The Politics of Pointillism - Paul Signac's In the Time of Harmony

Art Galleries Worldwide
11 followers
In 1895, Polsinyak made this painting, In the Time of Harmony. The Golden Age is not in the past,
it is in the future. This painting, however harmless and peaceful it may look,
is a powerful work of propaganda. Indeed, this painting had to be censored by Sinyak himself.
It was originally titled In the Time of Anarchy. Why did Sinyak change his artwork's title?
To answer this question, we must first look at the painting itself. If it makes you think of
a Sunday afternoon on the island of La Grande Jatte, then you'll understand that both Seurat
and Sinyak worked in close proximity. They both developed the technique now known as pointillism.
More on that later. In the Time of Harmony shows us a peaceful landscape where people read,
paint, feed their children, play sports, where people love. In the background,
you see people dancing next to a tractor. If our analysis of this painting was limited to
its second title, In the Time of Harmony, then we'd have to agree that this landscape represents
harmony. A time when people will be free, live without conflict, and just be happy.
But this would be a pretty superficial analysis of the scene. A safe analysis as it doesn't imply
any political engagement, just the fact that harmony and peace is good. Of course,
Sinyak is representing freedom, happiness, and harmony, and he is saying that these are good,
but to what ends? Why does he do it? If we all agree that we should strive towards a time of
harmony, what's the point of advocating for it? Well, this is where the original title of the
painting is deeply relevant. This isn't only in the time of harmony, but in the time of anarchy.
Before going any further, before analyzing this painting through the lens of anarchism
as Sinyak originally intended it to be, let's first talk about anarchism. If your conception
of what anarchy is boils down to chaos, destruction, and lawlessness, then you might be confused that
this is Sinyak's anarchy. These two conceptions are quite radically opposite and both can't be
true at the same time. But to put simply, no, anarchists don't fight for chaos, they fight for
harmony, as Sinyak brilliantly illustrated. In a nutshell, anarchism fights for harmony by
eliminating any forms of illegitimate authority, among which are racial, sexual, economical, and
political hierarchies. The idea is that these hierarchies don't prevent chaos, but maintain it.
Order, as defended by systems of power, doesn't stand against chaos, but perpetuates it by holding
on to hierarchy. When some people hold significantly more power than others, then this inevitably
creates conflict and tension, in a word, chaos. Anarchism fights for collaboration over competition,
for solidarity over independency. It both puts an extreme importance on collectivities, but also
on individuals, as both aren't opposites. As anarchist thinker Errico Malatesta put it,
The idea is that every individual can only prosper through an engaging and prosperous community,
and that the emancipation of people will come with the emancipation of the group.
And this concept is intimately linked with the very way Seurat and Sinyak painted. Pointillism
can be seen as an anarchistic mode of expression. Like many other neo-impressionists, both Seurat
and Sinyak were anarchists. They both believed in the abolition of capitalism and in the abolition
of the state. They both believed that individuals could only be free through collective emancipation
and that the collectivity could only be free through individual emancipation. And what is
pointillism if not that? The emancipation of the individual dot through hundreds if not thousands
of other dots. It's the reassertion of the dot of the individual, but while keeping in mind that,
without the other dots, a single dot isn't much. The collective, the canvas, can only thrive through
every single dot and their individual colors, and the dot can only be more than just a dot
through the collective. Now let's go back to in the time of anarchy. This peaceful landscape is
actually filled with anarchist symbols. The man picking fruit from a tree not only symbolizes
prosperity, but also that the tree doesn't belong to anyone. Nobody will stop him under the pretense
that this tree is theirs. The abolition of private property is essential to the time of anarchy,
as private property itself creates chaos. If you want to learn more about that,
check out my video on Basquiat's Defacement. Under the man picking fruit is a man reading,
perhaps symbolizing freedom of thought and ideas, but also the idea that, without the constant and
exhausting necessity to work for a capitalist, people might have more time and more energy
to educate themselves. The arts are represented in the background as, again, people might have
more time to dedicate themselves in artistic development in the time of anarchy. The couple,
central to the painting, not only represents free love, but also the appreciation of beauty as they
both admire a flower. As Signac said, when the society that we dream of exists, when rid of the
exploiters who exhaust him, the workers will have time to think and to learn. He will appreciate
all the qualities of a work of art. Finally, the last element of this painting I want to focus on
is the people dancing next to a tractor. The idea here is pretty simple, but extremely important.
