Early Christian Schisms - The Woes of Constantine - Extra History - Part 2

History for kids
11 followers
Comments are disabled for this video.
Last time we talked about a few of the doctrinal disputes that tore the early
church apart, even while they were being persecuted from the outside by the
emperors in Rome. Disputes that to them seemed so important that they were often
a bigger concern than getting thrown to the lions for their faith. Disputes that
have been passed down to us for 2,000 years because they were so important to
the early church that they made their way into the Bible. But the outside
pressures on Christianity are about to end. Constantine is busy repealing the
laws against Christians, and in 313, with the Edict of Milan, he restores
essentially full rights to Christians within his empire. But this itself brings
up another tricky problem.
What do you do with those who had buckled under the pressure of the
persecution? Those who had recanted or turned their back on the faith when
threatened with imprisonment or death? What do you do with the fact that so
many of those who had been asked to turn over the scriptures or to sacrifice to
pagan gods were not merely converts to the religion, but even priests? Can you
let them take an equal footing with those who had stood firm? Can you let
those who had wavered in their faith administer the faith? And again, this
question split the church. In North Africa, a bishop named Caecilian was
elected the Bishop of Carthage, but he was a treditor, or one of those who had
handed over Christian scriptures when threatened with persecution, and so his
election was contested. In general, most of the Christian population was alright
with accepting back into the fold those who had lapsed during a time of greatest
trial, but especially in North Africa, there was a group that was far less
forgiving. They viewed any sacraments given by such a bishop invalid, and so
soon elected their own bishop, Donatus, and refused to acknowledge the authority
of Caecilian, the bishop recognized by the church in Rome. As letters flew back
and forth and sermons were given,
Donatus decided to do an end run around those who were trying to unseat him, and
This was basically unheard of. The church settled church matters, the emperor
settled matters of state, but here it was, and Constantine agreed to step in. Now
this sets a precedent for hundreds of years of emperors, if not directly
commending the church, at least having a great deal of sway over church matters.
It effectively broke down the barrier between church and state, but at that
time no one knew that, and that's certainly not what Donatus was thinking
about. He was probably just trying to figure out how to get a fair shake when
right then the only people who were allowed to judge his case were the very
people he had essentially rebelled against, and the emperor was willing to
grant him that. Constantine designated that a hearing be set with the Bishop of
Rome and three other bishops from Gaul that he would pick personally to make
sure that they had no stake in the matter.
Then he went off to do other imperial things, but when the Donatus' case came up,
the Bishop of Rome had ninja'd in an additional 15 bishops that just so
happened to agree with him. So, as you can probably guess, the trial didn't go so
well for Donatus and his Donatists. In fact it went so poorly that not only was
their case thrown out, but their supporters were branded as heretical. So
of course Donatus was pretty miffed, and wrote the emperor again, saying, hey look
there were about a dozen and a quarter more guys in that committee than you
appointed. Can we like get another fairer hearing maybe? So Constantine, interested
in bringing the church back together, said yeah sure, and this time I'm just
going to call a bunch of bishops from all over and have them hear you out so
that way it can't be unfair. And so that's what he did. The Donatists again
made their case, and again their case was rejected. This time too their views were
branded as heretical. Largely, as I understand it, because it calls into
question the sacrament of penance if there's something, even something as
momentous as turning your back on the religion, that you can't atone for. So the
Donatists went back to Africa and sent Constantine a third letter, but by this
point he had just about had it. He was actually hanging out at the trial this
time and he felt like they'd gotten a fair shake.
What do you guys want? Meanwhile, conflicts between the two viewpoints had
begun to escalate to violence in North Africa, and that was it.
Constantine basically said, don't make me come down there, and threatened to crush
them all under his sandal. But then he got distracted by an itty-bitty civil
war and had no time for this ridiculousness. So the Donatists
essentially became a major splinter church in North Africa that would be a
thorn in the side of the Empire for years to come. And in the countryside it
would survive right through Justinian's reconquest of North Africa, centuries
later. In fact, the Donatists would later harbor anti-Roman rebels, and some
scholars have even argued that the disunity they caused weakened the
province, and essentially made it indefensible during the Arab conquests.
