be the essence of substance,
whatever extension is there, substance must be. This substance, he assumes, to have originally
been divided into equal angular particles, each endowed with an equal degree of motion.
Several systems, or collections of these particles, he holds to have a motion about
certain points or centers, and that the particles moving round these composed so many vortices.
These angular particles, by their intense motions, he supposes to become, as it were,
ground into a spherical form. The parts rubbed off are called matter of the first element,
while the spherical globules he calls matter of the second element, and since there would be a
very large quantity of this element, he supposes it to be driven towards the center of each vortex
by the circular motion of the globules, and that there it forms a large spherical body,
such as the sun. This sun, thus being formed, and moving about its own axis with the common
matter of the vortex, would necessarily be thrown out some parts of its matter,
though the vacuities of the globules of the second element constituting the vortex,
and this especially at such places are furthest from its poles, receiving, at the same time,
in by these poles, as much as it loses in its equatorial parts, and by these means,
it would be able to carry around with it those globules that are nearest,
with a greater velocity, and the remoter, with less. And, further, these globules which are
nearest to the center of the sun must be smallest, because, were they greater, or equal,
they would, by reason of their velocity, have a greater centrifugal force, and recede from the
center. If it should happen that any of these sun-like bodies in the centers of the several
vortices should be so encrusted and weakened as to be carried about in the vortex of the true
sun, if it were of less solidity, or had less motion, than the globules towards the extremity
of the solar vortex, it would descend towards the sun, till it met with globules of the same
solidity, and, susceptible of the same degree of motion with itself, and thus being fixed there,
it would be forever after carried about by the motion of the vortex, without either approaching
any nearer to, or receding from the sun, and so become a planet. Supposing, then, all this,
we are next to imagine that our system was first divided into several vortices,
in the center of each of which was a lucid spherical body, and that, of some of these
being gradually encrusted, were swallowed up by the others, which were larger and more powerful,
till at last they were destroyed, and swallowed up by the biggest solar vortex,
except some few, which were thrown off in right lines from one vortex to another, and so became
comets. It should also be added, that in addition to the two elements mentioned above,
those particles, which may yet exist, and be only in the course of reduction to their globular
form, and yet still retain their angular proportions, form a third element.
This theory has found many opponents, but in the state of our work we conceive our duty to be
that of giving a simple narrative of the philosophers' ideas, rather than a history
of the various criticisms upon those ideas, the more especially as our pages scarcely afford room
for such a mode of treatment. Having formed this method, Descartes proceeded to apply it,
the basis of certitude being consciousness. He interrogated his consciousness, and found that
he had an idea of a substance infinite, eternal, immutable, independent, omniscient, omnipotent.
This he called an idea of God. He said, I exist as a miserably imperfect finite being,
subject to change, ignorant, incapable of creating anything. I find by my finite,
by my finitude rather, that I am not the infinite. By my ability to change, that I am not the
immutable. By my ignorance, that I am not the omniscient. In short, by my imperfection,
that I am not the perfect. Yet, an infinite, immutable, omniscient, and perfect being
must exist, because infinity, immutability, omniscience, and perfection are applied as
correlatives in my ideas of finitude, change, etc. God, therefore, exists. His existence is
clearly proclaimed in my own consciousness, and therefore ceases to be a matter of doubt
any more than the fact of my own existence. The conception of an infinite being proved
his real existence, for if there is not really such a being, I must have made the conception.
But if I could make it, I can also unmake it, which evidently is not true. Therefore,
there must be an externally to myself, an archetype from which the conception was derived.
All that we clearly and distinctly conceive as contained in anything is true of that thing.
Now, we conceive clearly and distinctly that the existence of God is contained in the idea we have
of him. Ergo, God exists. Lose history of philosophy. Descartes was of opinion that his
demonstrations of the existence of God equal or even surpass in certitude the demonstrations of
geometry. In this opinion, we must confess, we cannot share. He has already told us that the
is clearly and distinctly conceived must be true, that imperfect and complex conceptions are false
ones. The first proposition, all must admit, is applicable to themselves. I conceive a fact
clearly and distinctly, and despite all resistance am compelled to accept that fact.
And if the fact be accepted beyond doubt, no higher degree of certainty can be attained.
That two and two are four, that I exist, are facts which I will never doubt.
The cogito ergo sum is irresistible, because indubitable. But cogito ergo dius est
is a sentence requiring much consideration, and upon the face of it is no syllogism,
but on the contrary is illogical. If Descartes meant I am conscious, that I am not the whole
of existence, he would be indisputable. But if he meant that I can be conscious of an existence
entirely distinct apart from, and external to, that very consciousness, then his whole
reasoning from that point appears fallacious. We use the word I, as given by Descartes.
Mill, in his system of logic, says the ambiguity in this case is in the pronoun I,
by which in one place is to be understood my will, in another the laws of nature.