As technology renders us more productive, we should be able to work less. If a tractor,
for example, allows me to do in 4 hours what used to take me 8 hours to do, then I could limit my
workday to 4 hours. However, if profit for the upper class is the only way to measure growth
in any given society, then working for this upper class is the only priority. Not the arts,
not education, not community, not love. In the Time of Anarchy gets rid of the upper class to
give the workers time to think, to learn, and to appreciate the qualities of a work of art.
The title In the Time of Anarchy reveals an infinitely more complex and fascinating purpose
to this painting. Everything about this work becomes so much more powerful when knowing the
If In the Time of Harmony is an empty ode to peace, In the Time of Anarchy is a sharp
criticism of the systems of domination preventing harmony and prosperity.
So why did Poissignac change the title of the painting? Why did he sacrifice the political
incisiveness of his first title? The rooster at the bottom right of the painting might be able
to answer that question. Élisée Reclus, another anarchist thinker, wrote of the rooster as a bird
that will fight until it wins or dies. Signac painted the rooster during the Trial of the 30.
But before talking about the 1894 Trial of the 30, I want to go a couple of years back,
all the way to 1871 where a two-month revolution took place in Paris. The socialist experiment was
Many anarchists were part of this revolutionary project, including, notably, Louise Michel,
and a genuine sense of revolutionary hope was created. Capitalism was undermined,
democracy was promoted and upheld, bourgeois rule was fading. But the French government had to put
an end to it. The government didn't want to lose Paris and it certainly didn't want socialists
worldwide to have hope. It didn't want Paris to become an example of a post-capitalist society
the same way it had once become a post-marxist example to Europe. So the government had to crush
the Commune, which it did. La Semaine Sanglante, or the Bloody Week, was a complete massacre.
It was estimated that around 20,000 Communards were executed in a week, not killed during battle,
but executed by firing squad. That's almost 3,000 socialists and anarchists killed per day
in the streets of Paris. This made clear to anarchists worldwide that a revolution was
possible but that any attempt at it will be brutally and violently crushed by the bourgeoisie.
It was made clear to anarchists by the Semaine Sanglante that a peaceful revolution would not
be possible and that the bourgeois would never relinquish their power without a fight. The
powerful would rather murder thousands of people than give up their power. So it's around that time
that propaganda of the deed started being adopted by anarchists. The idea was to very often inspire
revolutions through violent revolutionary action. Many bombs were thrown at bourgeois institutions,
symbols of the bourgeoisie were taken down, many regicides, tyrannicides, and assassinations were
done against the ruling class. Why? Because, as exemplified in the past, these people would murder
anarchists if any of them even thought of threatening their power. By killing them,
revolutions could be sparked and the future of these revolutions would be more secure.
American President William McKinley was assassinated in 1901 and French President
Sadiq Arnaud was assassinated in 1894, both murdered by anarchists. The same year, in 1894,
the Trial of the Thirty tried thirty anarchists for being, well, anarchists. This was done under
les lois scélérates or the Wicked Laws which notably prohibited anyone from doing any anarchist
propaganda. These laws were adopted by the French government in response to anarchist bombings and
assassinations of the elite worldwide. Some of the defendants were friends of Signac,
mainly Félix Fenéon, whose portrait he painted in 1890. So why did Signac change the title of
his painting? It's simple. Censorship. Signac had to sacrifice the political efficiency of his
painting in order to not be jailed. He wanted to criticize the government's inherent authoritarian
nature, but he couldn't because of this very nature. In the Time of Anarchy became In the
Time of Harmony because harmony, to Signac, was a synonym of anarchy which wouldn't send him to jail.
It's really a shame that this masterful painting lost its political significance due to its change
in title. Most people who will see this painting will gloss over the extremely important political
advocacy of its creator. But perhaps there might also be advantages to this censorship.
Signac was able to parallel anarchy and harmony. He was able to present anarchist ideas through art
and these ideas, now that we can openly talk about them, can be shared through his painting.
We can talk about how these ideas were so dangerous to the ruling class that they had to
censor them. We can talk about how some artists believed in these ideas enough to put their lives
on the line to paint them. If you enjoyed this video, I encourage you to share it with friends
because I do believe this painting is extremely important. Also, I made a whole video going
through the process of making this very essay, so check it out if you're interested. Thank you so
much for watching, thank you for liking and subscribing if you have already, and I'd also
like to thank especially YouDesignIWrite, Kohler, and every other patron for supporting the channel.
If you also want to support the channel, check out patreon.com forward slash the canvas.