So there's one crack in the unity of the Empire and the church that doesn't ever
go away. Now it's time to talk about the next, even bigger one.
Arianism. Because just as the Donatist question was flaring up in Carthage,
another schism was beginning to spin out of control in Alexandria, where a bishop
named Arius was preaching a brand new understanding of the Trinity. Which means
I'm going to now try and define the Trinity on the internet.
Okay, so it's time for disclaimer two. We are not theologians. What I'm offering
here on any of this is meant as a serviceable understanding for people
interested in exploring the history that's so intimately wrapped up in these
things. But there is a lot more depth that could be gone into here, and the
exact definition, well, that could be debated for 2,000 years. And it has. So
that said, what is the idea of the Trinity? It's the concept that God is the
Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost all rolled into one.
Okay, so what does that mean? Well, in the loosest form, it's the idea that God the
Father is in heaven, God the Spirit acts upon the world, and God the Son is the
Christ who came down in human form to wash away humanity's sins. Now that part
seems simple enough, but there's one more part to it. The part that everybody
fought about. In Trinitarian belief, God is the Father, the Son, and the Holy
Spirit, but the Father is not the Son, nor the Holy Spirit. The Son is not the
Father, nor the Holy Spirit, and the Holy Spirit is neither the Father nor the Son.
Confused yet? That's okay, it's one of the most difficult concepts in the entire
Christian faith, and it's something that has caused more debate and infighting
than almost anything else. But hopefully that brings everybody up to speed enough
so that we can talk about this radical new idea that Arius was preaching. What
was it? Well, he was preaching that because God the Father begat God the Son
while they were both still divine, God the Son was less than God the Father.
They weren't co-equal and co-substantial in the way that the Trinitarian
formation laid out. Now, this may not seem like a big deal to you, and fair enough.
Truth is, the local bishop in Alexandria seemed to see it the same way. At first,
he didn't do anything about this fractious doctrine, but soon it became
clear that this wasn't just going away. The congregation was divided. Arguments
were breaking out in meetings of the faithful. It was time to step in. The
bishop in Alexandria called a synod, and they decided that this Arian doctrine
was heresy. Arius was stripped of his priesthood, and he and his followers were
excommunicated from the church. But it was too little too late. This idea had
already spread throughout the Eastern Empire. This became a grueling feud that
threatened to tear the church in two. Now, Constantine was trying, for a number of
reasons, to basically hand these Christians the keys to being the number
one religion in the number one empire in the known world, and here they were,
squabbling worse than pagan cults. Constantine was irked by this. So, he sent
down a cleric that he trusted to settle the matter, and armed him with a letter
that ends thusly,
Basically, he was saying,
guys, for serious, just stop fighting, let me get back to emperor stuff, please.
But it just so happened that the cleric he sent down was a strident Trinitarian.
So, instead of finding a resolution and bringing everybody back together like
Constantine had asked, the cleric decided that smashing the Arians in the face was
a better idea, and he succeeded in basically causing a bunch of riots and
not much else. So, the cleric called a council to settle the matter once and
One where, at least theoretically, the Arians would be heard out. But the
emperor, probably with an exasperated sigh, wrote to him, knowing full well that
this council organized of the local clergy and the clearly biased cleric
that he had just sent down, was just another excuse to beat on the Arians, and
suggested that they make it a truly universal council, inviting
representatives from every district in the empire to come together and finally
hammer out, once and for all, these squabbles that they'd been having, so
that he could get back to emperoring and spend some time founding a new capital
in his own name. So, join us next time as we dive into the council of Nicaea,
perhaps the most famous church council of all time. Will they solve the problems
of the Christian church? Will they end the schisms once and for all? Find out
next time, or just take a wild guess. You'll probably be right.