If the conception, existing as it does in my mind, had no original without,
the conclusion would unquestionably follow that I had made it, that is,
that the laws of my nature had spontaneously evolved it, but that my will made it would not
follow. Now, when Descartes afterwards adds that I cannot unmake the conception,
he means that I cannot get rid of it by an act of my will, which is true, but is not the
required proposition, that what some of the laws my nature have produced, other laws,
or those same laws in other circumstances, might not subsequently efface,
he would have found it difficult to establish. Treating the existence of God as demonstrated
from the priori idea of perfection and infinity, and by the clearness of his idea of God's
existence, Descartes then proceeds to deal with the distinction between body and soul.
To prove this distinction was to him an easy matter. The fundamental and essential attribute
of substance must be extension, because we cannot denude substance of every quality,
but that of extension, this we cannot touch without at the same time affecting the substance.
The fundamental attribute of mind is thought. It is in the act of thinking,
that the consciousness of existence is revealed. To be without thought,
would be without consciousness. Descartes has given us, among others, the axiom,
that two substances are really distinct when their ideas are complete, and no way imply each
other. The idea of extension is complete and distinct from the idea of thought, which latter
is also clear and distinct by itself. It follows, therefore, that substance and mind are distinct
in essence. Descartes, from the vagueness of some of his statements, subjected himself to the
changes of asserting that existence of innate ideas, and the following quotations will speak
for themselves on that subject. When I said that the idea of God is innate in us, I meant more than
this, that nature has endowed us with a faculty by which we may know God, but I have never either
said or thought that such ideas had an actual existence, or even that they were a species
distinct from the faculty of thinking, although the idea of God is so imprinted on our minds,
that every person was within him having the faculty of knowing him. It does not follow
that there may not have been various individuals who have passed through life without ever even
making this idea of a distinct object of apprehension, and in truth, they who think
that they have an idea of plurality of gods have no idea of God whatever.
This seems explicit as negativing the charge of holding doctrine of innate ideas,
but in the Edinburgh Review, several passages are given amongst, which is the following.
By the word idea, I understand that all can be in our thoughts,
and I distinguish three sorts of ideas, adventitious, like the common idea of the
sun framed by the mind, such as that which astronomical reasoning gives of the sun,
and innate, as the idea of God, mind, body, a triangle, and generally all those which represent
true, immutable, and eternal essences. In regard to those rather opposite statements,
Luce says, if Descartes, when pressed by objections, gave different explanations,
we must only set it down to want of a steady conception of the vital importance of innate
ideas to his system. The fact remains that innate ideas form the necessary groundwork
of the Cartesian doctrine. The radical error of all ontological speculation lies in the assumption
that we have ideas independent of experience, because experience can only tell us of ourselves,
or of phenomena, or, nomina, it can tell us nothing. The fundamental question, then,
of modern philosophy is this, have we any ideas independent of our experience?
Descartes' disciples are of two classes, the mathematical cultivators of physics,
and the deductive cultivators of philosophy. The first class of disciples are far in advance of
their chief, and can only be considered as having received an impulse in a true direction.
The second class unhesitatingly accepted his principles, and continued his thinking,
although they developed his system in a different matter, and arrived at a stronger conclusion
than Descartes' courage would have supported. Some of the physical speculations of Descartes
have been much ridiculed by subsequent writers, but many reasons may be urged,
not only against the ridicule, but also against the more moderate censure,
which several able critics have dealt out against his individual character.
It could be remembered that the theories of all of his predecessors were mere conjectural
speculations, respecting the places and paths of celestial bodies, etc.
Innumerable hypotheses have been formed and found useless, and we ought rather to look
what Descartes did accomplish under the many difficulties of his position,
in respect to, then, the state of scientific knowledge, than to judge harshly on those
speculations, which, though attended with no beneficial result to humanity at large,
were doubtless well intended by their author. He was the first man who brought optical science
under the command of mathematics, by the discovery of the law of refraction of the
ordinary rays through the diaphanous bodies, and probably there is scarcely a name on record the
bearer of which has given a greater impulse to mathematical and philosophical inquiry than
Descartes. Although, as a mathematician, he published but little, yet in every subject
which he treated, he has opened not only a new field for investigation,
but also a new road for the investigators to proceed by. His discovery of the simple
application of the notation of indices to algebraical powers has totally remodelled the
entire science of algebra. His conception of expressing the fundamental property of curve-lines
and curve-surfaces by equations between the coordinates has led to an almost total
supersedence of geometry of the ancients. Contemporary with Galileo, and with the
knowledge of the persecution to which that father of physics was being subjected by the Church,
we are tempted to express our surprise that Descartes did not extend the right hand of fellowship,
help, and sympathy to his brother-philosopher. But it is nevertheless the fact that, either jealous
of the fame of Galileo, as some have alleged, or from a fear of being involved in the same
persecutions, Descartes abstained from visiting the astronomer, although travelling for some time
near his place of abode in Italy. Lewis, in his Life of Descartes, says,
Descartes was a great thinker, but having said this, we have almost exhausted the praise we
can bestow on him as a man. In disposition he was timid to servility, while promulgating the
proofs of the existence of the Deity. He was an evident alarm, lest the Church should
see something objectionable in them. He had also written astronomical treatise,
but hearing of the fate of Galileo he refrained from publishing, and always used some chicanery
in speaking of the world's movement. He was not a brave man. He was also not an affectionate one.
