Warhammer vs Mace!!!

Rune Slicer
2 followers
1 Video ViewยทNov 28, 2024
It's Warhammer versus Mace. Yeah, so some people have asked me to make a comparison of Warhammers,
which is one of these, usually with a hammery side and a spiky side, and Maces. Here's an
example, this is a so-called flanged Mace because it's got flanges on it, okay. These occupy a
similar place in medieval and renaissance warfare, that is they are both primarily used by
people in armour against armour. They are fundamentally anti-armour weapons and they
are also both, as you can see from their length, they're quite short. They are predominantly
used by horsemen, which of course, fully armoured guys that we would sometimes call knights,
sometimes called knights, would generally be wearing full armour and they would spend most
of their time fighting as cavalry, unless they were English, because the English liked to fight
on foot a lot and tend to use longer weapons than this, therefore. But these short weapons are
really specialised as horsemen's weapons and are, as aforementioned, anti-armour weapons. So what's
the difference between a Warhammer and a Mace? Why might you choose one rather than the other? Well,
this is a bit of a mystery. I should say straight up that the actual combat manuals or treatises
dealing with these kind of medieval weapons and renaissance weapons don't actually talk about
these weapons very much. There is a slight, they're shown here and there in some treatises,
for example, you can see a certain type of Eastern European Warhammer appears in Tauhoffer,
the 1459 version, I believe, maybe the 67 as well, and also there's a mention of them, I believe,
in Pietro Monte, which is from 1498 originally, but published later or printed later.
And equally you see Maces here and there, but there are no real, really detailed, descriptive
accounts of how to use these things, as far as I know, correct me if I'm wrong, in any medieval or
renaissance treatises. However, we do have enough clues to know roughly how these things were used
and they were used more or less like a one-handed sword or perhaps a Messer was at the time,
obviously with changes to account for their different form. They have no handguard,
but you'd be wearing gauntlets, but they have no handguards to assist with binds, for example.
They're fairly short, they're shorter than a sword, than a one-handed sword usually is,
they're even shorter than a Messer usually is, and obviously with a Warhammer you have a spike
on one side, which is for a certain type of piercing attack, but equally you can use it for
hooking. But the thing to remember with the point is that points can get stuck in things, so whilst
the point might be very good at penetrating through mail, for example, or even potentially
through the thinner plates of some pieces of armour or jamming into the joints of armour,
it might get stuck. So your hammer face, for most of the time, unless you can see a particular
opening to jam that point into, the hammer face is probably what you're going to use predominantly
for smashing the opponent in the head and the knees and other places that are going to maybe
impede his ability to fight, and then when you see an opening you might spin around to the point
side and jam the point in somewhere. But you won't want to be sticking the point into things all the
time. The mace, no options. An interesting thing about the mace is if you look at the Warhammer,
you've got two directions on it, so in that sense it's a bit like a sword in the sense that the
sword has two edges and this essentially has two main striking faces. Yes, you might be able to hit
with the end, you can hit with the flat, in fact some Warhammers have little spikes on the side
here where the rivet goes through, so you could hit with the flat, but generally speaking they're
designed like an axe or a halberd or a sword indeed to hit either forwards or backwards
either way round. Whereas a mace, a bit different to that, it can hit in any plane. So a mace can
hit obviously with a backhanded strike, a forward strike, it can hit with the flat, you can sort of
wrap around, do this kind of strike that you sometimes see in stick fighting or cane fighting
or even in SCA fighting with rattan sticks where you can actually wrap the thing around because
you don't have to worry about which bit, as long as you hit with the head you don't have to worry
about the plane that you're hitting with. So in that sense I suppose looking at the pros and cons
of Warhammer versus mace, which is what people want to hear about, the mace I suppose you can
be more indiscriminate with it. In terms of weight and length and balance they're the same,
they fulfil the same basic purpose, they're basically anti-armour weapons, they're quite
heavy for their size but they're quite short. So the mace you can be more indiscriminate with
and hit any old direction you like and you're going to have impact, however it's not going to
really. These little spikes, they might pierce very slightly into mail but really what those
spikes are there for is not to pierce in the way that the Warhammer spike is there to pierce,
so this will actually work like a dagger essentially to penetrate things with the Warhammer
but with the mace the flanges are not really going to chop, they're not going to pierce,
those points are really there to bind into the thing you're hitting, to concentrate more of the
energy of the blow into the thing you're hitting. Obviously plate armour is designed to be
deflective, so the reason why you have a mace with pointy bits on here or some that you will see
that are like a ball with spikes sticking out, sometimes called a Morningstar, that type is
really to bind onto the thing you're hitting at the moment of impact to transfer more energy to
the target instead of glancing off and then a lot of energy is lost. And that's exactly the
same reason that with the Warhammer you'll notice it's not a totally smooth or rounded or flat face
but you have a little spike in there, that spike is not really there to penetrate as such but more
to bite, so when you hit it's not just going to skim off the helmet it will actually bite slightly
into the helmet and transfer all of the energy through into the target underneath the armour.
So there we go, there's a few things about mace versus Warhammer, they're essentially similar
kinds of weapons but they have different, very slightly different, strengths or different
advantages to each other. Which is my personal favourite? I prefer the Warhammer, I just prefer
the look of it and I like the fact that you've got a choice of being able to
do two different types of things with the head end, whereas with the mace you just kind of hit
with it. Lastly I should say, I'll just put the mace down for a second, I should say that
I've concentrated purely on the hitting end of the weapon here, but just like with any other
weapon, but particularly with medieval weapons, the whole thing is a weapon, so in close combat
I can defend with this part, sometimes I can even defend with the bottom part, I can defend with
the top here, I can hook with this part, I can hook with this part, if I have a spike on the end
I can jam in there, I can hit with the pommel, I can defend with it as a short staff, I can jam it
into someone's elbow joint in here and assist to do locks and binds on their arm, if we come
into wrestling, bam, and we're in armour and we've come in, we've grappled, if I can get this around
the back of their neck, bam, in there, dunk, I can scissor their neck, use this as a
as a wrestling and locking device as well, so there are all sorts of ways you can use this,
not simply like in a computer game, hit hit hit, but you can use it as a fully dynamic
object, any end of it, any part of it can be used in many different ways. Good, thank you.
