The WORST Contract In Baseball Nobody Is Talking About
iTalk Studios
908 followers
The WORST Contract In Baseball Nobody Is Talking About
#mlb #baseball #sports
LG Store Link - https://bit.ly/iTalkStudios_LG
Amazon Store Link - https://bit.ly/iTalkStudios_FireTV
iTALK STUDIOS INSTAGRAM: https://instagram.com/italk.studios?utm_medium=copy_link
iTALK STUDIOS TWITTER/X: https://twitter.com/italkstudiosyt?s=21
iTALK STUDIOS SECOND CHANNEL: @iTalkStudiosExtra
VIDEO MUSIC CREDIT TO @mikhelvin AND @samuelkimmusic
Mik
► Spotify: https://spoti.fi/3jaB7yS
► Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/mikhelvin
Samuel Kim
► Spotify: https://spoti.fi/2vYKPBd
► YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/c/samuelkimmusic
► Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/samuelkimmusic
I hadn't talked about the Cubs for a long time on this channel, it seems, and now all of a sudden
I'm making my second video in a row about them, so welcome to Cub Talk Studios, I guess.
So Cody Bellinger's contract isn't very ideal for all the reasons I talked about in the last video,
but it could be a lot worse considering it's only a three-year contract. They want to get
rid of it desperately. But worst case scenario, they suck it up for two more years and just
But there's another deal on the books for the Cubs that I never looked at as a great
signing to begin with, but I didn't realize just how truly bad it looks right now,
and that's the Dansby Swanson contract, their shortstop. From the moment they signed him away
from Atlanta, my feeling was just, eh, it's nothing crazy. Sure, it's a good solid baseball
player to add to your team, but probably an overpay. And two years into this contract,
I'm gonna go as far as to say it's an extreme overpay and a really unnecessary move for the
Cubs to make. This is nothing against Dansby Swanson personally, there's nothing bad about
the guy, he seems to be a really good person, I love how he and his wife are both talented athletes,
his wife Mallory Swanson is a soccer player who won a gold medal in this year's Olympics,
that's cool, I love that. That is the definition of a power couple, although unfortunately their
kid now has the inevitable expectation for me to be a two-sport athlete, like Shohei Otani,
but baseball and soccer. No pressure at all, just, you know, I expect nothing less now.
Swanson plays hard, and one thing that's consistent about him is how reliable he is to play.
He's never been very injury prone, and that's valuable on its own. But when you look at the
contract he's on, it's really not ideal. Dansby Swanson was a perfect fit in Atlanta,
with a big reason being the money he was making. Any team would be perfectly fine with paying
Swanson $10 million, which is the most the Braves ever paid him in a single season,
his last before signing with the Cubs. Now it's easy, obviously, to look in hindsight with
decisions that are made. It's not really fair to do that though, because sometimes good decisions
are made, they just don't work out, and it's not fair to blame the person who made the decision
after the outcome. But in the case of Dansby Swanson and the Cubs, I don't think it was ever
a good idea to sign him. It's similar to the Tigers signing Javi Baez, which is a far worse
contract and situation, but Swanson's is bad in a similar way in a sense that the contract was
never a great idea to begin with, and it's only proven to be that way. The contract he got is
obviously important, because again, if Swanson gets paid say $10 million a year, and he's not
nearly the highest paid player on the team, and you have money going to other guys who are more
impactful, this isn't as big of a deal. But Swanson's contract is for over $25 million a year
over 7 years, and he's the highest paid Cub. That's a good chunk of money and a long commitment.
Forget the time he's since played in Chicago. Was what Swanson did in the 6 years he played in
Atlanta worth giving him that contract? No. If you're going to give anybody that much money
over that many years, you gotta expect them to hit pretty damn well. Maybe not MVP level,
but all-star level for sure. Maybe top 10 in MVP votes. Something along those lines.