There was in him a deficiency of all finer feelings, but he was even tempered and studious
of not giving offence. We are tempted, after a careful perusal of the life and writings of
Descartes and his contemporaries, to be of an opinion that he was a man who wished to be
considered the chief thinker of his day, and who shunned and rejected the office of friendship
from other philosophers, lest they, by being associated with him, should jointly wear laurels,
which he was cultivating solely to form a crown for himself. Despite all, his brow still bears
a crown, and his fame is a freshness, that we might all be justly proud of if appertaining
to ourselves. We trust that in these few pages we have succeeded in presenting Descartes to
such of our readers who were unacquainted with his writings sufficiently well enough for them
to appreciate him, and to induce them to search further, and at the same time we hope that those
better acquainted with him will not blame as for the omission of much which they may consider more
important than the matter of which appears in this little tract. We have endeavoured to picture
Descartes as the founder of the deductive method, as having the foundation stone of
all his reasoning in his consciousness, and with all that said we reach the end of
Iconoclast's writings on Descartes. Interesting, aren't they? Perhaps not what you expect,
he always goes in really harsh on them, but I like it. But before we go,
I think that we ought to mention that all of these ideas of Descartes didn't exist in a vacuum.
In fact, several of his contemporaries raised significant objections to his philosophy,
challenging him, and in turn enriching and adding to the discourse of the time.
So I'm going to highlight three of the main detractors, that being Pierre Gassendi,
Thomas Hobbes, and Princess Elizabeth of Bohemia. Let's start with Gassendi,
he was a French philosopher, priest, and scientist who was a staunch advocate of empiricism,
which is the belief that all knowledge comes from sensory experience, which put him at odds
with Descartes, who was a rationalist believing in innate ideas and deductive reasoning.
Gassendi argued that the mind is like a blank slate, and that we acquire knowledge through
our interactions with the world around us, not from any pre-existing ideas within us.
He also took issue with Descartes' strict separation of mind and body, what we call
mind-body dualism. Gassendi felt that this division made it difficult to explain
how the mind and body could interact if they were completely different substances.
He advocated for a more integrated understanding of human nature,
one that didn't split our physical and mental experiences into entirely separate realms.
Now, moving on, we have Thomas Hobbes, an English philosopher best known for his work on
political philosophy. You might have heard of his book Leviathan, Magnum Opus. You should read it.
Well, Hobbes was a materialist, meaning that he believed that everything exists in material,
including thoughts and consciousness. This directly contradicted Descartes'
idea of an immaterial mind interacting with a material body.
Hobbes was skeptical of Descartes' famous declaration, I think, therefore I am.
He questioned whether truly thinking proved the existence of a separate immaterial self.
Hobbes also criticized Descartes' method of radical doubt. He felt doubting everything
could lead to an endless spiral of skepticism, but wouldn't necessarily bring us any closer to
the truth at all. And lastly, let's talk briefly about Princess Elizabeth of Bohemia. Now, she
might not be as widely known, but her correspondence with Descartes reveals some of the most pressing
charges against his philosophy. Elizabeth was highly intelligent, you see, and thus deeply
engaged with philosophical questions. She questioned how the immaterial mind could
influence the material body if they were entirely separate substances. Once again, that mind-body
interaction problem. She also pressed Descartes for a clearer explanation of how this interaction
worked. If the mind-body is so different, by what mechanism does the mind cause physical actions
in the body? Of course, these questions highlights a significant gap in the dualism of Descartes,
and pushed him to try to address the issue more thoroughly. Once again, questions always add
to the discourse. But why were these critiques so significant? Well, they didn't just challenge
Descartes, but they propelled philosophy forward. Gassendi's emphasis on empiricism
influenced the development of scientific methods that rely on observation and experience,
and Hobbes' materialism contributed to the ongoing debates about the nature of consciousness
and the relationship between the mind and body. As for Elizabeth, well, her probing questions
anticipated later philosophical and scientific inquiries into how mental and physical states
interact, a question that remains central in fields like psychology and neuroscience.
And with that all being said, I think that's enough for today on Descartes. I hope you
enjoyed it. I hope you enjoyed Iconoclast's thoughts about him. Interesting fellow.
I'm going to thank my top-tier patrons and supporters on YouTube, Memberships, and Patreon.
Ben, Britt, Charles, Aaron, James, Jeffrey, Melissa, Scott, Stark Factory, Wendy, Jayden,
Sherry, Jessica, Christine, Sally, Katiana, Christine, Fezaba, Legitmus, Maverick, Susan,
and Dr. Neuro Nerd. Don't think I'll get tired of saying that one.
Thank you very much for joining me. You know, I always appreciate it. And if you want to keep
learning stuff, well, you better come back tomorrow. Who knows what I'm going to be talking
about. We'll figure something out. But you know, I'm here pretty much every day, at least for the
time being. Good night, everyone. Lots of love to you all.