There's just one slight issue. Dansby Swanson was never a very good hitter. He wasn't awful,
and he did improve in his later years with the Braves, but he was never that
valuable offensively. He was always strictly a defensive shortstop, which is important and
fine to have if you don't have him on a big contract and when you have a ton of heavy
hitters around him like the Braves did for years. From 2018 and on, Swanson's defensive
range at shortstop, a premium position, has been elite. It's a big thing that plays into
his value as it should be. So let's look at what the Cubs were looking at before they signed him.
Hitting-wise, from Swanson's rookie season through 2022, his last year with the Braves,
all of his offensive numbers were not very good. They weren't awful, they weren't unplayable,
but he was just simply below average. The league average OPS plus is 100, and his career OPS plus
at this point was 94. Simply a below average bat with great defense at shortstop. Solid players
are hard to come by with any position. Any team would happily take that. But would any team
happily take that for $177 million over 7 years? Absolutely not. And 2 years into his Cubs contract,
we see why. He did have an above average season offensively in his first year with the Cubs,
nothing crazy, but solid, especially when you put it with his great defense. But again,
overall as a player, when you factor in his underwhelming bat, he's nothing that special,
so it's already not a great deal, and then he has a 2024 season even worse.
In a year where offense was down throughout the entire league, Swanson was even worse than the
league average. Does he play great defense? Yes, and his defense really is that great,
I mean just look at these plays. He's incredibly fun to watch go to work out there, but there are
plenty cheaper, less long commitment alternatives to Dansby Swanson to do exactly what Dansby
Swanson does if not better. And forget the money for a second. When Swanson was doing this in
Atlanta, it worked because again, there was a really, really strong offense around him. He
never had to be even close to the best hitter in that lineup, and that's another issue in Chicago.
The way Swanson is doesn't work as well when you're counting on him to be one of if not the
best hitter in the lineup. The Cubs offense doesn't suck, but it's nothing special either,
and to have Swanson, a player who isn't anything that special, especially offensively as your
highest paid player on a team full of players who aren't anything that special, isn't a very
good situation to be in. And they have him on the books for 5 more years, so it's not like this
thing is any close to being over. Is this Javier Baez or Anthony Rendon levels of bad? No, of
course not. But the Cubs cannot be comfortable paying a guy an average of over $25 million a
year to be a league average hitter at his best for the most part. Look at Swanson's old teammate,
who also left the Braves in Freddie Freeman. He's on a 6 year $162 million contract with the
Dodgers. He's making slightly more annually, but less overall, and none of that seems right.
You could argue Freeman is underpaid per year, if anything. He is 5 years older than Swanson,
so that does play a factor, but Freeman is a Hall of Fame hitter who's only gotten better with age.
Swanson isn't even close to that, yet the Cubs are committed to him for more years and money.
We know the kind of player Swanson is at this point. It's not like he's about to hit his prime.
He's basically in his prime or about to leave it. He's probably not going to come out of nowhere
and be an MVP candidate. He's going to likely continue being a defensively great but average,
maybe even below average bat. I'd say a good example of what Dansby Swanson should be,
or at least closer to what he should be considering the money he makes and the contract,
is Carlos Correa. Correa couldn't stay healthy last year, that's his problem and I hope he's
healthy next year because he's fun as hell to watch, but going off what he did when he was
healthy, great offense and defense. That's what he did, and those numbers are worth what he's
making, which is somewhat similar to Swanson. Correa's making more money over less years,
but with the contract Swanson's on, I'd say Swanson doesn't have to have necessarily as
strong of a bat as Correa's, but maybe a tier below. But in reality, he's like 2 or 3 tiers
below. Defense is great, and you'll get money providing great defense, but hitting is what
gets you the big big bucks, and it really does look like the Cubs made a big mistake committing
big big bucks in many many years to a defensive first player like Dansby Swanson who's never
been anything but that. And unless something unrealistically drastic happens, it's going
to continue to be the case. Let me know your thoughts and thank you for watching.
